…Israel Bonds Dinner Hears Dr. Tanter Dr. Raymond Tanter will be the speaker at the Israel Bonds/Congregation B'nai David tribute to George Vine 6 p.m. June 13 at the synagogue. Dr. Tanter, who has been teaching at the University of Michigan since 1967, has also taught at the University of Amsterdam and the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. He has served on the senior staff of the National Security Council at the White House, where his responsib...…
…Cr) w w H- CC H- w UJ H- 102 Down by the Sea I In Brighton Beach, better known as Little Odessa, the rhythms of life on the boardwalk have a decidedly Russian lilt. PHOTOS BY KIM MULLER-THYM n the early 1970s, it earned the nickname "Little Odessa." Jews from Odessa flocked to Brighton Beach, Brooklyn, for its beach front and distinctly Rus- sian flavor. Today, waves of immigrants from all over the former Soviet Union continue to ...…
…(NYANA), which helps settle the immigrants. The grapevine is very strong." Mr. Handelman estimates that 150,000 Soviet Jews live in one of New York's five bor- oughs. Of that figure, he said, 80 percent live in Brooklyn or Queens, with 65 percent in Brooklyn. He believes there are about 30,000 Soviet Jews liv- ing in Brighton Beach. For many of the immigrants, Brighton Beach is a stepping stone for their new lives as Americans. As they become...…
…AMAZING MARKETPLACE THE JEWISH NEWS How To Advertise To advertise to almost everyone in our com- munity in this amazing classified section, simply call 354-5959 by 10 a.m. on Tuesday. These advertisements may be charged over the phone to your MasterCard or Visa credit cards or you may mail in your ad with a check to The Jewish News, 27676 Franklin Road, Southfield, Michigan 48034. We cannot bill for these ads. Our classified "liners" cost $...…
…I AMAZING MARKETPLACE TRANSPORTATION D TRANS Corp. Sedan, imousine, passenger & han- ap van, also charter bus ervice, airport transporta- on. 24 Hour Fax 962-2464. -800-45-SEDAN. RANS-ACE AIRPORT huttle. Personal, profes- ional, preferred. Advance otification please. 355-2201 ANSPORTATION TO and v.om doctors, shopping, er- rands. Best rates! Steve Katz, 592-0975 INSTRUCTION TUTOR MATH/science. Cer- tified teacher, grades 7-12. come to yo...…
…!AMAZING MARKETPLACE INSTRUCTION EMPLOYMENT PROFESSIONAL SERVICES MISCELLANEOUS WANTED RESEARCH. MLS degree. Qualified librarian will con- duct info searches/ library re- search for you in any area. Specialties include business, health, law fields. 557-4491. CASH FOR partial estates, glassware, old pictures, anti- ques, hunting/fishing, golf items, old store stock, an- tique lamps, old movie post- ers, very old accumulations. Call Tom, 4...…
…Pick Up A Pen And Respond By Letter... ...Or Pick Up The Phone For Speedier Service THE JEWISH NEWS 1-900-420-2010 27676 Franklin Road . Southfield, MI 48034 . 4 The cost for responding to or retrieving messages is $1.49 per minute. There is a minimum charge of $1,49 You must have touch-tone service to place an ad; however, you may respond to an ad with a pulse (rotary) phone. You must be at least 18 years of age to respond to or place an...…
…AMAZING M ETPLACE , MISCELLANEOUS HOUSEHOLD GOODS WANTED BEAUTIFUL, SENSUOUS, intelligent lady, 5'6", cheerful, fun-loving, healthy, youthful and slender, mid-50's, look- ing for a kind, loving, honest, romantic gentleman who is emotionally and financially stable, under 65. #64836 Attractive, petite, spirited, lover of the arts, seeks dance partner, harmonizer, best friend and lover, with intel- lectually and physically ac- tive, creative l...…
