PAGE FOUR THE MICHIGAN DAILY WEDNESDAY, MAY 4, 1955 PAGF.~ vrn~it THE MICHIGAN DAILY WEDNESDAY, MAY &, 1955 COMPETITION NO REASON: U. S. Should Build Army According to Necessity "We Interrupt This News To Bring You The Latest Chapter Of "John's Other Amendment'-" SHOCK TREATMENT: Delinquency Films Need More Realistic Endings By ERNEST THEODOSSIN Daily Movie Critic 1UVENILE DELINQUENCY is now being displayed in a current MGM * release. "Blackboard Jungle," the melodramatic story of school- room hoodlums. In many respects, "Blackboard Jungle" closely resembles Stanley Kramer's 1954 production, "The Wild One," which presents in docu- mentary fashion a tale of motorcycle gangs that terrorize a small DAILY OFFICIAL BULLETIN MILITARY MANPOWER should be developed along lines of necessity rather than along lines of competition. A proposed defense cut would give General Matthew B. Ridgway 146,000 men less than he has planned for in his armed services develop- ment plan. Opponents of the defense cut have argued that Chinese Communists would be en- couraged to make stronger military moves as well as increase their military strength. But even if the Communists do increase their army, the United States is prepared to increase its manpower when necessary. Pearl Harbor taught the Government the lesson about un- dermanned armed forces. A recent National Guard alert showed that manpower could be gathered within a short time, thereby lessening the need for a larger force. Manpower must necessarily be increased but in proportion to technological advancement. THE NEED FOR SURPASSING Russia's mili- tary strength has been brought up numerous times. Although we are in competition with the Soviet Union in many ways, this competition must not cause the United States Government to increase its military establishment only to outdistance the Russians. If this premise were used, the United States, just by sheer popula- tion, could never outdistance Russian manpow- er, if the Russians intend to recruit every able man they could. The strength of the armed services not only depends on the number of men, but also their placement according to where they are needed. Fifty-thousand strategically placed soldiers can be of more use than 150,000 soldiers scattered at random. SINCE THE DEFENSE CUT has been sug- gested, General Ridgway should be able, if necessary, to rearrange his plans according to the number of men he will be working with. If the general feels that his present military num- bers are inadequate, there should be good rea- son for increasing our armed services. At present, competition with Russia seems to be the only reason against a defense cut. Press- ing world conditions are also important in con- sidering military increases, but does a Far East- ern stalemate require a defense cut? It does not. It does require a keen awareness and read- iness for increases if they are needed, when they are needed. --David Kaplan Statistics Back Up Vaccine Effectiveness FAITH is as easy to lse as it is difficult to win. As a result of the recent outbreak of polio, from still undetermined causes, a great deal of faith has been thrown out the window, causing science to suffer from a failure of the public to examine statistics. We cannot afford to ignore statistics in con- sidering the success of the Salk vaccine. After inoculation of thousands of children last sum- mer it was revealed that the vaccine is 85-90 per cent effective, with little or no harmful effects from the vaccination. Considering this statistical success of the vaccine, it appears too much emphasis is being placed on the 29 paralytic cases reported of the 300,000 children who received an inoculation. A board of experts, of which Dr. Salk was a member, decided this year that it is safe to go ahead with nation-wide inoculations. As for the Cutter Laboratories' production, of the vaccination (the preparation to which many attribute the outbreak on the West Coast), judgment must necessarily be withheld until further investigation can be attained. -Lew Hamburger LETTERS TO THE EDITOR TODAY AND TOMORROW By WALTER LIPPMANN WHEN, AS IN the affair of the two differing replies to Chou's statement about Formosa, a mistake has been made, has been admitted, and has been corrected, the ordinary and sport- ing thing to do is to forget it. But both in Europe and in Asia we are being drawn into vast and intricate diplomatic activity. The mistake made in the State Department a week ago last Saturday-when the President was away on his farm and the Secretary was away on his island-was very