Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Download this Issue


Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

This collection, digitized in collaboration with the Michigan Daily and the Board for Student Publications, contains materials that are protected by copyright law. Access to these materials is provided for non-profit educational and research purposes. If you use an item from this collection, it is your responsibility to consider the work's copyright status and obtain any required permission.

November 10, 1929 - Image 4

Resource type:
The Michigan Daily, 1929-11-10

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.


.J lJ 1.1! 1...7 i _ 1 4

54r tdytoin 114141
Published every morning except Mondal
dunring the Uni.ersity year ny toe Board in'
Control of Student ?hlicaticns.
Member of Wetein Conference '4it riai
The Associated Press is exclusively entitled
to the use for republication of all news dis-
patches credited to it or. not otherwise credited
n this paper and the local news published
Entered atjthe posto..ce at Ann Arbor,
Michigan, as second class matter. Special rate
of postage granted by Third Assistant Post-
Waster General.
Subscription by carrier, $4.00; by mail, $4.50.
Offices: Ann Arbor Press Building, May-
nard Strpeet.
Phones: Editorial, gg25; Business, 212t4.
Telephone 4925
Editor.....................George C. Tilley
City Editor......... Pierce Rosenberg
Newis Editor............ George E: Simons
Sports Editor .........Edward L. Warne", Jr.
Women's Editor...........MNarjorie Fbllmer
Telegraph Editor......... Cassam A. Wilson
Music and Drama........William J. Gorman
Literary Editor ........ Lawrence R. Klein
Assistant City Editor...... Robert J. Feldman
Night Editors
Frank E. Cooper Henry 3. Merry
William C. Gentry Robert L. Sloss
Charles R. Kaufman Walter W. Wilds
Bertram Askwith Lester May
Helen Bare David M. Nichol
Maxwell Bater William Page
Mary L. Behymer Howard H. Peckham
Benjamin I. Berentsoi Hugh Pierce
Allan H. Berkman Victor Rabinowitz
S. Beach Conger John D. Reindel
Thomas M. Cooley Jeannie Roberts
John H. Denier Joseph A. Russell
Helen Domine Joseph Ruwitch
Margaret Eckels William P. Salzarulo
Katharine Ferrin Charles R. Sprowl
Carl S. Forsythe S. Cadwell Swanson
Sheldon C. Fullerton Jane Thayer
Ruth Geddes Margaret Thompson
Ginevra Ginn Richard L. TFobin
jack Goldsmith Elizabeth Valentine
Morris Grovernan arold n. Warren, Jr.
Ross Gustin Charles White
MraeHars G.LionelWillens





Campus Opinion
Contributors are asked to b th l 3C
wofisit ther ibl' es to eii3 tr n 3iO
wordsit posib - An. ymo cc.m'


Music And Drai

maAbo-ut Bkoi-ks

rouAncations will be disregarded. The "Ci t HAUL" iOR OF
names of communicants will, however,
be. regarded as confidential, upon re- j A Review, by Robert Wetzel DOUGLAS' ROMANCf;
quest. Letters published should nutbe
construed as expressing the editorial Friday night Mr. Thurnau's play, Nerinda; by Norman Douglas;I
opinion of the Daily. I
"City Haul," was made known to The John Day Company; New York,
an oddly-assorted audience that New York; Price $2.50; Review copy
somehow looked, as if, having by courtesy of Print and Booki
To the editor: heard there was a free show, they Shop.
Alas. The time of the football had come out of their holes in the Nerinda was first published in
season has again come when the ground determined to see it. Like 1901 under an assumed name, and
perennial multiplicity of groans all audiences for- whom free shows it is only lately that this interest-
and anathema over the present are given, they were unresponsive ing study has come to be known as.
seating arrangement at football and inattentive, and they came in the work of Norman Douglas. Thif;
games, rises in deep crescendo. late. In fact, the audience's de- book is a piece of fantastic litera-
Since completion of the new sta- layed entrance, terrible as an army ture. In some of its aspects it re-
with banners, should have been minds one of the strenuous tales
dium when the practise of reserv- vitaphoned and turned on during of Poe, though as the whole it has
ing unsalable blocks of seats for the strangely placid fight scene in none of the morbidity of the great
the undergraduate first came into the second act. American narrator. In no respect
vogue, the deplorable custom has Of all the dramatic forms, melo- does it reach the intensity o emo-
been the particular and constant drama is perhaps the hardest to tions that is found in Poe, and th*
write or produce. An amateur play- is due to the different viewpoints
abomination of the student on the wright may very possibly possess held by the writers. Poe is exact,
campus. And rightly so. such knowledge of character, or scientific, and analytical; he weighs
Nor does the future hold any such sensitivity to emotion, as to every word to make sure that there
hope for the harassed and dis- enable him to write an effective i can arise no mistaken meaning.
traught holders of coupon books. comedy or a powerful tragedy; but Douglas is not conscious in word
Indeed, far from alleviating the sit- melodrama-the drama of situa- selection. Every word is microcosm
tion, action, and movement--- is to him. The sentences never be-
uation, the constant increase in de- almost always beyond his grasp. * " i'i- ,
yS by~ndhiSgUas- i dA.LU th0~ fl in im

