THE MICHIGAN D'AtLT WEL)NESDAV- IANIIAR.V &-'IfIAA a.aaa.i i aavraavt's . . st'aaaia YYL"yl;'VWw aNiIAV U& s1%v i AUY a, lflZ M MAN OF THE YEAR? Time's Choice of Dulles Clearly Debatable F OR THE second year in a row, Time maga- zine's choice for the Man of the Year is{ debatable (Understatement of the Year). Last year, German Chancellor Adenauer was chosen over Sen. McCarthy though the latter certainly had the most to say during the year and caused his "ism" to be felt throughout the world. Secretary of State Dulles, Time's Man of 1954, said a lot last year, certainly, and no one can say that he didn't get around fast enough. But in reading the magazine's reasons for so honoring Dulles, one can't help feeling that it is more like a toastmaster saying to his audi- ence "now let's give him a round of applause to show we support him" than anything else. DULLES' INFLUENCE was felt, granted. He was at many conferences, doing much- needed coordination, mediation and such. But at the same time, the Secretary's occasional hasty remarks led to some embarassing mo- ments. The foundations for the Western European Union were laid by Dulles and this is doubt- lessly worthy of much credit. (Dulles has been more successful in his dealings with Europe than with Asia). But does it make him the Man of the Year? WE CAN especially ask this question when we think of France's Mendes-France. He managed to close, even in France's defeat, the war in Indo-China. He was present at France's abandoning the EDC, but still managed to hold onto his post as Premier. And he brought his country to approve the new WEU, and re- mains in office. His work was felt throughout the world. From Asia we have Indo-China's Ho Chi Minh who brought the Reds to victory in that coun- try at the Geneva peace conference at which he came to the fore as Asia's man of the year. And in the background we had with us, as usual, Russia's Malenkov who didn't say much but certainly had his finger in all the world's pies. SINCE THE Man of the Year should be that person who had the most influence on the world scene, it does seem that while the world was quite aware of Dulles, there was greater awareness of these other men. In the cover story the list of events that happened during the year, or the problems that were solvedl, were credited directly or by im- plication to Dulles, but certainly some of them, like the solving of the Suez question was much nMore in the hands of others than in Dulles'. ANY CHOICE for the Man of the Year is likely to be given an arbitrary one in most cases. But in the case of Time magazine a more than usual interest and prestige has be- come attached to the individuals chosen. Those picked are often referred to as the Man of the Year in the press and in other periodicals. Time's selectioon always stands as a starting point in reviewing the events of the year. We cannot belittle the Secretary's accom- plishments, but except to show support, there should be no reason to enlarge them. It was "nice" that Time expressed its support of Dul- les, but there still remains the question of who was the Man of 1954? --Harry Strauss "A Fellow Can't Remember To Take Everything" s 7..t TODAY AND TOMORROW: Republican Loss Lets Ike 'R ise A boePry Reece Report Shows Need To Curb Investigators T WO charges have been leveled against tax exempt foundations, which have grown in number from 200 in 1930 to more than 5,000 in 1954. One charge is that the foundations have been formed to avoid taxes. The more serious charge, of a political nature, is that in giving grants for studies in politics, eco- nomics, psychology, racial problems, educa- tion and family problems, the foundations have aided "un-American" and "subversive" movements. Principal targets for these at- tacks have been the Rockefeller and Carnegie foundations and the Ford sponsored Fund for the Republic. After examining several thousand question- naires and listening to extended testimony, a special House committee headed by the late Eugene Cox of Georgia gave the foundations a clean bill of health on the second charge. The majority report of the Cox inquiry, re- leased in 1952, reported that "the few in- stances where foundation funds have gone to the support of the Communist line were in- advertent and not Intentional." The Cox Com- mittee praised the foundations highly for their explorations in the field of social sciences. N APRIL; 1953, however, Rep. B. Carroll Reece (R-Tenn.) charged the foundations with a "diabolical conspiracy" to promote so- cialism and managed to get himself