E MICH GAN DAILY Propaganda In The Press, No. 6: Potential Effect On The Public; Opinions Little Changed; Press Today Is Almost Entirely Conservative I' /' m -b and managed by students of the University of n under the authority of the Board in Control of Publications. led every morning except Monday during the . by year and SumnV Session. Member of the Associated Press Issociated Press is exclusively entitled to the republication of all news dispatches credited to ot otherwise credited in this newspaper. All f republication of all Other matters herein also d at the Post Office at Ann Arbor, Michigan, as lass mail matter. iptions during regular school year by carrier, lmail, *4.50. REPRESENTED FOR NATIONAL ADVERTISING BY National Advertisi/ig Service, Inc.. College Publishers RePresenative 420 MADIsoN AVE. NEW YORK. N. Y. CHICAGO 'BOSTON - LOS ANGLAS - SAN FRANCISCO er, Associated Collegiate Press, 1938-39 Board of Editors g Editor . . Robert D. Mitchell 1 Director . . . . . Albert P. Mayio tor . . Horace W. Giimore eEdiitor. . . Robert L Itzhenry e Editor . . . . 8. R. Kleiman e Editor . . . . . Robert Perlman e Editor . . . . . . Earl ilman e Editor . . . . . William Elvin a Editor . . . . . Joseph Freedman litor . «.. . . . " Joseph Gliee s Editor . . . Dorothea Staebier Editor. . . . . . Bud Benjamin Business Departnent Manager. . . . . Philip W. Buchen anager . Leonard P. Blegeiman ing Manager, . . William L. Newnan s Business Manager . . Helen Jean Dean s Service Manager . . Marian A. Baxter NIGHT EDITOR: JUNE HARRIS. he editorials published in The Michigan y are written by members of the DalyW f and represent the views of the writers t " 4 A RTHUR C. HORROCKS, in his ad- dress to the Foremen's Institute here t week, painted a bright picture of industry's ure. He said that industry for the first months this year is 30 per cent better than during e same time last year. f it is true, as Mr. Horrocks believes, that the feels of industry are actually rolling forward ain, certainly nothing should be placed in. eir way. That is the attitude industry takes, A the administration seems to be falling in e with that view. A great hindrance to recovery, however, was inted out recently by the Council of State vernmerlts which met in Chicago. The Coun- emphasized the existence of restrictive trade rriers between states in spite of the prohibi- n in the first article of the Constitution. President Roosevelt said in a communication, the conference that "damaging restrictions" the last few years have hindered the free flow commerce within American borders. "Busi-, 5s, agriculture and labor have all suffered," said, "because of State and regional discrim- tory measures adopted in 'vain hope of pro- ting local products from the hazards of eco- nic fluc'tuations." 3e added that "Interstate trade barriers, if owed to develop and multiply, will . . . con- ute problems even more serious than inter- tional tariffs." ['he conference learned of the -bewildering and tly mass of restrictions which truckers of rchandise face ininterstate commerce. Regis- tion fees for a five-ton truck driving froW bama to South Carolina amount to $1,100. es or taxes on incoming trucks in a number states range from $30 in Illinois to $400 in bama. 'he "Ports of Entry" and "Inspection Sta- as" in eight states are hardly more than in- state tax collection agencies. Many grading, eling and packaging laws are so administered to "protect" home industries. In many cases, -of-state beer has a higher sales tax than al brands. And there may be special license s and restrictions on those who sell it. Since reciprocity is the only effective weapon tes can use against each other, the selfish, low-your-nose trade policies these several tes have adopted may ultimately constitute .angerous threat to our national unity, instead only to industry as at present., -Hervie Haufler urphy's Reforms )ne of the great tragedies of the Roosevelt ministration is that Thomas J. Walsh of Mon- a died on the eve of his assumption of the ies of Attorney General; and that the Presi- it chose as his successor the easy-going, poll- il-minded Homer Cummings. The realization what might have been is brought home by the w Attorney General, Frank Murphy, whose h idealism, stern conception of the duty of blic officials and administrative vigor are rem- scent of Senator Walsh. In his comparatively short tenure, Mr. Murphy s already made a deep impression on the mtry by actions on a score of fronts, and on ssouri particularly because of his scornful re- ;al to permit the Pendergast fixers to influence By JOSEPH GIES In the five previous articles I have cited some of the means by which newspapers propagate their views through tricks of phraseology, dis- tortion and emphasis. By being constantly on the lookout for these devices we can do much to mitigate their effect. Before going into that, however, let us examine a few facts in connection with newspaper propaganda in general and its potential effect on the public. Elmo B. Roper, Jr., writing in Publi Opinion Quarterly for July, 1937, on "Neutral Opinion on the Court Proposal," said: "Contrary to the apparent belief of some poli- ticians in election years, public opinion on mat- ters of importance does not change overnight.