4A - The Michigan Daily - Thursday, January 10, 2002
albe lltiguu aft lg
420 MAYNARD STREET
ANN ARBOR, MI 48109
EDITED AND MANAGED BY
STUDENTS AT THE
UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
Editor in Chief
Editorial Page Editors
Unless otherwise noted, unsigned editorials reflect the opinion of the majority of the Daily's
editorial board. All other articles, letters and cartoons do not
necessarily reflect the opinion of The Michigan Daily.
" I helped
him; he helps
me, we love
- Florida Governer Jeb Bush as
quoted in The New York Times,
explaining why President George Bush
allowed him an Oval Office signing
ceremony for an agreement regarding
restoration ofthe Florida Everglades.
tvJ. av)4h ''t Cc 40va e S} tr+s 40 wo.A K -Sa
The shopping news
DAVID HORN HORNOGRAPHY
H appy Thursday, books. Students have the opportunity to better Our school, which feigns a belief in the mer-
everyone. What a gauge the requirements and content of classes its of a liberal arts education, has seemed to me
cruel change of may be, determine their affection or disaffection in my three years as an College of Literature,
events that has led you into for the professor and the class itself and then Science and the Arts undergraduate to be incon-
this classroom this morning. choose whether or not to enroll permanently. siderate of the myriad interests of some stu-
A week ago you were From there the professor can go to work with a dents. Organizational studies and
recovering from a nasty class of kids who have had every opportunity to interdisciplinary studies are offered, but they are
New Year's hangover - bail on him, but have chosen to pursue whichev- a small token for students who, like me, hoped
the awful aftertaste of too er subject with eagerness and excitement, to sample from the palette of academic colors.
much tequila and too much I would like very much to see a version of There are so many classes I want to learn
Tennessee. Today you're dealing with the this "shopping" system implemented at the Uni- about But I have a limited number of hours in
fourth day of class. You're in an overcrowded, versity. the day, a limited number of credits per term
overheated, entirely uncomfortable room some- I understand that ours is a large, public and a limited number of terms in my four years.
where (possibly the MLB). Professor isn't just university and that there are certain constraints I have some classes that are required and the rest
going over the syllabus and letting you leave that exist here that do not exist elsewhere. But are ones that I genuinely want to take. Do I sac-
like she did on Tuesday - she's teaching. She's surely something can be done to provide stu- rifice my desire to learn for the sake of a less
got chalk in her hand. Her notes are prepared. dents with more academic freedom in choos- stressful term or perhaps for a better grade point
This is class. You've bought the books, you're ing their classes. average resulting from having to juggle fewer
enrolled and there's no going back. As things stand now, students are allowed classes? If that troubling sacrifice is made, how
But there ought to be. 20 or so days to settle into their permanent is it made? I'm a curious kid. Class A and class
What if you were able to jump ship today or schedule. There is a drop/add deadline and won- B both sounded good. Let me get a real taste of
tomorrow or two weeks from now? What if derfully there is a late drop/add deadline (which them before I decide.
there were no assignments given by your pro- I have benefited from on two separate occa- A shopping period would be a possible
fessors in these first weeks of class? What if sions), both of which are necessary. approach to providing greater freedom to the
there was no expectation that you did any read- The problem is that if I am enrolling in a kids who last week were as far (intellectually,
ing? Indeed, what if there was no expectation class at the end of January because I found a physically, emotionally) away from school as
that you even set foot in any line at any book- class that I had been enrolled in on pre-colonial they could be and are wondering today how
store? Peruvian architecture to be, say, over my head, I they ever convinced themselves that they could
This version of academia (which is utopian am likely going to be woefully behind in this handle Organic Chemistry or Nietzsche or pre-
to the slackers among us) exists in universities new class on global biodiversity. Readings have colonial Peruvian architecture. Throw students a
that are not ours. At some schools, most notably been assigned, discussions have been had, lifeline and open up the doors to every class-
Yale, students are permitted a "shopping" peri- papers may have been written but for three room as the new semester begins.
od of about two weeks, during which they are weeks I had been reading about the Gateway of Oh yeah ... And to my various professors
encouraged to attend any and all classes that the Sun at Tiahuanacu, convinced that I could this term - I love you all and I wouldn't dream
may pique their various interests. Professors are figure out how Moche architecture differed of going to any class but yours.
sympathetic to their students' decision-making from Nazca. I couldn't. I dropped the class. I
process and ease into the material without need X number of credits still and have always David Horn can be reached
requiring, for instance, the purchase of text- been intrigued by biodiversity. via e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org
V LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
W ould Raim w ant his ment isn't killing, but "only" incarcerating Rather, their lives are made strenuous by
indefinitely, without trial, orwithou evi- stri&t ahd ppresgive regulatinh9inj e by
rights violated? dence? The death or mistreatment of any foreign military.