Priv.ic Wive Connections
with all Markets
Securities bought or sold on
commission basis
Telephone 22541
Brown-Cress & Co.
Investment Securities
First Floor Ana Arbor Trust Bldg.

---- - . _ .. __ _ .. __ ..., .p._..... .. ,

ow-M tit,


'a ti
803 East Washington'
One Block North from Hill Auditoroi:m
Breakfast, Lunch and DinmeIr
$8.00 per week
Lunch and Dinner, $6.50 pcr week

- .1


t _ _I
.afl.tAR. .nW.. S.....

I -- . - . --.-- I


ma-nd for seats is so pressing that Your successful melodramatist
presently we shall have the Seniors needs-and usually possesses- nof
in the end zones, Juniors behind greater quality than mere crafts-
the press box, the Sophomores on 1manship; but that very craftsman-
t ship is something that comes only
friendly limbs in the neighboring with years of practice in the thea-
forests and the lowly and degen- tre. To know life's thrilling cli-
erate Frosh arrayed on the roof of maxes, one need never darken a3
.ln inl U £fiion _ sager_'-.o;. t wflen-- one-aesires-to

come excnea ;ney oiw msmpii
calmness. The experience with
Douglas is quiet, it is dreamy and
peaceful (even in the story of Na-
rinda which is of madness). Poe
holds you in a vice, and plays with
your imagination on a trembling
key until you have closed his

