8 - The Michigan Daily - Friday. October 29, 1999 'Music of the Heart' repeats old story of fight for children By Christopher Tkaczyk I}).uly Arts, Wr iter Wes Craven makes scary movies - The "Nightmare on Elm Street," the "Scream" trilogy, and now "Music of the Heart." Unfortunately for Craven and his band of picture-making ghouls, "Music of the Heart" is the first non-horror film to cause violent quakes in its viewers. And all in time for Halloween. "Music of the Heart" tells the true life story of Roberta Tsavaras, a sub- stitute teacher in East Harlem, Manhattan, who teaches violin to an average of 150 students per year. In 1994, when Tsavaras was informed that funding for her violin program at three elementary schools had been cut by New York City's Board of Courtesy of wner Bros. The boys of Mr. Bungle will celebrate Halloween at Clutch Cargo's tomorrow night. Bungle to haunt Clutch Cargo's By Adlin Rosii Daily Arts Writer Formore than 10 years now, Mr. Bungle has consis- tently released some of the most musically challenging and confusing records extant. The band's self-titled debut album including songs that ranged in style from Polka to Death Metal within eight measures; the follow up release, "Disco Volante," was a soundtrack for the insane: and this year's "California" finds the group forg- ing into Brian Wilson's musical terri- tory. "We do our best to make all our releases different," said Mr. Bungle Mr. bassist Trevor Dunn. "It's never real- Bungle ly a conscious attempt. Our writing Clutch Cargo's process involves us all just coming s+nday at 9 p.m. up with parts and swapping tapes of them and later we put it all together." Although Mr. Bungle has made a career of making music with unex- pected progressions, not even the most devout fan of the group could haveIanticipated the mellow direc- tion of "California." "The title for that record was actu- ally an afterthought. We had spent our time recording the nimterial, and after we played it back, 'California' seemed like a perfect title because of the mood the music evoked," Dunn said. Dunn explained, "There's so much good music out there if your willing to look for it. There's always some record that I end up getting that makes me want to just quit.playing music because it's so good." Dunn's music collection sprawls across various styles, including jazz and bluegrass. "Right now I'm in a big Willie Nelson phase, I haven't gotten any of his IRS stuff yet but I will," he said. Despite being a long-standing member of the Warner Brothers roster, the group seems to also remain finan- cially humble. "We still tour in a van and stay at Best Westerns and places like that. We don't have a driver or anything like that either. Usually after a show I like to do the driving. it actually helps me relax," Dunn mused. Mr. Bungle's strong defiance of the mainstream is no easy task. It seems as though it would be difficult to make a living not catering to popular trends. Dunn explains his secret to longevity in the music industry: "Being musically diverse. When I am not playing with Mr. Bungle I do a lot of session work for other musi- cians, collaborate with other people and I have my own jazz trio, called the Trevor Dunn Trio." Regarding being a hired gun for other musicians, Dunn mentioned that he actually would not mind being given the opportunity to play bass in Britney Spears' live band. "I think it would be fun for a while, and I bet it pays good!" he said. "I guess she just taps into this nostalgic side of me from when I was younger, when I had a crush on Debbie Gibson." The group's performance at Clutch Cargo's on Halloween will be an exceptional treat for fans. Dunn explained, "There's no opening act, we're dubbing the tour 'An Evening With Mr. Bungle' and we are going to play two sets. We haven't quite decided at this point what.we're going to do exactly, but it's likely that we will be doing a set of just covers of songs and sound- track pieces we like and play our own material during the second set." Education, she the Heart No Stars At Bnarwood and Showcase fought back and enlisted the help of Arnold Steinhardt of the Guarneri String Quartet, who convinced big name friends Itzak Perlman and Isaac Stern to perform with the kids for a benefit concert at Carnegie Hall, the world's cathedral to music. Meryl Streep plays a kind-hearted violin teacher in "Music of thraHart, For some, unexplained reason, Tsavaras' name has been changed to Roberta Guaspari for the film. Maybe producers hoped that a story about an Italian-American woman would draw a bigger box office buck than that of a Latina-American. Other than this nominal undersight, Tsavaras' story remains true to life, including her marital troubles and condescending personality. In "Music of the Heart," Guaspari is chastised for her abrupt, demeaning treatment of the school children, who she treats with the same stern coaching style as she does her own kids. The story of Robert Guaspari begins in 1980 after she and her two sons have moved back in with Guaspari's mother, played by a deli- cately unbalanced Cloris Leachman. Guaspari takes a job as a gift wrapper and runs into an old friend, portrayed by the portly Aidan Quinn, who gained more than his respectable share of weight for the film. For rea- sons unknown, Quinn is given second billing for the film, but only appears in a few scenes. He becomes Guaspari's first love interest and helps her secure her teaching job at the East Harlem school, where begins her crusade to place a bow in every child's hand. "Music of the Heart" is based upon Allen and Lana Miller's 1996 docu- mentary "Small Wonders," which gar- nered an Academy Award nomination ', _____________ for Best Documentary. Many of the scenes in "Music of the Heart" come straight from the documentary, .adding only the earlier parts of Roberta Tsavaras' story, including her first