6 - Tuesday, September 23, 2014
The Michigan Daily - michigandaily.com
Decision day: Devin Gardner or Shane Morris?
Short-term risk
could result in long-
term reward
By ALEJANDRO ZUNIGA
ManagingSports Editor
Whether or not Devin
Gardner will remain the
Michigan football team's
quarterback in the upcoming
weeks will be decided Tuesday,
coach Brady Hoke said in
Monday's press conference.
The Wolverines are 0-2
against the Power 5 teams
they've faced, Notre Dame and
Utah. What's more, they didn't
enter the red zone - much less
score an offensive touchdown
- against either of those
opponents. And in those games,
Gardner has accounted for six
turnovers (five interceptions
and a fumble).
Meanwhile,sophomore Shane
Morris has no touchdowns
despite appearances in eight
games and a start in the 2013
Buffalo Wild Wings Bowl.
Don't expect a two-
quarterback system like the
Wolverines employed. late in
2012 with Gardner and Denard
Robinson. Hoke said the coaches
haven't considered platooning
under center.
Who should be Michigan's
starter? The Daily breaks down
the pros and cons ofbothoptions.
Devin Gardner, Fifth-year
senior
Anyone who can displace one
of the most electrifying players
in program history midway
through his redshirt sophomore
year is set up for being labeled a
bust.
And that's what happened
with Gardner. After he started
the year as wide receiver, an
injury to Robinson forced
Gardner to move back under
center. Behind him, the
Wolverines went 3-2 in their
last five games, picking up wins
over Minnesota, Northwestern
and Iowa, but falling in close
games to Ohio State and South
Carolina.
Gardner finished 2012 with
11 touchdowns and just five
interceptions, but that didn't
translate into a breakout
2013 season. Behind a porous
offensive line, Gardner tossed
11 picks, but the quarterback
rarely had
made some inexplicable
mistakes. Against Utah, he
missed receiver Devin Funchess
on an easy slant route, and he
was benched after throwing
a pass straight to a baiting'
linebacker.
That game was emblematic of
Gardner's entire 2014 campaign,
which has
enough time been replete
in the pocket If M a with errant or
to throw. If ichigan underthrown
For instance, makes the switch balls,
against i telegraphed
Michigan expect some passes and
State, Gardner incorrect
was sacked growing pains. reads.
seven times as And
the Wolverines Gardner's
accounted threat as a
for minus-48 runner has
rushing yards. been all but eliminated. The
Michigan released former quarterback's longest run this
offensive coordinator Al year is for just 18 yards.,
Borges after 2013, and some Quite simply, he just doesn't
of Gardner's struggles this seem to be improving.
year almost certainly can be In Nussmeier's system,
attributed to the transition to Gardner is failing as a passer,
Doug Nussmeier's schemes. and his ability to create is also
But this fall, Gardner has being largely impaired.
Shane Morris, Sophomore
Anyone who argues that
a transition to Morris this
weekend would be seamless is
either lying or sorely mistaken.
Morris has seen meaningful
action just twice while at
Michigan. In last year's Buffalo
Wild Wings Bowl, he went
24-of-38 for 196 yards, but
many of his completions came
on passes behind the line of
scrimmage.
And upon relieving Gardner
on Saturday with about 10
minutes to play, Morris promptly
accounted for two turnovers
of his own, throwing an
interception and then fumbling.
So if Michigan does make
the switch to Morris, expect
some growing pains. Despite
Gardner's struggles, he has four
weeks of game experience under
Nussmeier and practiced as the
No. 1 quarterback throughout
the offseason. Morris has never
proven himself as a better game
manager than Gardner.
If there's one area in which
Morris holds a definitive edge
over Gardner, it's in his arm.
Saturday, the sophomore
uncorked a 60-yard rocket
while under pressure in his own
end zone. Meanwhile, Gardner
underthrew several wide-open
receivers all afternoon.
And Morris is no slouch on
his feet, either. He dashed for
40 yards against Kansas State
in December, the longest run
by any Wolverine last year. And
he has demonstrated similar
mobility in his action this fall.
Of course, many may prefer
Morris simply because he has
been touted as the future of the
program.
This is Gardner's last year,
and Michigan's coaches must
weigh the risk of starting an
unseasoned quarterback to the
reward of developing him into a
better player before next season.
4
RUBY WALLAU/Daily JAMES COLLER/Daily
Fifth-year senior Devin Gardner moved from his temporary position at wide receiver back to quarterback in 2012. Sophomore Shane Morris has a strong arm, but he's also turnover-prone and hasn't yet thrown a touchdown pass.
Call: #734-418-4115 iews bullets:
Email: dailydisplay@gmail.com
Hoke presser
Los Angeles Times Daily Crossword Puzzle
Edited by Rich Norris and Joyce Nichols Lewis
ACROSS 3 Bullfight "Bravo!" 39 Couturier 49 Like some
1Redace to mist 4 Dehasoy'o Christian ancient
8 Insubstantial stuff "Las's 40 Shrek, for one calendars
11 Into deliverers 5 Syria neighbor 41 Blackstone 53 Mummy's home
14 Short outingfor a 6 Last letter ofta 42 Grand Canyon 54 Genesis twin
ogger pilot's alphabet pack animal 55 Grandma
15 From A to Z 7 Marksimilar to a 43 Sudden wind 56 CPR providers
16 The smile on a hyphen 45 Chess pieces 59 Canadian
smileyface, say 8 Waiting room and board, e.g. interjections
17 Green gem waiters 46 Reservations 60 Stephen ofvThe
18 Where to leggo 9 Very much 47 Bamyard animal, Crying Game"
your Eggo? 10 Be in the game in totspeak 61 EPA concem
20 Period of 11 Checking 48 Ink squiter 62 Arch city: Abbr.
meaningful conclusively, in
interaction chess ANSWER TO PREVIOUS PUZZLE:
22 Having the 12_- de cacao MESAS I SUP E G A L
wherewithal t3 Carpentry - -
26 Taketo urt t3astener B R O N C S E T H A R T E
27 From square one 19Performed really A S A N A O C E A N V I E W
28 "That'sausing poorly S T R 0 L L B Y S E E D E D
your head!" 21 San _ Obispo, A A A S E A S
33Detachfromthe Califomnia I D O L W O R S H I P C P A
dock 22Colorotwater M A N I A S T I N S H U N
34 Sharply 23 Cookout supply M N lS TP S J
delineated,asa 24Walkona bad 0 R I N G H A M F L A P S
contrast kneesay F L O E F O B B 0 0 K 1 E
35 Egyptiansnake 25Novelist F A N C R Y S T A L B A L L
36Actress Chadlotte Umherto S L A T E L K
35 s Lanka 29Dividednation C A F T A N TAI L GIA T E
39ooy-_ 31Teacerskuity B I L L Y C L U B O N S E T
42 Living thing ani rspurity I NA RAT
44fMk eresponsible 32Dublin-born R E P O S W A G E T 0 N S
46 Planck's Nobel 37 In every aspect xwordeditor@aol.com 09/23/14
prize-winning 1 2 3 4 s a a 9 10 11 12 13
formulation
48 Insulting remark 14 15 0
50 Equal: Pref.
51 Carnivorous 1
dinosaur, briefly 20 21
52 Small musical
interval sung in 22 23 2a 2 us 27
choral warmups
57 Let go us 29 a 31 32
58 Movie equipment
63"0. _fortune's 3a 34
fool!": Romeo 3 3s 37 38 39 40 41
64 Studt to practice?
65 Surreptitiously... 42 43 44 4
and a hintto 20-,
28-, 46- and 52- as 47
Across
66 8-owntreaters: 4s 0 51
Abbr. 52 53 54 55 56
67 Get at a store
68 Traditional 57 5 v5s9 1 yr162
Yuletide quaff
DOWN
1 Soul, to Zola as83 68
2 "A Christmas
Carol" hoyp y effrysecslen0/2/1
Oaa4'iaiuooCotentAgency, L' 31
"PRIME" PARKING FOR Sale
721 S. Forest "Forest Place"
$1500 Limited Passes Remaining
734-761-8000
primesh.com
CAMPUS PARKING $70/MONTH,
near U of M bus. 734-418-2050 or
i.fo@828greene.com
THESIS EDITING. LANGUAGE,
organizution, formaL All Disciplines.
7341996-0566 or writeon@iserv.net
By ALEJANDRO ZUN1IGA Against Notre Dame and
ManagingSportsEditor Utah, the Wolverines' two
Power 5 opponents so far,
Brady Hoke's regular Monday Gardner has combined for six
press conference was televised turnovers (five interceptions
nationally this afternoon by and a fumble).
ESPN. But Woke
The said he's
Michigan "He'll handle impressed
football coach with
addressed it like a leader Gardner's
his team's leadership
quarterback daeven as his
situation, does, hI ateve status as the
whether he happens " team'sstarter
believes the remains in
program is in question.
a crisis and "He'll
! NORTH CAMPUS 1-2 Bdrm.!
! Riverfront/Heat/Water/Parking.!
! www.HRPAA.com !
WWW.CARLSONPROPERTIES.-
COM
734-332-6000
H ELP WANTED
SUPPORT CHILD ABUSE VIC-
TIMS! Volunteer at Washtenaw Child
Advocacy Center. Staff the waiting
room. Work with kids. Must be 18+
yr(s). Will be screened for background
& criminal history checks. 4 hr shifts at
least once a meek for at least 4 months.
M-F 8:30-4:30. Call 734-544-2925.
more.
On who will start at
quarterback Saturday:
Sophomore Shane Morris
saw extensive playing time for
the first time all year against
Utah, replacing a turnover-
prone Devin Gardner in the
fourth quarter. After the game,
Hoke said the quarterback
position is up for grabs, and he
said in the press conference
that Saturday's starter will be
named tomorrow.
Hoke said he'll look at
efficiency when making
the decision, but that both
quarterbacks have been
"competing and challenging"
since fall camp began in August.
Michigan hasn't considered
platooning the two
quarterbacks, Hoke said.
handle it
like a leader does, whatever
happens," Hoke said.
Onthestateoftheprogram:
Hoke said he won't allow
criticism about his team's
2-2 start affect his coaching,
explaining the players
and coaches share similar
frustrations to the public.
He said he doesn't believe the
program is in a state of crisis, and
that they're building "a program
with a great foundation."
On improvements:
Hoke believes the Wolverines
will be a good football team.
When?
"Saturday," he said. "I think
we need to be a good football
team, don't you?"
-I-
INTERNSHIPS
INTERN WANTED FORfBirmingham
lawmoffice for 1-2 years. Must have at
leastBA or-BS widhstog es/coin
puter skills. Paid Position. Email resume
& transcript to: michawoffice@gmailcom
BUY 2 PEPSI PRODUCTS,
GET A FREE DAILY!
t
I
A