100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Download this Issue

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

This collection, digitized in collaboration with the Michigan Daily and the Board for Student Publications, contains materials that are protected by copyright law. Access to these materials is provided for non-profit educational and research purposes. If you use an item from this collection, it is your responsibility to consider the work's copyright status and obtain any required permission.

March 20, 2006 - Image 8

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Michigan Daily, 2006-03-20

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

Monday
March 20, 2006
arts. michigandaily.com
artspage@michigandaily.com

RTS s

8A

. . .... .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . . . . ...... ..... ..........

VFOR ttĀ°
VAGUE U HT L I

A political vendetta

WACHOWSKI-SPAWNED
ADAPTATION ALMOST
COMES THROUGH
By Imran Syed
Daily Arts Writer
Who is codename V, the anarchist superhero
of the Wachowski broth-_
ers-produced adaptation "V
for Vendetta"? Is he a vile, V for
vigilante villain, or a via- Vendetta
ble, victorious vindicator? At the Showcase
Through massive explosions, and Quality 16
poetic rhetoric and gripping Warner Bros.
- though ultimately inane
- martyrdom, he is a little
of both. But most audiences will find the film so
overstuffed with political versings that they will
verily venture that he's little more than a vain
incarnation of a verboten vision.
OK, enough of that. "Vendetta" centers
around a young woman, Evey, who, while brave
and bright, is most interesting because she is
played by the vibrant Natalie Portman ("Clos-
er"). She's the good little citizen of her totalitar-
ian society, or so we think.
When the vandal known only as "V" begins
a plot to overthrow the government through a
series of violent actions, Evey becomes a vital
part of the crusade. Through her painful, cap-
tivating and even touching journey, she learns
that defeating your friendly neighborhood Big
Brother is harder than you might think, and the
same variables that drive governments to mad-
ness live within us all.
"Vendetta" should certainly be applauded
for its bold and "uncompromising vision of the
future," as the tagline reads, but the core mes-
sage comes across rather distorted.
What's handled best is the meaning of the
word "terrorist" in contrast to "freedom fight-
er." We hear "terrorist" thrown around so often
today that we forget many of our country's
"good guy" founding fathers were terrorists in
Britain's eyes. Some Brits even still consider
Guy Fawkes (upon whose anarchist exploits V

Getting into Rick's just got a whole lot harder.
fashions his mask) as a terrorist, though he'd
be a freedom fighter to others. This distinction
cannot be overstated in our increasingly com-
plex, political world.
Yet just about the rest of "Vendetta's" moral-
ity is tangled and puzzling. We know the film
is vehemently anti-authoritarian, and we get a
strong feeling it doesn't support what the West
is doing on the battlefield (Iraq is explicitly
mentioned) and to its own societal freedoms.
But if the authoritarian government of a fiction-
al England is wrong to deplore the "godless ...
former United States," whose vision is the righ-
teous one? Curtailing freedoms clearly isn't the
way to go, but if not doing so caused the greatest
nation in the world to collapse, then does the
film suggest we do the same?
As for the performances, Portman shines like
she always does. Given her knack for making
even the most pathetic dialogue sound almost
reasonable (consider the "Star Wars" prequels),
she balances out the never-ending political ver-
biage rather breezily.
Hugo Weaving ("The Matrix") is the man
behind the maniacal mask of V, and he delivers
a passionate, almost convincing performance as
a tortured social patriot. The film's resident bad
guys are undoubtedly malicious, but for all their
corruption and evildoing, it's hard to believe

they could have committed a greater atrocity
than shave the celestial curls that once dwelled.
atop Ms. Portman's head.
"Vendetta" is a bold move for most involved,
Portman most of all. Born in Israel, she has been
something of an activist for peace in the Middle
East all her life and understands the true terror
of terrorism better than most.
With this film, which considers the idea that
all terrorists are heroes to someone else, she
risks coming under fire in her own community,
much like Steven Spielberg did for "Munich."
As unfortunate as it is, the fact that nothing
- not even terrorism - is a black-and-white
issue is something too many people are unwill-
ing to accept.
If the film had a clearer, refined and more
coherent focus, "Vendetta" might have made
a social statement comparable to last fall's
revered "Good Night, and Good Luck." Both
films scream out about the dangers of the direc-
tion our society has recently taken, but "Ven-
detta" does so in a simplistic and ultimately
incomplete way.
And this factor will most likely bring undue
scrutiny to the loyalties and intentions of its
stars. A government where you can't even con-
sider some ideas for fear of being considered
disloyal? Now that does sound familiar.