Davi arr rr ns q1. ,11 " te vew huse stae-dor;but when one desires t
epsteadJohn Willoughby Douglas is romanticist. And
nesnedy 'ta seOn shudders in contemplation of put those climaxes into an effec- ougl i usmnths nd
cans Levvy Barbara W right '.Itog 1 il si h oet
kussenl E. McCracken Vivian Zimit the fate of band and the cheering tive play, it is helpful, if not abso- i e uha i the to
Dorohy Mgeeto hve een ornthis edition that the idea of the
Dorothy Magee section. lutely necessary, to have been bornale has had its parallel in actual
BUSINESS STAFF jthe glori- Iust off-stage during a performance le
Teehoe211 Ltuscnsdrbriefly te loi of "The Fatal Wedding." life, we are stubborn and, believe
Telephone 21214 ous and God-given spectacle in the TheFotat poddig. that most of the comments are the
A. J. JORDANGR. stadium from student perspective. These somewhat pontifical gen- result of the author's personal ex-
AJ. DN JWith high visibility, the student eralizations are occasioned by the perience. Narinda is the story of
Assistant Manager posesn odeeih a fact that, in "City Haul," Mr. Thrur-
a rpossessing good eyesight may makefathtm'iyHuM.Th- an Englishman who, looking far
ALEX t . SCHERR onau has attempted to scale, not the ideal described by Plato, fell
ALEX K. SCHERER tout the blurred forms of Morrison, Parnassusbu rather the Black-e esry
Truck, Gembis, and Draveling, on arnass's butlratherstea'slc min love with a statue in a Pompeiian
Department Managers the horizon. By bringing one's Maria of melodrama, so zealously museum. The vision of this statue,
Avertising.....T. ollister .Mabley glasses into play, one may attain a guarded by Messrs. Mack, Hymer, Narinda, went everywhere with
Advertising s.erH AH alvron fleeting glimpse of Heston or even Shipman, Dunning & Co. The as- him, and finally led him to suicide
Service.... .(eorge A. maer Norm glie cent is not so long, but it is in some in effort to be with her spirit.
Circulation ............... 'ernorv Daniels. The whereabout respects more difficult. Thus, the
$ Accions...on o such microscopic mammals as t M.' sp This is an eccentric piece of writ-
Pu~aios.......... o~eIlmitnfact that Mr. Thurnaus first play, ig eyitrsigb h ato
Simrall and Dahlem is a matter of aiming at melodrama, has gone bg, very teresting by the fact of
Assistants theory. i wide of the mark, is quite unimpor- its subjectivity. The work is'ac-
Raymond Campbell Lawrence LTcey Wherefore it has come to pass cording to the psychologist Maud-
Robert Crawford George Patterson that only the student of gifted im- jesnfore-rdaine. But the or sley "ingeniously and logically con-
Harry B. Culver Charles Sanford less tore-ordained. But the fact
Thomas M. Davis lee Slayton agination may enjoy a football seived and carried out." It reflects
Norman Eezer Robert Sutton game in his own stadium, thanks to thaed hi play Mr hraur as the modern tendency, and the ro-
Donald Ewing Rger C. Thlorn revealed a feeling for character andmathemoe tendency. o ianter-'
James Ho er*loseph van Riper a system of seating students that an instinct for situation, is, on the mantic tendency too, to give atten-
N orris Johnson Rert Williamson is an elaborate annual insult. tion to abnormalities. The possi-
Charles Kline William R. Worboys sanebotenulisl, other hand, a matter of high im- bevleo hsbo ssbett
MArvin Kotacker The University of Michigan ble value of this book is subject to
The nivesityof Mchign portance.
Laura Codln g A- MW l boasts, the finest stadium in these His play is, frankly, ragged,mud- much conjecture. It is a faithful
Beimiice Glaser Slvia ;iller United States of America. Thanksf died, and inept; but it is also prom-
Hortense Gooding ielen E. Miiselwhite one is hastild informed of the d psychology according to Maudsley.
Anna Goldberg Elanor Wakinshaw oreising-and, as first plays go, not
Dorothea Waterman alumni. The Stadium has a maxi- I But it i a picture for the scien-
Night Editor-WALTER WILDS mum seating capacity of some made his tyro "Fanny" write. Aim- that is all,hMr. Douglas is not
s______ - - - -- ninety thousands. The student maehstro"an"wrt.Am interested in the reason why the
in actuality Mr. Thurnau has be- c the
SUNDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 929 body may perhaps aggregate twelve ing, perhaps, at being Galsworthy, about as it did. He Is entirely ro-
_ -f thousand. Which leaves, roughly, come a sort of unsuccessful -Willard . i th w th th
seventy five thousand seats for the Mack. But the stuff of which ef- manticinti way wi e pur-
bondholders, alumni and what have fective drama is made is present pose of catching an intense mo-
BEWARE PROPAGANDA. you. The alumni are obviously en- in abundance in "City Haul," and ment of experience, But the critic
a titled to first consideration in the is bound to ask .about the relation
Quite a heated argument was distribution of the remaining sev- shT out omIt. Up to Friday nigh, this experience has to life. For
stirred up in yesterday morning's enty five thousand seats. Neither after all were are alive and this
seso fth nvriy rs lbthe alumni nor any one else has he had not done so.1 alivity is not found in the death
session of the University Press club heau iosas foeeed As it is, the best scenes in the ah eo0un~tga so
covninoe h rtflesjust, claim to seats of any kind in Asis h es cnsi h that the hero of Douglas' story
o n n the publicityhmannndhis illthe stadium until the student body show take place before the first sought. If scientists had believed
of the publicity man and his will- has been given the best seats in act, and between the second and the way that the romanceers do,
ingness to present to the reading the place. The teams are of the third; the murder alleged to have there would have been no attempt
public the absolute facts untaint- student body and they represent been committed by Terry, and the to understand abnormals. Psychol-
