Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Download this Issue


Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

This collection, digitized in collaboration with the Michigan Daily and the Board for Student Publications, contains materials that are protected by copyright law. Access to these materials is provided for non-profit educational and research purposes. If you use an item from this collection, it is your responsibility to consider the work's copyright status and obtain any required permission.

April 11, 1924 - Image 5

Resource type:
The Michigan Daily, 1924-04-11

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.


,. ...


Turner's "Europe Since 1870"
Attacked By Eastern Professor



I~A controversy which involve; the fu: theri makes the statement that'
Prof. W. L. Badger, of the chemical!authenticity of the account of the "England and Germany were the two
engineering department, will present aushsntithe dcountries desirous of avoiding war in
causes of the World war related in thes
two papers at the spring meeting of ss1914."
the American Chemical societyi pages of the history, "Europe Since3r
y i 1870," recently published by Prof. E. Professor Barnes makes the charge
Washington, April 21 to 25, in addi- 7R. Turner, of the history department, that no historian could have read the
papers presented before the gather has aroused much interest in the cur- scu ce. properly and then come to the
rent issue of the New Republic. conclusion that Professor Turner
He, in conjunction with L. A. Pridg- In the April number of that mag- reached, stating that he couldn't "un-
eon of the chemical engineering de- azine, Professor Turner answers the derstand (the conclusions) as a stu-
partment until last year and now with criticisms of his book which were' dent of history, though I do get some
the Diamond Crystal Salt company, made in a review of the causes of the ili-ht from an incidental knowledge of
swill present one before the division war by Prof. Harry E. Barnes, of clinical psychiatry," together with the
of industrial and engineering research Clark university. Barnes declared the inference that Professor Turner was
In connection with their heat transfer Michigan historian- has been false to nfpenced to write as he did. catering
symposium, which will occupy two of the "responsibility of a historian and to the "hyste-ia" of the day, that he
the four days. the purpoae of history," and alls on righ t further the sale of the volume.
Another paper, upon sugar evapora- all American historians to accept the ,lie asks the question finally, "Shall we
for problems, will be read before the "challenge of Professors Turner and ' uir" histolians to make a decent
sugar division of the society by Pro- Hazen (who is also included in his and respectable effort to tell the truth
fessor Badger who will lead the dis- attack)., and bring them to judge- so that we m"y rely upon them for in-
cussion upon his paper, as well as ment before the bar of professional dispensable material in the guidance
upon two thers that are to be pre- historical opinion." ciintelligent rublic thinking, or shall
sented before the industrial and engi- The debate is aroused over the stand we have to admit that history is, in
neering research division. 'taken by both Professors Turner and var ying degree, but disguised person-
While he is in the East Professor Charles Downer Hazen, of Columbia al, partisan, religious, or national pre-
Badger will also attend a meeting of universIty, that, to quote Professor judice and bias, and come to the con-
the executive committee on the ques- Turner, tthe Great war was begun by elusion hat it is worse than 'bunk'?
tion of heat transfer of the National 'e;many, and while it aroae from If history is to be mere literature, then
Research council. He was appointed large general causes, and though all we should dispense with professional
on this board recently at the national the participants were in some sense historians, and call in the novelists,"
meeting of the council when it was de- to blame, yet Germany was the prin- Professor Turner has recently re-
cided to investigate the matter of heat cipal immediate factor that made the rimned his position in the University
traf, war not to be avoided." It is this history department, to accent a post
1belief that Professor Turner reiterates on the history faculty of Yale univer-
in his reply in the New Republic, and sit.
INI M STYV it is in answer to the restatement of
his stand that Professor Barnes re-
In his letter, the Clark professor ad-LOOK !
COU SE FORI vances the view which he declares to
be held by most of the "revisionist" On the Inside BAC1h COVER of
Co-operating with the Michigan school of historians, who do not hold Your TELEPHONE BOoK.
Electric Light association the electric- any one nation more responsible for
al engineering department will give the cataclysm which threatened to:
a khort intensive course for electric engulf the world in 1914, than anoth-
metermen here during all of the com- er. He says, "There is practical unan- sIi4)E SALESMEN
ing week. The school is under the imity that the immediate responsibil- Shoewn, 4, Saturday and nex
direction of Prof. Benjamin F. Bailey. ity rests primarily upon Ilotezendorf A veek
It was held last year for the first and the war party in Austria, and - Detroit
time and its success then insured its Grand Duke Nicholas, Sukhomlinov Phone Mr. heodge herry---
repetition this Year and military group in Russia." He








The opening address will be given
by J. C. Langdell at 10:30 o'clock
Monday morning. The mornings
throughout the week will be devoted to
lectures on various phases of the
meter. In the afternoons the time will
be spent in the electrical laboratory
where experiments with various met-
ers will be conducted. The annual
banquet will be held at 6:30 o'clock
Friday evening. Practically all in-
struction will be given by members of
the department of electrical engineer-
ing of this University. Some special
topics will be discussed by other spe-
The purpose of the course is to as-
sist the electric utilities of the state
in the training of men in the theory
of operation, testing and maintenance
of electric meters. it is expected
from the advance registration that
there will be a large number in at-
~tendance this year.