…I AMAZING MARKETPLACE SERVICES BASEMENT WATERPROOFING ROSE APPLIANCE REPAIR Interior & Exterior Repairs Licensed — Insured. Excellent Guarantee. Experienced Professionals. Lowest Prices. Estimates Over Phone. EXPERIENCED IN-HOME SERVICE Low Rates All Makes & Models Servicing 7 Days ALL-WAYS DRY We clean dirt cheap COMMERCIAL - RESIDENTIAL OFFICES All work guaranteed. Very reasonable. Call HAROLD COHEN 350-3076 GUTTERS AND DOWNSPOU...…
…I AMAZING MARKETPLACE SERVICES FOGELMAN APPLIANCE SERVICE Discount Prices All Makes - All Models Kenmore & Whirlpool Specialist BUILDING CO. Specializing in Home Renovations: LDR ENTERPRISES Custom Home Builders REFERENCES AVAILABLE (313) 358-2725 LICENSED AND INSURED MAX THE HANDYMAN You Name It — I'll Do It! MOPHEAD'S CLEANING SERVICE The Best Cleaning Service Houses Condos Stores Offices BONDED FREE ESTIMATES Call 559-3070 ...…
…AMAZING MARKETPLACE SERVICES DOD MENDELSON Heating, air condi- tioning, installation, and repair. PAINTING BY SAM BARON Interior • Exterior Quality work at reasonable prices $25 service call Nothing per hour plus parts. References Free Estimates STATE LICENSED #3984 855-0437 CHIMNEYS, PORCHES, all masonry work. Leaks, fleshings. NALIAN Licensed and insured. 828-2733 553-8067 UVONIA PAINING Interiors • Exteriors ■ Drywall R...…
…AMAZING MARKETPLACE REAL ESTATE SERVICES RENTALS SIDING and ROOFING •Aluminum/Vinyl Siding •Seamless Gutters/Trim •Porch Enclosures •Storm Windows & Doors •Replacement Windows "Rodgers does it Right" Licensed Builder Insured L.J. RODGERS Home Improvements HUNTINGTON WOODS 399-1233 , I ODORLESS & ORGANIC INSURED • FREE ESTIMATES • GUARANTEED WORK 1-800-956-2131 28545 GREENFIELD SOUTHFIELD Bloomfield Porch & Screen Screens repa...…
…REAL ESTATE RENTALS FRANKLIN POINTE TOWNHOUSES Franklin Road, South of 12 Mile Unique Ranch Style Living Luxury 2 and 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, tub and stall shower. Private entrance and patio. Park at your front door. No stairs. Laundry room in unit. Dinette in kitchen. Heat included. $700 Two bedrooms 1292 sq. ft. $769 Three bedrooms 1537 sq. ft. 355-1367 Discover for yourself why ORCHARD CREEK APARTMENTS of Farmington Hills is the comm...…
…REAL ESTATE RENTALS MORE APARTMENT FOR THE MONEY! "Both the social atmosphere and community are diverse in their interest and tastes to provide a wealth of ethnic and cultural blends." F TANGLEWOOD APARTMENTS Spacious 1 bedroom apartment. 850 sq. ft. Carpeting, blinds, cen. air, walk-in storeroom, all kit- chen appliances. Carports Available. Ask about our Special 569-6149 BIRMINGHAM — Gary Davis Home for rent. Downtown Historic Hous...…
…REAL ESTATE ENTALS NOW PRE-LEASING FOR SUMMER MOVE-INS! Move in by July 15th & take advantage of our sizzling Summer Specials and enjoy our: • Sparkling Pool • Bubbling Spa • Pool-side sundeck • Tennis Courts 1 Bedroom/Den and 2 Bedroom Apartments Luxury Community Including All These Extras V Efficient, modern kitchen appliances Washer & dryer V Attached garage 'V Mini/vertical blinds V Vaulted ceiling V Natural woodburning fireplace V W...…
…HUNTINGTON WOODS OPEN SUN. 1-5 25886 PEMBROKE FARMINGTON HILLS HUNTERS POINTE SUB. REAL ESTATE FOR SALE Contemporary two- story, 2,144 sq. ft. 2.5 baths, 4 bedrooms, family room, finished basement, 2-car att. garage. Custom built for owner in 1968. $199,500. Owner 541-4511. Pond Lake Lot. 4 bed- room, 3.5 bath Colonial. Finished basement, library, family room. Mint. $297,000. By owner 661-5770. mor Landmark Title Services DECORATOR PER...…
