Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Download this Issue


Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

This collection, digitized in collaboration with the Michigan Daily and the Board for Student Publications, contains materials that are protected by copyright law. Access to these materials is provided for non-profit educational and research purposes. If you use an item from this collection, it is your responsibility to consider the work's copyright status and obtain any required permission.

December 07, 2001 - Image 7

Resource type:
The Michigan Daily, 2001-12-07

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

The Michigan Daily - Friday, December 7, 2001- 7

Continued from Page 1.
at the opening of the hearing.
Judges first heard arguments in Gratz v.
Bollinger, which challenges the use race in
admissions policies in the College of Litera-
ture, Science, and the Arts.
CIR is appealing the district court's decision
last December, in which U.S. District Court
Judge Patrick Duggan ruled that the Universi-
ty's current admissions policies are legally
sound, but the grid system that was in place to
evaluate students until 1998 was not.
Grutter v. Bollinger was argued next. The
University is appealing the decision by U.S.
District Court Judge Bernard Friedman that the
Law School's admissions policies were not
The court is expected to release its decision
sometime next year.
David Herr, who presented CIR's appeal in
the undergraduate case, said in his opening
remarks to the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals
that his firm was fighting to defend the rights
of "all students who were discriminated against
based on race."
CIR contended that the use of a point system
in LSA admissions was merely a thinly veiled
quota system.
"You don't have to call it a quota, you don't
have to call it reserved seats. ... The results are
identical. It functions the same way," Herr said.
The University argued that providing stu-
dents with a racially diverse educational envi-
ronment is a compelling government interest
and that the methods the University employs to
attain that level of diversity are fully constitu-
the michigan daily
EVER WONDER why you smoke? Want to
make a quick $40? Female smokers age 25-
35 needed in a study on smoking and
genetics. Only takes 2-3 hours of time. Blood
withdrawal and questionnaires involved. Call
1-800-742-2300, #6308.

"All students learn much better in a diverse
student body and atmosphere," argued Univer-
sity lawyer John Payton, "The three things
Judge Duggan took issue with, we stopped
Duggan ruled last December against the
University's use of a grid system to evaluate
candidates, automatic rejection of certain
applicants and use of protected seats.
Payton stressed that while the University
gives 20 points on a 150-point scale to black,
Hispanic and American Indian students, "acad-
emic matters count for 110 of those points."

A sign lies on the
wet brick of
Fountain Square in
yesterday afternoon
during the rally
preceding the
"We don't seek a fixed number of spaces,"
Payton argued. "Having merely token numbers
of minority students simply is not adequate."
The judges questioned all sides about what
constitutes a critical mass of students.
"The answer is not a number; it's an educa-
tional reality," Payton said. "You know when
the students in your student body don't see
themselves as symbols but as members of their
"We have a pool of minority applicants that
is so small that it forces us to admit nearly all
qualified applicants," Payton admitted.
Ted Shaw, head counsel for the LSA inter-

venors, who represent the interests of minority
high school students, reiterated the need for affir-
mative action to reverse past discrimination.
"Affirmative action didn't spring from the
soil, it didn't materialize from thin air. It did
not suddenly dawn on the University in the
'60s and '70s," Shaw said.
The University implemented affirmative
action fully aware that minorities had not had
the same opportunities, Shaw argued.
Herr rebutted the intervenors' claim that
affirmative action was necessary to right past
wrongs. "We don't think there is a remedial
claim," he said. "The remedy for that is not
more discrimination."
"The University did not embark on affirma-
tive action to reverse past discrimination by the
University of Michigan," Herr added.
The 70 minutes allotted to the LSA case
were followed by 40 minutes of arguments in
the case involving the Law School. Payton
again represented the University. Kirk Kolbo
represented CIR, and Miranda Massie repre-
sented the intervenors.
Judge Alice Batchelder asked Payton if
plaintiff Barbara Grutter were a black woman
whether she would have been accepted to the
Law School.
"If Barbara Grutter were black, she would
have a whole different set of life experiences,
and therefore the answer would be yes," Payton
said, stressing that race stretches across socio-
economic borders. "Race affects the black
woman whether she is in Grosse Pointe or the
inner city. ... You're not immune to the effects
of race just because you are in good economic
circumstances or poor economic circum-