disturbing indeed.' For it showed that on a matter of great con- sequence the Department had not been in- structed and did not know what was in the Secretary's mind. Needless to say, diplomacy cannot be effi- cient if the State Department and the foreign service have to act not on clear instructions but on their own assumptions, as they did that Saturday morning, about what are the Secre- tary's purposes and policies. AS MR. DULLES conceives the office of Secretary of State, such a lack of under- standing is almost unavoidable. He treats him- self not as the top executive of our foreign affairs but as the operator. His relations with the President, his relations with Congress and his meetings with Foreign Ministers, take up .so much of his time and energy that he can- not pay anything like sufficient attention to the administration of our foreign affairs. This operating procedure will become im- possibly inefficient in the period of intense diplomatic activity which is now opening. We are about tp be engaged in critical diplomatic encounters and negotiations at all the key points on the 'borderland of the Communist orbit-in that great semicircle which runs from Japan and South .Korea, through For- mosa, Viet Nam and Southeast Asia, through the Middle East to Austria and Germany. The problems are enormously complicated and they are very much inter-related. They de- mand coherent and consistent direction from the center, from Washington. President Eisen- hower is not a Roosevelt or a Wilson who means to be his own Secretary of State. Under Eisen- hower, and in the global complexity of our Sixty-Fifth Year Edited and managed by students of the University of Michigan under the authority of the Board in Control of Student Publications. Editorial Staff Eugene Hartwig......................Managing Editor Dorothy Myers....... ................City Editor Jon Sobeloff........................Editorial Director Pat Roelofs.................Associate City Editor Becky Conrad.........................Associate Editor Nan Swinehart........................Associate Editor Dave Livingston....,,,..........sports Editor Hanley Gurwin................Associate Sports Editor Warren Wertheimer............Associate Sports Editor Ros Shlimovitz................. women's Editor Janet Smith................Associate Women's Editor John Hirtzei. ........... Chief Photographer Business Staff Lois Pollak........ ....Business Manager Phil Brurskill..........Associate Business Manager Bi1 Wise........................Advertising Manager Mary Jean Monkoski................Finance Manager Telephone NO 23241 affairs, the office of Secretary of State cannot be left vacant most of the time. There has to be someone of the highest authority in Washington who is in continual and steady command of all the diplomatic sectors. I have heard an old hand in the for- eign service say that he wished the airplane, or at least the Secretary's airplane, had never been invented. THE CHARACTER of the problems which we shall now be dealing with requires a deep reappraisal in Washington of some of the basic conceptions of our post-war diplomacy. We are being drawn into momentous negotiations, and it is only too painfully obvious that both in Europe and in Asia the Communist powers have the diplomatic initiative. Why? Is it be- cause they are stronger than we are or that they are cleverer than we are? Not in my book. They are certainly not stronger than we are-be it by the standard of war and of ultimate military power or by the peace-time standard of human welfare. And when we remember what Stalin and Molotov contributed by their mistakes to making the Marshall Plan a success and to making NATO a going concern, we need not think that they are infallible or preternaturally clever. Our trouble, in my view, is that we have never adapted the great conceptions of our foreign policy to the revolutionary consequences, which have followed from the Soviet Uiion's achievement of nuclear weapons. One basic conception of our foreign policy-in that it envisages a containing military ring of anit- Communist states-is out of date. The concep- tion was worked out under Truman and Ache- son before 1949, that is to say before we knew that the Soviet Union was breaking our mono- poly of the atomic bomb. Since that time, it has been the inexorable logic of atomic armaments that the borderland nations must, and that they will, seek se- curity and survival in policies to prevent war, and to avoid being involved if war cannot be prevented. THE REASON that Moscow and Peiping have