The Weather
cold-
L
A6P, AOF
.Ahb.-
fa r t
A6F
att!j
Editorials
The First Of The
Sunday Forums...
Why Germany
Must Devalue ...
Unsettled and somewhat
er. Mostly cloudy.
VOL. XLVII No. 37 ANN ARBOR, MICHIGAN, SUNDAY, NOV. 8, 1936
PRICE FIVE OENTS
Quakers Take
Varsity, 27-7;
End Michigan
Hold On East
Statistics Prove Wolverines
Completely Outclassed In
All Departments
Murray, Elverson
Lead Foes' Attack
Sweet Plunges Over For
Kipkemen's Only Score;1
Penn's Passes Good
By FRED De LANO
FRANKLIN FIELD, Philadelphia,
Penn., Nov. 7.-(Special to The
Daily)-Pennsylvania today ended
Michigan's 10-year dominance in in-
tersectional gridiron warfare by com-
pletely routing the Wolverines, 27-7
before 35,000 people here at Franklin
Field.
At only one time during the battle
did Michigan force the play, this
coming early- in the third quarter
when they scored their lone touch-
down. At all other times the Quakers
were completely in charge, and with
Francis Murray and Lew Eleverson
leading the way gained, sweet re-
venge for last year's defeat at the
hands of Kipke's charges in Ann Ar-
bor.
Fighting Wolverines
It was a fighting band of Wolver-
ines that faced the hard running
Quakers here today but it takes more
than just fight to down Pennsylvania
this year. With such -a decisive tri-
umph over Michigan on their 1936
record the Quakers are planning to
seek the -Rose Bowl bid.
Before the game was three minutes
old Penn was well on its way to vic-
tory, the Elverson-Murray combina-
tion having already started to func-
tion in a winning way. After Murray
had returned the opening kick-off to
his 27-yard line he dashed through
Michigan's line 27-yards to the 48.
After two unsuccessful line plunges
there by Kurlish, Murray faded back
and threw a long pass to Elverson,
who had passed up the Michigan
secondary. He crossed the goal line
standing up and with Murray adding
the extra point from placement Penn
led. 7-0.
It was the superb punting of Mur-
ray that kept the Quakers in com-
mand. Five times he punted out of
bounds within the Michigan 20-yard
line and one other punt was downed
on the three. In this way Penn kept
Michigan's back to the wall through
most of the game.
Quakers Gain 212 Yards
Penn made eight first downs and
the Wolverines four, gained 212 yards
to 98 by rushing and through the air
gained 54 yards while the Wolverines
did not complete a pass. The sta-
tistics give an accurate story of the
game in themselves, showing Penn's
complete dominance.
The Quakers' second touch-down
came mid-way in the second quarter
with Elverson again carrying the ball
over the goal line. One of Murray's
punts went out of bounds on Michi-
gan's eight yard stripe and Sweet
punted back to Elverson who re-
turned to the Wolverine's 39-yard
line.dKurlish and Murray cracked
the line twice to take the ball to the
27 and then a lateral from Murray
to Miller placed Penn on the 18. El-
verson picked up 12 yards off tackle
and on the next play crashed over
for the tally. Murray's kick was
again good.
The third quarter opened with:
(Continued on Page 6)
1,150 Students
To Get $13,000
NYAPayroll
NYA checks for the first monti
have arrived and are ready for dis-
tribution, it was announced yester-
day by Prof. Lewis M. Gram, director
of the projects here.
$9,013.72 will be distributed to 905
undergraduates, it was announced,
and graduate students totaling 245
will receive $4,103.15.
Students may call for their checks
between the hours of 8 a.m. and4
p.m., at the University Storehouse.
Assignment cards must be presented
II -" - --O --tla
New Bar Head
f
t
t
s
t
I
t
i
t
c
it
Teacher's Duty Is To Discover,
Expose Truth, Wenger Claims
Ethics Code For Teachers attitude by Prof. H M. Davidson of
Formulated ByAAUP;the Romance Languages department
AAUP; at Hillsdale College. Then, he point-
Hirinig Standards Set ed out, problems of over-supply of
________would-be teachers might be lessened.
The codification of teaching ethics Clarification of the action justified
has been the problem for the last in extraordinary cases of faculty in-
two years of a committee which yes- efficiency or incompetency was also
terday through its chairman, Prof. advanced as a corollary of the taking
C. N. Wenger of the English depart- of this position by teachers general-
ment, submitted its report to the re- ?ly.
