8A - Wednesday, April 2, 2014 The Michigan Daily - michigandaily.com Season in review: 2013-14 'M' hockey Position-by- position grades By JEREMY SUMMITT and ERIN LENNON Daily Sports Editor and Daily Sports Writer In a season with high highs and even lower lows, a second straight Michigan hockey season without an NCAA Tournament appearance is tough to swallow. Despite a talent-filled roster, one unit's weakness emerged often enough to overshadow another's hot streak, and ultimately, the Wolverines became the first team out on Selection Sunday. With hindsight at 20/20, the Daily grades Michigan's season. Forwards: The team lacked a dominant scoring threat all season, which eventually cost it a berth in the NCAA Tournament. Say what you want about forwards freshman JT Compher, sophomore Andrew Copp and junior Alex Guptill, but they came up short in separating themselves as elite scoring options when Michigan needed one most. That's not to say the trio isn't loaded with talent, but the Wolverines never had that go-to guy up top in late-game situations. Despite averaging 3.06 goals per game, the offensive unit could never string together more than a few impressive performances in a row. The Wolverines scored seven goals in three separate games throughout the year, and an abundance of potential was present from the beginning of the season. But when the offense went cold, finding the net was like trying to dig through ice with a toothpick. Grade: B- Defense: At one point in the season - the point at which the Wolverines had only one loss to blemish a record that included wins over Boston College and Boston University - the fledgling defense was asked to produce more on offense. At one point in the season, freshmenNolanDeJong, Michael Downing and Kevin Lohan filled the voids left by former Michigan defensemen Jacob Trouba and Jon Merrill, and they did it admirably. Guided by seniors Mac Bennett and Kevin Clare, the unit made an offense that netted fewer than three goals a game look good. But by the end, Michigan's top four defensemen - Bennett, Clare, Downing and junior Sinelli - combined for just 44 points. Bennett finished with 14 points, the captain's lowest, total since his freshman year. This inexperienced unit was predicted to be the weak point for a program that emphasized defense en route to 22 straight NCAA Tournament appearances. But no one could have predicted defensive blunders from veteran players. No one could have foreseen three turnovers-turned-goals that turned a 3-1 lead into a 4-3 loss to the Nittany Lions, just as no one could have predicted a Bennett gaffe three weeks later against the same, lowly opponent. Grade: C- Special Teams: One of the most evident strengths of Michigan's season was its special teams play. The power-play unit ranked 22nd in the nation with a 19.55-percent success rate. Tied for second in the Big Ten with eight power-play goals, senior forward Luke Moffatt played a pivotal role all season on the man advantage. Meanwhile, the penalty kill didn't fare quite as well statistically with an 81.7-percent success rate, ranking 33rd in the nation. However, the Wolverines did accumulate four shorthanded goals. Three came from Compher - good for the best mark in the Big Ten. At one point in the season, Michigan surrendered just two power-play goals despite taking 21 penalties in a six-game span. While the impressive performance on the defensive end didn't translate into positive results - the Wolverines went 2-3-0-1 in those games - Michigan coach Red Berenson had been preaching consistent penalty killing. Perhaps that was the lone consistent effort his squad displayed for much of the year, but it was certainly something to hold in high regard. Grade: B+ Goaltending: Sixty-three times in the first round of the Big Ten Tournament against Penn State, freshman goaltender Zach Nagelvoort gave his team another chance to salvage its season. One more save and a goal from his teammates, and the Wolverines may very well be practicing at Yost Ice Arena this week. Instead, Nagelvoort was screened midway through the second overtime frame, and his school record-breaking effort became the last of his freshman campaign. Without strength at the position, some of the Wolverines' nine one-goal wins are losses. Though the last two years of Michigan hockey ended without an NCAA Tournament appearance, perhaps the most striking difference between the 2012-13 and 2013-14 seasons was goaltending. Last season, from a horse race of disappointing candidates, then-freshman Steve Racine emerged as a leader, taking the Wolverines to a CCHA final and earning himself the starting job come September. But when the sophomore suffered a groin injury, it seemed consistency would be a luxury Michigan couldn't afford for a second straight season. In the