IT- JR THE MICHIGAN DAILY THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 21, 1952 A Note to Miss Snead "Now,, Here's A General I Have Confidence In" j OFTEN THINK back to my grade school days. I suppose many of us do for we all enjoy a good reminiscence now and then. And, far from unwarranted sentimentalism, recollecting is a healthy passtime. It enables one to get a firmer hold on the present by putting in order his thoughts and impressions of the past. Also, if the indulger isat all objeitive, he can squeeze a little constructive criticism into his re- Verie which might be helpful to the next generation. My memories of grade school are various. One of the most vivid is of a class I attend- ed once a day for perhaps four years. It was called "auditorium" but its subject mat- 'ter was much wider than the title indicates. The three subjects taught in auditorium which I most clearly remember are art and music' appreciation and citizenship. To the extent that a 10 year old can appreciate Michelangelo and Bach, the music and art instruction was a success. The teachings in citizenship were not. Blind patriotism, which better suits a totalitarian subject than a democratic ci- tizen, was the prevailing tenor of the ar- gument. It was in this class that I first learned to cheer George Washington and to hiss Benedict Arnold. I am not inti- mating that such reactions are improper for an American citizen but I do suggest that they are shallow. Miss Snead (our teacher) took a danger- ously narrow view to her subject. I cannot recall ever hearing anything about tolerance, sympathy, human dece cy, the importance" of personal friendships or any other of the qualities necessary to individual citizens in a free and civilized society. The emphasis was on how-how to pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, how to behave properly while someone else was talking. Obviously Miss Snead's prime -con- cern should have been why: why pledge to the flag, why behave graciously towards the speaker at a meeting. . We are all aware of the consequences of the "how" manner of instruction. Its auto- matic assumption that pledging to the flag or being quiet while another speaks is the right thing to do discourages a critical atti- tude on the part of the pupil. Its aim be- comes mechanical obedience rather than un- derstanding and independent action. Later on, when someone tells the child that Jews are bad and must be exterminated, as Hit- ler did the German youth, he does not ques- tion the truth of the fact but only thinks about.how he can put it into practice. Thus, though it can be called the easiest and quickest means of grade school in- struction ("Let the children understand later"), it is actually dictatorial. As such, it is disasterous to democratic attitudes and Institutions. Nor is the "how" method of instruction the exclusive property of Miss Snead or the primary schools, for if it were there would be small cause to worry. "The children" would understand later and all would be well. I REMEMBER my high school Americas history book. It was full of half-truths; all of them hiding sordid facts about the United States or giving us more credit than we deserved. .he colonies, as this book would have it, fought and defeated the British prac- tically singlehanded. It did mention that the French gave us some aid, principally 'in the form of Lafayette, but ignored Bri- tain's great conflict with France, com- pared to which the revolution was a side show. Nor did the book report William Randolph Hearst's part in pushing the U.S. into a largely unprovoked attack on Spain in 1898; nor did it tell how the Rockefellers and Morgans and Vanderbilts really made their fortunes. All these facts and many more are part of American his- tory and U.S. citizens should know about them. The connotations that the history book carries are obvious. High school students are still considered "children" and thus they must find out .the "why"-the facts-later on. By the time a person graduates or leaves high school, however,,it is already too late. A big part of our youth neVer even get out of grade school; the army carries on its in- struction on the 5th grade level. Thus, only Miss Snead could have had the chance to instill a democratically critical attitude in the first place. Of the high school graduates, only a small minority ever go on to college or do enough reading on their own to find out that behind the glitter of America all is not gold. * * * NOW LET US LOOK at college, for a pe- culiar thing happens here. Suddenly our mental child has become a grown up. Edu- cators assume that he already knows enough to make intelligent well-grounded