the initiative in propaganda and in diplo- macy is that they have adapted their diplomacy to the facts of life in the age of nuclear wea- pons. In this age there are only two nuclear powers, only two which have nuclear weapons for the offense and have also the distance, the depth, and the space to survive a nuclear of- fensive. Since 1949, despite all the grandiose pacts floating on the surface of events, there has been a deep and steady undertow which has been idragging the non-atomic powers-which include Japan and Germany, all the little bor- der states and others too-into some kind of middle position where they have a hope, a chance, of not becoming involved in an atomic war. MOSCOW AND Peiping now have the initia. tive because they have made their own, and are using for their own interests the pol- icy towards whic hall the non-atomic powers are being drawn by the logic of their own help- lessness in a war with nuclear weapons. Our policy, which, is to expect every anti- Communist or non-Communist nation to line up with us in a posture of defiance, is incom- patible with the realities of nuclear weapons. It has hcome a din1nma'v nf Colonl Blimn A other Unicorn . . To the Editor: AS LAW STUDENTS we are proud of our University's rec- ord this year in their regulation of students' public and private activities. We realize the necessity for this type of regulation in an academic community such as this and, because of the especially heavy study load which we in the Law School must carry, we are especially happy with the state of peace and quiet which has re- sulted this year. However, it has lately come to our attention that this expertly imposed tranquility is about to come under heavy attack from a certain element of the student body which resides within the very walls of the Law School. This group, whose purpose seems to be to subvert all public dignity and authority, has made periodic as- saults upon the peace which have, recently, come dangerously close to disaster. Only last spring they came frighteningly close to plung- ing us all into disgrace. It will not be necessary to discuss the shame- ful episode in detail, But we are sure that no one has forgotten the affair of the Unicorn in the Garden. Fortunately our good Dean took the matter in hand and saved us all from the ignominy which such a prank would cer- tainly have visited upon us had it been allowed to succeed. Because this feckless rabble came so close to success last year we feel that it would be wise for the powers of law and order to be again on guard for there are cer- tain signs, barely visible to the untrained eye, which seem to in- dicate that preparations are afoot for new abominations. On the way to class today we were distressed to see that a new Unicorn was tak- ing shape within the very halls of Hutchins. There can be little doubt that there is some relation between this impertinence and last y ear's embarrassing beast. As yet, only the spoor of the animal has appeared but expert trackers as- sure us that the Unicorn is never far from his spoor. Perchance we are presumptuous in our warning. No doubt our busy administrators have these cul- prits under observation. However, we, feeling, as we do, that we and our school would suffer should these persons be allowed to per- petrate another of those juvenile and dangerous projects, warn all other responsible members of the Law School community to be on guard against any incursions into their orderly pursuit of know- ledge. -George Granger, William Sesler, D. Joseph Ferraro aningTradition . . . To the Editor: LATELY I have been greatly con- cerned with the waning tra- dition of Michigan. As I pass the Union, I realize that the students lack the interest to carve their names in the Union tables. Fewer than 30 of the many seniors have availed themselves of the chance to enrich this tradition. It is my only hope thatthis fine bit of "old Michigan" does not escape our grasp. --Cornelius Sipple * * * For Realism . . . To the Editor: I THINK that William Brumm's editorial "Not One Square Inch for Appeasement" is one of the most illogical and emotional editorials I have read. I am sure that Mr. Brumm is proud to be an American and wants his coun- try to be one which he can be proud of. Further he feels that "it's time we acted like Ameri- cans." Perhaps we should stop act- ing like Americans and take a les- son from England and adopt a foreign policy of reality. It was an Englishman who said "We recognize Red China for the same reason we recognize Mount Ever- est on a rainy day, simply