sophomore's place, Nagelvoort, a late commit out of the NAHL, provided coaches with an almost-happy problem - two reliable starting goaltenders. Michigan hockey coach Red Berenson's teams have now failed to reach the NCAA Tournament in consecutive seasons. For much of December and January, Berenson made his decisions on a nightly basis, giving the nod to the goalie who performed best most recently, and forcing the two to compete during the week. After seven consecutive starts, when it seemed like Nagelvoort would be first on the depth chart each night, a slip-up against Penn State in February forced him onto the bench against No. 1 Minnesota. Ultimately, Nagelvoort - who finished the season with a .929 save percentage, allowing just 2.20 goals per game - established himself as an elite netminder along the way and, after weeks of uncertainty, received the starting role when it mattered most. But like this season, consistency in net came just a little too late. Grade: A- Canteen shining, Hagerup returns ByALEXA DETTELBACH Daily Sports Writer It may only be a few weeks into spring football practice, but the early-enrollees are already making waXes. Defensive NOTEBOOK tackle Bryan Mone and offensive tackle Mason Cole have been the talk of the upperclassmen, but leading the pack in recent practices is wide receiver Freddy Canteen, who has emerged as a viable option in Michigan's passing game. With a thin receiving corps, Canteen's hands and polished route running are a welcome surprise for the Wolverines. Canteen expects to make plays in the fall and calls himself the fastestplayer on the team. "I believe he's the second fastest, to me," joked freshman safety Brandon Watson. "But he's agood playergood routerunner." Watson and Canteen have been teammates since the summer after seventh grade, and the two decided to continue the tradition when they both committed to Michigan on the same day. But it doesn't end there - the two friends are also roommates and have been going up against each other almost every day in practice. - The Daily looks back on the best and worst of the 2013-14 campaign By ALEJANDRO ZUNIGA Daily Sports Editor It was all going so well, wasn't it? The Michigan hockey team was 10-2-2 and had climbed as high as No. 2 in the national polls. The Wolverines had stellar goal- tending, luck and just enough offense to look like contenders for both Big Ten and national championships. You know the rest. On Dec. 27, Western Michigan exposed a porous defense like no other team had, adding an emphatic conclu- sion with the game-winning goal on a fantastic individual play by Josh Pitt with 19 seconds remain- ing in overtime. Thanks to more surprisingly poor play and some badly timed bye weeks, the Wol- verines didn't win a game until nearly a month later. Michigan lost to Penn State in the opening round of the Big Ten Tournament, finishing the sec- ond half of the season with a sub- .500 record that had turned the Wolverines into a middling team and placed them squarely on the NCAA Tournamentbubble. BEST WIN: It's easy to point to the Wolverines' 6-2 win over No. 1 Minnesota on the final day of the regular season as their biggest moment of the season. And, to be fair, Michigan needed that result to have any chance at an NCAA Tournament at-large bid. But the Golden Gophers had already clinched the Big Ten title and played like it, taking some of the luster off of the rout. In retrospect, the Wolverines' biggest win was their season- opening 3-1 triumph over Boston College. They held the Eagles' two Hobey Baker Award finalists, Kevin Hayes and Johnny Gaudreau, to just four total shots and no goals. Sophomore forward Andrew Copp picked up a goal and two assists for Michigan, feeding senior forward Luke Moffatt with a cross-ice pass that put the team up by two early in the third period. WORST LOSS: Here are four for the price of one. * Dec. 28: In the consolation game of the Great Lakes Invitational, Michigan lays an egg against Michigan State. Sophomore goaltender Steve Racine makes 37 saves, but the offense stagnates in the 3-0 defeat. If the Wolverines find a way to win, they likely earn an at-large bid to the NCAA Tournament in March. * Feb. 8: A day after embar- rassing Penn State, the Nittany Lions return the favor. Freshman netminder Zach Nagelvoort sur- renders three goals on the first nine shots he faces, and Michi- gan can't find twine all night as Penn State picks up its first-ever Big Ten win, 4-0. If the Wolver- ines find a way to win, they likely earn an at-large bid to the NCAA Tournament in March. * Feb. 21: With 4.6 seconds left in regulation, the Nittany Lions stun the Yost Ice Arena crowd with a tying goal, and they eventually finish the overtime upset, 5-4. If senior defenseman Mac Bennett clears the puck instead of making a blind