…REAL ESTATE OR SALE WEST BLOOMFIELD OPEN SUN 1-5 MAPLEWOODS NORTH 4392 Pinehurst IWEST BLOOMFIELD — STUNNING CONTEMPORARY 1 Detached condo. Guarded entrance. 2,000 sq. ft. White decor, open, airy design. Mirrored walls, 2 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, library. Full basement, 2-car garage. Decking overlooking wooded area. $206,000. W-79L0C B1 1267 UNION LAKE — WEST BLOOMFIELD 174 ft. on lake with wide open views and sandy bottom. Ranch with major...…
…I REAL ESTATE FOR SALE FORTUNE PROPERTIES BLOOMFIELD HILLS CHARMING QUARTON & FRANKLIN AREA OPENING DOORS TO YOUR FUTURE! • Residential • Commercial • Relocation Specialists 2,266 sq. ft. quad level with 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, features large master bedroom with adjoin- ing 1/2 bath, 1st floor study with adjoining pow- der room, large custom deck situated off of family room with wood burning fireplace. Newly con- structed custom white kit...…
…I REAL ESTATE 1 HUNTINGTON WOODS RALPH MANUEL OPEN SUN. 1-4 • 12928 LA SALLE LANE FOR SALE NORTH OAK PARK OPEN SUNDAY 2-5 14700 TALBOT Four bedroom Col- ,' onial, contemporary decor, 2 1/2 baths, at- tached garage. Move-in condition. Must sell. $108,500. 543-8328 Large, custom three bedroom ranch offers many exceptional improve- ments on nearly 1 acre wooded lot! Over 2,384 sq. ft., featuring three bed- rooms, large modern kitchen, fam...…
…REAL ESTATE I FOR SALE RAMBLEWOOD Outstanding 4 bed- room, 2.5 both cus- tom contemporary. Ceramic entry, bridge overlooks great room. Library, gourmet kit- chen, vaulted ceilings, finished lower level, central air, deck, beautifully land- scaped, yard backs to common. Gatehouse community. $263,500. 96DEE OPEN SUNDAY Stunning 1990 Con- temporary Colonial. 2600 sq. ft. w/walk- out. Huge kitchen, great room, dining room, library, first flo...…
…REAL ESTATE 1 OR SALE HIRE THE MOST SUCCESSFUL CENTURY 21 AGENT ) IN THE MIDWEST 1989 TO 1991. SANDY NORMAN / $10,000,000 MAN. Hire A Company With A Major Relocation Dept. 642-8100 • 855-7766 CIRCLE THIS! , WEST BLOOMFIELD CONDO Fantastic 3 bedroom, 2.5 bath townhouse, 2 kitchen pantries, I deck, attached ga- rage, new carpet and decor. Only $127,500 WELLINGTON WOODS CONDO Large upper ranch with updated kitchen, fireplace, laundry r...…
…I REAL ESTATE FOR SALE Completely re- modeled 4 bed- room Colonial. Within walking distance of Tem- ple Beth El. Up- dated interior and exterior. Asking $189,900. Call 932-3804 OPEN SUNDAY 1-4 MOST LIVABLE HOUSE FOR LEAST MONEY! Franklin Corners offers a spacious Colonial with a contemporary flair. Well maintained with an open floor plan, large kitchen, 4 bedrooms and Birmingham schools. East off Middlebelt south of Maple. 6711 Woodside. ...…
…FARMINGTON HILLS EXTRAVAGANZA REAL ESTATE FOR SALE WEST BLOOMFIELD FRANKLIN VALLEY SUB 7047 SPRINGRIDGE Three bedroom, 2 bath, white formica kitchen with built-ins. Updated throughout, neutral decor. 21/2-car attached garage, central air, full basement, large treed lot. Open Sun- day 1-5 p.m. $152,000 851-4449 WEST BLOOMFIELD Stunning ranch condo, 1,854 sq. ft. w/ 24x14' family room. Many up- grades. Guarded corn- munity. Perfect for si...…
…REAL ESTATE I Give someone another birthday . FOR SALE OPEN SUNDAY 12-4 6570 BUCKLAND WEST BLOOMFIELD South of Commerce West off of Greenlake Rd. Immaculate, 3 bed- rooms, 2 baths. Ranch with large finished basement. Newly remodeled kit- chen and bath. New carpeting throughout. Central air, 21/2-car garage. Lake privileges. $120,500. 360-8890 OPEN SAT. L SUN. 12 TO 5 WEST BLOOMFIELD Great family home by owner, all updated 4 bedroom Co...…