- While a convincing case might be made out in behalf of the fickleness of public opinion, it re- mains by and large one of the most solidly de- pendable forces in this country." He then quoted the Fortune Magazine polls on the Supreme Court of April, 1936 and April, 1937. In the first, before the court fight, 21.7 per cent of the people thought the court stood in the way of the people's will, 39.2 thought not, the rest being non-com- mittal. A year later, in the midst of the press campaign against the court plan, 28 per cent favored the plan while 36 per cent opposed it. Another group of 14 per cent preferred "some other way" of changing the court. On the whole there was 'little change in sentiment. Reorganization Bill; Yet in the case of the Reorganization bill, there is no doubt that the measure was defeated by a public opinion artificially created. The key to the successful use of propaganda in the lat- ter instance probably lies in the obscure nature of the Reorganization bill, and the general pub- lic's uncertainty about its purpose. It was com- paratively easy to induce ignorant people to believe that the bill would establish a "dicta- torship," because hardly anyone actually read the measure's content. It is undoubtedly of great significance that so purely emotional an appeal to the American people at large could be so suc- cessful. One is inclined to wonder .whether an appeal for a dictatorship (under another name, of course) might not be equally successful some day. It is easy to imagine the reactionary press demanding "emergency powers" for a conserva- tive President in a time of crisis. Prof. Theodore Newcomb of the psychology de- partment of Bennington College presented a summary of attitude studies in the October, 1937 issue of Public Opinion Quarterly. Ektent ana likelihood of attitude changes, he found, are determined largely by the direction in which ,change is attempted. A correlation between lib- eralism and intelligence, which he said "may apparently be accepted as a demonstrated phen- omehon" and a similar correlation between lib- eralism and amount of information on the sub- ject in question, seem to indicate that all people can be influenced toward liberalism more easily than toward conservatism, and that this is especially true in the case of people of above- average intelligence. The important qualification is' the institutional allegiances transmitted by families, which are hard to break. Borne Out In 1936 Election The lesson of the 1936 campaign seems to bear out this contention. As a writer for the Quarterly, after discussing at length mistakes in the Republican campaign strategy, remarked with somewhat humorous gravity, the Democra- tic victory was not due entirely to superior pro- paganda technique. It demonstrated that, if actions do not necessarily speak louder than newspaper copy for the American public, at least they do if combined with a good radio personality. Without going into the question of the actual relative merit of the two candidates in 1936, we can say with so'me assurance that the public was presented with both sides of the question in reasonably adequate form. The point is, as the New York Times once remarked, propaganda itself is not dangerous, a monopoly of it is. As long as both sides of any issue get ample opportunity to indulge in catch- words, sloganeering and petty distortion, no who have disgraced the Judicial robes; it is be- cause the courts have played fast and loose with the assets of bankrupt estates, parceling out their administration to political hangers-on for the collection of extortionate fees; it is because each Federal Judge has been permitted to run the affairs of his-court like a petty kingdom, with no system of co-ordination; it is because Judges have been selected on a basis of partisan con- siderations, as a reward for political activities, rather than for their intrinsic merit. Mr. Murphy proposes to take corrective meas- ures. The Mantons are to