(. PAGE TWO THE MICHIGAN DAILY TUESDAY, AUGUST 4, 1953 ---- Third Class Citizens MUCH CRITICISM has emerged this sum- mer of Miss Snead- Teacher of fictious history and propa- ganda . . Teacher by rote . . Teacher not out of interest or sincerity or concern for those who shall be taught . . . Teacher marking time till a suitable gen- tleman proposes or . . . Teacher, because she is incapable of a better paying job .. . Once having recognized that Miss Snead exists, labelled her and taken note of the blight she is upon the teaching profession, it seems time to call attention to the school system that allows Miss Snead to parasi- tically feed upon the minds of youth and/or demands she do so and the nation that al- lows such school systems to operate and/or demands they be so. The "and/or" qualification represents an unsolved "chicken and the egg" ques- tion. Does the American public school system make Miss Sneads or simply toler- ate them for lack of better material? Does the United States insist upon such school systems or simply ignore their failings? The teacher is no less a third class citi- zen today than he was in pioneer days. The 19th century emphasis on readin', ritin' and 'rithmatic has only lately been lessened by attention to shop and trade skills. Yet the public schools have done little for the exceptional student. For the less academic minded we have supplied mech- anical instruction and commercial courses. But "the above-average student learns despite the teacher" is an oft-quoted, fear- fully apt phrase. AS MERE custodians our teachers are per- haps, not underpaid. As teachers, if they dare to be teachers, if we allow them to be teachers, they are distressingly underpaid. We spend billions for destruction. We spend billions too, to aid disaster victims, to feed the starving, to rehabilitate the broken. Government funds to aid education are bacteria in a drop in the bucket of U.S expenditures. No parent would hesitate a moment to call a doctor in to set Johnny's broken leg. Of what use is Johnny's healthy body, If his mind is undeveloped. No parent would trust his child's bodily health to an incompetent, inadequately trained layman. It certainly seems a para- dox then that the same parent so willingly trusts his child's intellect to that third class citizen, the underpaid teacher. If one day, Americans wake from their lethargy and demand teachers be 'first class citizens, as highly trained as doctors or dentists, with the same type of internship, then we shall have to pay them accordingly. * * * ONE RATHER wealthy St. Louis commun- ity underwent such an awakening. Dis- satisfied with the calibre of public school instruction, they called in a group of ex- perts and asked, "what shall we do?" "Treat your teachers as you would doc- tors and lawyers and pay them accordingly" their experts told them. The St. Louis community set up a $10,- 000 a year salary schedule and the result was a staff consisting entirely of teach- ers with doctorate degrees. There is a teacher shortage throughout the nation. When our elementary schools open next fall there will be 70,000 teachers too few. School teaching has fallen far behind the other professions in prestige, according to a Life Magazine editorial. "Teacher colleges concentrated on methodology and neglected subject matter; too much "how" and not enough "what." A breakdown made last winter of the Se- lective Service College Qualification Test results showed students of education pulled in the lowest scores of all. Life cites a campaign, spearheaded by Harvard, aimed toward overhauling our public school training. p* - * THE EMPHASIS is on subject matter, more than on methodology: after four years of general study, in the liberal arts or the sciences, selected holders of B.A. de- grees are given a higher degree in teaching after a fifth year of study, part of which included a practical internship in the pub- lic schools. In the East 29 colleges have joined Harvard in this undertaking, Life re- ports. Unfortunately, the University does not seem to have taken the same attitude to- ward the teaching problem. Instead of raising standards they have lowered them. Recently they lowered the average for admission to the education school from 2.5 to 2.25. There has been talk locally of even more emphasis on methodology rather than sub- ject matter, discussion of a degree which would allow a teacher to teach any subject regardless of her major field. To anyone dedicated to the cause of im- proving education, such steps can offer only one consolation. Things might eventually become so bad, that only forward steps could follow. Such medicine would be pretty dif- ficult to swallow and no one with an ounce of backbone will swallow it without a pretty big struggle. Those who have remained apathetic or «.L.. ~~~u - ..