(( want everyone to remember
why they need us!" screams
the High Chancellor's projected
visage, a stark Big Brother addressing his
soulless co-conspirators in a shadowy
government conference room.
Government reminders come in all
forms in the new film "V for Vendetta,"
from the fabrication of national disas-
ters to the censorship and control of the
media - all in the name of protecting
the powerful. Luckily for the residents of
the dystopian fantasy, one
man stands against the tide
of totalitarian terror.
But this is a movie, and
anyone can guess the rest.
Morally conflicted yet sin-
gle-mindedly righteous, and
coming off a stint in some-
thing decidedly resemblingx
a Holocaust medical experi-
mentation camp, the film's
hero V has no memory of AMA
who he once was. His only AND
apparent goal is to finish
the work Guy Fawkes started in 1605 by
attempting to blow up Parliament.
Like Fawkes, V is a terrorist. It's a term
the Chancellor's administration doesn't
mind throwing around, but an odd one for
filmmakers to choose as a label for their
titular hero - particularly when that hero
chooses London's Underground as the
delivery service for his Parliament-bound
explosives.
In light of the bombings of London's
public transportation system this summer
and the terrorist attacks of Sept.IIthat
left this nation stunned in fear and rage,
and particularly in light of U.S. politics
that have changed since then, giving your
hero the marker of "terrorist" is a tremen-
dously bold step.
Such a hero, fighting against such a
regime, has been understandably scruti-
nized and dissected. In concept, they say,
"V for Vendetta" is undeniably political.
But while any movie centered on a
character like V is politically bold, the
assertion that "Vendetta" itself is neces-
sarily and inherently a piece of political
art is not as easily defended. There's a
government cloaked in lies and shadows,
exploiting and tyrannizing its people
through a campaign of perpetual fear.
There's a vigilante terrorist challenging a

N
)Ri

conventional concept of just action.
But so they had those in "Star
Wars," too.
In the past year, America has become
a wellspring of political art, from George
Clooney's stylishly subversive "Good
Night, and Good Luck" to Stephen
Gaghan's incendiary "Syriana" to Ste-
ven Spielberg's explosively powerful
"Munich." To call these films political in
nature gets at the very heart of their exis-
tence. Politics is the point.
But now take "Vendetta,"
a middling action film, its
best assets good-enough
special effects and Natalie
Portman. Based on a graphic
novel by Alan Moore ("From
Hell"), the film's most salient
descriptors are probably "fun"
and "noisy" The happen-
stance of using a totalitarian
government as the villain
4DA - OK, one that spews unset-
tling rhetoric, harnesses the
ADE public fear of national crisis

and craves power above public good,
sure - is ultimately a narrative device.
If oppressive regimes, a sci-fi fanboy's
favorite nemesis, must by their very exis-
tence be allegorical to present-day gov-
ernments, we may have to reconsider the
political significance of, say, "Aeon Flux."
"Vendetta," which wears the well worn
trope of political oppression, is not nec-
essarily a political film. But then again,
neither is it apolitical.
Political impact can't be measured
by intent or novelty (lucky, because
"Vendetta" has neither on its side), but by
effect. Indeed, it was not the politically
vocal "Good Night, and Good Luck" that
became the flashpoint in film this year,
but a quiet love story about two cowboys
in Montana that resonated. Whether it's
a 52-year-old lifelong conservative who
finds himself empathizing with thwarted
gay love, or a 13-year-old kid discovering
a message of civil disobedience in a Guy
Fawkes mask and silly, alliterative ver-
bosity, in the moment when art connects
with intellect - that's political.