gional conference of the American In the section on relations be-
Association of University Professors. teween teachers and the non-aca-
Declaring that the report was in- demic world the code states that a
tended to bring discussion on the teacher should not do extensive out-
issues with which it dealt, Professor side work for pay in the academic
Wenger left the floor open for com- year, except with proper permission.
ments and suggestions from the This statement was approved with
other members of the society. Some the qualification that sufficient sal-
of the questions raised and the pro- ary be paid to the teachers by the
visions of the code touched upon in institutions.
the resultant discussion were: "Secretively" accepting payment for
In defining relations of a teacher partisan presentation of teachings
to his profession the code declares a was also condemned by the code. This
teacher's first duty to be "the dis- too, was also generally agreed upon
covery and exposition of the truth although secret payment was pointedI
in his own field of study to the best out to be little worse than paymentl
of his ability." With this there was of any sort, or advocacy of any ob-I
general agreement. viously partisan project.
ROSCOE O. BONISTEEL
R. 0. Bonisteel
Express Own
Ideas, Slosson
Tells Conclave
Says Teachers Should Not
Neglect Their Opinions
In AAUP Address
Carlson Hits DAR,
Hearst And Legion
Warns Professors That
Loyalty Oaths Threaten
Democracy
A professor teaching controversial,
subjects should be careful to point
out other existing opinions, but at the
same time should not neglect to state
his own, Prof. Preston W. Slosson of
the history department told members
of the American Association of Uni-
versity Professors gathered here for a
regional conference yesterday.
The meeting was divided into three
sections, all under the chairmanship
of Prof. A. H. White, head of depart-
ment of chemical and metallurgical
engineering. It began with a morn-
ing conference at 10 a.m., followed
by a luncheon meeting at 12:15 p.m.
and the afternoon council, at which
Professor Slosson spoke, at 2 p.m.
Controversial Limit Defined
Teachers of subjects close to cur-
rent thought, such as modern history,
philosophy and political science are
most frequently indicted on the
charge of introducing extraneous ma-
terial into discussion, Professor Slos-
son said, but the difficulty of defin-
ing extraneous matter in such sub-
jects is very great.
The chief limitation on a profes-
sor teaching a controversial subject
should be respect for his students, he
continued, and too often this is not,
Elected Headj
Of State Bar
New President, Prominent
In Professional Groups,'
Leads 5,800Lawyers
Roscoe O. Bonisteel, Ann Arbor at-
torney, and a graduate of the Law
School was yesterday elected presi-
dent of the State Bar Association of
Michigan by the board of commis-
sioners of the association in a meet-
ing held at Lansing.
Mr. Bonisteel becomes by virtue of
his election to this post the head of
' an organization composed of 5,8001
members who practice law in the
State of Michigan.
Long active in professional organi-
zations, Mr. Bonisteel was appointed
in 1935 by the Supreme Court of
Michigan to the board of commis-
sioners of the State Bar, a body
composed of 21 members. He was
elected first vice-president of the
board of commissioners during that
same year.
"The board of commissioners is an
active body of the State Bar Associa-
tion and was originally appointed by
the Supreme Court of the State of
Michigan," Mr. Bonisteel said yes-
terday. "However, the board of com-
missioners will be in the future elect-
ed by the members of the entire as-
sociation, and the president of the
State Bar is chosen from the board of
commissioners."
Mr. Bonisteel was graduated from
the Law School in 1912 and was ap-
pointed city attorney in Ann Arbor
in 1921 and held that office until 1928.
He is former director of the Michigan
Municipal League and was president
of the local University of Michigan
Alumni Club in 1934.
In addition to his membership in
various regional and national profes-
sional organizations, Mr. Bonisteel
has been active in politics. He has
been a delegate to Republican State
Conventions on numerous occasions
r and in 1928 was a delegate to the
Republican National Convention in
Kansas City from the second con-
gressional district of Michigan. He
was a presidential elector from the
same district on the G.O.P. ticket in
1932.
E fti 1
t
t
c
i
c
f
GovN~ernment I'ore
Checks Rebel Drive
On* Spanish Capital
As to what should be meant by
'discovery,' however, there were evi-
denced differing opinions. "Original
investigations," one aspect of 'dis-
covery' mentioned in the code, was
attacked on the grounds that no
college professor properly teaching
his subject had time for original
work.
Under the relations of a teacher
to his colleagues the code stated that1
no "unfair" competition for position,r
rank or salary should be indulged
in by faculty members, and that "in-
discriminate disparagement" of other7
teachers should be avoided. It fur-
ther added, however, that "honest
and timely appraisal of a colleaguea
that is for the benefit of educational
service" should not be restrained.