«. :i...«...A F... 41n1i m t PERFORMER'S VIEWPOINT: Milhaud's Quintet No. 1 w ith Piano By ROBERT COURTE (Associate Professor of Viola and Chamber Music and Violist of the Stanley Quartet) DURING THE YEARS of their individual careers members of the Stanley Quartet have quite often met people who were apolo- getic about not being able to appreciate a contemporary chamber work. This cate- gory of concert-goers whose musical back- ground is probably limited to the period of impressionism wants some explanation of how to listen to modern music and also to know the reason for its existence. Since a vast subject of this kind would take con- siderable time to explore, our very first approach is generally to relate the evolution of architecture, painting, and literature, to music. This elementary and summarized article is to explain why our contemporary composers do not write music sounding like works written a century ago. Those listeners should know, first of all, that the greatness of a composer resides in his continuous creation; that he might be in- fluenced by some strong musical personality and become what we could call his disciple, but his music should be personal. To men- tion only a few names: Stravinsky, Bartok, Hindemith, Honegger, and Milhaud, write in a personal manner. They have a style of their own and although they belong to the same era it would be difficult to detect any similarity common to them all. Darius Milhaud is considered amongst the most prominent musicians of our day. The Aix-en-Provence-born composer spent the early years of his life in the midst of a splendid tradition, a descendant of an old family.established in one of France's most beautiful surroundings since before the Christian era. During his youth this avant-garde com- poser had to suffer the hearing of what we still consider great works, sometimes fight- ing against his violent reaction while listen- ing, for example, to Wagner. At sixteen, af- ter attending a performance of Parsifal, he said, "Je me suis ennuy6 a mourir." If he has to be judged now upon his feeling about that work, we ought to be indulgent when considering the duration of that extremely long opera (six hours including supper!!). Milhaud does not think Wagner the great genius a fair majority of composers think he is. This majority does not include Verdi, as we know, but it is doubtful that without the advent of Wagner, Othello and Falstaff would have emanated from his pen. Com- petition proved helpful in this case. Obvi- ously Milhaud was not to become one of Wagner's followers. His style, briefly men- tioned, is a combination of simple diatonic melodies with polytonal counterpoint which can produce a highly dissonant effect upon untrained ears. THE PICTURESQUE Provence seems al- ways to guide his charming and distin- guished melodic line. Although the master has been ill all his life, his music is never morbid, but, on the contrary, always alert, vivacious, and good-humored. A performer who, in my opinion, is a creator, will be- come Milhaud's good friend if he does not take his tempi too slowly. A slightly -faster pulsation than indicated is always very welcome. While composing he occasionally uses the keyboard but only for purposes of final checking. Stravinsky states that compos- ers should always be in contact with "la matiere sonore." Milhaud does not think so nor does Hindemith who completed the finale of his 2nd string trio enroute from Germany to Italy. So both methods are, I assume, matters of personal conception. The quintet with piano to be performed tonight by the Stanley Quartet and Ben- ning Dexter, is not in reality his first work written for this combination of instruments since excerpts of the ballet "La creation du monde" have been arranged for the same instrumentation by the composer some twenty years ago. The quintet was written for the centennial of Mills College, Califor- nia where Milhaud teaches composition. This is another work which gives the performer opportunity to trust not only his knowledge but also his musical instinct. To a person who was asking how we successfully put to- gether works of that caliber, I gave the usual explanation of how we carefully study the score, how we "dissect" the work, and finally reach an agreement on its interpre- tation. And yet, regardless of the thoroughness of preparation, it is impossible to analyze ev- ery detail since certain phases of perform- ance must be left to the inspiration of the moment. A meticulous analysis of these de- tails would preclude the spontaneity of the presentation. It would be, I am afraid, like the millipede who once tried to determine the order in which his legs moved when walking and consequently found himself suddenly paralyzed. "Better Take This One Tn For Questioning" vES EAtT -I BttL SKt - ~ .