The Michigan Daily - Friday, October 8, 2004 - 7
Continued from page 1
to avoid tax increases or to decrease benefits, at least
in the short term, to solve the problem.
"Neither (Bush nor Kerry) has a real proposal,"
said Peter Diamond, an economics professor at the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology. "A politician
that goes to the voter and brings bad news hurts his
Both candidates have avoided being the bearers of
bad news for the large part, though they sometimes
He added that Bush's less specific plan is based on
the guidelines of not increasing the Social Security
payroll tax, not changing benefits and creating a plan
that makes room for voluntary personal retirement
Some speculate that the President's reluctance
to accept the committee's proposal stems from
fear that he would then have to defend a detailed
proposal with its shortcomings and criticisms
before the election.
The lead criticism comes from a report from the
Social Security Administration, which finds that under
the committee's proposal of creating a system with
personal accounts. Social
address the topic.
"The Social Security
who are on Social Secu-
rity today," Bush told a
crowd in Florida a few
weeks ago. "Baby boom-
ers like me, I think, are in
pretty good shape when it
comes to the Social Secu-
rity trust. But we need to
worry about our children
and our grandchildren."
But with projec-
tions that Social Secu-
rity funds will run dry
within the next 15 years,
trust is solvent for those
"A politician that goes to
the voter and brings bad
news hurts his election
- Peter Diamond
Massachusetts Institute of
Technology Economics professor
Security could find itself
in a deficit as early as
2006 and it could take up
to 70 years to get out of
But the Congressional
Budgetary Office, which
evaluates fiscal policies,
finds that under this pro-
posal Social Security
would actually be bal-
anced 20 years earlier
In April of this year, Kerry told Tim Russert of NBC's
Meet the Press, "I'm not going to cut Social Security
benefits. I'm not going to extend the retirement age. And
we're not going to have to raise the premiums."
In other interviews and speeches, Kerry has told audi-
ences that he also will never privatize Social Security,
sticking with the program's original goal of providing
benefits guaranteed by the government.
Since he has focused more on what he will not do then
on actual plans to save social security, researchers as
well as Republicans assume that Kerry will do nothing
but wait for the economy to recover.
"If you talk to some of Kerry's advisors, off the
record, they'll tell you, he doesn't have a plan for Social
Security," Smetters added.
Smetters said under Kerry's plan, his only option is
to increase the money in the Social Security Trust Fund
by improving the economy. But this is only a short-term
solution, he added, because a surplus in the Social Secu-
rity funds will eventually run out.
In fact, since 1983, when Social Security reform began
to rake in a surplus by reducing benefits and increasing
the payroll tax, the money has largely been used to bal-
ance the federal deficit.
Researchers have proposed alternative solutions,
among them a proposal by Diamond, which calls for
a combination of raising taxes and cutting benefits
to balance Social Security.
Diamond also suggests raising the maximum amount
of one's income that can be taxed for Social Security,
saying that the current system allows wealthier Ameri-
cans - who live longer and receive benefits longer - to
disproportionately benefit from the system.
The maximum taxable amount is yet another gray
area, in which both candidates have made vague or
This and all the other gray areas in their policies,
have allowed Bush and Kerry to slip by without solid
plans on saving Social Security, which could come
at the expense of the current generation of young
A Gallup Poll from March shows that 58 per-
cent of young people ages 18 to 24 are either very
or somewhat dissatisfied with the current state of
Social Security and Medicare.
"It's really just the selfishness of previous genera-
tions," Smetters said. "A lot of times they may not
realize they're extracting so much, but they are."
Continued from page 1
Faculty in the Frieze Building
are thrilled at the prospect of a new
facility, but expressed some concern
with regard to the displacement of
academic departments located in
the building during the two years
of construction. Units such as the
Asian Language and Cultures, Com-
munication Studies and the Center
for Judaic Studies are unaware of
their fate. The Provost's Office is
currently working to create plans
for temporary relocation.
Faculty in the Theatre and Drama
Department, who are set to move
to Walgreen Drama Center and the
Arthur Miller Theater on North
Campus once construction begins,
are confused about their move. Eric
Fredricksen, chair of the Theatre
and Drama Department, said the
department was told by the Wal-
green Drama Center planning com-
mittee that the facility would not
be ready until 2007 at the earli'est,
while the administration is plan-
ning to move them in 2006 once
The University said the theater
will be ready by the time the demo-
lition of Frieze begins.