because it exists." By refusing to deal with Red China we can only delay any solution of our problems in the Far East. Mr. Brumm has not looked at the real issue. It is not that we must stop Red China from mov- ing another inch, but that we must prevent the entire southeast As- ian Continent from being overrun by Communism. This can be done in several ways; certainly war is one of them. However I cannot agree with Mr. Brumm's conclu-. sion that "with God on our side we will be victorious." On the front page of the same paper that the editorial appeared in (Tuesday, April 26, 1955) was an article with the headline "Red Strength at High Peak." Quoting the article we see that "Red China's air force could be doub- led or tripled 'overnight' by the Soviets." Reading on further we find that the Russian army is "the most powerful land force in the world, (and is) 'in an excellent state of combat readiness.' Time is running out in the Far East and our strategic position may be ebbing away. We risk los- ing both our position and our pres- tige without gaining any conces- sions. War would not bring im- mediate rescue of the fifteen California town. The principle aim of both films tail the misadventures of amoral, vicious youngsters who threaten the lives and property of innocent citizens. IN "THE WILD ONE," the townspeople are cut off from po- lice protection; in "Blackboard Jungle," the young teacher (Glenn Ford) who enters the schoolroom finds that neither school authori- ties nor law enforcement agencies offer solutions to his discipline problems. In both instances, the citizens are completely incapable of cop- ing with the situation. They are face to face with the most dan- gerous of animals-the human animal. The audience can only experi- ence frustration; it is expected to identify with the persecuted vic- tims who are unable to regain the freedom of ordering their lives. HOWEVER, AT this point, the tone of the two films diverges. "The Wild One" is a documentary film; it reveals a situation as any newsreel might reveal it. It offers no solution. It does not attempt to scale its new-found evil on a sys- tem of values. It points out; it does not comment. "Blackboard Jungle," on the other hand, approaches the prob- lem quite diferently. Its function is to exploit, to present the viewer with a series of shocking scenes, e.g., rape, robbery, knife fights. About half way through, "Black- board Jungle" loses its potency and drive in an over-long roman- tic passage and in an attempt to solve the problem it has presented. The solution-people are basic- ally good and just need under- standing-is at best only a partial answer, for it ignores the social and economic conditions which foster juvenile delinquency. * * * BY PLAYING amateur psycho- logist and resolving personality conflicts, Ford changes the char- acter of his reckless charges, turn- ing them into virtual Little Ford Fauntleroys. This is unbelievable, to say the least. "Blackboard Jungle" is an out- standing film as a melodrama; it startles and it shocks and it volds the viewer's attention rather con- sistently. Yet, this does not remove the fact that its plot and presenta- tion are pure hokum. And while it purports to document social evils, it is still very weak when compar- ed with "The Wild One." All of this sudden interest in juvenile delinquency p r o b a b 1 y means a cycle of such films. If Hollywood's previous behavior is any indication, future films should rapidly become stereotyped. Yet, it is still to be hoped, that if the screen is to witness a par- ade of knife toting junior hoods, the answers given will not only be dramatically acceptable, but also realistic and accurate. American airmen and 41 United States civilians being held by Mao's regime. It will just place more American lives in jeopardy. I agree with Mr. Brumm when he claims that most Americans don't want to start a war with China. But I will go one step far- ther and say that I don't want to place China in a position that will force her to start the war. We don't have to "stay out of ...