* 1N " 'I 1 11 L://N / '. DAILY OFFICIAL BULLETIN MATTER OF FACT: Taft and Eisenhower N JCURRENT (mOUVIESi~ f t At the State.... LILI, with Leslie Caron and Mel Ferrer. F YOU ARE going to accept this film at all, it must be a fairy tale in which the evil spell that has been cast over the enchanted frog-prince is broken at last by a Cinderella princess who loves-him because she has learned how to penetrate to his beautiful soul. Since the film for the most part demon- strates its right to be approached on such a level, it is good summer.fare. In Techni- color, it has some nice sets and above- average performances. Careful not to be a fantasy on the explicit level (tidily seg- menting off its choreographic "dream" se- quences), it remains pleasantly sentimen- tal and light-headed, and certainly not to be taken for real. The plot involves a French orphan girl of sixteen, played by Leslie Caron, who wan- ders into a carnival (a milieu common to at least three pictures seen here in the last month.) This carnival features among oth- ers a prestidigitator "extrordinaire," played by Jean Pierre Aumont, and a puppeteer, played by Mel Ferrer. The magician has all the obvious charms and pays the girl the ob- vious attentions. The puppet master on the other hand is cussed mean, except when he is manipulating his several dolls. It is through the dolls, of course, that the puppe- teer-frogprince eventually makes his true feelings known to the girl. Before this, however, the troubled or- phan becomes involved in the puppet world, her childlike "innocence" making her a pe- culiarly engaging Fran to the puppet man's Kukla and Ollie. Nobody needs to be told that two entrepreneurs from the Follies Paris will be set on their heels by this per- formance, and rush to sign the pair. The plot resolves as the girl dances her way through the curtain of illusion to discover the very human lover behind. In many ways, the puppets are the stars of the film. Cleverly characterized, they make for fine Technicolor close-ups and provide what are easily the best scenes of the picture. Direction and choreography are both by Charles Walters, who seemed to have a good overall sense of film rhy- thm, but was somewhat too cautious in de- lineating the dream from the reality. Consequently, the two dance sequences that depicted "illusion" tended to be gar- ish and explicit, overcompensating for "real" events which had drifted into a dull sameness. The choreography, however, may be commended for its brave attempt to advance the plot integrally. As a whole, the picture has unity, some good color, and much lyric charm. -Bill Wiegand The Daily Official Bulletin is a official publication of the University of Michigan for which the Michigan Daily assumes no editorial responsi- bility. Publication in it is construc- tive notice to all members of the University. Notices should be sent in TYPEWRITTEN form to Room 3510 Administration Building before 3 p.m. the day preceedingupublication (be- fore 11 a.m. on Saturday). TUESDAY, AUGUST 4, 1953 VOL. BXIII, No. 28-S Notices School of Business Administration. Students from other Schools and Col- leges intending to apply for admis- sion for the fall semester should secure application forms in Room 150. School of Business Administration Building as soon as possible. Students in the prebusiness program in the College of Literature, Science, and the Arts should secure the forms from a prebusiness adviser and return the completed forms to him. Veterans eligible for education and training allowance under Public Law 550 (Korea G.I. Bill), whether they have received Certificate for Education and Training, (VA Form 7-1993) or not must sign Monthly Certification of Train- ing, VA Form 7-1996a, in the Office of Veterans' Affairs, 555 Administration Building, between July 31 and August 6. For the convenience of those veter- ans whose Summer Session classes end August 1, 1953 the Office of Veterans' Affairs will be open the morning of Saturday, August 1 from 8 a.m. to 12 noon. Lectures TUESDAY, AUGUST 4 Lecture, auspices of the Department of Civil Engineering. "Current Progress in Steel Construction." T. R. Higgins, Director of Engineering for the Amer- ican Institute of Steel Construction. 4:00 p.m., Room 311, West Engineering Building Linguistic Forum. "Society and Lin- guistic Change." Alf Sommerfelt, Pro- fessor of Linguistics, University of Os- 1. 