But students who attend classes
in the Frieze Building praised the
administration's decision to tear
down the building, even though
many acknowledged that they would
not reap the benefits of the planned
"Even if I'm not going to, be
around, its, good to see something
being done," LSA freshman Kenata
Bush's loosely laid out plan of creating personal
investment accounts for young people to collect
after retirement most likely will not help the chil-
dren of baby boomers, and in some cases not even
The reason behind this is what researchers point to
as the transitional costs of transforming Social Securi-
ty into a program that allows for personal investment,
as Bush is proposing. They also say this transition
will further exhaust the Social Security Trust Fund
and reduce benefits in the short term.
Analysts say Bush's plan is less concrete than it
seems. In 2001, Bush created a committee to develop
a Social Security plan, but he has not formally accept-
ed either of the committee's two proposals.
While Kerry and others have criticized the
president's ideas about Social Security reform,
the plan they are blasting is often that of the com-
mittees, which Bush has yet to endorse, said Kent
Smetters, a University of Pennsylvania business
the michigan daily
than the SSA's prediction.
The differences, however, are attributed to methods
For this reason, Diamond remains critical of per-
sonal investment accounts, saying that they do not pro-
vide a solution for retirees in the immediate future.
"President Bush thought the money would just
appear," Diamond said about the deficit that will be
created in the next 70 years, if personal accounts are
to be instated.
But he added that despite the problems with
Bush's plan, he finds nothing more promising in
"Kerry doesn't have a plan because if he had a plan
he would be delivering bad news, and then the Presi-
dent could say, '(Kerry) wants to cut your benefits and
I would never do that,' " Diamond said. "In fact very
few Democrats have filed a plan on Social Security."
Kerry has said hardly anything on the topic that
can be construed as actual policy, and what he has
said has been vague.
E DE RA L AG ENCY? Robert Chin
Account Executive of the Week
YOU READ, YOU DECIDE.
20 YEARS OF RESEARCH IN ONE BOOK Dinner Is on us for
FEDERAL RESERVE FACTS ajob well donel
NO HYPE, NO WILD THEORIES.
$4 PER COPY -D'Emato's
CHECKS/MONEY ORDERS "4 lts"
PAYABLE TO: FRN NEWSLETTER -Detroit Free Press
M 'l T:o.so
159 CHANDLER AE.1620 WW0a0.o
COLLEGE CLEANERS: PROF. Dry Clean-
ing & Ldry. Free summer storage. 715 N.
University next toHill Auditorium. 662-1906.
HORSE BOARD, ENGLISH/DRESSAGE
riding lessons on good, trained horses. Leas-
ing, too. Close to town. 995-0092.
J'S LIGHT HAULING 734-776-5236: all of
your light hauling needs. We haul anything.
PRIVATE TUTORING FOR LSAT,
LAW SCHOOL HNALS, BAR EXAM
-perfect180 on LSAT
- Michigan Law graduate (3.85 GPA)
- licensed attorney
-10+ years of teaching expeience
- hundreds of delighted students
STUDENT WRITING TUTOR, exp., semi-
retired UM Phd., published writer. 761 3427.
THESIS/ BOOK EDITING. Language, orga-
nization, format. All disciplines. 25 yrs. exp.
996-0566 or firstname.lastname@example.org
HEALTHY VOLUNTEERS NEED for re-
search study: Dept. of Anesthesiology seek-
ing healthy volunteers aged 18-60 of any gen-
der or ethnicity to participate in a study for
drug-drug interaction which involves an an-
tiplatelet medication (Plavix@) and a choles-
terol lowering medication (Lipitori). Com-
pensation is prorated up to $250 for entire
study (total of 56 days). For info. call
1-800-742-2300, category 2207 or e-mail
email@example.com and mention category
LANDSCAPING, PRIVATE HOME near
campus. Flex.hrs.$8/hr. 971-3321.
LOOKING FOR P/T & Flex. hrs.? Want the
best of both worlds? Work for yourself, and
a great company w/ Instant Furniture Rental.
Instant Furniture is looking for housewares
set-up person for corperate furniture rentals.