appointed chairman -of a new committee to investigate foundations. The Reece Committee released a majority report the Monday before Christmas. It was signed by Rep. Reece, Jesse P. Wolcott (R- Mich.) and Angier Goodwin (R-Mass.). The two Democrats on the committee, Rep. Wayne Hays and Mrs. Gracie Pfost filed a minority report. Essentially, the Reece Committee's majority report is an insult to public intelligence. It is a product of frenzy, hysteria, anti-intellectual- ism and legal and judicial know-nothingism. Messrs. Wolcott, Reece and Goodwin have come up with a vindicitive, unsubstantiated smear-- but in the end it will not be foundations that are smeared-it will be Messrs. Wolcott, Reece and Goodwin. INDIGNANTLY, the majority report charges the foundations with deliberately promot- ing such obvious evils as "internationalism," "globalism," "socialism," and "empiricism." (The Reece committee probably got carried away with "ism's" when they included "em- piricism" which the dictionary says is "a philosophic technique basing conclusions on experience and experiment rather than ab- stract logic.") Foundations are also accused of "propagandizing blindly for the United Na- tions" and supporting a "conscious distortion of history." The most interesting aspect of the majority report is that it was prepared and released without ever hearing what the foundations had to say. As unlikely as it seems in this day and age, the investigated parties were never allowed to present a defense. For the first ten months of its existence, the Reece Com- mittee took no testimony. It was "preparing an approach." When hearings were finally begun last May, the staff did most of the testifying. Rep. Reece denied the foundations' requests to appear in their own defense but magnanimously allowed them to submit state- ments. REP. HA.YES and Mrs. Pfost described the majority report as an "ugly stain" on the House. They charged, in their minority report, that the foundations had been "indicated and convicted" under procedures which violated "every principal of our constitution." One question, among others, comes to mind: If such solid institutions as the Ford Founda- tion (assets $518 million) and the Rockefeller Foundation (assets $300 million) can be treat- ed in such summary fashion, what limits, if any, will be placed on abuse to ordinary citi- zens? Foundations have financial backing, in- fluence and prestige to protect them against jackals like Rep. Reece-Mr. Next-Door Neigh- bor has not. SEVERE criticism has often been levelled against the procedural safeguards of Con- gressional investigating committees. During the heyday of witchhunt investigations when men like Jenner, McCarthy and Velde were drunk with their power to abuse and control, Con- gress should have realized its obligation to re- examine the rules of inquiry and establish safe- guards. The Reece majority report makes such reexamination imperative. If Congress acts to curb the almost unlimited power of investigating committees, Rep. Reece will go down in history as the investigator who con- vinced Congress investigations needed investi- gating. -Lee Marks By WALTER LIPPMANN tT IS A remarkable fact that in the weeks since the election the prestige and power of Presi- dent Eisenhower have risen steep- ly. This has happened in spite of the fact that the most significant Democratic gains were in the ter- ritory where the Republican party is most strongly pro-Eisenhower, Why, nevertheless, is the Presi- dent's power growing? PRIMARILY, I believe, because the elections have put an end to his attempts to do the impos- sible-namely to unite the two wings of his party under his lead- ership. The Republican Senate Chairmen who, by virtue of sen- iority alone, controlled the legis- lative and the investigating com- mittees were not willing to be led by President Eisenhower. They did not feel they had to make any im- portant concessions to him. After the death of Sen. Taft they acted as men not concerned with the future of the Republican party as a national organization. This attitude of their applied not only to measures-such as the trade program-but to the Presi- dent's constitutional prerogatives in the conduct of- the Administra- tion and in the choice of personnel in the executive branch of the government. The record of legis- lative usurpation during the first two years of the Eisenhower ad- ministration is the blackest since the days of the Reconstruction. During this time the President himself was in deepening trouble because he could not lead these