decisions on national problems and he is put to work learning a profession. Thousand enter engineering college. Thousands more become pre-dental, pre- medical, nursing, business administration, education, and etcetera students. At the same time our educators are making this assumption, society as a whole is making another. It still considers the student a child and woe be to the university which' 'does not outwardly concur. Universities must ban political speakers, since the child is liable to get a good idea from the wrong man. They must regulate their student's hours carefully, provide a home away from home down to the last soda fountain. The university must read the student paper carefully, so that its better moneyed alum- ni will not be offended. And so forth. Inwardly, however, the universities , are holding their own. They can still offer courses like "The Philosophic Basis of Com- munism, Fascism and Democracy," and "The Mind of Primitive Man" to the few liberal arts students left who wish to take them. They .can still use history books written by a German or Russian author. But the pressure is growing greater and perhaps someday sooner than any of us would like to think the colleges will have to succumb to blind patriotism too. The House un-American Activities Committee is com- ing next week. Maybe loyalty oaths will drop in the next. And where is this anti-demo- cratic, anti-critical, conform-to-the-tradi- tional - without - a - doubt pressure coming from? From all' the people who never got past the Miss Snead level of instruction. They are everywhere. They are the chil- dren who were never allowed to grow up and who will insist that their children not be allowed to mature either. They are the children who are voting, raising fami- lies, rising to responsible civic and eco- nomic positions and getting scared when- ever someone disagrees with the majority view. They are the fuzzy thinkers who re- fuse to distinguish between dictatorship, socialism and atheism just because Rus- sian Communism incorporates all three; and who insist we kill all the ideas with a gun. Well, this is enough. This is the reason I would like to suggest to all the prospective grade school teachers who have read this far that they broaden their approach in teach- ing their pupils citizenship. That they ex- plain why to their students. That they en- courage questions, help them to doubt and to know what they are pledging allegiance to. At the same time they might say a few words on behalf of tolerance, friendship and sympathy.. There are some who will say that chil- dren are incapable of understanding such- things. I would disagree with them; we are the ones who teach them to be intolerant in the first place. Also,'a person canriot grow up unless he is given a chance, and the exist- ing educational system discourages growth on nearly every level. If we are to encour- age maturity we may as well start at the beginning. -Richard King ette'm TO THE EDITOR The Daily Welcomes communications from its readers on matters of general interest, and will publish all letters which are signed by the writer and in good taste. Letters exceeding 300 words in length, defamatory or libelous letters, and letters which for any reason are not in good taste will be condensed, edited or withheld from publication at the discretion of the editors. i DAILY OFFICIAL BULLETIN (Continued from Page 2) Applied Math. Seminar: Thurs., Feb. 21. 4 p.m., 247 W. E. Prof. Churchill will speak on Legendre transforms and Prof. Dolph's proposed convolution property. Seminar in Linear Spaces will mect every Thursday at 4 p.m. in 3011 A.H. Mr. Kuller will speak on Banach Alge- bras. Geometry Seminar: Thurs., Feb. 21. followed by a discussion on the "Pur- pose of Criticism in Modern Poetry." Prospective members and interested parties are urged to attend. American Society for Public Adminis- tration Social Seminar. 7:30 p.m., West Conference Room, Rackham Bldg. Speaker: Irving McNayr, County Man- ager of Montgomery County, Maryland. Subject: "Organizing County Govern- ment for Efficiency and Economy." Members, wives and friends are in- vited. 4:10 p.m., 3001 Angell Hall. Mr. Kilby will continue his talk on "Convex Poly- Newman Club. Mardi Gras party, hedral Cones". 