7:30 p.m., Rackham Amphitheater. Lecture, Institute for Mathematics Teachers, "Mathematics in Agriculture," by D. M. Kinch of Michigan State Col- lege. 11:00 a.m., Room 130, Business Ad- ministration Building. Lecture, Institute for Mathematics Teachers, "The Role of Mathematical Models in an Empirical Science (Con- tinued)," Clyde H. Coombs, Assoc. Prof. of Psychology, University of Michigan, 7:30 p.m., East Conference Room, Rack- ham Building. Sociedad Hispanica-Dr. Jose Vilar- Bonet, Professor of Medicine, University of Barcelona, Spain, will give a talk in Spanish on the subject, "Aspectos cul- turales de la region catalana," Wednes- day. August 4, at 8 p.m., East Confer- ence Room, Rackham Bldg. Open to the public. Special Psychology Colloquium: Prof. Gustav Bergmann, Visiting Professor in Philosophy, from the State Univer- sity of Iowa, will speak on "The Logic of Psychology." Wednesday, August 5, 4:00 p.m., Angell Hall, Auditorium D. Amiya Chakravarty on The Art and Action of Gandhi: a critical view of Gandhi and the role of India in world politics. Visiting professor of English and author of The Indian Testimony, Mr. Chakravarty will speak from his in- timate knowledge of both Gandhi and India. He will concentrate on the ends and means of Gandhi, and on the tech- nique which has been called Conquest by Love. Sponsored by SRA and com- mittee for a Student Fellowship of Reconciliation. Lane Hall, Thursday, August 6 at 8:30. Academic Notices Doctoral Examination for Richard William Kebler, Physics; thesis: "The Excitation of Spectra of Highly Ionized Aluminum Atoms in a Low Pressure Spark," today, 2038 Randall Laboratory at 2:00 p.m. Chairman, W. W. McCor- mick. Doctoril Examination for Paul El- len, Psychology; thesis: "The Com- pulsive Nature of Abnormal Fixations,, today, 7611 Haven Hall, at 2:00 p.m Chairman, N. R. F. Maier. Doctoral Examination for Eric Bel Hoteling, Pharmaceutical Chemistry thesis: "Polycycic Quaternary Ammon- ium Salts," Wednesday, August 5, 252 Chemistry Bldg., at 2:00 p.m. Chairman F. F. Blicke. tet No. 1 (with piano) following. The Beethoven Quartet in C-sharp minor, op. 131 will be heard during the second half of the concert. Student Recital. Verena Stelps, Pi- anist, will present a recital in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Music at 8:30, Wednesday evening, August 5 in the Rackham Assembly Hall. It will in- clude the works of Bach, Beethoven, Ravel and Brahms. The recital will be open to the general public without charge. Exhibitions Museum of Art, Alumni Memorial Hall. Popular Art in America (June 30 -August 7). General Library. First Floor Corridor. Incunabula: Books Printed in the Fif- teenth Century. Kelsey Museum of Archaeology. Gill- man Collection of Antiques of Palestine. Museums Building, rotunda exhibit. Steps in the preparation of ethnolo- gical dioramas. Michigan Historical Collections. Mi- chigan, year-round vacation land. Clements Library. The good, the bad, the popular. Law Library. Elizabeth II and her em- pire. Architecture Building. Michigan Chil- dren's Art Exhibition. University High School. Childrens' Books from Fifty Countries. Events Today The Lydia Mendelssohn Box Office is open today from 10 a.m. until 5 p.m A few tickets are available for the Monday night, August 10th, perform- ance of the opera, The Tales of Hoff- mann, presented by the Department o Speech and School of Music. Square and Folk Diincing, Lane Hall, this evening atF7:30-10:00. Everyone wel- come. Coming Events This week in the Lydia Mendelssohn Theatre Thursday, Friday and Satur day, August 6, 7 and 8, the Department of Speech and the School of Music wil present Jacques Offenbach's fantastic opera, The Tales of Hoffman. Music di rection is by Josef Blatt with the stag direction by Valentine Windt and the choreography by Betty Pease. All per formancesrbegin promptly at 8 p.m Late comers will not be seated unti after the prologue. THE ROMANTIC Hero was n( longer the knight, the wander ing poet, the cowpuncher, the avi ator, nor the brave young distric attorney, but the great sales man ager, who had an Analysis o Merchandizing Problems on hi glass topped desk, whose title o nobility was "go-getter." --Sinclair Lewis By JOSEPH' ALSOP WASHINGTON -- The curious story of the relationships be- tween Robert A. Taft and Dwight D. Eisenhower tells a lot about Taft, as well suggesting the kind of gap that can be produced by Taft's absence from the Senate. It must be remembered that these two, men, who became such intimate partners, began with the profoundest suspicions of each other. For Taft, even before Eisen- hower made his great decision, the General was always a potential rival and, what was worse, a mem- ber of "George Marshall's group" in the Army. This was the Sena- tor's shorthand for the more world-minded military officers, whom he frankly intended to re- place if he got the chance with "Douglas MacArthur's group." And for Eisenhower, by the same token, Taft was always the symbol of wrong-headedness about America's world role. The threat that Taft would receive the Republican nomination was the lever, in