Massie argued that affirmative action is nec-
essary to remedy past discrimination as well as
increase diversity on campus. She presented
boxes filled with more than 50,000 signatures
in support of affirmative action.
"The petitions express what is so fundamen-
tally important about integration, they express
that the majority of Americans want the law on
this question to speak the truth," Massie said in
her opening statement.
"Until we reach a point where we have rough
proportionality, we haven't come far enough,"
Massie said.
CIR argued that the Law School's admis-
sions policies, which were struck down in
March by U.S. District Judge Bernard Fried-
man, ignore qualified white applicants in favor
of minority candidates.
"What we have here is a double standard in
admissions. Justice Powell did not approve of
that," Kolbo argued.
All three sides were in good spirits following
the hearing.
"The court zeroed in on all the major prob-
lems with the University's case," said Terence
Pell, director of CIR.
Pell said that although the University has
made "cosmetic" changes to its admissions
system, they remain unconstitutional. "They all
raise the same legal issue. ... The University
has tried to elevate form over content.
"The hearing made clear how devastating the
facts are for the University," he added.
"I'm glad to have gone through another
step in the process. It's a long process," said
Grutter, the plaintiff in the Law School case,
after the hearing. "We all just have to wait for
the ruling."

FOR 6+. 800-838-8203 OR

GREAT CASH FOR a morning person!
Driver needed to Redford, Mon.-Fri., meeting
place in morning neg. in Manchester/Ann
Arbor area. Start after Jan. 1. (734) 428-8638.
Experienced, reliable, maticulous.
References needed. Close to campus. 1/2
day/wk. Call 763-1592.
spring season -men's and women's lacrosse.
Around $45/game depending on level.
Lacrosse experience helpful, not mandatory.
Training will be provided. Women's refs.
contact Elaine at ETORVINEN@aol.com
Mens refs. contact Clark at
0 inichlaxref@home.com
We need Bio, Chem, Biochem, ChE,
Pharm Sci or related sci people to join
A U -connected biotech co near campus.
Research a new eye drug delivery system:
Polymers, lasers, enzyme immunoassay,
And work with a MD on human subjects.
Start now, full time for I or 2 years.
E-mail: admin@eyelabgroup.com
Church needs a student to: change light
bulbs, run errands, spot clean, do basic yard
work, etc. Must have own transportation. Be
avail. 2 days/wk Tues.-Sat. anytime between
lam and 5pm 5-15hrs/wk $7.50/hour or
better. 769-4157.
OVERWEIGHT WOMEN (18+) who are
current taking weight-loss supplements
needed for a study at UMCAM Research
Center. Contact Jenna or Aileen at 998-7712.
Position available for late afternoons/early
jevening hours beginning Winter terma. Will
STrain Come to Varsity at 625 Church St.
kitchen help job, female pref. 8 hrs. weekly.
7 days. Great food, good pay, Please leave a
message at 662-3418.
ROMULUS SCHOOLS are seeking an
after-school Drama teacher and a foreign
language teacher. $15/hr. 4 hrs/wk. (734)
722-1050 x273. strongd@roinulus.k12.mi.us
SCOREKEEPERS is now hiring Cooks,
Floormen and wait staff for immediate
openings. Bring your class schedule and
apply today at 310 Maynard A2 - Across
from Borders Books Downtown. 995-0100.
SEMESTER BREAK work: 2-8 week work
program. Possible to continue in the spring.
$14.05 base/appt. Internships/scholarshi ps
available. Work at home over break; over
400 throughout US, Call and apply now!
Help children from other countries learn
English. Gain valuable teaching skills!
Must have good English, interpersonal and
organizational skills. Must have experience
with children and internationals. Apply at the
Community Center on North Campus(1000
McIntyre). Call 763-1440 or
e-mail aliens@umich.edu. EOE.
U.M S'T'AF/F & STUIDENTS needed! You
arc needed for a study on the events of 9/11.
Earn $5 for 20 min. email survey. Go to
and personable people for sait staff
positions. Will train. Varied shifts avail.
Call 764-2142.
OF NURSING business and finance office.
Develop interpersonal, organizational;
professional, office, and computer skills.
Responsibilities include light typing,
copying, filing, telephone coverage, and mail
sorting. 1-2 students needed. $8-10 per hour.
Contact Reva Frye at 764-8153.

Cook, clean, organize, enjoy pets and
outside. 9-2pm or F1'. $8-10/hr. 769-2795.
DRIVER NEEDED to pick up 2 kids (12
&14) for two schools in Ann Arbor. M/W
1:30 to 3:15pm T/Th/F 2:15 -3:15. Need own
car $75/wk. 995-2447 eves. 615-4507 day.
Needed Jan 7-mid June.
LOVING BABYSITTER for 3-yr. old boy.
Non-smkr., own transportation, 1-yr
coniritment, 6-8 hrs./w k., afternoons,
$10/hr. Westside Ann Arbor. Call Cathyc @
PART TIME CARE giver needed for 3 and
7 year old girls in our Burns Park home.
Excellent pay and benefits. 12:30 to 5:30pm
Mon-Fri. Need references and car. Non-
smoker. Call 764-9498, leave message.
SITTER NEEDED IN E. Ann Arbor home.
Occas. eves. & wknds. for 2 yr. old. Over 18,
exp. & own car pref.734-975-8866.