8-12 midnight, Fri., Feb. 22, Recreation room, Saint Mary's Chapel. Entertain- Rotating Seminar in Mathematical ment: comedy skits, musical renditions, Statistics: Sat., Feb. 23, 2:15 p.m., 3201 square and round dancing. Refresh- Angell Hall. Speakers: Prof. D. A. ment. All Catholic students and their Darling, University of Michigan, and friends are invited. Prof. Benjamin Epstein, Wayne Uni- versity. International Relations Club. Pan- Modern Poetry P IS CAMPUS has long had the reputa- tion, though sometimes phrased in dif- ferent terms, of being culturally arid in most circles and sopping wet in other, smaller ones. The culture hounds, generally speaking, are supposed to have little ,to do with the non-aesthetes, and definitely visa- 7ersa. Not being an enthusiastic backer of this theory, I find myself encouraged now and then to hear about projects or activities which tend to disprove it. The latest is the announced revival of the Modern Poetry Club. I might say to begin with that I am dis- tinctly biased in favor of .the group, having enjoyed participating in its activities for some time prior to its disbanding two years ago. The basi idea was then, and presum- ably will be now, the discussion of modern poetry in an easy, non-academic climate,-the nat.ural result of a small group talking over matters in which they are interested. This is not to say that we didn't learn anything; on the contrary, I think we all profited to some extent, perhaps primarily in learning how to appraoch modern poetry for the most enjoyment. As I recall, membership was never lim- ited, either in name or in practice, to stu- dents. of English or closely associated fields..Rather, anyone who felt a sufficient interest to show up at a session was wel- comed, and I have been assured by the new sponsors that this will hold true now. Of course, the success of the Modern Po- etry Club at this point rests in the interest of its members. They will have their first meeting tonight in the League, and if you are so inclined, why not drop up and sea what goes on? I can promise some interest- ing talk, not an unpleasant thing in itself, and if you happen to pick up a little edu- cation on the side, so much the better. -Chuck Elliott Democracy rVHE RECENT news story out of San Fran- cisco telling how the good citizens voted a Chinese born mechanic out of their neigh- borhood seems to indicate that some of our people could use an Americanization course from foreign born citizens. Sing Sheng and his American born wife, in typical democratic fashion invited the residents of the neighborhood in which he moved, to take a vote on whether they wanted the Sheng family to remain their neighbors. The neighbors responded in equally undemocratic fashion by asking the Shengs to leave their white paradise. We have heard the social scientists over and over again explain that the coloring of the skin and the slanting of the eyes means no more than the coloring of the eyes or the slanting of the toes. Of course if we interpret a different col- ored skin as a red stop light and never get close enough to see what makes the person DRAMA At Lydia Mendelssohn;. JOAN OF LORRAINE, by Maxwell An- derson, produced by the Student Players. THE STUDENT PLAYERS, in six produc- tions since their organization in Febru- ary, 1950, have been devoted to bringing to the campus the Broadway flavor in play production. At times, as in last spring's "Finian's Rainbow," they have managed to match anything that has been presented by amateurs hereabouts in the last five years. The very things that made "Finian's Rainbow" so good, however, operate to the disadvantage of "Joan of Lorraine" and leave it no more than a moderately interesting student production. At least, the same wide-eyed innocence and pur- poseful energy that brightened last . spring's musical popped up so frequently in the current offering that the brooding quality of the drama was dissipated in the ----------- MUSIC I one-level force of the presentation. These qualities (innocence and energy) are, no doubt, real elements of the enigma of Joan of Arc, but the playwright felt, for maximum effect, they must be funneled through the sophisticated alter egos of the director and the star who are putting on the play of "Joan." Without the implication of still unspent resources in these characters, the play will not really come alive and be left somehow groping by the challenge of the trial and adjuration scenes. James Brodhead, in the important role of Masters, plays with cynicism, but with- out much sense of tired humanity. Patricia Skinner, in the difficult title role, has warmth, but not quite enough range to give the dual part its fullest meaning. Theatrically, the play moves very well. It uses the same "stage which is a stage" that "Our Town" employs and compels interet with equal effectiveness. It is probably at its best in the last half of the first act in the' scene which introduces the Dauphin. This role, played- by Roy Strozzi, does not re- quire much dual interpretation but gives the play some of its richest moments. Among the