truth, that forced Eisenhower into politics. Despite the good sportsmanship with which Taft accepted the dis- appointment of his highest hopes, the experiences of the campaign hardly made matters better be- tween the two men. Appearances were preserved, but that was all. The real state, of their relations was disclosed-indeed was luridly illuminated-by Taft's bitter at- tack on Eisenhower's choice of Martin Durkin as Secretaxy of Labor. * * * IN SOME SENSE, however, this was a turning point. The pro- fessional Republican politicians hastened to point out to the Presi- dent-elect that if he did not choose to work with Sen. Taft, he must get ready to fight him to the death. They added that a fight with Taft would rend the party asunder and cripple the President in Congress. Meanwhile, one sus- pects, Sen. Taft was also impress- ed by the failure of any of his usual allies to support his Durkin statement. At any rate, from this inci- dent the decision clearly arose, in the minds of both these men, that they must work together somehow. At first it cannot have been easy. But before long mutual respect was born and then a warm liking. The story has been told before, of how Taft remarked, almost with an air of surprise, that he was finding Eisenhower "a man of good will." What was more in- teresting and revealing was the . rapid change in Eisenhower's as- sessment of Taft. Previously, Eis- enhower had only known what may be called Taft's public face. f Exposure to Taft's working face produced an entirely different es- timate of the man. This was, indeed, one of the keys to Sen. Taft's political career. When on the stump, when involved in public debate, Taft did not imi- tate other politicians in speaking softly and walking carefully. Part- ly because of his essential honesty, partly because of his combative- ness, Taft spoke more strongly, he expressed his views in a more extreme manner, he was more than usually careless of those who might disagree with him. HIENCE the people who only saw Taft's public face were sharp- ly divided, into those who agreed with him, who were passionate in their admiration, and those who disagreed, who were almost equal- ly passionate in their distrust. Taft at work, in contrast, showed all his deeper qualities of courage and determination, intelligence, practicality, unremitting industry. Close-to, even more than in pub- lic, the style of Taft the man, the humor, the absence of the slight- est trace of stuffed shirt, also showed very strongly. These were the qualities that made Taft a great and deeply respected legislator-one of the few members of Congress in our times, indeed, to make an enor- mous national place for himself by the simple performance of his legislative duties and func- tions. And Taft's largeness, his capacity for work, his unvarying command of facts and situations, ended by producing an aston- ishing reversal at the White House. Where there had been fear and suspicion, there was not positive dependence. From time to time there might be a rub, to be sure, as there was over the budget. But by and large, the President came to depend upon the Senator in a way that very few Presidents of the past have depended upon members of their party in Con- gress. It was curious to observe the almost lost feeling that was manifested at the White House, . hen Sen. Taft's illness forced him to abandon the Senate lead- ership, and he was no longer there to rely on. In these last weeks the Presi- dent has begun to take upon him- self the normal Presidential duties of party leadership, which. he had previously omitted. Like a ship captain deprived of a pilot, Eisen- hower has perforce begun to do his own navigating. The result, it must be added, has been ex- tremely impressive. Yet that does not alter the fact that the Senate without'Taft is a much smaller place, while the White House with- out Taft has been a much less happy and self-confident place. (Copyright, 1953, N.Y. Her. Trib., Inc. 4 E 46 .4 fr ,I / IL n t f c f is )f IetteA4 TO THE EDITOR The Daily welcomes..communications from its readers on matters .f general interest, and will publish all letters which are signed by the writer and in good taste. Letters exceeding 300 words in length, defamatory or libelous letters, and letters which for any reason are not in good taste will be condensed, edited or withheld from publication at the discretion of the editors. British in Kenya. . To the Editor: Is FE+ MUSIC+ MR. BERGE'S letter on "British- in Kenya" is a complete dis-e appointment. Before telling yous what conclusion I have drawnr about his article let me point outE some of the salient weaknesses int his argument. He finds it difficultt to differentiate the liberal from£ the conservative reactionary im- perial British. Please note