…I D B I TUA RI ES page 126 bor; son and daughter-in-law, Jacques and Dyane of Wood- side, Calif. 89, of Detroit, died May 30. She is s urvived by brothers, Nathan of Miami, Dr. David of , Livonia. ROSE SCHIFF, i CHARLOTTE ELBINGER 75, former Detroiter of San Diego, died May 26. She is survived by daughters and sons-in-law, Judith Kaplan Karon of Duluth, Minn., Linda and rank Furlong of Los Angeles, Ellen and Stuart .Left of West Bloomfi...…
…Graveside and Cemetery Chapel Services MAKE THE MOST SENSE! Maples MILDRED BLOOMBERG, 76, of West Bloomfield, died orfman Funeral Direction (313) 546-4700 BETTY DAVIDSON, 85, of Wixom, died May 25. She is Brochure Available • Savings of up to $1000 or more • Indoor Chapel Services available on most cemetery grounds • A complete service including all shiva needs • Serving all cemeteries Alan & Jonathan Dorfman Licensed Funeral Direc...…
…IN-STORE COPIES OF THIS AD AVAILABLE! cas- .7.0 L OPEN EVERYDAY SUN.-THURS. 7 a.m. - 12 Mid. FRI. & SAT. 7a.m. - 1 a.m. All Our Kosher Products Are Certified Kosher Or Sanctioned By The Metropolitan Kashruth Council Of Michigan fliMMERY® CJ SILUR FREE FAT IFREE iGE GREAM 6698 Orchard Lake Rd. In the West Bloomfield Plaza 737.1610 (FAX: 737-0999) TRY A FREE SAMPLE! ITALPASTA • LINGUINI • SPAGHETTI • ROTINI PAS 0 LIMIT 4 ONE POUND ...…
…timeless reminder of your love. . . the diamond eternity ring. For uncompromising value, quality, and selection the name to trust in diamond eternity rings is Tapper's. For service and value as it should be. Diamonds and Fine Jewelry 26400 W. 12 Mile Road • Southfield, MI 48034 • 357-5578 - • *Styles shown may not be in stock but can be ordered. jimjIMIIIMIIIIIMM …
…I 1J Ijo Celebrating 50 years of growth with the Detroit Jewish Community 1 9 9 2 THE JEWISH NEWS 2 5 SIVAN 5 7 5 2/JUNE 26, 1992 Looking To Labor AMY J. MEHLER STAFF WRITER `e of POLITICS Hot Races '92: 11th Congressional District Sizzles campaigning, the Labor Party, led by former Israeli Defense Minister and Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin, won 47 seats in the new Parliament, up from 38. The Likud Party, led the last four...…
…*Must own vehicle as of April 1, 1992. Offer expires Sept. 23, 1992! Two Convenient Locations To Serve You. • GARDEN CITY 425-4300 SOUTHGAT :2 5 8890 32000 Ford Rd. West of Merriman Rd. 16800 Fort St. At Pennsylvaii gr. 2 FRIDAY, JUNE 26, 1992 …
…32940 Middlebelt Rd. (At 14 Mile Rd. in the Broadway Plaza) JEWELERS For the best in quality and design Phone: 855-1730 Farmington Hills, Michigan THE DETROIT JEWISH NEWS 3 …
…EMERGENCY! We moved on June 15 a On June 15, the Emergency Center and all other outpatient healthcare programs at Providence Medical Center on 10 Mile and Haggerty closed permanently. These services moved to Providence Park, 47601 Grand River and Beck Road, just off of 1-96, at the Beck Road exit. So beginning June 15, when you think EMERGENCY...think Providence Park. Our entire staff from Emergency, Outpatient Surgery, Lab and X-ray are a...…
…THE JEWISH NEWS Vol. CI No. 16 Associate Publisher Arthur M. Horwitz Editor Emeritus Philip Slomovitz Managing Editor Phil Jacobs Associate Editor Alan Hitsky Assistant Editor Elizabeth Applebaum Staff Writers David Kotzen-Reich Kimberly Litton Amy J. Mehler L_.- j -- Contributing Editor Elie Wiese! [ Washington Correspondent James D. Besser Foreign Correspondent Douglas Davis Israel Correspondents Ina Friedman Larry Derfner Photographer Gle...…
…EDITORIAL A Watershed Election In Israel's History Israel's national election on Tuesday is already being described as a watershed in the country's political history. Among the significant changes: after 15 years of Likud leadership, the Labor Party will lead the government, signaling a will- ingness to make at least some territorial concessions for peace; prospects for Arab- Israeli peace talks will improve with Yit- zhak Rabin, a more prag...…
