100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

March 22, 1974 - Image 36

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 1974-03-22

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

Historic Brandeis Letters Shed Light on Many
Zionist Matters and Related Jewish Occurrences

Purely
Commentary

(Continued from Page 2)
ish historian. Brandeis acknowledged the
books in a letter to Friedlaender, June 25,
1915, expressing indebtedness.
He was a busy man, involved in many
law suits and in labor arbitration. Yet he
was meticulous in his handling of Zionist
affairs. There was nothing that could be
judged as too trivial for him to tackle per-
sonally. When financial matters were in-
volved he personally went over the figures
penny by penny; when he gave a gift in-
tended for a specific purpose, he accounted
for every detail; when he incurred expenses
and wrote them off with gifts, he indicated
the importance of thorough and correct
bookkeeping. •
This reviewer, in the early Zionist ac-
tivities—he had occasion to be with Bran-
deis several times at Zionist and American
Jewish Congress functions—thought he was
the nut to propose that the name of Theo-
dor Herzl should be honored not on the
anniversary of his death but on his birth-
day. How good to learn from this letter to
Jacob deHaas, Aug. 6, 1915, that Brandeis
had that in mind much earlier: "Dear Mr.
deHaas: When you and Mr. Lipsky take up
the matter of program, I suggest that
Herzl's birthday, May 2, be selected for
the Herzl celebration instead of his death-
day. Note the celebration of Washington's
birthday and Lincoln's birthday, etc."
Jacob DeHaas is believed to have been
the man who interested Brandeis in Zion-
ism. He played a great role in Brandeis'
Zionist activities throughout the lawyer's,

later the Supreme Court - justice's, entire
active life.
There are so many important links with
Jewry and Zionism in these lettess that it
is most difficult to select even the most
important, and the names of the most noted,
even for a lengthy review. There are many
names not to be ignored. An example is that
of Rabbi Samuel Lazaron, who correspond-
e'd with Brandeis, to whom Brandeis sent
his speeches and essays that were pub-
lished as pamphlets — "Zionism and
'Patriotism," "A Call to the Educated Jew"
and "The Jewish Problem." Dr. Lazaron
had become active in behalf of the Federa-
tion of American Zionists as a public
speaker in many communities (he addressed
the Detroit Zionists at one public rally).
But he later became one of the bitterest
enemies of Zionism and to this day, in his
85th year, he remains a Council for Juda-
ism antagonist of the Zionist cause.
Many other names are among those who
corresponded with Brandeis, including lead-
ers of the Bnai Zion, editors—he readily
befriended Yiddish newspapers and writ-
ers—and personalities who interested them-
selves in contacting the eminent lawyer
even before he gained fame as a member
of the highest court in this country.
Because of Judah L. Magnes' important
place in Jewish history, as president of the
Hebrew University, reference to him in a
review of the Brandeis letters cannot be
evaded. There were many letters to Magnes,
in relation to the war relief and other ac-