civilian, or any innocent, for any reason, is In fact, just look at the annual human rights
still a crime in itself. It does not matter if that reports (see Amnesty International) of these
To THE DAILY: person happens to be American, Israeli, Pales- two regions and one would quickly learn why
I wonder how adamantly Manish Raiji tinian or Afghan. they breed a small number of terrorists.
would defend the elimination or curtailment of In his column, Raiji places the United States
individual rights for the "benefit" of the collec- CHRIS FARAH in the same group as oppressive countries with
tive if his individual rights were those being Rackham terrible human rights records; countries which
sacrificed for our common "good?" deny populations that they occupy their natural
Granted, if he were arrested and held indefi- rights to hold a plebiscite to determine their
nitely without evidence or public trial, it would - fate.
be a real shame, considering we all know he is IndLa, Israel not FADIshmAWI
guilty of no wrong. But according to his logic, LSA sophomore
hey, if a few eggs have to be cracked to make democraticnatons he letter writer ispoliticalchair ofthe
an omelette, so be it. This makes perfect sense Arab-American Anti-Discrimination Committee
until you realize that each of these "eggs" is a To THE DAILY:
living, breathing human being. Manish Raiji's column, "Collective safety
The hypocrisy of those who argue that gov- trumps individual rights," (1/9/02) can be
ernments should be allowed any means of described as nothing more than un-American. Haddad not entitled
"defense" - including, we must assume, the What it suggests abridges the most basic funda- .
murder of innocent members of the public - in mental rights of all inhabitants of this country. to a c1zens rights
order to protect, who else, the public, never As an American, I am particularly offended at
ceases to amaze me. Many of the same people the suggestion of removing the Constitution To THE DL:
who so rightly condemned the killing of Ameri- from the practices of this country. To suggest After following the story of Rabih Haddad
can civilians on Sept. 11 as terrorism, are now that due process of law not be guaranteed is an r ythe fact that peo-
the same individuals who say it's OK for us to attack on the foundations of this great nation. ple continueI to reamfer toubled him as a citizen.
kill civilians, as long as we're doing it for a Furthermore, Raiji unwittingly places the cobin Horfrt im s a citizen.
good reason. And as long as those civilians U.S. in the same group as India and Israel. He Rabi Haddad is not a citizen ohe United
aren't American citizens. Although, check that refers to these two countries as democracies, States and is not entitled to all the rights which
- Raiji also absurdly claims that it would be which are "plagued by individuals who aren't citizens enjoy. His visa expired, period.
fine to murder countless people (necessarily playing by the rules." If Haddad were a citizen he then would be
including innocents and civilians) and even Democracies? What democracy exists in entitled to rights which these protesters are
Americans, as long as it was done for a good the West Bank? What democracy exists in demanding, but he is not a citizen, he is a man
cause, like the Civil War. Kashmir? whoallegedly supports terrorist organizations
I thought this war against terrorism was a The roots of these problems are the fact that through his "charity" and remains in the this
war against the murdering of innocents and they are not democracies. The indigenous country illegally.
civilians. How can we justify using the same inhabitants of these territories do not have their ANDREw DEYOE
techniques, even if that means the govern- fundamental right to self-determination. LSA junior
V FROM THE UNIVERSITY WIRE
What kind of global village?
STAFF EDITORIAL a simple yes or no, Congress having surrendered
by the Indiana Daily Student its right to add amendments to this legislation.
Representative democracy at work - too bad it's
The fight against the Fast Track bill itself for corporate interests instead of citizens' interests.
changed Dec. 6, when 215 Democrats and But the "compassionate conservatives" and
Republicans effectively sold a critical legislative "new Democrats" rally behind the flag of oppor-
power to the executive branch. The focus now tunity at home and development abroad. So what
falls on Fast Track's results. No one U INDIANA about the most recent exam-
doubts that the Senate will give the presi-U N ple of this global develop-
dent the authority to negotiate interna- BL OOMING TON ment - NAFTA?
confined to the sweatshop districts. Environmen-
tal contamination and corresponding public health
risks have only increased under NAFTA.
Maybe the Bush administration has learned
from the dismal destruction wreaked by NAFTA.
Nope. The latest proposed international trade
agreement, the Free Trade Agreement of the
Americas takes NAFTA as its model. Congress
set no goals for the talks held last April in Quebec
City. Many members of Congress have little to no
idea what the agreement entails. Not to worry.
tional trade agreements and to draft all impending
According to the public interest group Global