chairmen nor could he get along without them- The election has released him from their grip and has solved the problem with which they oppress- ed him. The President is free to be the kind of President he was chosen to be, the only kind of President he really knows how to be. This is a President represent- ing not a faction, not even a mere party, but that preponderant majority of moderate men and women who are in both parties. The spectacle of Eisenhower as- sociated even at second hand with a campaign to accuse the Dejno- crats of twenty years of treason was as absurd as it was ignomin- ious. The real Eisenhower consti- tuency is measured by the two- thirds of the Senate which voted to Condemn McCarthy; they re- present and reflect the prepon- derant American majority. THUS IN the second half of his term Eisenhower has come in- to the position which is particu- larly and indeed uniquely his own. This is to be a President who, standing above mere party com- petition, unites the great mass of the nation. And on what does he unite them? The President said the other day that it was on a policy of progressive moderation. No doubt that is so. But the main issues that really arouse the peo- ple are not the legislative propos- als. There are no very hot differ- ences over those prposals. The real issues are those of war and peace, national security and per- sonal freedom. These are issues of life and death. The original mission of Eisenhower was to lift these issues out of politics, above the factions, and away from the demagogues and the agitators. Until last spring Gen. Eisen- hower was on the way to being as unsuccessful a President as was Gen. Grant. Like Gen. Grant he was bewildered and helpless in McCarthy and fought back on the question of who was to run the Army. And this was followed by the President's decision not to in- tervene in Indo-China This de- cision marked the defeat of the war party and the emergence of President Eisenhower as the ar- biter of high policy. THERE ARE many signs that the President will now have an easier time dealing with his own party. The pro-Eisenhower half is, of course, more than ever warmly attached to him. There will still be the hard core of the extreme right-wing. But they are no longer in control of any of the crucial committees, the President does not have to appease them in order to carry his measures, and they are left with nothing much more than the right and the pow- er to speak. They have no power to act and not much power to ob- struct. For all the great issues of war and peace, of security and freedom, the President now has behind him an overwhelming ma- jority-reflected by at least two- thirds of the Senate. This accounts for the fact that though the Republicans lost the election, the Republican President is growing stronger. After two years in the wilderness of faction- al politics, Eisenhower is back home among his real friends. EISENHOWER'Sapresent posi- tion, that of aleader with a following dependent upon the other party, is by no means un- precedented in American politics. Al Smith, for example, was just about the best Governor New York State has had; never, if I remem- ber correctly, did Al Smith have a legislature controlled by his own party. Indeed, it can be argued I think, that in the American sys- tem of government with its separ- ation of powers, it is not at all abnormal that the executive should operate not with his own party united behind him but with a coalition. When the executive knows how to talk to the people as a whole, he can often do better by rallying around him his own personal majority than by attemp- ting to do only what all the dif- ferent factions of his own party can be persuaded to agree upon. Cfrr Sixty-Fifth Year Edited and managed by Students of the University of Michigan under the authority of the Board in Control of Student Publications Editorial Staff Eugene Hartwig ......Managing Editor Dorothy Myers ............City Editor Jon Sobeloff .,....Editorial Director Pat Roelofs ......Associate City Editor Becky Conrad .........Associate Editor Nan Swinehart .......Associate Editor Dave Livingston .........Sports Editor Hanley Gurwin ... Assoc. Sports Editor Warren Wertheimer ..r......r.. e..Associate Sports Editor Roz Shlimovitz ...... Women's Editor Joy Squires ..Associate Women's Editor Janet Smith .Associate Women's Editor Dean Morton ...Chief Photographer Business Staff Lois Pollak ........Business Manager Phil Brunskill, Assoc. Business Manager Bill Wise . ...... Advertising Manager Mary Jean Monkoski .Finance Manager Telephone NO 23-24-1 DREW PEARSON: Washington Merry-Go - Round WASHINGTON - Inside story can now be told of how young Deputy Attorney-General Bill Ro- gers actually overruled the Presi- dent of the United States in ap- pointing a Federal judge. President Eisenhower had prom- ised to appoint outgoing Sen. Bob Hendrickson, New Jersey Repub- lican, to the U.S. Court of Appeals as his consolation prize for step- ping aside and letting Clifford Case run for the Senate. In fact, Ike had given his personal word on this to Hendrickson's colleague, Sen. Alex Smith, also of New Jer- sey. But at the same time, young Rogers had also made a commit- ment-namely, to wangle a Fed- eral judgeship for Joseph McGar- raghy on the D.C. District Court. As long-time GOP boss. of the voteless District of Columbia, M- Garraghy was too much of a po- litico to risk appointing him to the higher Court of Appeals. However, a vacancy existed on the Court of Appeals, not the Dis- trict Court. To get around this difficulty, Rogers deftly managed to promote District Judge Walter Bastian to the Appeals Court and thus create an opening for Mc- 3arraghy down below on the Dis- trict Court. All this was pulled off smoothly without notifying the President, who is supposed to appoint Fed- eral judges. And by the time Ike heard about it, Bastian's appoint- ment had already been -sent to the Senate for approval. Meanwhile, Senator Smith of New Jersey had spread word around the Senate that Ike had promised the Appeals vacancy to Senator Hendrickson. So when Bastian's name came to the Sen- ate instead, it made Smith look like a fool. He telephoned the White House in a rage and ac- cused the President of "a breach of faith." Senate GOP leader Bill Knowland of California joined in the protest. Ike decided, however, it would be too embarrassing to withdraw Bastian's appointment after it had already been announced. So he tried to mollify the Senators by offering Hendrickson the Am- bassadorship to New Zealand. By this time Hendrickson was really sore. He had agreed not to run for re-election, had watched Clifford Case win instead, and now the promised judgeship had faded to an ambassadorship "down un- der." So he pouted and refused to say whether he would accept or not. After his friend, Amos J. Peas- lee of New Jersey, was appointed ambassador to next-door Australia, however, Hendrickson decided he would like to go to New Zealand after all. But by this time, the State De- partment didn'tdwant the job and had gone ahead with other ar- rangements. Today the diplomats are frantically trying to straight- en out the mess, Oldest Senator THE OLDEST member of the new 84th Congress, 87-year- old Sen. Theodore Francis Green of Rhode Island, plans to set a new record before this session of Congress ends. If he lives beyond Feb. 26, 1956, he will be the oldest active Sen- ator in our history. That record is now held posthumously by for- mer Sen. Justin Smith Morrill of Vermont, who lived to be 88 years, 8 months and 14 days while still in the Senate. At the rate he's going, Green ought to be a cinch to be the new champ. The latest physical check- up showed him to be in excellent condition, and, having just been elected for his fourth six-year term last November, he has ev- ery intention of finishing the term at the age of 92. "Then I may think about re- tiring," says Green with a wry grin. Meantime, the spry, bache- lor Senator is kept busy as the Jhairman of two committees by day and on the capital's social whirl by night. Office aides say he averages two or three social functionsa week. Certification Confusion AS THE House of Representa- tives was about to convene yes- terday, young Lyle Snader, out- going GOP Clerk of the House, held his breath. For a time it looked as if the Democrats would- n't control. It happens that getting elected to Congress isn't enough, to en- title a Congressman to his seat in the House. The Secretary of State of the Congressman's home terri- tory must also officially "certify" him before he can be seated. And last week two important states had not certified their Congress- men as the zero hour approached. Moreover, they were states - ?