…4111111111111111111111- - -- OPINION Why A Journalist Needs Thick Skin And Lofty Vision DAy TALKS 6 BILATERAL - GARY ROSENBLATT Editor Editors and publishers of Jewish weeklies often feel like the Rodney Dan- gerfields of American Jew- ish life. i , When rabbis sermonize on what needs to be done and [ the Federation executives plan it and the philan- thropists pay for it, the Jew- ish journalists try to report it — and are taken to ta...…
…LOCAL NEWS Affording the best is not the question .. . Finding the best is. Court Continued from Page 1 Justice Anthony Kennedy, was joined by Harry Blackmun, John Paul Stevens, Sandra Day O'Connor and David Souter. "No holding by this court sug- gests that a school can persuade or compel a student to partici- pate in a religious exercise," Jus- tice Kennedy wrote. "This is being done here, and it is for- bidden by the Constitution. "Our s...…
…OF PRIMARY IMPORTANCE! Primary Election on August 4. In Michigan, religious conflict has pointed to the Bloomfield Hills schools, where a long- standing debate over Christmas celebration could resurface. The debate in Bloomfield Hills schools started at the end of 1988 • when a group called Taxpayers - Organization To Restore Cul- tural Heritage first surfaced at a board of education meeting. Members of the now-defunct TORCH, which included ...…
…WHAT EVERY MAN SHOULD KNOWABOUT IMPOTENCE. The real tragedy of impotence is letting it go untreated fatigue, alcohol, drugs, smoking, stress and depres- even one more day. Stop denying yourself and your sion. Medicines used to treat such things as depres- sexual partner an important part of your life. Impo- sion, high blood pressure and ulcers can be part tence can be treated in almost every case. of the problem. Age alone is not a cause of i...…
…UP FRONT - Ross Perot: Is He The "Least Of Three Evils? By nature, Jewish voters are wary of Ross Perot. But they're less than thrilled with President Bush and Bill Clinton. JAMES D. BESSER Washington Correspondent oss Perot, the stealth presidential can- didate who has enrap- tured the nation with his in- surgent third-party bid, has apparently failed to win many Jews to his burgeon- ing cause. But that could change quickly if President ...…
…You paid for the Bat Mitzvah, the orthodontist, college and a good part of the wedding. SO WHAT'S ANOTHER $31? You probably paid more for a new cumberbund. But then, when was money ever an object when it came to your kids? Especially if it was something to help them. Now that they're married you can still do something good for them. And it won't cost a whole lot of money. For $31 you can give your kids a subscription to the Detroit Jewish Ne...…
…Michigan's Newest mama Dealer Brings You Michigan's Largest Inventory! milti 1993 MBZDBRX-7 626 DX 1993 Demo, auto., air, 2.0 L DOHC, 16 valve, 4 cyc., 14 inch wheels, intermittent wipers, AM/FM ca.,. child safety rear door locks, tilt, driver's air bag, rear defog. Stk. #670 Lease for only $249 1992mazDa 929 3.0 DOHC 24 valve V-6, cruise. 4 spd auto w OD. 15 - Ines ier alloy wheels. p. Ike.. leather int w 'trim. pwr sunroof. p. doors...…
…DETROIT I FIFTY YEARS AGO I Palestinian Jews Ready As Axis Prepare Attack This column will be a weekly feature during The Jewish News' anniversary year, looking at The Jew- ish News of today's date 50 years ago. PHIL JACOBS Managing Editor A state of total recruiting was engaged in Palestine to defend against a gathering Axis battle group in the Egyp- tian frontier, reported The Jewish News. All able-bodied men and wo- men between the ...…