(war) at all costs" but we should take necessary measures to avoid war if at all possible. -Gerald Goldberg is to shock the viewer, as they de- DREW PEARSON: Ike Talks About Assassins WASHINGTON-Gov. Luis Mun- oz Marin, first Puerto Rican ever elected governor of Puerto Rico, and the best governor the island has ever known, was con- ferring with President Eisenhow- er regarding various Caribbean problems. Among other things he doesn't want too high a minimum wage fixed for Puerto Rico and pointed out that the present aver- age wage in the island-58 cents an hour-is higher than the min- imum wage in England, France and Italy. He also urged President Eisen- hower to help set up a Caribbean Commission including every Brit- ish, Dutch and French possession in the Caribbean as well as Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands, in or- der to secure better cultural and tconomi cooperation in that area. The Prtoident was sympathetic to bth ideas. During the confer- ence they got to talking about the Puerto Rico nationalist who had attempted to assassinate President Truman and had shot several con- gressmen. * * * "I WAS DRIVING through New York," remarked the President, 'when a friend pointed out a build- ing which he said was the head- quarters of the Puerto Rican na- tionalists." "That must have been the jail," replied Governor Munoz, "because all I know are in jail." "I don't see why they should want to shoot me," continued Eis- enhower jokingly. "I have announ- ced that I was for independence if Puerto Rico wants independence. You're the man they should shoot, not me." "They've already tried," replied the Governor, a little ruefully, doubtless having in mind the oc- casion when the nationalists stormed his home about a year ago. * * * HERE'S THE inside story of how the State Department issued a statement one day that the U.S.A. would not discuss a cease- fire with Red China without Chi- ang Kai-shek; then three days later said we would discuss a cease- fire without Chiang Kai-shek. This was not a minor snafu per- petrated by a minor State Depart- ment official. Nor was it entirely the fault of Herbert Hoover, Jr., the Undersecretary of State who originated the first statement. He phoned a copy to Gettysburg, talk- ed to the President about an hour on the phone. Later, two things happened. First, Senator George of Georgia got a tremendous ovation when he told the American Society of News- paper Editors that we should talk to the Red Chinese about peace no matter what the circumstances. SECOND, the State Department received a four-page confidential cablegram from Premier Moham- med Ali of Pakistan, who visited this country last year and is a good friend of the U.S.A. At the Bandung Conference, Red China's tough-talking Prem- ier Chou En-lai had two confer- ences with the two rival leaders of what was once British India, now are Pakistan and India. According to the secret cabled reports of U.S. diplomats, Chou's talk with idealistic Premier Nehru was a flop. Nehru tried to be the peacemaker of Asia, but got cold- shouldered. Though Nehru wanted the Red Chinese leader to guarantee the neutrality of all non-Communist Viet Nam, Chou would guarantee only the small and unimportant states of Laos and Cambodia. Im- plication was the Reds would pene- trate the rest of Indo-China -- namely, the much richer, more powerful Viet Nam now undergo- ing revolt. Premier Nehru finally left the Chou conference peeved and dis- %ppointed. WITH NEHRU'S rival, Premier Mohammed Ali of Pakistan, Chou was more cooperative. Perhaps he cxrnc r1P.ihrn+a .wni- tem (Continued from Page 2) tenor; and Morley Meredith, baritone; Philadelphia Orchestra, Thor Johnson, Conductor. SAT., MAY 7, 2:30 p.m. Jeanne Mitch- ell, violinist; PhiladelphiarOrchestra, Eugene Ormandy, Conductor; Festival Youth Chorus, Marguerite Hood, Con- ductor. Program: Overture "Donna Di- ang" (Reznicek; Mozart Sinfona Con- certante; viennese Folk and Art Songs; Schubert Unfinished Symphony; and the Mozart Concerto in A major. SAT., MAY 7, 8:30 p.m. William War- field, Baritone, Philadelphia Orchestra, and Eugene Ormandy, Conductor. Pro- gram: Overture and Allegro from "La Sulitne" (Couperin); Songs by Handel, Brahms and Copland; Dello Jolo's Epi- graph; and Concerto for Orchestra (Bartok). SUN.,MAY 8, 2:30 p.m. University Choral Union; Lois Marshall, Soprano; Leslie Chabay, tenor; Morley Meredith, baritone; Grant Johannesen, Pianist. Program: Carl Orf's "Carmina Burana" and Prokofieff Concerto No. 3 in. major. SUN., MAY 8, 8:30 p.m. Rise Stevens, Mezzo-soprano; Philadelphia Orchestra; Eugene Ormandy, Conductor. Program; Arias from operas by Gluck, Tschaikow- sky, Saint-Saens and Bizet; Bloch Cop- certo Grosso No. 2 for String Orchestra; and Tschaikowsky Symphony No. 4 in 1 minor. Tickets, pnd further information, may be procured at the offices of the Uni- versity Musical Society, Burton Memo- rial Tower, through Wed., May 4. Beginning Thurs. a.m., May 5, tickets will be available at the box office in Hill Auditorium during the day; and n after 