***EARLY SPRING Break Specials!
Cancun & Jamaica From $389! Air, Hotel,
Free Meals, Drinks! Award Winning
Company! Get Group - Go Free! Florida
Vacations $129! springbreaktravel.com
ACAPULCO'S #1 Spring Break Company,
BIANCHI-ROSSI TOURS, wants you to Go
Loco in Acapulco! Book Spring Break
2002's Hottest Destination with the only
company specializing in Acapulco!
Call 1-800-875-4525 or log onto
Travel Free-ask how!
SPRING BREAK 2002 for U. Michigan
students! Student Express offers Mexico,
Jamaica, Bahamas, and Florida for Spring
Break 2002!! Best prices! Call 800-787-3787
for details and ask for a free brochure.
SPRING BREAK 2002 Jamaica, Cancun,
Bahamas or Florida. Join Student Travel
Services, America's #1 Student Tour
Operator. Promote trips at Michigan and earn
cash and free trips. Infornation/Reservations:
1-800-648-4849 or www.ststravel.con

The Rev. Fred Shuttlesworth, a Cincinnati civil rights advocate, rallies the crowd In Fountain Square before the court hearing.

WINTER CHILDCARE substitutes: w<
according to your schedule. Great job1
psych and education students. Fun j
il ual encourag Call St. Paul a


SPRING BREAK: Cancun, Jamaica, All
Florida destinations. Best Hotels, free parties,
lowest prices' www.breakerstravel.com
Op 800-985-6789.
YOU KNOW US, we know you. So why
would you book with those other guys? We
are here all year for you! SPRING BREAK
2002. The best packages at the best prices.
Starting at $449. Call or stop by: Council
Travel 1218 S. University.- (734) 998-0200.

Continued from Page 1
affirmative action, joined ralliers on
the skywalk where the stage was set
up. Byrd said Wilson told police that
protesters grew angry at his arrival,
ripping the sign from his hand and
threatening to throw him over the edge
of the balcony.
Police closed off the balcony follow-
ing the incident but said Wilson decid-
ed not to take any legal action against
the demonstrators.
"He has every legal right to be here,
holding that sign. He's exercising his
rights like everybody else," Byrd said.
Standing in the thick of a group of
people in the square was Jon Cramer, a
2001 University graduate and Cincin-
nati attorney.
"This is like a little piece of the
Diag in Fountain Square," he said. "I
was following this issue at the Univer-
sity of Michigan and I wanted to see
what it was like here, especially in
such a different atmosphere."
Some of the people donning ponchos
and enduring the rain were not part of
the movement but came to the rally as a
learning experience. "I can see there's

"To a degree affirmative action is racism,
but it's the lesser of two evils.'
- Jayson Robertson
University of Cincinnati sophomore

real passion. I'm definitely sympathet-
ic; said Eastern Michigan University
sophomore Katie Belamucki, who trav-
eled to Cincinnati with a class.
Others shrugged off the weather. "If
it was hot, cold, snowing, you still
gotta fight," said University of Cincin-
nati sophomore Jayson Robertson.
Robertson added he could see some of
the points of some of the opponents of
affirmative action.
"To a degree affirmative action is
racism, but it's the lesser of two evils,"
Robertson said. "We had to fight for
everything we wanted.... If we didn't
have the system, we would literally
have nothing."
Students at Purcell-Marion High
School in Cincinnati attended the rally
on a school field trip. Megan Ware, a
high school junior, said her history
teachers have been discussing the mer-
its and limitations of affirmative action

in her classes.
"We told our teacher that we need
affirmative action," Ware said. "We
have to fight for it and then we can fix
all the little quirks."
An older generation of activists
seemed to see the torch being passed
to a new generation.
"It's great to see a new group of
people who are, I hope, committing
themselves to a fight that defines the
highest principles of democracy," said
Chester Grundy, director of African-
American student affairs at the Uni-
versity of Kentucky. Grundy said he
drove to Cincinnati with about 20
University of Kentucky students and
Recalling a quote by author Franz.
Fanon that every generation must find
its mission and either fulfill or betray
that mission, Grundy said, "I hope this
is a generation finding its mission."