be driven from office, bankruptcies should be handled, instead of on a fee basis, by responsible officials serving on salaries; the work of the courts should be coor- dinated to relieve intolerable delays and docket congestions as the United States Supreme Court has coordinated its work; while political con- siderations will continue to play a part in the. selection of Judges, there must be a limit. On the last-named point, Mr. Murphy re- marks that, within the short space of three months, we have witnessed the appointment of nine men in the appellate courts "who, for rare learning and integrity, it would be difficult to surpass." Unfortunately, in the.same period, we have also witnessed the appointment of a Judge in Louisiana whose activities during the Huey Long regime unfit him-for the bench, and an unseemly row in Virginia in which the President played small-time politics in an apparent and unsuccessful attempt to rebuke two hostile Sena- tors. The country has' a long way to go before the Murphy conception of the Federal judiciary is attainer. hu tthere qsems nonmustion that he great harm will be done. This is probably true even when there is a marked discrepancy in the relative volume of propaganda. The marginal audience, people who haven't made up their minds in advance, will be stimulated to do some measure of thinking, to at least consider which of the stereotypes has the greater rational value. The press at the present time is almost entirely conservative. The New York Post, The Louisville Courier-Journal, The Philadelphia Record, The New York Daily News, The St. Louis Star-Times and one or two others are the only members of the regular press which can possibly be called liberal, and even they frequently take the con- servative side. The labor press is discouragingly small. This is a chronic situation with no immediate prospect of remedy. It is undoubtedly highly dangerous, for the masses of the people cannot be expected to take any special care to get at both sides of social, political and economic mat- ters. It is certainly open to question whether the majority of the press can be counted on to support democratic institutions if those institu- tions threaten the publishers' interest, or even tio maintain impartiality in news columns. In this connection, certain facts brought out by a study made by Leo C. Rosten last year are of great interest. Mr. Rosten interviewed the Washington cor- respondents, the elite of the journalistic profes- sion, on the dependability and general worthi- ness of American press, publishing his findings under the auspices of the Social Science Re- search Council (The Washington Correspond- ents, Harcourt, Brace & Co., 1937.) In anony- mous replies to a questionnaire, 86 per cent of the 127 men who stated their views, expressed the opinion that "compartively few newspapers give significant accounts of our basic economic, conflicts." Other Views Expressed Other views expressed by the correspondents included the following: 60.5 per cent believe the press devotes too much space to scandalsand sensations; 63.8 per cent believe the publishers' cry of "Freedom of the Press" in fighting against the NRA wasa ruse; 46.2 per cent beileved most newspapers printed unfair or distorted stories about the Tugwell Pure Foods Bill (a majority since 32 per cent expressed no opinion on this matter); 60 per cent admitted it was almost im- possible for them to be objective in their report- ing because of their employers' bias; 55.5 per cent testified that they had seen their articles "played down, cut or killed for 'policy' reasons." Questioned concerning the integrity in news presentation of the nation's newspapers, the correspondents named the following journals "most reliable:" (in order) The New York Tines, The Baltimore Sun, The Christian Science Mon- itor, the Scripps-Howard papers, The StLouis Post-Dispatch, The Washington Star, The New York Herald-Tribune, The Washington Post, The Philadelphia Record, and The Kansas City Star. The least reliable, in order, were given as: the Hearst newspapers, The Chicago Tribune, Tli Los Angeles Times, the Scripps-Howard papers, The Denver Post, The New York Herald-Tribune, The Washington Post, The Philadelphia Record, The 'Daily Worker and The Philadelphia In- quirer. Divergence Of Opinion Certain newspapers, it will be seen, appear in .both classifications, indicating considerable di- vergence of opinion among the correspondents on the merits of the particular newspapers. This indirectly bears out our earlier contention that it is not propaganda itself which must be guard- ed against, but the