7:00 p.m. Events Today Undergraduate Zoology Club presents "Tropical Fish, their Behavior, Care and Breeding." Frank McCormick, Univer- sity Acquarium, Wed., May 4, 3:15 p.m, 328 E. Liberty. Resident Directors' Seminar Wed., May 4, at 2:30 p.m., League. vice Presi- dent James A. Lewis will speak. Michigan Crib Meeting. Room 3B, Michigan Union-$:00 p.m., Wed., May 4, Room 3B, Michigan Union. Arthur Carpenter will speak on "Law in Pub- lic Life." Refreshments. U. of M. Chapter of the Amerle Society of Civil Engineers will me Wed., May 4, at 8:00 p.m. in Rackham Amphitheater, jointly with the Mich- igan Section of the American Society of Civil Engineers. E. Thomas Baker, Chief Engineer, Michigan Turnpike Authority will speak on "Studies of the Michigan Turnpike Authority." All members of the local chapter are re- quested to attend. Guests invited. The 49th Annual French Play. Le Cercle Francais will present "L'Avare" a comedy in five acts by Moliere Wed., May 4, at 8:00 p.m. in Lydia Mendels- sohn Theatre. The Box Office will be open today 10:00 a.m.-8:00 p.m. Members of the Club will be admhtted free of charge by returning their membership cards. r Student Zionist meeting, Wed., May 4 at Hillel. 8:00 p.m. Israeli dances will beataught after the meeting. Episcopal Student Foundation. Stu- dent Breakfast at Canterbury House, Wed., May 4, after the 7:00 a~m. Holy Communion. Senior society Meeting Wed., May 4 at 9:15 p.m. in the Union. Hillel. Petitions for positions for the executive committee and the adminis- trative council may be obtained at Hil- lel. The deadline for executive 'peti- tions is May 4. The deadline for the administrative council petitions is May 10. Interviewing for Freshman Rendez- vous Counselors, Wed., May 4, 2:00-3:00 p.m. at Lane Hall. Those who have re- ceived notices, please call Lane Hall if unable to appear at this time. Wesleyan Guild, Wed., May 4. Mid- week Worship in the chapel 7:30-7:50 a.m. Mid-week Tea in the lounge at 4:15 p.m. Westminster and Lutheran student groups will sponsor a discussion on "Medicine and Christianity" today at 9:15 p.m. at the Presbyterian Church. Leaders include Drs. John Henderson and Frnk Sladen. Medical and premed students especially invited. Refresh- t ments. Coming Events Hillel. There will be no more Fri. evening dinners for the rest of the semester. La. Petite Causette meets Thurs., May 5 from 3:30-5:00 p.m. in the left room of the Union cafeteria. Christian Science Organization Testi- monial Meeting, 7:30 p.m. Thurs., Up- per Room, Lane Hall. International Center Tea. Thurs., 4:30- 6:00 p.m. Rackham Building, Sailing Club. Meeting Thurs. at 7:45 p.m. in 311 W. Eng. Episcopal Student Foundation. Stu- dent Breakfast at Canterbury House. Thurs., May 5, after the 7:00 a.m. Holy Communion. Confirmation conducted by the Right Reverend Archie Crowley, 5:00 p.m., Thurs., May 5, in the Chapel of Saint Michael and All Angels. Final Social Seminar. Michigan Chap- ter, American Society for Public Admin- istration. T. Ledyard Blakeman, Direc- tor of the Detroit Area Metropolitan Regional Planning Commission, will dis- cuss "Regional Planning and Admini- strative Action" Thurs., May 5 at 7:45 p.m. in the East Conference Room of the Rackham Building. Refreshments. Christian Science Lecture by Henry Allen Nichols of Los Angeles, Califor- nia, on, "Christian Science: The Goal of Scientific Knowledge," Mon., May 9 at 8:00 n.m. Auditorium A. Angemi Hal ALMOST A TRADITION: Pulitzer Prize Winners Draw Debate By HARRY STRAUSS T'S ALMOST tradition. Literary prizes lead to debates. When the National Book Award gave its 1954 award to William Faulkner's "A Fable," all of the literary columns noted the mixed reviews the novel received, and pointed to others, notably Harri- ette Arnow's "The Dollmaker," as more even works. Monday the Pulitzer committee announced its awards and, for the first time, Faulkner won, and he won it for "A Fable." Ironically, the international Nobel Prize came to him first. . ** * ma follows his symbolic" Camino Real," a success d'esteme. "Cat" returns to his earlier successes, be- ing a play about a Southern fam- ily. The potent commentary on mendacity in a somewhat deca- dent household makes superb the- atre. . This is the second Pulitzer Prize in Drama that Williams has re- ceived. He was awarded the 1948 prize for his "A Streetcar Named Desire." Also a two-time winner is Gian- Carlo Menotti. He was awarded the 1950 music prize for his monu- mental, "The Conusul," where he first attempted to bridge the gap nf drama and onera. In his "The