The setting of definite standards
for employment or discharge of in-
structors was foreseen to be a prob-
able result of adoption of such an
Student Body To Greet
Team At Depot Today
Michigan's football squad arrives
at 2:45 p.m. today at the depot and
it is planned that they will be re-
ceived by members of the' student
body, according to Miller Sherwood,
37, president of the Men's Council.
Arriving on the same train with
the team will be Michigan's band
which will play for the occasion, ac-
cording to a wire received by Sher-
wood last night from Dr. William Ra-
velli, director of the band.
A cheer leader will also be there'
to aid in welcoming the team, Sher-1
wood said, and "it is hoped that de-.
spite yesterday's loss the student body
will take advantage of this oppor-
tunity of showing their appreciation
of the team," he added.
Mearns Finds
Children Have
Innate Artistry
Parent Education Institute
Hears Speaker Describe
Rhythm In Speech
Drawing the seventh annual Parent
Education Institute to a close, Prof.
Hughes Mearns of New York Uni-
versity spoke of an innate artistry in
children yesterday in the University
'M' Band Dazzles
Crowd With Novel
Marching, Music
Fr. Conlin s
National Union
EndsActivity,
DETROIT, Nov. 7-/P)--The Rev.
Charles E. Coughlin announced to-
night that his National Union for So-
cial Justice, which he said was "thor-
oughly discredited" as the result of
Tuesday's national election, will cease
to be active and that he was "hereby
withdrawing from all radio activity
in the best interests of all the
people."
His National Union, he said in a
farewell broadcast, "is not dead; it
merely sleeps. It will live as long as'
truth lives, because the sixteen prin-
ciples (of the Union) are immortal."
Recounting his views of the Presi-
dential election, the Royal Oak,
(Mich.) priest announced the union
will adopt a "policy of silence" to-
ward the New Deal administration.
His withdrawal from the radio
field is a fulfillment of a promise
made at the Cleveland Convention of
the National Union last summer
when, after the Union endorsed the
Union Party presidential candidacy
of William Lemke, the priest said he
wduld abandon the air if Lemke failed
to poll nine million votes.
By A Staff Correspondent 1
PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 7.-(Special
to The Daily)-Michigan's football
team may have lost, but the Michi-
gan band and the contortions of
Drum Major Fred N. Wiest, '38SM,j
gave the several thousand students
and alumni present something to ]
cheer about.>
The band was introduced onto thei
field by a 16-trumpet fanfare, com-,
pared by newspapermen in the press;
box to that of Fred Waring's orches-
tra. The band then surrounded the
trumpeteers, playing the Victors andj
forming the champagne bottle which
was given last week in the Illinois
game. This time the formation end-'
ed in a "P."
Between halves the band formed
three revolving crosses to "The Music
Goes 'Round and 'Round." They al-,
so gave their interpretation of a
firecracker which exploded, sending;
b'andmembers all over the field and
forming a block "P" enclosed in a
keystone. Meanwhile the band played
the University of Pennsylvania march.
This latter act received a great ova-
tion from the entire crowd.
Friday morning John Houdek, base
player, ate his breakfast with his
instrument about his neck. Yester-
day Philadelphia papers carried his
picture and a cut of the Keystone
formation.
The band closed its Philadelphia
stay last night when it broadcasted
at 10 p.m. on the National Broad-
casting Company's tenth anniversary
program.
Student FearedI
the case. "An 'A' paper too oftenI
means simply that the student has'
just guessed what the professor1
wants," he remarked.
Prof. Clyde L. Grose, of the history,
department of NorthwesternhUni-
versity, spoke after Professor Slosson
on "The Professor's Profession."
Stating that a professional spirit was
as essential to good work as an ama-
teur spirit is to good play, he enum-
erated three kinds of knowledge every
professor should have: understanding'
of his subject, sympathy with other'
subjects, and a knowledge of people.
Shepard Addresses Group
Imbuing the student mind with
particular doctrines results not so
much' from one-sided presentation of
the facts as from an emotional 'con-
ditioning, Prof. John S. Shepard of
the psychology department told the
morning session of the conference.
Professor Shepard's talk followed the
opening of the conference by Profes-
sor White.
Indoctrinated beliefs, he declared,
involve an emotional 'block' to any
rational approach to the subject, and
are determined by the extent of emo-
tional experiences which the believer
High School auditorium.
Professor Mearns presented several 1
examples by relating stories of smalle
children who spoke in a definite
rhythm and inflection scheme.-
In opening his address he said "as'
soon as children begin to speak they 11
attempt the language of literature.'
During those early months and years,,
when they are struggling with thev
difficult medium of language, occa-n
sional flashes of achievement come."