exclusive control of it by a particular individual, group or class. Naturally, one tends to consider those newspapers reliable which present one's own side, and unreliable those which do not. Clearly, one cannot hope to find the truth by reading one or two news- papers, even with the greatest precautions against deception. A synthesis of propaganda is the only possible path to truth in the present condition of journalism, and such a synthesis, though by no means impossible to get, is diffi- cult. The Daily Worker will just about balance any Hearst newspaper, The Midwest Record will balance The Chicago Tribune, in news slant. But the Worker and the Record do not reach more than one per cent of the total readers who see the Hearst and McCormick publications every day. Whatever the future may bring in the way of development of labor and liberal newspapers through subsidization, trade union publications or other means, the outstanding fact about the American press in its present state remains thit the great majority of Americans read their in- formation on daily events from newspapers whose copy is slanted toward conservatism. It Seems To Me By HEYWOOD BROUN I listened with interest to the speech which Harold L. Ickes made about newspaper columnists. It seemed to me both lively and high spirited, and to' my ears it was rather more prankish t h a nC vitriolic. B o t h those who were praised and those 44 who were blamed will be wise, I be- - lieve, to take their brickbats or bouquets with a heavy side dish of salt. - The Secretary of the Interior was1 for the most part kidding. He is like- ly to find that he chose a tough audience for badinage, because even the most humorous of columnists is likely to be a fellow much more able in the matter of making jokes than taking them. Insofar as Secretary Ickes was seri- ous I disagree with him on several points. He touched all too lightly on the root causes of columning and columnists. In attacking the mem- bers of the craft, or.racket, to which I belong the Secretary failed to note the environmental influences which made us what we are today. A lot of it can be bl'amed on bad housing and a lack of ventilation, Mr. Ickes and I are newspapermen of approximately the same vintage. He was writing baseball in Chicago about the same time that I was dong a similar chore in New York. And so he has been in a position to watch with his own eyes the genesis of columnists. DAILY OFFICIAL BULLETIN Publication in the Bulletin is constructive notice to all members of the University. Copy received at the office of the Assistant to the President until 3:30 P.M.; 11:00 A.M. on Saturday.. * * * No single person invented this type oa feature. Its genealogy is far more palpable than that of Topsy. Signedi columnar comment was sired by; newspaper editors when they began to abandon the old tradition of per- sonal Journalism. As a baseball writer Harold Ickes ought to know that no fan would pay much attention to any account of a game unless a name appeared at the head of the article. If the piece con- tained bitter comment about a pitch.- er or an outfielder the average fan' would want to know, "All right, but who says so?" i A popular : reaction is somewhat similar in the case of Presidents. Thel dogmatism and omniscient attitudea which Secretary Ickes assigned to? columnists is far more apparent than' real. Indeed, it is a surface manifes- tation of inward quakings and qualms. The derisive finger of scorn has.1 often been pointed at all who use the first person perpendicular in carload lots. And yet "I" is a far less swaggering word than the editorial "we." Even though a columnist may seem to be sounding off with twenty-one guns, that telltale "I" betrays the fact that he speaks for himself alone and not a battery or corps of tanks. On the other hand, the "we" of the unsigned leader may suggest that the estimate set down comes from a convention of all the pundits of Man- hattan or Emporia, Kan. The columnist should not be obliged to add "in my opinion" to every sen- tence which he sets down. That goes without saying. It is the ghost which invariably haunts his writing. Any faithful reader gets to know the limitations of Sir Oracle as well as his virtues, if any. The addict should understand that he is not dealing with a stream of living water spring- ing out from the eternal rock but taking a tepid beverage from a most imperfect filter. * * * It should be easy for any column reader to take both the beam and the mote out of the eye of the com- mentator whom he chooses to peruse. He can do that much more easily than the columnist himself. Any