best of the supporting cast were Shirley Forsyth and John Geralt. The production does, in short, competently handle Anderson as a dramatic technician, but beyond, leaves him little more than a cracker-barrel tragedian. -Bill Wiegand At The Michiganz. . THE WELL RACE RIOTS are not pretty things, and this picture carries the realism leading up to one much further than any of the previous Negro problem movies. Because of the relatively unknown cast and the cas- ual acting of extras, the film assures the Law School Admission Test: Candi- dates taking the Law School Admission Test, February 23, are requested to re- port to 100 Hutchins Hall at 8:45 a.m., Sat. The session will last until 1 p.m. Psychology Colloquium. Fri.. Feb. 22, 4:15 p.m., Rackham Assembly Hall. Dr. Ronald Lippitt, of the Research Center for Group Dynamics, will speak on "Replication of a Field Study on Social Influence." Doctoral examination for Peter Ray- mond Girardot, Chemistry; thesis: "A Tracer Study of the Reaction between Sodium and the Diammoniate of Di- borane," Thurs., Feb. 21, 3003 Chemis- try Bldg., 1:30 p.m. Chairman, R. W. Parry. Bacteriology Seminar. Fri., Feb. 22, 11 a.m., 1514 East Medical Bldg. Speak- er: Dr. Cyrus Levinthal. Subject: Bacteriophage. History Make-up Examinations. Sat., Mar. 1, 9-12, 2016 A. H. You must ob- tain written permission from your in- structor, and then sign list in History Office. ConcertsI Organ Recital: Carl Weinrich, guest organist, will be heard in a program at 8:30 Thursday evening, February 21, in Hill Auditorium. Compositions by Buxtehude, Sweelinck, Bach, Haydn, Honegger and Hindemith. Open to the public without charge. Mr. Weinrich is Director of Music at Princeton Uni- versity Chapel. Exhibits Museum of Art, Alumni Memorial Hall. Four Centuries of French Prints, through February 26; Venice (LIFE Photographs), through February 28. Weekdays 9 to 5, Sundays 2 to 5. The public is invited. Fine Arts under Fire, a photographic exhibition prepared by theaeditorsof LIFE magazine, through March 1. first floor Exhibition Corridor, College of Architecture and Design. Events Today Seminar. Lane Hall, 7-8 p.m. First meeting of a series of ten on the sub- ject: "The Thinking of One of the World's Great Men-Albert Schweister." Discussion leader: Dr. Kenneth Leisen- ring. Pershing Rifles, National Honorary Military Society of Pershing Riflemen. Smoker, 8 p.m.,, Room 3D, Union. All first and second year cadets, in either the Armty or Air ROTC, interested in becoming members of this organiza- tion are invited to attend. (All P. R. of- ficers not needed for drill are to be at the Union at 7:45 p.m. in complete uniforms). First year experiences in marketing jobs. The 6tudent Marketing Club presents three speakers from the mar- keting field. Each speaker is a re- cent graduate of this school and will discuss with students his experiences during his first year in marketing work, prospects in his field, etc. Speakers: Donald J. Massnick, U.S. Steel Co.- Marketing Research: D. Roger Mac- Naughton, I.B.M.-Industrial Selling; and Arthur Cone, Sears, Retailing. 7:30 p.m., 131 Business Administration. All students are urged to attend, Modern Poetry Club. Organizational and membership meeting, League, to be el discussion by three students on "What should be the policy of the United States toward Indo-China," 7:30 p.m., 1035 Angell Hall. Open to everyone on campus. Kappa Phi: Supper and program, 5:30 p.m., at the Methodist church. All Imembers are urged to be present. International Center Weekly Tea for foreign students and American friends, 4:30-6 p.m. U. of M. Sailing Club. Meeting, 7:30 - p.m.311 West Engineering. Business meeting. La p'tite 'ausette meets from 3:30 to 5 p.m. in the south room of the Union cafteria. Wolverine Club: 'Ensian pictures wil be taken at 7:15 p.m., Union. ComingEvents' Canterbury Club: Holy Communion, 7 a.m. on Friday, followed by breakfast in Canterbury House. Motion Pictures, auspices of the Uni- versity Museums. "Cell-Structural Unit of Life." "Cells and their Func- tions," and "Life in a Drop of water." 7:30 p.m., Fri., Feb. 22, Kellogg Audi- toritun. Second Michigan Conference for Fac- ulty, Administrators and Graduate Stu- dents will meet at the Union Sat., Feb. 23. for an all-day conference, the theme being: "Christian Values in Higher Education." Open to local faculty as well as those from colleges over the State. Speaker at the luncheon: Dr. Edwin E. Aubrey, 'University of Penn- sylvania: "Adequate Resources for the Christian Teacher." Telephone Lane Hall for reservations. Oratorical Contest. The University of Michigan sponsors an oratorical contest with speakers from the Universities of Michigan, Wis- consin, Minnesota, Northwestern, Iowa, and Western Reserve. Preliminaries will be held Fri., Mar. 14, 4 p.m., 4203 n- gell Hall. This contest is open to sophomores, juniors, and seniors. The topic must be one of public interest, the length not over 1800 words. Further information may be had from members of the staff of the De- partment of Speech, or at the office of the Department, 3211 Angell Hall. 