/fra.cnrh1,pf-.. n+-, M icri-ra m with RECORD REVIEW Herman's Latest Album Completes Jazz Cycle F WOODY HERMAN'S recent album, "Dance Date On Mars," is any criteria he has completed the jazz cycle and is back where he start- ed ten years ago, In 1945 and 1946 he succeeded Benny Goodman as the top jazz clarinetist and was proclaimed as the new "King of Swing" from coast to coast. His band was known as the "Herman Herd" and it was the first big band to come into prominence after the war. In fact it was the first talented band to come along since Goodman, Harry James arhd Tommy Dorsey were at their peak in the late thirties and early forties. That rip-roaring Herd hit harder than any jazz group before or since. Its 1946 Carnegie Hall Concert was considered a worthy successor to Goodman's concert there in 1938. MAESTRO HERMAN either tired of all the noise, as Kenton does every few years, or he decided to "progress" to something more sophisticated. Nevertheless, in 1949 Woody switched to leading a small bop combo which was fashionable among jazz artists at the time. Three years ago he decided big bands were coming back and he wanted, to come back with them. He couldn't get satisfactory guaran- tees for his new venture from any of the established recording com- panies, so he formed his own, Mars Records, from which comes the title of this recent album. He called his new orchestra the "Third Herd." (There never was a second Herd unless one considers six enough to make a herd). This new band hit the Jazz scene with surprising force considering it ap- peared on a new label. It made the bands on top at the time, like Ralph Flanagan's and Ralph Marterie's sound quite shallow when com- pred with the Herd's solid-as-a-rock reasonance. Trumpeter Pete Con- doli was gone from the old Herd but men like steady drummer Don Lamond and comical Chubby Jackson were back. Then came the letdown. It soon became apparent that this wasn't a "Third Herd" but just the first one with a few minor changes. MUCH OF THE old Herd is heard in the "Dance Date On Mars" album. One number, "Early Autumn," sounds exactly like the one recorded by the old Herd. "Stompin at the Savoy" also sounds very familiar, and not because other bands play it so much. "Perdido" may be new but the ending sounds just like "Wild Root" of the 1946 Carnegie Hall Concert. The other numbers are evidently new and in two of them, "Jump in the Line" and "The Blues In Advance," one of the few changes in the new Herd is painfully apparent. It seems Woody no longer plays his clarinet very mucl but instead had become a vocalist. Woody can't sing any better than Dizzy Gillesepie. The only difference is that D szly is supposed to be funny. Two numbers do seem to have a certain freshness about them with- out Woody's voice to interupt. "Terrissita" and "Celestial Blues" dem- onstrate new uses of the marimba, piano and rhythm patterns which indicate that there is still a progressive attitude, an originality present which could put the Herd back on top of the jazz world. --Robert Polley DI (Continued from Page 2) where in the state of Michigan. BA or advanced degrees in any field. Lectures Phi Sigma Society. "Some Aspects of the Ecology and Physiology of Desert Animals" (Illustrated) by Dr. William R. Dawson, Department of Zoology. Rackham Amphitheatre Thurs., Jan. 6, at 8:00 p.m. (Refreshments after meeting for members & guests). Open to the public. Business meeting-7:30 p.m. "Living Religions of the Peoples of Russia," Nicholas T. Goncharoff, for- mer Russian Army Tank Commander, and Frank R. Barnett, professor, Wa- bash College. Thurs., Jan. 6, 8:00 p.m., Kellogg Auditorium. Sponsored by Lane Hall. Academic Notices Doctoral Examination for Henry WallacerDecker, Romance Languages and Literatures: French, thesis: "The Debate on Pure Poetry, 1925-1930; A Critical Survey," Wed., Jan. 5, East Council Room, Rackham Building,' at 3:30 p.m. Chairman, R. J. Niess. Doctoral Examination for Robert Dorl Francis, Bacteriology; thesis: "Studies of the Immunological Relationships be- tween Viruses of the Psittacosis-Lym- phogranuloma Venereum Group," Wed., Jan. 5, 1566 East Medicai Bldg., at 2:00 p.m. Chairman, W. S. Preston. Doctoral Examination for Helen Mary Maertens Wadsworth, Psycholo- gy, thesis: "The Relationship between Experimentally Induced Stress and the Characteristic Mode of Expression and Level of Anxiety," Wed., Jan. 5, 7611 Haven Hall, at 10:00 am. Chairman, H. L. Raush. The Applied Mathematics Seminar will not meet this week because of the Goldstein Lecture at 3:30 p.m., Jan. 6, in Aud. C, M.H. Geometry Seminar: Wed., Jan. 5, at 7:00 p.m., in Room 3001 A.H. Prof. George Rainich will speak on "Pure Differential Geometry." Doctoral Examination for Kent How- ell McKnight, botany; thesis: "Psi- locybe Mutans Sp. Nov.: Morphology and variations," Wed., Jan. 5, 1139 Natural Science Building, at 1:00 p.m. Chairman, A. H. Smith. 