pass, or Nagelvoort makes one more save, or the Wolverines put away the Big Ten's worst team when they have the chance, they likely earn an at-large bid to the NCAA Tournament in March. * March 20: Needing one win to all but assure themselves a spot in the NCAA Tournament, the Wolverines fall to Penn State again,2-1, in the first round of the Big Ten Tournament. In the first of two overtime periods, Copp wrists a shot that rattles off the post and spins on the line but never fully crosses it. One more inch and the Wolverines likely earn an at-large bid to the NCAA Tournament. Instead, as Michigan's online schedule reads, "there are no upcoming events." BEST GAME: If any one game showcased Michigan's maddening inconsistency, it was the March 14 meeting with Minnesota. The Wolverines took a 2-1 lead into the first intermission, pouncing on every Gopher mistake to the delight of the raucous crowd at Yost. But Michigan didn't score the rest of the way and took five penalties in a 3-2 overtime loss. The Wolverines demonstrated their ability to go toe to toe with the nation's best team. Minnesota was fighting to clinch first place in the Big Ten and played like it, and Michigan still delivered a blow in the first period. That scoring touch disappeared in the final 40 minutes and into overtime, but the Wolverines hung on for dear life, coming just 136 seconds from a tie that would've likely earned them a berth in the NCAA Tournament. BEST SINGLE-GAME PERFORMANCE: There's no debating this one. With the season on the line, Nagelvoortset a program record with 63 saves against Penn State in the Big Ten Tournament. The freshman stood on his head, and Michigan needed the performance, as it recovered from an apathetic first two periods to force overtime. Nagelvoort did everything his team could've expected from him and more, but he didn't get much help. In 92:47, the Wolverines only scored once, and the freshman netminder didn't see the shot that buried itself in the twine behind him and ended Michigan's season. TERRA MOLENCGRAFF/Daily Michigan coach Brady Hoke met with kicker Will Hagerup regularly to help mentor him following last year's suspension. responsibilities, but now the two are battling it out for the starting position. Wile will also take the reigns as the starting place kicker. "There's HAGERUP BACK IN ACTION: After being suspended for all of last season due to a violation of team policies, fifth-year senior punter Will Hagerup is practice field. Hagerup was Punter of the Ye: he hasn't seen gar the 2013 Outback lothas happened and a half. Last season, th Wile took over always "The people who been good let owncompetition I let down moSt between us," Hagerup said. were beginning "i think it's believe in fun to have to e(multiple) " " guys at the me again. position. He did a really good job last back on the year, and it will be a really good competition." the Big Ten During his year off, Hagerup ar in 2012, but had weekly meetings with me action since Michigan coach Brady Hoke, Bowl - and a Athletic Director Dave Brandon, in the last year Director of Athletic Counseling Greg Harden and a personal en-junior Matt counselor. the punting "They gave me multiple hours per week ... and seeing them weekly is something I'll never be able to thank them for," Hagerup said. "This was important because it showed that the people who I let down most were beginning to believe in me again. ... Being reinstated was representative of that trust being built." Hoke officially notified Hagerup that he would be reinstated for the 2014 season last May, but the punter had an entire summer to fill with football not an option. The Milwaukee native spent five weeks working in a steel factory, an experience he called one of the most grueling of his life. HAMMY ISSUES: A pair of early enrollees, wide receiver Drake Harris and linebacker Michael Ferns, have both struggled with hamstring injuries this spring. Harris is no stranger to the injury, having sat out his senior season with hamstring issues. After a fast start to practice, the freshman now finds himself sidelined the rest of the spring. "The injury is in a different place (from high school)," Harris said. "The way I felt this time was a lot different than from high school, soit's nothing too major." On the other hand, Ferns has been able to play through his injury, has practiced the last two weeks and plans to play Saturday in the spring game. Ferns has seen time at the weak-side position in practice, and though the linebacker corps is arguably the team's deepest position, he still has a possibility to see the field regularly in the fall. Want year-round football coverage? Of course you do It's allon MhicgaDatly toni OBAMA'S BRACKET HAD MSU WINNING THE NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP LOL 3 I j a