slave to a six-day stint might under- take an auto-psychoanalysis and pro- claim to the world, "I think I should list the following blind spots in what I laughingly call my mental equip- ment." But when he was done even an inexpert accountant would dis- cover that he had omitted at least a dozen failings. Fortunately, columnists can func- tion by both direct and ricochet fire. For instance, a friend of mine told me that the first thing he read every morning was the effusion of a man whose name happens to be pure prussic acid as far as I'm concerned. "You' don't mean you like his stuff?" I inquired. "Like it!" roared my friend. "I think he is the greatest rascal who clutters the earth. But I've got low blood pressure. When I'm finished with that poisonous tripe of his I'm so mad that it peps me up for the whole day." Accordingly, any columnist under attack by Mr. Ickes or other critics can keep his chin up and reply, "I grant it is a poor thing, but at least it is my own and not a moving pic- ture." Union To Give Life Cards Registration for life membership in the Union will be conducted from ' (Continued from Pag 2) anoeing, boating, lifesaving and if >ossible sailing. Salary: $90. 2. Cook for Michigan Girl Scout amp. Salary: $110. Literary Seniors: The Cap and :own Committee has officially chos- :n Moe's Sport Shop and advises fit- ing at once. No deposit required. The Bureau has received notice of he following Civil Service Examina- ions. Last date for filing application s noted in each case: Michigan Civil Service: Welder Bridge Worker A. Salary range: $130-150. May 4. Weights and Measures, Inspector B. Salary range: $105-125. May 5. County Accounts Examiner IL Sal- ary range: $200-240. Right of Way Agent II. Salary range: $200-240. May 10. Boys Supervisor C. Salary range: $80-100 less maint. May 10. United States Civil Service: Senior Air Safety Investigator, $4,- 600, May 22. Assistant Librarian, Department of Justice, $2,600, May 22. Complete announcements are on file at the Bureau of Appointments and Occupational Information, 201 Mason Hall. Office Hours: 9-12 and 2-4. University Bureau of Appointments and Occupational Information.- Academic Notices Sociology 51: Make-up Examina- tion will be held Saturday, April 29, at 2 p.m. in Room D. Haven Hall. Freshmen, College of Literature, Science and the Arts. In order to give freshmen adequate opportunity to discuss their sophomore elections with their counselors, appointments may now be made at the Office of the Academic Counselors, 108 Mason Hall, telephone, Extension 613. You will be notified by post card when to ararnge for your appointment. Freshmen will find it to their de- cided advantage to secure official ap- proval of their sophomore elections now, since opportunities for consul- tation in the fall will be of necessity very limited. Arthur Van Duren. Concerts Carillon Recital. Sidney F. Giles, Guest Carillonneur, will give a re- cital on the Charles Baird Carillon in the Burton Memorial Tower, Thursday evening, April 27, at 7 p.m. Exhibitions Exhibition of Six Paintings by Three Mexican Artists-Rivera, Or- ozco, and Siqueiros-and water colors by Alexander Mastro Valerio, under the auspices of tle Ann Arbor Art Association Alumni Memorial Hall North and South Galleries; After. noons from 2 to 5; April 27 through May 13. Lectures American Chemical Society Lecture Prof. M. S. Kharasch, of the Univer- sity of Chicago, will speak on "The Present Day Status of the Struc- tural Theory of Organic Chemisfry,' in Room 303, Chemistry Building today at 4:15 p.m. Mayo Lecture: The annual William J. Mayo Lecture will be delivered by Dr. Harold I. Lillie, in the Hospita Amphitheatre, University Hospital on Friday afternoon, April 28th, a 1:30 o'clock. Doctor Lillie will speal on the "Correlation of the Specia Practice of Otolaryngology with th General Practice of Mediine." All Junior and Senior classes wil be dismissed to permit students t attend this lecture. The Staff an Internes of University Hospital ar cordially invited to be present. Events Today The Political Science ]Round Tabi will meet this evening at 7:3 p.m. in the East Conference Room o the Rackham Building. Subject "Scope and Methods of Political Sci ence. Institute of the Aeronautical Sci ences: All members of the Institut are informed of a meeting to be hel this evening, at which time ar election of officers will take place This meeting will be held in Natura Science Auditorium at 7:15 p.m., in stead of the Amphitheatre of the Rackham Building at 7:30 p.m., a originally scheduled. Movies will b shown, and the inspection trip to th Curtiss-Wright