The number of set-ups vary weekly & since
you are you're own boss, you pick the time!
We're looking for a self-motivated & detail
Call Cindy @ 734-327-4500 for more details.
MAKE $$$ TAKING Online Surveys.
Earn $10-$125 for Surveys.
Earn $25-$250 for Focus Groups .
MAKE MONEY AT home taking surveys?
Is this possible? Find out the truth at
MUSIC INSTRUCYOR NEEDED, 1/2 hour
lesson, 10 yr. old boy learning to play alto
sax. Please contact Mary Beth 662-8391.
NOW HIRING ALL positions, $12-35/hr.
Apply online @ www.work-for-students.com
RESEARCH DATA COLLECTION
The University of Michigan Survey Research
Center is recruiting people with strong com-
munication skills and interest in the social
sciences to join a team conducting national
public opinion telephone interviews. Candi-
dates need to be highly self-directed with a
professional telephone manner for conduct-
ing research interviews. Experience with
IBM compatible computers helpful and bilin-
gual fluency in Spanish highly desirable.
Keyboard/typing skills required. Must be
available to work a minimum of 16-20 hours
per week. Competitive wages starting at
$9.50/hr. and $10.50/hr for Spanish inter-
viewing. Pick-up and submit an application
immediately during weekdays 9 a.m.- 5 p.m.
at the University of Michigan, 42> Thomp-
son St., room #1201 or at 1230 Eisenhower
Place, Am Arbor. The University of Michi-
gan is an Equal Opportunity, Affirmative Ac-
SMALL ANIMAL VET Hospital seeks full
or part time receptionist, candidate must be a
motivated, team oriented animal enthusiast.
Send resume to Washtenaw Vet Hospital
4618 Packard, Ann Arbor 48108.
START AT $9.50/HR. and make new friends
while supporting your University. MICHI-
GAN TELEFUND now hiring students for
flexible night and weekend schedules. Awe-
some Resume Builder! Work Study / Non-
Work Study. Apply online:
www.telefund.umich.edu or 998-7420.
WEB SITE DESIGNER WORK-STUDY
POSITION AVAILABLE IN THE LIFE SCI-
Primary responsibility will be to assist the Di-
rector of Communications of the Life Sci-
ences Institute with web content mainte-
nance, updates and design.
Job Requirements: Exp. using DreamWeaver
or other web design applications. Knowl-
edge of current publishing languages includ-
Excellent writing skills and desktop publish-
ing skills in Photoshop/Illustrator; a scientific
background or interests are also desired. The
student will need to provide examples of writ-
ing and web work, if avail.
Hourly rate will be $10.00 and we are look-
ing for the selected student to work 10-12 hrs.-
/wk. If you have been awarded work-study
and are interested in this position, please con-
tact Erin Stephens at (734) 615-5684 or at
WORK-STUDY STUDENT NEEDED. Stu-
dent to work with rodents in a medical re-
search environment. Animal husbandry expe-
rience pref. Flexible hours. Please send re-
sume to firstname.lastname@example.org
CANCUN, ACAPULCO, JAMAICA
From $459! FLORIDA $159!
Cancun Prices Are $100 Less Than Others!
Includes Meals, 30-50+ Hours Drinks!
Ethics Award Winning Company!
NEED 3 OR 4 GOOD SEATS for the
Michigan State football game on Oct. 30.
Two pairs or 3-4 together. $$. Call collect
905-468-8269 or email email@example.com
SPRING BREAK 2005
Hiring reps!! Free Meals!!
Nov. 6th Deadline! Free trips for groups.
Hottest destinations and parties.
www.sunsplashtours.com 1800-426 7710.
Join Amerca's #I ShFde0 Tar QperWtWr
* * I " , ,
Call for group discounts
Book local with someone you know and trust.
f y # 734-769-2555
TRAVEL 1218 SveuiyA
SE RVFCES 734-998-0200
Two different programs!
Paul Taylor Dance Company
FRIDAY, OCTOBER 8, 8 PM
SATURDAY, OCTOBER 9, 8 PM
Paul Taylor has been called a genius, a legend, a cultural
icon, a pioneer of American modern dance. Whether
investing everyday movement with breathtaking beauty
or reminding us that we are not as removed from our
prehistoric ancestors as we like to think, this former Mar-
tha Graham Company dancer rivets audiences with his
astonishing inventiveness, poignancy, and wit.