'Age of Reason' The very nature and design of religion, if I may so express it, prove, even to demonstration, that it must be free from every thing of mystery, and unincumbered with every thing that is mysteri- ous. Religion, considered as a duty is incumbent upon every liv- ing soul alike, and therefore, must be on a level to the understanding and comprehension of all. Man does not learn religion as he learns the secrets and mysteries of a trade. He learns the theory of religion by reflection. 'It arises out of the action of his own mind upon the things which he sees, or upon what he may happen to hear or to read, and the practice joins itself thereto. -Thomas Jefferson ; SL Reasons . . To the Editor: AS "one of the .campus's most popular young dillitantes," who helped to push the time limit motion through Student Legisla- ture and the Student Affairs Com- mittee last year, I feel it only fair that the arguments in favor of the new bias bill proposal be pre- sented more fully than Mr. Hel- man has stated them. Certainly the new version is watered down, not because SL is afraid of another setback, but be-a cause the last setback taught many of us that it is necessary to proceed slowly when dealing with such a conservative, perhaps reac- tionary administration. Many of those who voted against the time limit did so in the conviction that SL must move more slowly toward a strong and effective motion, and that such a- motion will come about only after' the administration has tightened its safety belt and admitted in an.' actual law that discriminatory' clauses are bad and cannot be allowed to remain untouched by a democratic institution in a democratic society. To date the University has never admitted that campus organizations should attempt to remove discriminatory clauses before they can be con- sidered full members of a demo- cratic society. Some who voted against the strong and in favor of the weak proposal did so to test the truth of rumors which have seeped' down through the lines to us- rumors that state the University does not care whether or not campus groups have discrimina- tory clauses in their constitu- tions. The new, weak, necessary mo- tion asks only the simplest actions from offenders. There is no ex- cuse for the failure of its passage unless the rumors are true. If the' rumors are not true, the Student Legislature will have forced the University to take some stand on this issue, no matter how weak a stand. Therefore, the way will be open for future strong legislation on this subject. But there must be something on the books concern- ing discriminatory clauses before we push through a time limit. The University is too conservative to swallow a time limit before de- vouring an appetizer.. -Leah Marks * * * French Rule . . To the Editor: There has been a great deal of criticism in the last month on the French administration of Morocco and Tunisia. Much of it has given a false impression of the forty years that France has been in these countries. Like any 'orm of government it has brought both advantages and disadvantages. If, on the one hand, Prance has controlled rather than I merely protected Morocco and Tunisia, on the other hand it has furthered economic prosperity, social peace, and a healthy population. If the French peopleare hated, how does one explain the thouands of young Moroccans and Tunisians who voluntarily enlist in the French army? On the other hand, it is true that the rights of free speech and assembly are not always respected and that theiFrench are still re- fusing the idea of a Moroccan Union, which means, in effect, that the Moroccan workers will have to join the French Commun- ist CGT (Union). If the French were not taking steps to encourage further im- provements and to end, their con- trol, there would be nothing to say in their defense. But they have promised to bring Tunisia and Morocco to independence. This program for the welfare of Moroc- co must not be sacrificed in 'order to satisfy the demands of colonists who fear that their interest may be affected by a change of sover- eigns. Nor must it be accelerated at a time when the possibility of Communist control is still threat- ening. I am sure that North Africa will finally be .given complete in- dependence