#1 Absolute Lowest Spring Break Price
#2 Reputable company, Award-Winning
Customer Service (see website)
#3 Free Meal Plans! (Earlybirds)
#4 All Destinations!
#5 Campus Reps earn $$, Travel Free!
Enough Reasons? 1-800-367-1252
Cancun, Jamaica, Bahamas, & Florida. Book
Early & get free meal lan. Earn cash and Go
Free! Now hiring Campuxs Reps.
endlesssummertours. corn
$50 OFF A SPRING Break with Bianchi-
Rossi Tours for you this Holiday Season!
Visit ebreaiknow co ifOr more info.
" r r r '

BE ANYBODY! Join the experimental
group in Black Rock Desert for a week of the
Burning Man festival. One of 19 Grand
prizes you can win for bringing your books to
Ulrich's or Michigan Book & Supply. Photos
on GotUsed.com
Travel to Canada to help researchers hunt for
elusive Bigfoot. Just one of 10 crazy grand
prizes you can win this year by bringing back
your books to Ulrich's or Michigan Book &
Supply. Get info at GotUsed.com
So you think
you're qualified
for a job other than
flipping burgers?

Continued from Page 1
84, watched from the USS Ramsay on Dec. 7 as the torpe-
doed USS Utah capsized and sank.
"The whole world changed for us," said Phillips, who is
from Easton, Md.
The world changed again for Americans after terrorists
attacked New York and Washington on Sept. 11. And
among this week's visitors to Pearl Harbor were people con-
nected to that 21st-century day of infamy.
Emergency workers from New York, here as guests of the
state and merchants, met Pearl Harbor survivors at a recep-
tion on Monday.
"To me, it was like a dream come true," said firefighter

Bruce Vannosdall, 46, whose squadron lost six members at
the World Trade Center and whose father fought in World
War II. "It's a total honor."
This anniversary is probably the last that will be attended
by a large number of survivors, said Harry Butowsky, a his-
torian for the National Park Service in Washington.
"They just took life and they lived it to its fullest,"
Butowsky said. "They had terrible memories, but they got
over it. They didn't live their lives with hate."
Even today, Hank Freitas, who was on the USS Tangier, a
seaplane tender tied up next to the USS Utah, gets emotion-
al being near the scene of the attack.
"I cry," said Freitas, 80, of Walnut Creek, Calif. "I was
out at Pearl Harbor yesterday and I cried from the time I got
there to the time I left."

Panama City Beach
from $39/night
Sandpiper Beacon beach
resor the "fun place"! Home
of the worlds longest keg
Drink draft beer all week long
" Tiki beach bar
. FrnItrtainmPnt hio Rnnnie

Then e Up your
resume by working with
The Michigan Daily Online
Deptartment. We are now hiring
account executives for
Winter 2002.
Great experience delivered
with commission based pay.
If interested, send an e-mail to

Continued from Page 1
action against those who decide not to
conduct an interview, the possibility
that they could has been a factor in
people's decisions.
"I guess people want to take care of it
and get on with their lives," Basha said.
"They fear they will be investigated ...
so they go through with it, even if there
is a shot at their dignity."
He said there is a view within the
United States that the Muslim and
Arab communities are angry with the
government over civil liberties con-
cerns, but - in Ann Arbor, at least -
that has not been the case.
Actions carried out by southeastern
Michigan officials have helped in
reducing the confusion and anxiety felt
by the Muslim and Arab community,
Rach' c isA

word about the negotiated deal. Every-
body wants to be the best prepared."
Federal authorities, local police and
community members reached a con-
sensus at a closed-door meeting Mon-
day permitting the remaining
interviewees to decide where the inter-
view would be held and who would be
present. Community members request-
ed that Ann Arbor police officers be
present at the interviews. The Univer-
sity Department of Public Safety last
week announced that its officers would
not participate in the interviews.
Ahmad said the climate in the com-
munity has not changed significantly
since Monday's meeting, and many
have been reluctant to make a decision
because they have not been fully
informed about the process.
"We're not recommending either
way - just providing as much infor-
mtinn n, oc ihce _ _ _ ased an our

ity that later they will come around
and harass you," Ahmad said.
Approximately 80 letters have been
sent from the FBI to University students
and Ann Arbor residents of Middle
Eastern descent between the ages of 18
and 33 who have entered the United
States on student, business or tourist
visas since January 2000. The letter
requested a response by Tuesday, but the
deadline was extended to next Monday
to allow community members to inform
interviewees about their civil liberties.
Ahmad said many men who have
chosen to conduct the interview have
requested that he and an attorney be pre-
sent. "If they ask inappropriate ques-
tions in front of us, we will go back to
the community," Ahmad said. "But
we're confident that they will stick to it."
The Ann Arbor mosque, intervie-
wees' homes and the Muslim Student
Aceiation office in the Michigan


Back to Top

© 2023 Regents of the University of Michigan