•

Toynbee, Seeking to Clarify Book,
Reiterates Anti-Zionist Views

World Zionist 'Leader Dies

Obituaries

LONDON, (JTA) — Abraham,
Avadio, who served for many
years as treasurer of the World
Zionist Organization, died here
at 74. Mr. Avadio was associ-
ated for many years in Germany
with Prof. Otto Warburg and
others in furthering the Pales-.
tine Land Development Com-
pany.
He settled in Palestine before
the' outbreak of World War 14
and had come here to dispose
of his private library, intending
to return to Israel later this
year.

NEW YORK, (JTA)—Arnold of the Nazis. To fail to learn by
LEAH MENUCK, 1706 Lee
LOUIS LOWY, 19467 Stans-
Toynbee, British historian who suffering, and to inflict on oth- Place, died March 14. Services at bury, died March 10. Services at
stirred up a controversy by anti-
Hebrew Memorial Chapel. Sur- • Ira Kaufman Chapel. He leaves
Jewish and anti-Zionist views in ers some of the wrongs that vived by her husband, David; his wife, Tillie; a daughter, Mrs.
have
been
inflicted
on
oneself,
his "Study of History," reiter-
two daughters, Mrs. Samuel Ma-- William Borin; a brother, Dr.
ated those views in a letter to are sins into which all human zell and Mrs. Ethel Benjamin; a William Lowy, of Chicago; and
the Jewish Fronter," organ of beings are prone to fall. This is son, Jacob; a brother and eight three grandchildren.
the Labor Zionist movement in one of the most odious and moat grandchildren.
the United States, in reply to desperate characteristics of our
* * *
ISAAC MARX, 14060 Rose-
criticism of him by Marie Syrkin common human nature.
LOUIS BEDERIN, 2468 Waver- lawn, died March 15. Services
in the magazine.
"Everything has its price as ly, died March 12. Services at
at Hebrew Memorial Chapel. He
Toynbee said that it was his well as its compensation. The Menorah Chapel, on Puritan. leaves
five sons, Sigmund, Sol,
view that in the issue between compensation for the tragic Survived by his wife, Anna; two Leo, Solomon
and Jack; two
the palestine Arabs and Zionists, position of being a member of daughters, Frances and Elsie; daughters, Mrs. Max Barth and
the Zionists were in the wrong. a persecuted diaspora is that, two sons, Oscar and Morris; and Mrs. Herman Mifhel; and three
Orthodox Leader Dies
He said that he saw the whole as such, one has the beau role. two sisters.
grandchildren.
* * *
story as a "tragedy," and added The price of the tragic posi-
* *
TEL AVIV, (JTA) — Rabbi
that a great share of the re- tion of being a citizen of a
LOTTIE M. LE VEY, of Miami
Mrs. BESSIE MELT RN SOSNA Meir Karelitz, leader of Poalei
sponsibility for the tragedy sovereign independent state Beach, Fla., died March 11. Serv-
rested on Great Britain, which of Israel, carved out by ices at Ira Kaufman Chapel. died March 2, in New York City. Agudath Israel and elder
was pursuing two incompatible force, first of British and then She leaves her daughter, Mrs. Services and interment were in brother of the late "Hazon
policies during its tenure as the of Israeli arms from a coun- Marion LeVey Roth, of Miami; New York. She leaves her hus- died here at 85 Thousands of
try previously inhabited by a brother, Herman Mittenthal; band, Sam; a daughter, Leona; persons attended his funeral.
mandatory power.
"But the tragedy as I see it, other people, is that, as such, and four sisters, Mrs. Jack Op- a son, Dr. Morton; two grand
goes back further than the date one has exchanged roles with penheim and Mrs. David R. Love, children; and two sisters and a
of the Balfour Declaration. I see one's former persecutors.
of Detroit, Mrs. Evelyn Green- brother, Mrs. Celia Leviant, Til-
earlier stages of it in the con-
"The Jews are still spiritually berg, of New York, and Mrs. Ray lie. Mellen and Sam Mellen, all
of Detroit.
version of both the Zionists and a peculiar people in having had Lewis.
* * *
* *
the Arabs to
Western secular a greater experience of suffering
In loving memory of our be-
ideology, Nationalism. The fan- than any of the rest of us and
MAX H. WISE, '746 Coiling-
SAM SHERMAN, 16160 Indi- loved mother and grandmother,
atical spirit in Nationalism in having learnt from their suf- wood, died March 13. Services at ana, died March 14. Services at Mrs. Fanny (Edelstein) Stolar-
comes, as I see it, from Chris- ferings those deep spiritual les- Ira Kaufman Chapel. He leaves Hebrew Memorial Chapel. Sur- sky, who left us on March 13,
