100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

September 27, 2002 - Image 33

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 2002-09-27

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

TOBIN from page 31

jump to the conclusion that
Barenboim's views on Wagner have
influenced his opinion of the Arab-
Israeli conflict, but that would be
unfair. On this subject, both
Barenboim and Said actually make a
great deal of sense.
Wagner's writings and beliefs about
Jews were, as Barenboim says, "mon-
strous." But he draws a correct distinc-
tion between Wagner's personal anti-
Semitism and "the things we have been
forced to associate with his music."
While Wagner saw his operas as an
all-encompassing art form that had
the power to redeem mankind,
Barenboim seems to understand that
his operas are, after all, just music,
albeit great music.
Despite the fact that after Wagner's
death, his family's Bayreuth Festival
performances of his works became asso-
ciated with Nazism (and this tie lingers
in the minds of many Holo-caust sur-
vivors), the notion that performance of
this music today has anything to do
with anti-Semitism is baseless.
Barenboim was in the right about
the foolishness of bans on Wagner's
music but, nevertheless, wrong when
he attempted to foist such perform-
ances on unwilling Israeli audiences
last year.
Yet what applies to Wagner's politics
goes double for Barenboim's own
questionable beliefs.
His gestures of friendship to the
Palestinians may win him peace prizes
but they do nothing to actually
achieve peace. Playing music for the
Palestinians won't make them stop
killing Israelis. Only defeat at the
hands of Jews with guns, not pianos,
seems to have the power to influence
them in that direction.
Barenboim forgets that German audi-
ences thrilled to Beethoven during the
Holocaust, without it having any
impact on their willingness to murder
Jews.
What makes him think his
Palestinian audiences are any differ-
ent? Does the fact that he can hold
marvelous dialogues about Wagner's
art change the fact that Edward Said
is a liar and a supporter of terrorism?
Daniel Barenboim may think his
music will transcend the hatred of the
Middle East. As someone who loves
the music that he plays and conducts
so well, I wish that it could.
The unhappy truth is that no one's
music, not even Daniel Barenboim's,
can drown the sound of homicidal sui-
cide bombers any more than the
sound of Wagner could drown the
screams of the victims of the Shoah.



Make your home look
as good as this rate.

Stretch your home improvement
dollar with one of the best
Home Equity rates around.

With the attractive rate on a Standard Federal
Home Equity Line of Credit, you can get a
handsome sum for home improvements, without
the unsightly interest charges of high-rate credit
card bills. Our Home Equity. Line offers other
benefits as well, including no points or closing
costs* possible tax deductions,** and easy access to
your funds simply by writing a check. So beautify
your, home and your loan. Visit any Standard
Federal location, call 1-877-732-8240, or apply
online at standardfederalbank.com .
Standard Federal Bank. A new way to get there

The Wall Street Journal

'The Annual Percentage Rate (APR) is based on the Prime Rate. Prime is the highest Prime Rate as published in the "Money Rates" section of
on the last publishing day of the calendar month immediately preceding the billing cycle. On August 30, 2002, Prime was 4.75% and the APR on Standard Federal's
Home Equity Line of Credit products varied between 4.00% and 7.75%, depending on your approved commitment amount and product. Prime is a variable rate; as it
changes, the APR on your account will change. The maximum APR is 21 %. A balloon payment will result at the end of the ten-year draw period. Standard Federal's
Home Equity Lines of Credit are limited to owner-occupied, 1-4 family principal residences and are subject to no less than a second lien position on your property
You must carry insurance on the property that secures this loan. Flood insurance required if necessary. There is a $50 annual fee after the first year if you are not a
Credit Exclusives member. See your banker regarding Credit Exclusives membership. Closing costs paid by Standard Federal Bank National Association.are limited to:
appraisal, title insurance, flood certification, and recording fees. Any additional fees or conditions imposed by the city, state, or county that the subject property is

located in will be the borrower's responsibility.
*"Consult your tax advisor concerning the deductibility of interest.

Standard Federal Bank.

Member ABN AMR() Group

Standard
Federal

standardfederalbanlccom

mmil
LENDER

Member FDIC
©2002 Standard Federal Bank NA

gewish.comTmstore

011

Where the Jewish Community Shops!

offering a huge selection of gifts
books, Shabbat & holiday
the Store often for new
Browse
lots
more.
items, kosher gift bdskets and
products!
items and specials. Over 3000

judaica...

exclusive source for all
41:? ' Your
for all simchas. Religious items, jewelry, music,

www.jewish. corn

9/27

2002

33

Back to Top

© 2020 Regents of the University of Michigan