and not just a change of rulers. The representatives of the Arab countries, who are trying to raise sentiment against foreigners in order to make their people forget the troubles they have had under their own rulers, would be better off to start worrying about the day they will no longer have their favorite scapegoat. J. G. Castel Month's Research . . . To the Editor: IT is interesting to note, in con- nection with Rich Thomas' controversial article, "I Killed the President" (Michigan Daily, Jan- uary 15), that the Soviet Union did publish a. reply to the war articles' in such magazines as Collier's. The Soviet magazine "New Times", which is available in English, published in its January issue an article pre-dated Janu- ary, 1956. It is written on the assumption that the U.N. had reached agreement on banning the A-bomb and that the Big Five had signed a peace pact in December, 1952. It says "Three years have passed since the Peace Pactwas signed, and with each month 'we have felt its beneficial. influence more and more. The cold war is over, normal economic relations have been restored be- tween West and East, the burden or armaments, which weighed so heavily on the peoples, has been substantially diminished ... And in Britain today--the results can -be seen in the rows of brand-new houses and schools, and in the better stocked larders, now that rationing is gone." According to William Stoneman (Chicago Daily News, January 28th), this article has been widely reprinted In Britain, Holland, France, Dn- mark and Italy. In view of the editorial note accompanying "I Killed the Presi- dent", with its stated purpose of "making those U.S. citizens (re- sponsible for the war articles) see the obviously detrimental effect their pieces have had on the world's uphill struggle for peace", this information is particularly relevant. Mr. Thomas' piece, under the guise of a genuine reprint from' a Soviet journal, has the effect of another attack on the Soviet Union. He could have found, with just a. little more effort, the actual stand taken, -Ethel Schechtman Sallie IH. Sears Paul Graubard Patricia Murphy SL Thanks .. To the Editor: O N behalf of the Student Book Exchange Board of the Stu- dent Legislature, I wish to express my sincere appreciation for the work that was done, and the hours that were spent, by the many students who helped make the operations of this semester a suc- cess. -Phil Berry, Chairman Student Book Exchange Board ~7I6 4 I 1: , - . ;, _z ,t s ti4 3'- Sixty-Second Year Edited and managed by students of the University of Michigan under the authority of the Board of Control of Student Publications. Editorial Staff Chuck Elliott.........Managing Editor Bob Keith...............City Editor Leonard Greenbaum, Editorial Director Vern Emerson ..........Feature Editor Rich Thomas ..........Associate Editor Ron Watts .............Associate. Editor Bob Vaughn ...........Associate Editor Ted Papes.............Sports Editor George Flint ....Associate Sports Editor Jim Parker .....Associate Sports Editor Jan James............Women's Editor Jo 'Ketelhut, Associate Women's Editor Business Staff Bob Miller.........Business Manager Gene Kuthy, Assoc. Business Manager Charles Cuson ....Advertising Manager Sally Fish...........Finance Manager Circulation Manager ........Milt Goetz Telephone 23-24-1 Member of The Associated Press The Associated Press is exclusively entitled to the use for republication of all news dispatches credited to it or otherwise credited to this newspaper. All rights of republication of all' other matters herein are also reserved. Entered at the Post Office at Ann Arbor. Michigan, as second-class mail matter. Subscription during regular school year: by carrier, $6.00; by mail, $7.00. I 1j T HE FIRST Ann Arbor appearance of the Singing Boys of Norway last night was an unfortunate example of what piecemeal programming and superficial conducting. can do to potentially good chorus material. It is difficult to understand why a group such as this one should feel com- pelled to scatter Norwegian folk-songs throughout their program, apparently at random, to hold the attention of the audi- ence. And it is unnecessary for a chorus capable of as diversified arrangements as a boys' choir to intersperse violin and piano solos in their program for the sake of variety. No choir, not even a group as appealing as a boys' chorus, can trans- form worthwhile music into a listenable concert without some sense of unified pro- gramming. Ragnvald Bjarne, who conducted the con- 1 BARNABY i"2 52 Let's all go into the dining room and cut the cake-Now where's Barnaby? Come, Barnaby. You have to blow out the candles- II . I