THE MICHIGAN DAILY MAGAZINE SUNDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 1922
JanuaryWhimsies-A Review
(By G. D. E.) tremely good. The first is a'bit of garet George Walker, wins my respect. Going back to the time of Chaucer,
Islofty tosh, well worded. Except for a bothersome repetition I can find no use of "hungered" as a
Following my criticism of November
Whimsies I was accused by nearly "Road-Sides," a prize essay of For- of a word or two, it is a fine bit of' noun, and even as an adjective it has
man Brown, is exceedingly trivial. work indeed. long been obsolete. Besides, the accent
all hands around as either having been The substance of "Cakes - and "My Task," a poem by Irene Mc- is on the antepenult and it would not
too violent, or having stooped to the Cream," the other prize essay, by Lois Fadden Kingston, is the old sobbing, take the article "an." Perhaps Miss
skullduggery of personal animosity. Whitcomb, is not much thicker, but much-used "mother" theme. It is al- Brunt meant to employ the word,
About the only persons who agreed it has a flash of originality and interest ways overworked and present in any "hungred." I find the expression "an
with me, strange to say;, were three to it. She has struck a good theme, periodical that carries much poetry. It hungred" several times in the King
of the Whie, s rtes, womI thad though she has hardly done it justice. nearly always raises a sniffle, and in James edition of the Bible. Well, that
of the Whimsies writers whom I had I suggest to her thereading of James rhetoric class it will nearly always noun is also long obsolete. It may be
criticized adversely. I appreciated Branch Cabell's "Taboo," wherein that fetch the writer an "A." It is, in brief, used of course-but is Miss Brunt's
this at the time, and I appreciate also author makes a prejudice against the an old dodge. poem a hymn? But let us read on;
thd civilized attitude of the Whimsies mention of food and the process of "Far Hills," a poem by Stella Brunt, the poem fascinates me.
editorial writer who asks for criticism, eating a symbol of the prejudice is easily the worst thing of the issue. "My wild -out-cry (sic) taints (hie!)
against sex in literature. Our two Not only is the whole business some- to a numbered sin.
either commsendatory or adverse. primary instincts, the desire to E what amorphous in its totality, but Before my Maker, I swear that such
If Whimsies can produce good stuff eat and the desire to reproduce, certain combinations of words are stuff is beyond me. Moreover, how
I am for it. I' have no prejudice are generally being much slighted completely 'beyond my ken. "An long has the verb "taint" taken the
against the publication nor against especially in American letters. I, hungered's misery"' is one such dative?
anyone who contributes to it. Proper- of course, discount the truck which phrase. It is a silly bit of pet-I "The half these tears, are they
ly edited, Whimsies should accomplish appears in Hearst's, Cosmopolitan, tifogging, it shows poor usage, in- not a joy to know
a great deal. It certainly should re- and other such bawdy periodicals. compatibility, and an outrage of poetic Such happiness can be?"
ceive enough material for some sort To get back to the essay, I must say license, to say nothing of bad spelling. (Continued on Page 8)
of selection. that it is finely written. My criticism
While the January number is faulty is, as I have said before, that :1[iss
in many respects and deserves criti- Whitcomb has hardly done justice to -
cism with about the degree of sever- her subject. If she had turned her
ity which I applied to the November keen humor to satire she would have
issue, still it shows a vast improve- improved the essay a thousand per-
ment. It is a hundred'percent better cent.
than the November number, and I wish Marjorie Rosecrans, whose effort IAn
to be approximately that much more praised formerly for its lack of pre-
lenient. As a matter of fact, I was tentiousness, turns about and delivers
not half harsh enought with the No. a shaft at the Pisiades--Knd falls
vember issue, somewhat short, Still I cannot say that - Hodd you like a brand new
The editorials of the present num- her poem, "Last Hours," is bad
ber, excepting the first one, are ex- "The Instrument," a poem rby Mar- "Cf TrTI R)fT-I ui A M =



..
...
...
..
:,
".
..,
:.
s ?
+e
wr
"..
.r
0
w
sw
s
s
N
r
s.
{I
} +ou
i
y
M

.J L/ lIZ )L. .LVIJUY 1ta Ll.. L3
If you are quick we will take it in trade
for one of these world-famous watches
Schlanderer & Seyfried,
Diamonds, Watches, Jewelry and
Silverware
113 E. LIBERTY ST.

«.
.
..
C
s
{'
s
s
_
rr
.
r
r
r
tr
s
r
m s



Winter Days invite
your Kodak
Our completely stocked shelves contain Kodaks and Brownies
of every model ready for your inspection-see them here.
Kodaks $6.50 up-all autograpic.
Brownies $2.00 up.
CALKINS & FLETCHER
324 S. STATE STREET

BAN KRUTAE
OF
Dresses, Coats, Suits and
Furs now in progress
A Bankrupt Stock. from a"Well-known firm selling
women's wear, is now on sale here. We bought
this stock right and we are- passing the savings on
to you. Never before have such bargains been
offered.
Every garment is new in style and perfect in work-
manship. Come and see these exceptional bargains.
ZWERDLING'S
217 E. Liberty St. Ann Arbor, Mich.
rrlrrlrlrrrrrlrrlrlrrrrrlrrr lrlirrrlrrrri l rrBll~illlrrrrrrrl![11H rirl rHltltH tlHH

I