Israel Delegation to Model

Joseph then made the
sons of Israel swear, "When
God does indeed take note of
For a change, Israel fared
you, you must take my bones well at the United Nations.
up with you from here."
But the United Nations was
—Gen. 50:25.
a model forum — the fourth
Eyebrows—Neckline—Arms—Legs
annual Great Lakes Invita-
Recommended by Physicians
FREE CONSULTATION
tional Model United Nations
GROUP TRAVEL A SPECIALTY
I
SHIRLEY PERSIN
(GLIMUN), held March 13-17
HAMILTON, MILLER, HUDSON
It•gist•n•d El•ctroJogist
& FAYNE TRAVEL CORP.
at the Holiday Inn and Cleary
I
ADVANCE BU _ ILDING
Auditorium, Windsor.
23077 GiEENFIELD
'Room 260
I
Providence iiot.iti ■ Ol
Northfond
The Israeli delegation, in-
PHONE 557-1108
cluding members of the
I
is Years Downtown
557-5145
United Nations Association at
Wayne State University,
walked off with top honors
and — better yet -- not one
Muoic 5ru4 for the 21i3criminaling
condemnation of Israel.
Mark Krauss, head Israel
itt nd Iii Orche3lra
Mack Fill
delegate (from the University
of Michigan), received the
best-delegate award, and the
Israeli delegation was
awarded honorable mention
even though its membership
was not at full strength.
p
Other delegates from the
La
;1.f
the t,
UN association at Wayne
were Laura Trise Basta and
Ronald P. Sandler, adviser,
who recently returned from
114/1./e"
the Hebrew University. A
graduate of WSU, he is for-
mer secretary general of the
UN Association at Wayne.
Mon. S. Thurs. 9:30-7:00
Miss Basta and Krauss
Fr. i :30-6:01
served on the Security Coun-
17540 WYOMING • TEL. 341-1330 • Tues., Wed.
Sat5
. 1 & 0- 30
cil and political committee at
GLIMUN.
•• •
Miss Basta reported that
despite "the usual speeches
Abe Cheraw, Says
by Arab delegates," neither
• •
the model General Assembly

nor Security Council passed
• '
• ONLY ARTISTIC UPHOLSTERERS
any resolutions condemning
GIVES YOU A 10 YEAR
Israel.
• CONSTRUCTION GUARANTEE
In fact, there was uni-
i t ON EVERYTHING WE BUILD.
versal approval for the way
• THAT'S BECAUSE WE
t• BUILD ONLY FINE

the Israel delegation con-
• • FURNITURE. IT COSTS YOU
ducted itself and for its pro-
• NOTHING TO SEE OUR
fessional presentation of ma-
SAMPLES. YOU'LL ENJOY A
terial on Israel's position and
• VISIT WITH OUR DECORATOR.
• •
background to the Middle
East
situation, she said.
.•
Designed as an education
a
CALL LII 4-5900
experience for high school
and college youth, the model
ARTISTIC
UPHOLSTERERS
INC.

United
Nations is meant to
• •
5755 SCHAEFER RD.
teach the young people how

(1 block North of Ford Rd.)
the UN functions and the rea-

Dearborn
LU 4 5900
• sons behind nations' foreign
ABE CHEROW, President
Open Daily 8 o.m. to 5 p.m.
iria••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• OOOOO •••••••••5:
policies.

FACIAL HAIR
PERMANENTLY
REMOVED

3

N.

/Wu

bye

F

358-3642

44

Itd 41

■ 4•41.i:

.„,

Norman Allan & (gat



-

tivities. There was a discordant note over
Magnes' resignation from the Palestine
Executive Committee. On that score, Profs.
Urofsky and Levy appended this note to
Brandeis' letter to Magnes, Aug. 26, 1915:
"On 30 June (1915) Magnes had sub-
mitted his resignation as a member of the
P.E.C., ostensibly over the question of the
congress. He wrote that he did not believe
any single organization could speak for all
of the Jews of America, and he urged that
LDB accept the offer put forward by Louis
Marshall (who was Magnes's brother-in-
law) for a confederated plan. Actually,
there were two unwritten reasons which
prompted Magnes's resignation. One was his
growing commitment to pacifism and his
fear that the Zionists were being pulled
into a pro-Allied position through the ac-
tions of men like Richard Gottheil. At a
time when most members of the American
Jewish community felt very strongly about
the war, Magnes's pacifism struck a dis-
cordant note. The second reason was
Magnes's belief that Zionism was moving
toward the idea of a state for the Jews in
Palestine, while all he wanted was the
`spiritual center' advocated by Ahad HaAm,
with whom Magnes was in close touch. At
first LDB refused to accept the resigna-
tion, and in several letters he completely
ignored it, urging Magnes to continue his
role as a mediator between the Zionists
and the American Jewish Committee.
Upon Magnes's insistence, LDB finally ac-
knowledged the 30 June letter. By this
time, Magnes's departure from the P.E.C.