At a luncheon rheld in the Union,t
Professor Mearns, who holds the onlyc
chairmanship of a department ofr
creative education in the country,t
said "we are discovering that dull
children by one measuring rod may1
be really bright when a different scale
is used."
He told of a boy "who failed to
get credit for a course in gas en-
gines but who later was credited highf
for gas engines-Charles Lindbergh."
Glee Club Chooses
Willians President;
oyalists Take Heart After
Driving Insurgents Back
From Madrid
ocalist Cabinet
Flees T Valencia
efense junta Prepares
War Plans; American
Embassy Is Haven
MADRID, Nov. 8.-(Sunday)-P)
-Socialist militiamen, fighting off
ascist forces marching against the
apital, massed tanks and guns to-
y to withstand an insurgent count-
-attack expected at dawn.
Thousands of refugees milled about
L their search for havens as a num-
er of insurgent shells scored hits on
Leir houses on the outskirts of the
pital.
-The militiamen, girding themselves
>r the morning struggle, took heart
om the successful resistance last
ight to Fascist onslaughts at Villa-
rde and El Campamento, north of
arabanchel Alto and south of Ma-
rid.
In a desperate battle, the militia-
Len held off the Fascist onslaughts
"d slowly driving back the insur-
ents, made gains of more than a
ile.
Machine guns and tanks, supported
y new fighting planes, figured in the
itter clash.
Batteries of Socialist guns within
te city limits poured shells towards
he Fascist lines, bringing home to
he Madrid population how near the
nemy was to the Capital.
The government, from its new pro-
isional capital in Valencia, urged its
upporters to continue the defense of
iadrid.
Following a cabinet meeting, it
ssued an official communique in
hich it stated its departure did not
iean abandonment or retreat.
Rather, it said, the government was
ransferred to Valencia to maintain
iplomatic relations and to coordi-
ate the anti-Fascist fight through-
>ut Spain.
In Madrid, the defense junta was
n session late in the night discus-
ing war measures.
WASHINGTON, Nov. 7.-(M-The
9merican Embassy at Madrid report-
d to the State Department tonight
;hat every effort was being made to
>ring to the Embassy all Americans
n the city who wish to go there.
Eric C. Wendelin, third secretary,
who is in charge of the Embassy, tele-
iraphed at 5 p.m., (Spanish time),
oday that there was a considerable
umber of American nationals then
in the Embassy where they had
sought protection.
Wendelin estimated that possibly
150 persons might seek refuge in the
Embassy building. He said there was
sufficient food in the Embassy for
khat number of persons for three
weeks.
18-Year-Old Youth
Tries To Kill Self
Ben Zant, 18 years old, shot
himself in the right shoulder last
night at the Square Gun Club on 611
E. William St., suffering a slight flesh
injury. Police rushed him to St.
Joseph's Hospital.
Zant had walked into the shooting
gallery, fired two of the three shots
for which he had paid a dime, and
waited for the attendant, Lawrence
Pratt of Ann Arbor, to turn his back
before he lifted the gun and fired the
third shot into his shoulder. The
bullet glanced off his arm and elbow.
He was the only customer in the
place at the time.
Authorities at the hospital said that
Zant had previously been confined in
the psychopathic ward of the Uni-
versity Hospital.
Seniors Are Instructed
On Campaign Rules
Seniors participating in campaign-
ing for the class election Wednesday
were told last night by Miller Sher-
wood, '37, president of the Men's
Council, that campaign posters could
be put on University hulltin hnoard
Modern Art Will Outlive Current
Popular Prejudice, Gooch
Says
has undergone. Youth, he pointed1 Robert Williams, '37, has been
M issing Turns out, is very susceptible to emotionalected president f the University
conditioning, and the early years of Glee Club for the coming year, it
U p At Hospital life are thus the most opportune time was announced yesterday.
for indoctrination. Other officers chosen include Tom
- forindotrinaion.Jensen, '37, vice-president; Howard
Advantage is taken of this suscep- Cerers, '3Eceretary; Hudson
Stanley Hawkins, '39E, reported tibility of youth in attempts at mass Carrothers,'38E, secretary; Hudson
missing Thursday, was reported yes- indoctrination such as are carried on Dunks, '38E, treasurer and Edward
L. Sinclair, '37E, business manager.
terday in the University Hospital suf- in Germany, Italy and Russia, Profes- In opening its concert season Fri-
fering from a broken nose. sor Shepard continued. For matters Ia night ts GleeCl se twc
Hawkins had been playing basket- (Continued on Page 6) aance one Clat ad on
ball in the Intramural Building appearances, one in Ypsilanti and one
Thursday afternoon when he was in-'I 'CHIC' SALE IS DEAD here. In Ypsilanti a crowdopsnt0
jearedthGoinggimgediatelyYtoithe'
Shospital, he gave no thought that he HOLLYWOOD, Nov. 7. - (P) - High School community fair. In Ann
ihpitbliteamnotoghthamCharles "Chic" Sale, 51, noted come- Arbor the club sang before the Parent
might be listed among the missing dian and author, died today of lobar Education Institute in the University
until yesterday's Daily announcedHihcho
that his landlady, Mrs. G. E. Cossar pneumonia. High School.