4

Students
Fly Cheaper
Wecnh..spring break, study abroad & more
Sample roundtrip Student Airfares from Detroit to;

- Andrade thinks "Aquamarine,"
is an allegory for early 19th-
century colonial Algeria. E-mail
her at aandrade@umich,4.
Dreyfuss
coasts
By Imran Syd
Daily Arts Writer

It's got to stop some time. How can
comedians like Jason Alexander, Julia

Miami $184
Denver $207
New York $220

London $473
Romae $570
Sao Paolo $647

Get ready for life after Michigan with Real Life 101.
This annual series of free, entertaining seminars is designed just for U-M students
and will, help you get ready for some of the big issues you face
March 14, 6-7:30 p.m.: Money Management 101
"Good Credit, Bad Debt"
Robert Pavlik, Vice President, MBNA Marketing Systems
This session was so popular last year that we're bringing it back. Designed
specifically for students and recent graduates, "Good Credit, Bad Debt" provides
answers to all of your money management questions and helps you avoid the
financial traps that new grads often face.
March 21, 6-7:30 p.m.: Relocation 101 "The ABCs of No Hassle Moving"
Jeff Abraham, Lindsay Stevens and Geri Rudolph of Stevens Van Lines
What do you mean I needed to reserve the elevator in order to move furniture
into my new apartment? Moving can be a daunting task, but it doesn't have to
be in this session tailored to those moving to a new city after graduation. Let
the professionals at Stevens Van Lines show you how to make moving a snap.
March 28, 6-7:30 p.m.: Personal Branding 101
"How to Stand Out in a Crowded Market"
William Ward, Adjunct Professor, Ross School of Business
As the work place becomes more and more competitive, how are you going
to get yourself noticed and rise above the clutter? Come to this personal
branding session to find out. Even with a University of Michigan degree, you
still need to be all that you can be in order to achieve the career (and life)
' ' f* f

Visit StudentUniverse.com for cheap student airfares
on major airlines to 1,000 destinations across the US
t and around the world.
4 f
o,-. -n
l k.,
~~'~ ' i, ___ __

Louis-Dreyfuss
and Michael
Richards continue
to man so many
misshapen star
vehicles in their
post- "Seinfeld"
days? But then as
characters who
were only one

The New
Adventures of
Old Christine
Mondays at
9:30 p.m.
CBS

dwItZe
mwqw -mv

StudentUniverse.com

dimension in "the greatest TV show of all
time" (according to TV Guide), maybe
it's not so hard to believe they're strug-
gling on their own.
Though she played perhaps the great-
est female sitcom character ever, Julia
Louis-Dreyfuss gets no free passes
here. The pilot episode of "The New
Adventures of Old Christine" is fairly
funny and an improvement from her
previous attempts. She's certainly tal-
ented enough to carry this show, if she
can find writing to keep pace with her
considerable potential as a comedian.
The titular character is a 40-some-
thing divorced mother of a young son.
The featured middle-aged antics and
self-conscious cracks are run-of-the-
mill sitcom fare, but Louis-Dreyfuss's
presence adds an original touch that
makes it all hilarious.
Because the character she plays has
the same mannerisms and eccentrici-
ties as Elaine did, viewers can't help but
imagine her to be Elaine (of course, the
notion of Elaine Benes as a mother trying
to balance a social life is slightly absurd).
But Louis-Dreyfuss carries nearly every
scene in a measured, deliberate, yet over-
all pleasing manner - she is the comedi-
enne that every sitcom claims to have, but
only "Seinfeld" ever did.
Her co-stars are mediocre to say the
least. The husband could be a cutout from
any one of hundreds of failed sitcoms
and the son, though cute, doesn't have the
comedic "it" to steal scenes. There are a
million possibilities with Christine's char-

I

at Dance Gallery Studio, 815 Wildt Street, Ann Arbor, Ml
Busch Gardens of Tampa, Florida is now hiring performers of many
talents for a variety of live show productions including an all new
show to open in May of 2006. We are particularly interested in:
comedic actors that can sing and/or sing and dance: Billy Crystal/
Nathan Lane/Martin Short type. We are also seeking: dancers that
can sing and act (comedy), vocalists that can act (comedy) and
dancers with strong jazz technique. We are also seeking kit
drummers and keyboard players. You should have an outgoing
personality, singing ability is a plus. No appointment necessary.
Brine prepared audition and a current non-returnable resume and

,,iirrp-;q vnifrp lonkina tor.

I

Back to Top

© 2021 Regents of the University of Michigan