The Wolverines and Fighting Irish have met sporadicaly since 1887, but Saturday the rivalry came to an end for the forseeable future. Notre Dame commanded a 21-point lead at halftir --and Michigan r threatened in t Devin Gardner accounted for four turnovers in the Fighting Irish's shutout win. A nightmare in South Bend A tell house at Notre Dame Stadium celebrated the Fighting Irish's 31-0 win over Michigan, the firt time the Wolverines haoe hes shut out in the series Notre Shame: Good, bad and ugl It wasn't all bad. But there were far more negatives than positives By GREG GARNO ManagingSports Editor We could have titled this "The not as bad, the bad and the ugly," after the Michigan football team was shut out by Notre Dame on Saturday, 31-0. We didn't, but there was plenty that went wrong in the Wolverines' first shutout since 1984. The Daily football beat picks out the good, the bad and the ugly from this week. The Good The weather was nice. A comfortable 70 degrees Fahrenheit on Saturday night with a perfect sunset and not a cloud in the sky. It looked good on TV and was great for tailgating. Aside from that, there wasn't much to be positive about. The Wolverines' run defense shined as it limited the Fighting Irish to 54 yards and one touchdown on 31 carries. That number includes minus- 14 rushing from quarterback Everett Golson, though. And most of those carries came in the fourth quarter, when Notre Dame had the game safely in hand. Junior wide receiver Devin Funchess was the lone bright spot for the offense, finishing with 107 yards on 11 receptions, but he wasn't always given the chance to jump up for the ball. The Bad Michigan's rush offense still posted a 100-yard game, but it failed to geta single runner over 30 yards and, most importantly, failed to score a touchdown. The combination of sophomore running backs Derrick Green and De'Veon Smith wasn't bruising enough to barrel over defenders, and the offensive line didn't open up holes. And the offensive line didn't do much to protect fifth-year senior quarterback Devin Gardner, who was sacked just twice but forced to run away even more. He fumbled the ball after the protection broke down and didn't have the time to sit in the pocket to pass to Funchess. The Ugly Senior kicker Matt Wile had a forgettable game in a season that isn't looking optimistic. Wile finished 0-for-2 on field goal attempts, making him 1-for-4 on the season. He couldn't manage to get the ball close to the goalpost on his second attempt, slipping on his plant foot. Michigan coach Brady Hoke said Wile's job wasn't in jeopardy, but backup kicker Kenny Allen was warming up on the sideline at times. Gardner didn't do much to help Wile out, though. Gardner and the rest of the offense failed to make it to the red zone and put him within a safe range. Gardner finished 19-of- 32 with 189 yards and four turnovers on the night. He started the game 6-for-6, but struggled for the remainder of See UGLY, Page 2B SOUTH BEND, Ind. - I've always been told you're supposed to start columns with a scene. But sometimes there is no scene. There's a nightmare that lasts three and a half hours. MAX It was COHEN supposed to liveup to its billing as the last game between two behemoths of college football, Michigan and Notre Dame, two teams that have provided fans the moments they won't forget. Someone was supposed to provide the moments that Denard Robinson, Desmond Howard and Raghib Ismail did, the ones you can relive as if they were yesterday. Not all endings are fairytales, though. Sometimes endings have three interceptions and a fumble from your starting quarterback, a secondary with more sieves than all of the opposinggoalies to ever play at Yost and an offensive line that has no answers in sight. Sometimes, endings are 31-0 drubbings. The beginning of the end was innocent enough. The Wolverine offensive line looked capable and Notre Dame used two timeouts in the first two and a half minutes of the game. Devin Gardner completed his first six passes and the game resembled nothing close to a blowout. Toward the end of the beginning of the end, there were two pass interference calls and they led to Notre Dame's first touchdown. The end cane quickly. With See NIGHTMARE, Page 2B SOUND OF SILENCE In 2011, Brady Hoke's bold answers inspired a fanbase. Now, the arrogance falls on deaf ears. SportsMonday Column, Page 2B A WELCOME HOME Playing for the first time at a renovated Phyllis Ocker Field, the Michigan field hockey team went undefeated. Page 3B