tianity, and Christian and Mus- sons that they have communi= a brother, Sam M., of Cincinnati, vived by his wife, Gizella; a son, 1953 (26 days.in Adar).
lim fanaticism, as well as sated to the Christian-Muslim O.; and two sisters, Mrs. Jack Frank; and a grandchild.
Sadly missed by .aer children
Christian and Muslim charity, half of Mankind. And that is Lewis and Mrs. Adolph Haas,
* * •
and grandchildren.
comes, I believe, from Judaism. why I feel that the tragedy of both of Shaker Heights, 0.
* *
GEORGE SARVER, 24001 Mor-
* * *
"I think Judaism is • like Zionist Israel's sins is greater
ton,
Oak
Park,
died
March
8.
In
ever
loving
memory of our
every other human institution than the tragedy of Nazi Ger-
TOBY GREEN, 3311 W. Chica-
in being a tragic mixture of many's.
go, died March 14. Services at Services at Menorah Funeral dearly beloved son and brother,
Chapel, on Puritan. Survived by Pfc. Robert Paul Weisman, who
good and evil. What is pecu-
"Israel's - spiritual, as well as Ira Kaufman Chapel. She leaves
liar about Judaism is not this; her political, future is bound up four sons, Dr. Lewis, Albert, Sam his wife, Mae; a son, Alan; a was killed- in action in the serv-
it is the potency, in Judaism, with the future of the Palestin- and Manning S.; a daughter, sister, Mrs. Morris Nessel; a ice:of his country on March 20,
of both the t wo conflicting ian Arab refugees. The righting MrS. Charles Mandell; a sister, brother, Barry, and his parents, 1945.
Always missed by his mother
elements and the conversion of the wrongs that these refu- 12 grandchildren and six great Mr. and Mrs. Louis Sarver.
and father and his brother .,
of half the human race—the gees have suffered is, I believe, grandchildren.
S * *
Donald.
* * *
Christian - Muslim half — to Israel's supreme duty and in-
MRS. BESSIE I\JEISEL, 3202
* *
the Jewish spirit, so that the terest. Being human, one is al-
SAM RAIDER, 17367 Kentucky, Leslie, died March 13. Services
In
loving
memory
of our dear
extremes of, good and evil in ways tempted to minimize the died March 14. Services at Ira at Menorah Funeral Chapel, on
Judaism have been reproduced wrong that one has done and Kaufman Chapel. He leaves his Puritan. Survived by her daugh- daughter and• sister, Molly Gu-
in Christianity a n d Islam. the suffering that one has in- wife, Estelle; a son, Jordan; a ter, Mrs. Ben Victor; a son, Sam- rovsky, who left us on March 22,
All three religions have in- flicted. But, of all Man's spir- daughter, Mrs. Alvin Fisher; uel L.; a sister, two brothers, 7 1951.
Sadly missed by her entire
compatible visions of God. itual infirmities, this is the one three brothers and a sister.
grandchildren and two great family.
* * *
They see God both as Love that brings the surest nemesis.
grandchildren,
and as Jealousy."
JEROME M. Z A C K, 40, of
"The only way of ending a
Toynbee opined that the first tragedy
DETROIT JEWISH NEWS 27
is to break the fatal 16170 LaSalle, an optometrist,
*bigots' in history were the Mac-
Friday, March 18, 1955
died Tuesday. Services were at
chain
of
sin
and
suffering;
and
cabees, since he defined bigot as the only way of breaking this is Kaufman Chapel Wednesday.
one who persecutes others on to recognize one's sin and to do -Surviving are his father, Na-
JOSHUA S.
account of his difference from everything possible to atone for than; a brother, Sam, and a
SPERKA
them in religious practice. Then it.
sister,
Mrs.
Ted
Gell.
Author of
This
is
the
only
way
for
he added,' "it is, in fact, tragic
*
*
as well as for Britain and
"ETERNAL
to be either guilty of fanaticism Israel,
SAM- INGER, 1785 Seward.
for
Germany,
because
it
is
the
LIFE"
. or to be the victim of it, and only way for any of us," Toyn- died March 6. Services at Heb-
Popular hand-
the Jews have been alternately bee concludes.
(Unveiling announcements may be in-
book on the laws
rew Memorial Chapel. Survived serted
by mail or by calling The Jewish
of MOURNING,
guilty of it and victims of it
News office, VE. 8-9364. Written an-
by his wife, Mrs Ida Inger.
KADDISH, YIZ-
since the second century B.C.
nouncements must be accompanied by
KOR, and YAHR-
* * *
the name and address of the person
ZEIT. Price $2.50.
"The irony of Jewish history HUC School Offers
Available at all
JACOB CAMEN, 11501 Petos- making the insertion. There is a standard
surely is that the Jews have
of $2.00 for unveiling notices,
Jewish book
