Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Download this Issue


Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

This collection, digitized in collaboration with the Michigan Daily and the Board for Student Publications, contains materials that are protected by copyright law. Access to these materials is provided for non-profit educational and research purposes. If you use an item from this collection, it is your responsibility to consider the work's copyright status and obtain any required permission.

March 11, 1992 - Image 12

Resource type:
The Michigan Daily, 1992-03-11

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.



11 Tuc AIA nrKiA1 rnl i G [ KAADM M

News Features/MARCH 1 lw2- -lo U. THE NANAL COv ure 7


(continued from page 1)
playgrounds.It's a situation that has some questioning who
is running the show.
"Who are the professors working for, the university or the
company?" asked Russell Jacoby, author of the "New
Intellectuals -American Culture in the Age of Academe."
Companies often invest their money in construction of
new research facilities on campuses - investments that can
pay dividendswhen they come calling for future projects
based on their relationships with the schools.
For example, Eastman Kodak, General Foods and Union
Carbide helped establish a biotechnology institute at
Cornell U. in 1983. And Washington U. in St. Louis has
signed a 12-year contract with the Monsanto chemical
corporation worth about $100 million. And this is only the
tip of the corporate-funding iceberg.
The companies, however, say this is nothing more than
the reality of the modern marriage of academia and
"The research universities are a tremendous resource for
scientific discovery, and what this funding does is marry the
discovery capability to a way to market and commercialize
those findings," said Gary Barton, science communication
director at Monsanto. "We can help the universities get the
benefits out into society."
Corporate Conflict
But many in today's research environment fear corporate
funding can lead to conflicts of interest. In some cases, it
already has. In 1988-89 it was revealed that researchers at
various universities reviewing TPA, a heart attack drug, also
were stockholders in Genentech, Inc. the company
manufacturing it.
Also, when the Allied Chemical Company funded
research for plant geneticist Ray Valentine at the U. of
California, Davis, they didn't know his study of nitrogen-
fixation would leave campus. Later it was discovered the
Calgene, a company Valentine founded, was a second site
for the research.
Problems stemming from double allegiances range from
criminal involvement to educational deterioration.
"When you manipulate the scientific information or
decide to buy or sell stock based on information only you
know - that puts you on the wrong side of the law," said Bob
Roseth, director of the office of news and information at U.

"Who are the professors working for,
the university or the company?"
- Russell Jacoby
of Washington.
But legal offenses aren't the only concern in the corporate
research game. Some fear that professors may botch, stall or
alter research to further their own financial or business
agendas. Research vital to tackling disease, saving the
environment or growing better crops could be jeopardized.
"It becomes a very incestuous kind of situation if there's a
failure to carry out the academic responsibilities in an open
environment," said Norman Scott,, vice president of
research at Cornell.
But Stanley Wright, director of corporate contributions
for Eastman Kodak, said such fears are incidental compared
to the benefits of corporate-sponsored research.
"What we're investing in is access to technology; we're
actually having them help us," Wright said.
Although the potential for conflict exists when
corporations spend millions, Cornell's Scott said the
research is critical to the advancement of technology.

"What good is research that doesn't move beyond the
scientific bench because of the great fear of conflict of
interest?" Scott said. "You have to make some balance
between entrepreneurship and conflict of interest."
Capping the Corruption
Fear of unethical behavior in the research lab has led to
attempts at regulating the practices of researchers.
In 1989, the National Institute of Health and the Alcohol,
Drug Abuse and Mental Health Administration proposed
guidelines to prevent conflicts of interest in technology
The NIH guidelines would have required faculty to
disclose their investments as well as the financial interests of
their spouses and children to university administrators. The
policy also would have prohibited faculty from having an
interest in any company whose products they were testing.
The proposals were met with mass disapproval from both
the Department of Health and Human Services and the
scientific community. Many universities claimed the
regulations would be counterproductive to their research,
and three months later they were withdrawn. The institute
currently is revising the restrictions.
Some now think the regulations should be reinstated. As
Jacoby said, if government officials have to fill out financial
disclosure forms, university faculty should, too.
"If someone is doing medical research and is a major
stockholder, it's something we want to know," he said.
"Why, at this point, should we trust them? Why not set it out
in print?"
But rather than wait for national guidelines, universities
nationwide are respondingby policing their own professors.
Harvard, for example, requires prior approval for faculty
members who want to make clinical referrals to businesses
where they or their families have interests.Johns Hopkins U.
requires faculty to report all written agreements involving
privately sponsored research. Massachusetts Institute of
Technology, Carnegie Mellon U. and Cornell also include
substantial conflict of interest sections in their faculty
Sheila Slaughter, U. of Arizona professor and author of
"The Higher Learning and High Technology" said
regulations such as these are a step in the right direction.
But, Slaughter added, they're small steps compared to the
scope of the issue.
"All the professions have guidelines; medicine does, law
does. They're hallmarks of a profession," Slaughter said.
"Butwe're notoriouslybad at policing ourselves."



Daytona Beach packages starting
from $691 Ocean front. Best locations.
Best prices. Book now, space is
limited. 1-800-563-8747.
STUDY ABROAD in Southern France.
Summer, Semester, Year programs.
Contact: French American Exchange
313 C Street NE, Washington, DC
Reach the biggest travel market in the
country with U. Classifieds! Call Sam at

Cruise the Bahamas
Swim. fish .snorkle & party
70' luxury motor yacht from S3751
pp/week. LeavesfromMiami.
The Great Escape Yacht Charers.1jnr.
Call for details (800) 421-6538
FLY FREE! Transporting
documents to Destinations
Worldwide! Send $9.95:
PENNLAND, (NC) Sacramento, CA

ru ti USA
The Worldwide Guide
to Cheap Airfares!
Everything you need to know to get the
cheapest intemational airfares available.
Actnom-wandget aieFlihvsvUSA -free
RUSH $9.95tav Insmider Pblcations,
2124 Kitredge St.,Third Floor
Berkeley. Califormia 94704
Unconditional Moneyback Guarantee

100+ease hook'et lists thousards o
summer jobs anywhere in U.S.
Room, board airfare free. Send
$10.00 to: National Student Financial
Planning Service, P.O. Box 390085,
Cambridge, MA 02139. 30-day
unconditional money back guarantee.
- :2 (D.
Ch Z0 £0 >
O nCw
.St.9 A
$ 14 .956

When you carry MasterCard' you've got a head start in life. You'll be welcomed at over 9 million fine
establishments around the world. You can get cash at nearly 200,000 bank locations and 76,000 ATMs
whenever you need it. And you'll be establishing something invaluable to you in the future: your personal
credit history.
Anyway you look at it, MasterCard is a great card for you to have. Because when you're on
the road to success, you need more than just the wind at your back. . MASTER THE MOMENT'
01992 MasterCard intrmational, Incorporated.

A FIT Md iscoveryT
england '23ngh s superiop clan ho em no Op
Belgium - -c mental breakfst(o course
hulland _ «:ar-cuediioven coachesW n U r
germ-ny «ree cont k backpach
ustria g three couron dinners
o yntcen4city 'end morn le b-
=swilperland S a v '4
(makes your
head spin)

Our discoveries are in
For information & application send $1 (p&h) to:
COVER TEST-315 0 Bristol - Saite 249-U
CostauMes,CA 92626k-1714135409397
CrCOVER TEST 1991. COVER TEST is a registered trademark
PROFESSIONAL RESUME Top quality typeset resumes. Fast tummundotime
20cwps J. Hampton,265 N. Ave.# 10 PsadeaCA911 0I

Back to Top

© 2022 Regents of the University of Michigan