ed with propaganda. 1 the university as constituted by the trial at which the gangsters tes- ogists saw their problem and
student body. No amount of ora tify, are scenes that cry to be writ- grappled with it, and it is ours in
George H. E. Smi'th, executive yI ten. The aunt from. Ireland has literature, also, to give writing a!
tory or stliterature, alsothetoagive
secretary of the League of Nations fact thatthe students have prior rich satirical possiblities which are definite connection with existence.
association, accepted the presence claim to points of vantage when as yet unexplored; and the re-in- R.E. M.
of the propaganda but cautioned their own team is involved in the troluction of Terry's fiancee would
spcal.Igreatly strengthen the second act. ! -_- -
that he must be aided and instruc- spectacle' . Like all first plays, "City Haul" is experiment in a difficult medium;
ted in surrounding his professionAn mdividual without remotest a sort of finger exercise in drama- and indeed "City Haul" was done
with ani unimpeachable code ofaffiliation with either school may tic craftsmanship for the play- with surprising competence, when
see the Michigan-Illinois game at,1
ethcs. He decrimeshe pre as Urbanafom the thgnIirs ya wright. In the presentation Fri- one considers that, to fill the large
ethics. He describes the press s Urbana from the thirty yard line !day night, it also became a sort cast, Mr. Windt had to call in many
an organ by which the propagan- and with average luck even the -of finger exercise in dramatic pro- players of next-to-no experience
dist could be made to work in the forty. Yet an honest, perspiring, duction. Melodrama is no easier to Mr. England's Deagan was very
open and set forth not only "thes d God-fearIng student at the direct than it is to write; and Mr. able indeed; working against the
n University of Michigan is expected Windt, a capital director of plays odds of the playwright's sentimen-
facts which he thinks will induce to be content with a seat in his in which character is stressed, is tality, he created a very tangible
readers to his cause," but also to own stadium that renders his view somewhat less happy when work- 1 character. Mr. Allen was out-
describe accurately "the unseen en- of the game extremely hazy from ing with a play of situation. standing in a brief bit, and shoulti
serdistance. He is not only
vironments." I:sheer dtone HPunch" is the sine-qua-non of have had more to do. Mr. Cur-
expected to be content, he is obliged melodrama; and in his directing, Tie's Terry was most sympathetic,
Publicity men, perhaps, have to rejoice and be exceeding glad Mr. Windt has not put in that in spite of bad team-work from
been influenced by the environ- i that he is allowed a seat of any body-blow at the emotions which his fellow-players in his two best
ment in which they are writing. kind. Mr. Thurnau neglected to include scenes. Miss Morin's Harriet was
This is an age of superlatives, and This, the writer contends in all his writing. Mr. Windt's fine feel- charming, and all too brief. The
with such keen competition in all humbleness, is not as the Deity in- ing for character and emotion are rest ranged from pretty good to
fields of endavor and achievement; tended it to be. of no great avail here; in "City pretty terrible, the worst being
the publicity man is required to The idea that thousands of mor- Haul," stage movement must be as either incredible or inaudible.
describe the pinnacle of success in ons without connection with either shrewdly and coldly calculated as A word for Mr. Holden's set, since
regard to the program which he school, team or any other interest the moves in a good game of chess. his fine stage designs so loften go
wishes to present. save only the spectacle itself, en- But Mr. Windt is not to be dero- unrecognized. Here he has con-
The present methods of the i joying the best seats in the stad- gated for his lack of the bag of trived, in place of the three sets
propagandist were defended by I ium whilst the student body lan- tricks so essential to melodrama. called for by the play, a unit ar-
several editors and directors of guishes in the suburbs, is a state Had he produced well a good melo- rangement which is not quite up to
publicity organizations by citing of permanent vexation. drama by a Broadway playwright,' his usual high standard. A unit
phefctthatrginiatnsby of casesngThere can be little question as he would have been scoffed at as a set is successful only when it either
the fact that n a number of cases i to how the student body stands in mere clever technician who hads u changes beyond immediate recog-
newspapers for publication is re- the matter. Dissatisfaction with done an unworthy thing adequate- nition with each change of scene,
core oers rtuict n r-the present plan is universal and ly. Hence, the fact that he has as in the Guild's "Major Barbara"
corded on the article. Ideep seated. produced none too well a maladroit sets; or else when it frankly makes
Althiough the essentials of the lThe marvel of the whole thing is melodrama by a local playwright no attempt to change with each
material may be of a most unbias- that this sentiment has not long is surely no great discredit. Mr. new scene, as in the Stratford Play-
ed nature the propagandist creates ago found utterance in a form of I Windt can give us moving produc- ers' sets. In "City Haul," Mr. Hol-
an entirely new impression abaut such finite emphasis as would bring tions of such worthy plays as "Re- den's unit-set did not change with
the facts, or greatly enlarges onI about immediate results in the I demption"; and after all, that is each scene, but it pretended to. It
the attributes of the article he is a f f revisionI t man men h what really matters. Besides, one mins mweln civ.ont1 hut ill-ocined.



k tha r r gh .A>>' y s b f y y r 4 lka ;4. {! b mil , MM WV }: V d t

Back to Top

© 2023 Regents of the University of Michigan