of 817 Arch St., and police author-
ities had been unable to locate him.Jae
His landlady was notified yesterday
morning of his whereabouts. He was
still in the hospital last night.
No further word has been received ipe Says M rs el
of the whereabouts of Woodrow Wil-
son Smithey, Grad., Negro, 23 years By SAUL ROBERT KLEIMAN can support a much increased agri
old, who has been missing since last
Tuesday. Neither his landlady nor Palestine is not merely a senti- cultural population.
the police have been able to supply mental proposition and the solutio rainfall comes in the winter, vegeta
any further clues. trifl t-omshiewis1-henwihntin, nh
of te Jeishproblem in Europe by .- . , 4, ..,, ,.
1
Y
t
n
r
d
0
e
Q
i
n
.t
Y
By ROBERT MITCHELL
Modern art, because it is the ex-I
pression of a modern era, will out- 1
last current popular reaction against
it and move toward a refinement of
what it has started, Donald B. Gooch
of the College of Architecture said
yesterday in an interview.
"Popular reaction to modern art,"
Mr. Gooch said, "is against its ex-
treme excesses, such things as cubism,
which were mainly experimental and
probably will not last. The whole
movement of modern art had its
beginning in a reaction against cer-
tain historical schools which stressed
highly developed technique in paint-
ing without much meaning behind
it. 'he new movement is seeking
more meaning and force with less
attention being :given to unnecessary,
details to create "prettiness." "In
the beginning it went as far in the
other direction, but now there should
come a period of refinement. Every
art movement has a beginning, high
point and decay. Modern art is still
in its youth."
No particular forms of painting are
being stressed over others in modern
y art, Mr. Gooch said. Perhaps there
were hung over the wall. Now it is
being done directly on the wall sur-
face itself.
Water colors, Mr. Gooch continued,
are having a strong revival, while oil
paintings, on the other hand, have
been going through a slight depres-
rion. Etchings will probably not for;
a long time reach the heights they
attained under Rembrandt and the
Renaissance school.
"It is difficult for anyone living at
the time of movement and change
to be able to determine which men
will be remembered for their work,"
Mr. Gooch stated, "but Diego Rivera
must be mentioned among outstand-
ing contemporary artists. Rivera is
not motivated in his work by the idea
of reaction as are so many others.
Instead, he has a distinctive type of
drawing to express his ideas, and his
work is a good expression of the
modern period. Rivera is best known
for his murals, but is a fine academic
artist also." John Marin is the fore-
most water color artist, he said, and
has been recognized in this field for
several years.
There are differences of opinion,
Mr. Gooch concluded, as to what
r
t-
-
c
i
s
Student Directory
To Appear Tuesday
The 1936-37 edition of the Student
Directory will be on sale Tuesday on
the campus and at the Union and the
League, it was announced yesterday
by Bud Lundahl, '38, editor.
The Directory, published under the
supervision of the 'Ensian, will list
the names, telephone numbers and
Ann Arbor and home addresses of
students. The names, telephone num-
the building of a Jewish National;
Home in Palestine is not, as a great,
many people seem to believe, a "pipe;
dream," according to Mrs. Bernard
Heller, who recently spent three
months there.
Mrs. Heller, who is a native of
Roumania where the Jewish problem
is now acute, has many friends among"
the Palestinian pioneers and thus
has an intimate acquaintance with
the question. She came to Ann Ar-
bor this fall after her marriage to'
Dr. Bernard Heller, director of the
Hillel Foundation, last summer in
tion is helped in the summer by
abundant dew." However, the distinct
division of the climate into a rainy
and dry period is more of an advant-
age than a disadvantage, Mrs. Heller
said.
"It makes Palestine an ideal coun-
try for the intense gardening and the
cultivation of various fruits, which
are thus given an opportunity to ripen
to maturity."
"There is practically no land worth
cultivating in Palestine for which
water could not be provided in large,
quantities from underground sources
or brought - in from neighboring