. ,




The School of Ratailing Trains for Executive Positions
Merchandising Personnel Teaching
Advertising Training Service
Finance and Control
Merchants are eager to secure trained men and women
in these fields
Service Fellowships
Class room and store are linked closely together
Illustrated booklet on application. For further information write
Dr. Norris A. Briscoe, Director of New York University School of
Retailing, 100 Washington Place, New York City.

Y OU owe it to yourself to investigate the possibilities
for personal profit which membership in our organi-
zation offers to you. It is an obligation incument upon
you to come in and let us go over everything with vou..and




Rugs are to a home what clothes are to a man.
your rugs here Spring Vacation for cleaning.
"Every Rug Shampooed with Ivory Soap"

clear away any misunderstanding you may have.

If you



haven't a definite policy with regard to your finances per-
haps we can help you formulate one. Now is the time to
begin saving if you have not done so in the past.

(Continued trom Paze wcur)
old scene in which something is about
to happen to the heroine and the hero
is hurrying to the scene. In this
particular show the heroine is about
to don the veil and be forever after
locked in the nunnery. The hero, as
usual, is hastening to her-and the
directors make much of the oppor-
tunity, showing alternate flashes of
the heroine, whom they call the bride
(presumably following the Catholic
ritual,) then of the Crucifix, which is
subtitled "The Bridegroom," and of
the hero dashing to the rescue in a
fast battle-cruiser belonging to the
Kingdom of Italy. One could hear
the audience gnashing its teeth and
chewing its nails in excitement.
Cowles, however, having scented the
murky atmosphere of tragedy in the
openingreels, was not disturbed.
The Italian atmosphere was dis-
tributed with peculiar justice. There
was Vesuvius, of course, who had been
persuaded to take part in the pro-
duction: of this hyper-feature, and
there were one or two people in the
cast who were really very Italian;
but the Gish is about as Italian look-
ing as I am, and made absolutely no
effort to look even foreign-even such
businesses as waving her hands and
shrugging her shoulders were not at-
Worst of all, there was no comedy-
the exhibitor's unpardonable sin.
Patronize Daily Advertisers.-Adv

PHONE 1911

rfhe future may hold anything in store for you.

You may

meet wtih sickness or ill-health; you may desire to build a

new home; a business opportunity may
you be prepared for any of these things?

await you.


If you want a good neat
job with service
attached come to
C"w Qrt kesf y
SObRUMbr 6etter impressons


Do not put this matter aside. Come in to our office or tele-


phone for one of our representatives NOW!


" up " and see us
Arcade Theater

$500900, 0


- 11l l i i ltl tttltllu tll 11lll1111 111 1l t1 !!! i lil llli lilllt ll l!!l11til l#l tis lil i
he Oreen mrcc mu-in
w During vacation, April 11 to April 22 .
Luncheons 12-1:30
Dinners 5 :30-7
Will also take care of parties as usual.
205 So. State St. 1306-R A1
A # I t # 1 #l t ti # 1 1 i l l i l l i l l l l l i litllt l t i t l l tl ill1 l~ l l l i l l l l ! ! i ! ! t lt l l t a i l # 1 l i l I l l i ltl ii i I
Ia I
A Vest Pocket Kodak
orAutographic Brownie


has been subscribed by members of this Association who
live in and around Ann Arbor. These people have a sound
financial policy. They have realized the profit to them-
selves which will come from their investment. Do YOU!

I -

Ours is a seed store. We carry
all kinds of seeds. There is a
demand for cheap lawn grass
seed. We supply that demand
by furnishing low priced gras-
ses of good quality, meaning by
that purity and quick growth.
If for any reason a customer
desires low priced grass seed
it will pay him to buy it at
our storey Justbecause we car-
ry the finest and most expensive
of grasses is no reason why we







) .r... . s A ..... . .rt ! wit / i r ",. 7 1 r .a t n

Back to Top

© 2020 Regents of the University of Michigan