764-2538 I www.ums.org
A valid college ID is required. Limit two tickets per student, per event, Rush
tickets are not offered if an event is sold out. Seating is subject to availability.
and Ticket Office discretion.
$10 Rush Tickets on sale 9 am-
5 pm the day of the performance
or the Friday before a weekend
event at the UMS Ticket Office,
located in the Michigan League.
50% Rush Tickets on sale begin-
ning 90 minutes before the event
at the performance hall Ticket
!"!!!!!!!!!!!!!WAIT STAFF, BUSSERS,
host/hostess apply in person at the Blue Nile
Restaurant 221 E. Washington St. Immediate
I!MBARTENDING!! $300/DAY POTEN-
TIAL, no experience necessary, training pro-
vided. 800-965-6520 ext.12-5.
!!BARTENDING!! $300/DAY Don't be
dipped off by mail order scams and phony
certifications. Bartending jobs don't come in
Jhe mail. Bar managers only hire those with
hands-on exp. Go to local state approved
hands-on school, Mix Masters School of Bar-
tending. 734-513-3600. www.icanmix.com
Candidates Needed For
Background And Crowd Scenes
For A Variety Of Productions
No Exp/Looks Req.
Earn Up To $19/Hr.
Immediate Openings/ITraining Provided
SAME DAY PAY
ASSISTANT BOOKKEEPING POSITION
. vail. P/T & FiT for a student housing prop-
erty management co. of UM campus. Must
have strong office skill, basic computer, must
be self-motivated and have basic knowledge
of Microsoft word & excel. Please inquire or
send resumes to firstname.lastname@example.org
ON-CALL BANQUET HELP with Michi-
gan's oldest independent food service com-
pany. $9-10/hr. Call Kim 734-677-5065.
Candidates Needed To Pose
As Shoppers For Local Stores
No Exp. Req./Training Provided
GET PAID TO SHOP
Earn Up To $15/HR
PAID BOTTLED WATER discussion group
in A2, Nov 4. $40. Need 12 people, ages
25-74. Diverse ethnicities encouraged to ap-
ply. Call Penny at 7343329200.
PAID JUICE/WATER DISCUSSION group
in A2, Nov 3. $40. Need 24 people, ages
25-74. Diverse ethnicities encouraged to ap-
ply. Call Penny at 734332 9200.
PARTICIPANTS WANTED: Judgment and
Perception Experiment at University of
Michigan near North Campus. Experiment
requires 2-hours and pays $20.00. To qual-
ify, must have English as first language, ages
18-30, and vision correctable to 20/20.
ARE YOU THE ultimate college student?
Sports Illustrated-wants you-to join our SI
Scouts Panel to speak on campus trends, col-
lege sports, & student traditions. Win fabu-
lous prizes! Go to siscouts.com & apply now!
THE DEPARTMENT OF Geological Sci-
ences invites you to participate in a day of ac-
tivities celebrating the long career of Profes-
sor Henry N. Pollack at the University of
Michigan. The celebration is scheduled to-
day, Friday October 8th. Activities begin
with a morning scientific symposium featur-
ing presentations by former students and col-
leagues from around the nation and world.
The symposium begins at 8:30 am. in Room
1528 C.C. Little, and will end at noon. The
program and more details can be viewed at
Later, at 4:00 p.m. and also in Room 1528 C.-
C. Little, David S. Chapman, Dean of the
Graduate School at the University of Utah,
will present the William T. Smith Lecture, ti-
tIed "From tectonics to climate change: a
tribute to Henry N. Pollack and reflections
on his forty year career at the University of
Michigan." Following the lecture there will
be a reception in Room 2540 C.C. Uttle. We
hope you can attend some or all of these
events honoring Henry N. Pollack.
PIF CHILD CARE for 2 young girls, wknds.
& eves. CPR, first aid. & bilingual Span-
ish/English pref. Call Laura 734-929-9551.
BARTENDER TRAINEES NEEDED, no
exp. nec. Up to $300 per shift. Age 18 + ok.
EARN $15 FOR participating in a video
game study, Must be at least 18 yrs. old. For
info., email email@example.com
..,: _ ... r _