401 Interdisciplinary Seminar on the Application of Mathematics to Social Science will meet Thurs., Jan. 6 in Room 3401 Mason Hall, 4:00-5:30 p.m. G. Livesay will speak on "Multivalued Logic." Seminar in Mathematical Statistics: Thurs., Jan. 6, at 4:00 p.m., in Room 3201 A.H. Miss Irene Hess will continue her discussion of Chapter VI of Coch- ran's Sampling Techniques. Engineering Mechanics Seminar in Conjunction with the Departments of Aeronautical Engineering, Mathematics, and Civil Engineering. Prof. Sydney Goldstein will speak on "The Steady Motion of an Incompressible viscous Fluid" at 3:30 p.m. Thurs., Jan. 6, in Auditorium C, Mason Hall. Doctoral Examination for Ralph Wal- ton Raiford ,Jr. Chemistry; thesis: gious Paintings of Giovanni Battista Gaulli," Fri., Jan. 7, 205 Tappan Hal at 3:00 p.m. Chairman, H., . Wethey. events Today Episcopal Student Foundation. Stu- dent Breakfast at Canterbury House, on Wed,, Jan. 5, after the 7:00 a.m. Holy Comm~union. Episcopal Student Foundation. Stu- dent-Faculty Tea from 4:00 to 8:00 -p.m. on Wed., Jan. 5, at Canterbury House. The Congregational-Disciples Guild 7:00 p.m., Discussion Group at the Guild House. Movies. Free movies, "Beavers" and "The Bobolink and the Bluejay," Jan. 4-10. 4th floor Exhibit Hall, Museums Building. Daily at 3:00 and 4:00, in- cluding Sat. and Sun., extra showing Wed. at 12:30. ULLR Ski Club will meet at 8:00 p.m. tonight in room 3G of the Union. Movie, "Skiing in the Valley of the Saints." Father Mac Phillips will conduct an open forum discussion in the Father Richard Center following devotions Wed, evening, Pershing Rifles: All P/R's meet at TOB in-uniform at 1930 hrs., Jan. 5 forO regular company drill. Be there! Re- member, we have drill meets in the very near future. Also, pledge exam will be given. Sophomore Engineering Class Board will meet tonight in Room 1300, East Engineering Bldg. at 7:30 p.m. Com- mittee work on elections will be dis- cussed. Open to the public. AAUP, Michigan Chapter, will meet Wed., Jan. 5, 8:00 p.m., in the East Conference Room, Rackham Building. Daen Fedele F. Fauri, of the School of Social Work, will lead a discussion on "University Participation in Social Se- curity," All faculty members invited. Le Cercle Francais will meet tonight at 8:00 p.m. in the Michigan°Union. All members are urged to attend as this, is the last meeting of the semes- ter and we will have elections. Two films will be shown and refreshments will be served. The Ensian picture will be retaken. Wesleyan Guild Wed., Jan. 5, Mid- week Worship in the chapel at 5:15 p.m. Mid-week Tea in the lounge, 4:15 -5:15 p.m. Special meeting of the Pre Med. So- ciety Wed., Jan. 5, at 7:30 p.m. in Aud. C Angell Hall for all freshman and sophomore pre medical students. Dr. Wayne L. Whitaker, assistant dean of the Medical School and Dr. Philip F. Weatherill, pre medical adviser, will speak. Coming Events The Congregational-Disciples Guild: 5:00-5:30 p.m., Mid-week Meditation in Douglas Chapel, 7:00-8:00 p.m., Bible Class at the Guild House. "Greeat Ideas of the Bible" La Petite Causette meets Thurs., Jan. 6 from 3:30-5:00 p.m. in the left room of the Union cafeteria. venez tous et narlez francais. t INTERPRETING THE NEWS I . By WILLIAM L. RYAN AP Foreign News Analyst THE YEAR begins on an ominous note, with rumbling threats from* Moscow. While there is every likelihood the Russians will continue to avoid any irrevocable steps that miglt plunge them- into the war for which they are unready they seem in a mood to take some calculated risks to prevent any combined Western action from menacing their long-range goals. The ominous note is underscored by the tone of the Soviet press in recent weeks. All through the debate of the French National Assembly on the Paris agreements to arm Western Ger- many, the Soviet press was engaged in an in- aims. The aim of the latest campaign seems to be to use the events in Paris and Western Europe as an excuse for demanding an in- crease of labor productivity in the Soviet Union, particularly in fields which might be connected with the military. OUTSIDE the Soviet Union, the Communist reaction to the French Parliament's rati- fication of the Paris agreements was swift and unanimous, suggesting it had been dictated well in advance, The reaction could be sum- med up in a line: "It's not over yet." There can be little doubt the Communists hope to strew all sorts of obstacles along- thW rocky road still to be traveled by the Western Allies before an effective European alliance comes into being. It rl k