…D retinas were not properly attached due to a buildup of r _scar tissue which needed to be removed. Following surgery, Yosi had difficulties breathing, which required a longer hospital stay and cost the family more than they ex- pected. - When Ms. Shoohani and Yosi arrived from Israel, they came with the $18,000 ---c they had raised to pay for the surgery plus additional funds to pay for other ex- penses. Most of the money ' 'came from her p...…
…S A V E S A V E S A V E S A V E 116 0 SAVE $ Detroit's Volume Honda Dealer WHY BUY HERE 1. SATURDAY SALES & SERVICE 2. FREE LOANER CARS* 3. LOWEST PRICES We Will Not Be Undersold! "FERNDALE CO N Ell _Pk SAVE $ SAVE $ SAVE $ SAVE $ SAVE LINKS AT PINEWOOD ADVANCE REGISTRATION FOR GOLF PACKAGE AND DINNER BANQUET CALL RICHARD GIBBS AT 358-0540. TO PARTICIPATE IN THE SOUVENIR JOURNAL ADS, SPONSORSHIP OR DONATIONS CALL BERNICE KESNER...…
…• Y 0 U' R E INVITED Party in the Park! , the time he was almost 'B drafted into the Israeli army. He was summoned to military headquarters three times before the Israeli brass finally rejected him because T he lacked a taudat brit milah (a certificate of circumci- sion). So how does a "nice Catholic boy" as Mr Hellman described his early life, become one of the , .staunchest defenders of the Jewish state? Also, why does '--- a Washington p...…
…The Best In Quality at The Best Price...Guaranteed! / il, 1"; 14 t1 prii -1,1"j 1 X 'fri V ',1 ci rr ‘ ...„..,....•.,_k -_-.. —,_•• ∎ ... ) 4W Air A/ f Ar /144, ' $1.585 Itst $999 Sale Ben Frank hopes his guidebook will turn on Jewish travelers to Jewish sites in Europe. OV WOODARD This brand new "Ramsgate' collection New Guidebo ok Helps Make Jewish Connection by Woodard has the look and elegance of hand-wrought iron but is c...…
…TAMAROFF • TAMAROFF • TAMAROFF • TAMAROFF • TAMAROFF • TAMAROFF • TAMAROFF ftwey. yaw Eft OkffirAv. aMaROFF" - TamaRoFF ramaRoFF - ZU NISSAN T V UICK BUICK NEW '92 BUICK PARK AVENUE 4 DR. SALE Was $27,469 ... PRICE $ 22 999* SAVE $4,470 o Buick's Premium Pkg., leather interior. Stk. #627938. • WELL EQUIPPED — NOT STRIPPED! Air bag, V-6 eng., auto. trans., air cond., tinted glass, intermittent wipers, tilt whl., cruise cont., re...…
…rue d: Tine Ogrl* I 11111111F I I The Advantages of SmartLease Cadillac Style .. . Continued from Page 18 No. 2669 Sedan DeVille so DOWN Power Astro Roof I 36 Mos. $468 00 + Tax No. 2337 only Eldorado $I I PER MONTH Roger Rinke Cadillac will install a Power Astro Roof for only $2.00 per month when you GMAC SmartLease a new Cadillac I during the month of I I $ 0 I DOWN 00 + Tax mt. I I No. 2551 Seville I IJ UNEi Gui...…
…STREIT'S CHOW MEIN NOODLES GOLD'S BORSCHT •REGULAR "TRY THEM WITH SOUP, SALAD, STEW & MEAT” Quality & Best Prices! fol d ' s = aux.,-Fuu •RUSSIAN STYLE •32 OZ. JAR • 12 OZ. BORSCHT II " 3711C? VII , E OWNED AND OPERATED BY THE HILLER FAMILY FOR OVER 50 YEARS! SALE GOOD JUNE 26 THRU JULY 2, 1992 „!: CC Matt.. l' 01...1 RUM mrss rcn WO JULTIFIOAL MONIS AbIND Ifthat INFL *gr. GREENFIELD EGG •ALL NOODLES VARIETIES STRICTLY FRESH ...…
…4 I r Reeling In The Numbers I CLOSE-UP I Jewish demographers' findings have a ripple effect nationwide. ARTHUR J. MAGIDA Special to The Jewish News 22 FRIDAY, JUNE 26, 1992 IF or all the breast-beating over a recent national Jewish pop- ulation study, with its worri- some data on the rapid increase of assimilation and intermarriage among Amer- ican Jews, little attention has been paid to who did the study and the validity of their in...…