Corporation, Buffaio N.Y., will be discussed. Camp Filibert Roth: All students i forestry who expect to attend Cam Filibert Roth this summer pleas meet in Room 2039 Natural Scienc Building, this afternoon, at 4:3 p.m. Important information wil will deal with the excavation of the dinosaur, which took place last sim- mer in Montana. An interesting evening is promised and every member is urged to be present. Phi Beta Kappa. Annual Initiation for members elected this year will be held in the Michigan League Chapel today at 4:15 p.m. Professor Herbert A. Kenyon will address the initiates. All new mem- bers are expected to be present at this meeting. Varsity Glee Club: There will be a business meeting and a short appear- ance in the Union tonight. Prof. Mentor Williams will discuss the Humar, Rights Roll Call at a meeting of the American Student Union tonight at 8 p.m. in the North Lounge of the Union. Everyone is invited to attend, Men's Glee Club. Rehearsal and business meeting tonight at 7:30. Short program for Chamber of Com- merce banquet. Payments for pic- tures are due. All music should be turned in at this time. Sailing Club. Meeting tonight at 7:30 pm. The revised, constitution and by- laws will be discussed. Entries .for the teams that will race at The Co- lumbia Yacht Club in Chicago in two weeks will be considered. Entries for The Quarterdeck Trophy races will also be taken. All members are urged to attend. Special invitation is extended to all students who are in any way in- terested in sailing or racing. tMen's Physical Education', lub. to- night.at 9 p.m. in Room 318Of te Michigan Union. Dean J. B. Ed- monson of the School of Education will talk. All members are cordially invited to be present. Omega Upslion, National Profes- sional Speech and Dramatic Sorority, invites all women interested in radio to come for auditions at Morris Hail, 7:15 this evening. Michigan Dames: The Book Group will meet in the Rackham Building this evening at 8 o'clock. Coming Events Phi Beta Kappa. The Annual Iita- tion Banquet of the Alpha Chapter of Michigan will be held at the Mich- igan League on Saturday, April 29 at 6:45 p.m. Price one dollar. Profes- sor Robert S. Lynd of Columbia University will speak on "Scholar- ship in Time of Crisis." All members r of Phi Beta Kappa are urged to at- t tend. Especially' are members of other Chapters invited. Reservations should be made at the Secretary's n office at the Observatory by Friday evening, April 28. Hazel Marie Losh, Secretary Phi Beta Kappa. Visitors to Schoolmaster's: You are invited to a tea, Friday afternoon, e April 28, from four to five o'clock in the University Eelementary School Library. Members of Pi Lambda Theta will be your hostess. Fraternity Presidents: There will n be a dinner meeting of house presi- y dents Tuesday, May 2, 6 o'clock at 1 the Psi Upsilon house, 1000 Hill St. t Tau Beta Pi. The next regular din- k ner meeting will be held at the Union tl on Monday, May 1, at 6:15 p.m. Pro- e fessor Sherzer will present a talk and moving pictures on the Hudson Bay 1 country. d The Annual French Play: The Cer- e cle Francais will present "Ces Dames aux Chapeaux Verts," a modern French comedy in one prologue and three acts by Albert Acremant, at the Lydia Mendelssohn Theatre tomor- e row at 8:15 p.m. All seats. are reserved. Tickets will f be on sale at the box-office today : from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. and tomorrow - from 10 a.m. to 8:15 p.m. A special reduction will be made for holders of the French Lecture Series cards. e The Outdoor Club invites you to ac- d company them on a bicycle hike Sat- n urday, April 29. . We will leave Lane Hall at 2 p.m. il Those who do not own bikes may rent . them. The following week we shall 1e hold a moonlight hike and weinie s roast. All students are cordially in- e vited to attend these outings. .e ; Suomi Club: Meeting at 8 p.m. Fri- day in the Upper Room at Lane Hall. n A symposium on women in journal- p ism, sponsored by Theta Sigma Phi, e journalistic sorority, will be held at 8 e o'clock Tuesday evening, May 2 at 0 the Michigan League. Catherine 1l Lynch of the Detroit Free Press, The Editor Gets Told German Play To the Editor: On Monday night the Deutscher Verein pre- sented "Die Gegenkandidaten." I would like to express my objection to the practice of some of the instructors of "forcing", their classes to go. One instructor gave his class the choice between the play and five pages of translation; another the choice between the play and a summary of a novelette the class was reading. Tt nn hp a ia,d i, e a g e that the nlsv