key, died March 9. Services at charge
measuring an inch in depth.)
stores and
been the chief sufferers from a Summer Dance Course
Hebrew Memorial Chapel. Sur-
spirit which they themselves
The family of the late Morris
A field-trip course in Jewish vived by two sons, Herman L. and
MENORAH CHAPEL
originally ,kindled. The tragedy
Joseph; three daughters, Mrs.
of recent Jewish history is that, dance, which will take students Phillip Schlussel, Mrs. Ida Ko- Diskin announces the unveiling
3800 PURITAN
instead of learning through suf- to seven countries including Is- valsky and Mrs. Yetta Turick; of a monument in his memory
at
1
p.m.,
Sunday,
March
20,
at
rael,
will
be
offered
this
sum-
fering, the Jews should have
12 grandchildren and 19 great- Beth Tefilo Emanuel Cemetery,
done to others, the Arabs, what mer by Hebrew Union Educa- grandchildren.
Woodward, between 8 and 9 Mile
had been done to them by the tion School, teacher-training de-
* * *
part ment of
Rds. Rabbi Goldman will offici-
Nazis.
LOUIS MANDELL, 17083 Joy, ate. Relatives and friends are
the Hebrew
"Though I was careful to Union College-
died March 9. Services at Heb- asked to attend.
bring out the Zionists' innocence Jewish Institute
* * *
rew Memorial Chapel. Survived
of the Nazis' cold-blooded, sys- of Religion. The
by his wife, Anna; two sons, Leo
The family of the late Arthur
tematic 'genocide' and the dis- course will be
and Edward; five daughters, Selman announces the unveiling
parity in numbers between the conducted by
Mrs. John Davis, Mrs. Harry Rif- of 'a monument in his memory
Jewish victims of the Nazis and Dvora Lapson,
fenburg, Mrs. Frank Wyner, Mrs. at 12:30 p.m., Sunday, March 27,
the Arab victims of the Zionists, dance author-
Harry
Kideckel and Mrs. Joseph at Clover Hill Park Cemetery.
I am sure I am right in holding ity, choreogra-
Ellison; one sister; 15 grand- Rabbi Lehrman will officiate.
that degrees of sin and tragedy pher, dancer
children and two great grand- Relatives and friends are asked
are not determined by the num- and member of
children
to attend.
bers of the souls concerned. Sin the School of
* * *
3unerat
and tragedy are done and suf- Education fac-
REBECCA ROSENZWEIG,
fered by each of us individually; ulty, who will
1947.4
Rutherford,
died
March
Dvora
iipson
they are not, and cannot be, lead a dance-
MONUMENTS
• CENTRALLY LOCATED
10. Services at Hebrew Memorial
collective.
seminar tour in cooperation
Only Jewish Chapel
Nor is -the tragedy of the Pal- with the International Folk Chapel. Survived by three sons,
By Karl C. Berg
the Northwest district
-estinian Arabs' sufferings at the Dance Council, the Israel Folk Wolf, Abraham and Solomon;
Max Wrotslaysky
Monument Works
hands of the Israelis a peculi- Dance Commission and the two, -daughters, • Mrs. s Bertha
• SPACIOUS. FACILITIES
arly Jewish tragedy; it is a c_om- Traite D'Union Universitaire. Stahl. and Mrs. Harry Green;
Owner
and
three
grandchildren.
•
Distinctive
Largest Jewish Chapel
mon human tragedy; like the The group will leave America
S. * *
Monuments
in Detroit
Jews own sufferings at the hand July 2 and return on Sept 7.
Reasonably Priced
SAMUEL WENNER, 3301 W.
$201 JOY ROAD
Grand, died March 11. Services
PURITAN cor. DEXTFR
Corner Wildemere
at Hebrew Memorial Chapel.
TY. 6-0196
Survived by his wife, Rose; three
UNiversity 1 7700
sons, Harold, David and Ben-
C. w. Moore, mgr.
jamin; two sisters and four
grandchildren.
* *
BERTHA SUTKIN, 3378 Stur-
died March 7. Services
The Excellent Facilities of The. Ira Kaufman tevant,
at Ira Kaufman Chapel. She
leaves her son, Murray; and two
Chapel are Known to Our Community,
daughters, Mrs. Ida Weinberg
17125-27 VAN DYKE AVENUE
and are Available at a Cost
and Celia; six grandchildren and
Opposite main entrance shi• Mt. Olivet Cemetery
two great grandchildren.
* * *
Within Reach of All
DETROIT 34, MICE-i.
TW. 2-6200
A N N A GOLDST.BaN, 20522
Ardmore, died March 10. Serv-
DESIGNERS • MANUFACTURERS
ices at Ira Kaufman Chapel_
She leaves her husband, Jacob;
MONUMENTS • GRAVE MARKERS • MAUSOLEUMS
FUNERAL DIRECTORS
two sons, Fred and Harold; a
GRANITE • BRONZE • MA RBLE
daughter,
Mrs.
Howard
Levitt;
9419 Dexter at Edison
WE EREC.T WORK ANY PLACE IN THE UNITED STATES
a brother, two sisters and five
4-8020
grandchildren.

.

In Memoriam

a

tk

-

-

Monument

Unveilings

MENORAH

Chapel

I

-

BROWS & IIIIISCH CO.

The Irk. Kaufman Chapel