that mil- lions of the British people are fighting hard for African self- determination; note also that it is the reactionary members of 10 Downing Street that make desper- ate attempts to enslave Africans. Mr. Berge pointed out that the priviledged Africans exploit the rest; this I confirm with reserva- tion. It is true all over the world, some people use their privilege to prey on others. Do not forget of course that the British Officers nourish such exploitation. I pro- mise you that when the Govern- ment shall be in our hands we4 shall pay such people in their own coins. The Kenya natives are still loyall to the British for two reasons. The first, ignorance of British objec- tives; the second, patience while they await British change of mind. In a society whose moral values are high, patience as a virtue is not misfitting. If Africans establish "Peoples Democracy" according to Mr. Ber- ge, whose fault is it? If the West provide the "heaven" Africans seek for, will there be any sense in looking for it elsewhere? I am sure democracy and racism are incompatible. Can you explain why the British practice both at the same time? To'think that Africans who demand independence are necessarily onmmunist inspired is, come to Gold Coast for develop- ment. It is doubtful that you are willing to accomodate other peo- ple as they do you. Everywhere the European goes he wants to own everything as "private property;" sooner or later there would be no more new "private property" on earth. Then he will be compelled to shift to another planet. Isn't it time for the Europeans to change attitude and learn to live with oth- er peoples of the world? I believe it is. -F. Chigbu-Ememe * * * McCarthy . .. To The Editor: THE LIBERAL WING of the Democratic Party, because of the principle of self-justified ex- pectations, is more responsible for McCarthyism than is the Senator himself. Had the situation not been made worse by the last Ad- ministration's desire to conceal, rather than uproot Communism in Government, by its desire to dis- credit him rather than refute his charges, the Senator would never have emerged from obscurity. Nor would McCarthyism be the world- wide myth it is if the Democrats would try to find, if possible, some other campaign issue or some con- vincing explanation for political defeat. For example, Tydings was beaten, not by McCarthyism, but by being identified with an un- popular state sales tax issue and by the backfiring of some anti- Negro campaign propaganda. It could be, also, that some Republi- cans are too faint-hearted regard- ing both McCarthyism and the far more dangerous McCarranism. The danger of McCarthyism is not the danger from an instinctive headline-hunter with infirm or- ganizational backing, but the re- _4 '# At Hill Auditorium... Robert Noehren, Organist. THE PROGRAM which Mr. Noehren play- ed Sunday afternoon consisted of the Fantasy and Fugue in G Minor by Bach, Three Chorale Preludes by Brahms, and the much-heralded Variations and Fugue on an Original Theme by Max Reger. The Bach work is one of that composer's masterpieces, full of bold, unexpected dis- sonances and exciting contrapoint. Mr. Noe- hren conveyed the meaning of the composi- tion perfectly. The fugue was played with unusual but very effective dynamics, with one level of volume used until well into the work. This seemed to bring into relief the structural aspects of the fugue better than music, show this composer in a very dif- ferent light from that to which we are accustomed. They are short contrapuntal fantasies on simple chorale tunes, prob- ably intended as counterparts to the Chorale Preludes of Bach. They are very beautiful pieces, and make one wonder what sort of music Brahms would have composed had he lived longer. Mr. Noeh- ren's performance of the Brahms, too, was excellent, though I disagreed at times with the registrations he used. The composition by Max Reger is a truly impressive one. Even on first hearing the logic and mastery of the work were appar- ent, and repeated listenings would undoubt- edly be very rewarding. Reger makes use in this work of a curious sort of chromaticism which is n+t naricnarly reminiscent of anv Sixty-Third Year Edited and managed by students of the University of Michigan under the authority of the Board in Control of Student Publications. Editorial Staff Harland Britz........ .Managing Editor Dick Lewis.......,.......Sports Editor Becky Conrad..............Night Editor Gayle Greene....,,........Night Editor Pat Roelofs.............. Night Editor Fran Sheldon............Night Editor Business Staff Bob Miller..,.........Business Manager Dick Alstrom.... Circulation Manager Dick Nyberg .......... Finance Manager Jessica Tanner.... Advertising Associate Bnh Kovas. . Advertising Associate 4' + I