was not the loss that it might have been
a year earlier."
Judge Julian W. Mack, who was presi-
dent of the Federation of Zionists and who
bolted the Zionist organization when the
Brandeis-Weizmann conflict arose, was a
close associate of Brandeis as indicated in
many of the letters.
Exchanges with Dr. Chaim Weizmann
and an early close relationship between
them also is in evidence.
The role of Nathan Straus also is in-
teresting. He had contributed generously,
and at one point he expressed concern over
relationships with the relief committee be-
cause he believed that the seekers of
philanthropy were after his money.
Brandeis' close relationship with _is
brother, Alfred Brandeis, becomes appar-
ent in the many letters addressed to him.
Alfred shared his brother's deep interest
in Zionism. Then there are a number of
letters from Brandeis to his wife, Alice G.
Brandeis, while Brandeis was away from
Boston in Washington.
The Urofsky-Levy-edited letters conclude
with a reference to the nation having been
electrified by President Woodrow Wilson's
announcement, Jan. 28, 1916, of his nomi-
nation of Brandeis to the Supreme Court.
The forthcoming volumes of Brandeis' let-
ters thus can be anticipated to be in
themselves electrifying. It will be impossi-
ble to fail to read them after the enlighten-
ing experience of having read the Brandeis
letters up to that time.

.

United Nations Gets Top Honors

what we believe to be the relationship with the United
truth in the Middle East Nations.
"You may not be as deeply
situation. But you may learn
something new, or acquire a Involved, or touched by what
better understanding of Is- Israel is, but the learning of
rael's point of view on the knowledge and the acquiring
events that transpired with of understanding and toler-
the Yom Kippur War, ter- ance are the foundations of
"We of the Israeli delega- rorism°, refugees and Israel's peace."
tion know many of you be-
long to delegations which op- 36—Friday, March 22, 1974 THE DETROIT JEWISH NEWS
pose Israel's position — op-
pose her very right of exist-
ence as a nation at this
year's GLIMUN. But perhaps
in your less busy moments
you will read this booklet
and think about Eretz Israel.
Wider
We are not expecting you to
398.6894
Plume
change your country's poli-
cies and positions because of

Most student participants
in the model UN were ad-
mittedly unaware of Israel's
position. In a . letter of intro-
duction to the literature cir-
culated by the Israeli delega.
lion, Krauss wrote:

Photogra 119 aetrD;60‘ks

C611121

People
Make-News

paper place

• Invitations • Gifts • Favors

Prof. ERNEST WINO-
• Stationery • Party Planning
COUR, who holds the Everett
M. Dirksen Chair in cancer
research, has been appointed
WEDDINGS • CONFIRMATIONS
head of the new virology
BAR MITZVAS SWEET 16 & SHOWERS
section at Weizmann Insti-
tute in Rehovot, Israel. Prof.
16300 North Park Drive (at North Park Place)
IZCHAK STEINBERG has.
357 3111
LSouthfield,
Mich.
been appointed head of the
9: 30-4: 30 Mon.-Sat.
institute's department of
chemical physics.

-

Men's Clubs I

BETH EL MEN'S CLUB
will present psychologist Dr.
Sonya K. Friedman at its
Breakfast Club and Discus-
sion Series 10 a.m. March 31
at the temple. Dr. Friedman
will speak on "Divorce and
the Jewish Attitude Toward
It." She is a columnist and
author, anad has appeared
on several television shows.
The. public is invited at no
charge.

There's more neighborli-
ness in a few kind words
than in a whole truck load
of treats.

ail

lig di

v"Our Name Says it all"

SPRING & SUMMER FASHIONS

30% OFF

Store Wide Sale

Sizes 8-18

Open Mon.-Fri. 11-4
Phone 542-4455

13721 W. 11 Mile
1 Block West of Coolidge
Diore Bldg.

Back to Top

© 2021 Regents of the University of Michigan