moments away from her estranged husband, the move to the Big Apple and the securing of her teaching position. If anyone should see this movie, they should go for the excellent per- formances delivered by Meryl Streep, Angela Bassett and Aidan Quinn, who all remind the gagging audience that they are fine actors in an, at best, mediocre film. Unfortunately, they are unable to revive this suffering heap of celluloid trash. Streep seems to have a penchant for taking drab, realistic "Mom" roles and turning them into masterpieces. It might've done her well to actually have real- ized the overly contrite writing and go-nowhere plot lines, interrupted by unnecessary, ineffective side dishes of heart-tugging nonsense. In one shocking scene, a female student of Guaspari's informs her that she must bow out of violin instruction and the upcoming Carnegie Hall per- formance because she and her mother have been forced to move away from an abusive father. The girl intends to return her violin to Guaspari, who, in turn, insists that the girl cannot be separated from it. Earlier in the film, Guaspari had inspired the girl to attend Juilliard for a young apprentice program. The torn audience watches as the girl walks off with her violin and Guaspari turns her heels and heads to the next rehearsal. There is no emotional response from Guaspari here, a scene that could've otherwise secured Streep her next Oscar. At this point, the film has built Guaspari to be a big-hearted fighter, but fails to develop her fully, because, of course, the show must go on. Other irksome scenes include racial disharmony and economic fantasy. Craven's vision of East Harlem is all too sterile. The only realistic panora- ma of Harlem arrives when Guaspari and sons first travel to the city in the early '80s. Graffiti and gangs are everywhere. But nearly 20 years later, the town has somehow cleaned up. Guiliani isn't that powerful. For obvi- ouslyimarketable reasons, the racial diversity of the children in Guaspari's classes is ideal. If one looks back to "Small Wonders," they'll get a taste of reality, where white kids are the minority in East Harlem. "Music of the Heart" presents an altogether dif- ferent atmosphere of the city. These "poor" kids have lawyer fathers and Doc Martens. "Music of the Heart" isn't void of racial conflict. In movies of these kind, there are always logs to throw into the fire. When one black mother informs Guaspari that she doesn't want her son to study "white men's music," Guaspari returns with "What would've happened if Arthur Ashe's mother told him not to play a white man's game?" Inspirational, this not. Of course, the mother gives in. Screenwriter Pamela Gray would do better to writing dialogue for horror films, a task not requiring her to think too hard. Gloria Estefan makes a brief cameo in two forgettable scenes. Thankfully her performance has been reduced to these and only these. And, by necessi ty of her contract, the film's sound track includes an upbeat, danceat Estefan song. Amid all of the flaw of "Music of the Heart," it is refreshing to see large slice of reality in the physical frumpishness made of all the charac- ters, which turns this docu-drama into an unentertaining comedy. Streep, wearing large, oversized dresses anti tangled, wavy tresses, is a moder mom, balancing upkeep of her home and supporting her family wit stressful, committed career. She is made to look bad in ways unimagin- able, and have to be seen to be believed. But Streep is not the only one delivering an laudable performance. Stern, Perlman and a slew of other quasi-famous musicians make cameo appearances in the film for the grand finale performance at Carnegie Hall. It is a treat to hear their virtuoso formances after sitting through a t W hour soundtrack of squeaking strings and spine-chilling noise, reminding one that, yes, this is a Wes Craven film. "Music of the Heart" raises an important question: Why make another movie, this time a fictional narrative, about a subject which has already received plenty of attention in a superbly constructed docun~. tary? Producers will probably ins t that, with the government's recent failure to secure funding for the arts, it is time that the public is made aware of the danger. This isn't the first time that politics play a role in movie making, but it is the first time that such a despicable, inadequate film is presented as a political vehi- cle. "Music of the Heart" will remind audiences of the horrors of cutting arts funding on both a local national level, but will it really ha direct effect on its viewers? My guess is no. If Hollywood attempts to turn an awarded documentary into a enter- taining film with a message, there should be a smart sense of respect given to the original documentary. "Music of the Heart" steals good, tre dialogue from "Small Wonders," and adds a bottle of Aunt Jemima. * But audiences will love "Music-of the Heart," for it plays to the eyes and ears of an audience with a sweet tooth. It's another attempt at a charm- ing struggle story about a heroic white woman who saves the inner-city kids from urban downfall by teaching them the joy of music, which can save anyone's soul. It's been done befote and it always sells. MIDWEST COMPOSERS' SYMPOSIUM Friday, October 29 Bitton Recital Hall, E.V. Moore Bldg., 8:00pm Saturday, October 30th Ieintosh Theatre, E.V. Moore Bldg., 10:00am Recital Hall, E.V. Moore Bldg., 2:00pm Recital Hall, E.Y. Moore Bldg., 4:00pm Rackham Auditorium, 8:00pm (Contemporary Directions*) The University of Michigan hosts the 1999 Midwest Composers' Symposium, a two-day festival featuring new works by student composers from five midwestern universities. The five concerts include works for various instrumental ensembles and electronica. Contact Stephanie Johnson at 913-0125 for more info. GUEST CONCERT: ARCHIGLAS, RUSSIAN CHORAL GROUP FROM ST. PETERSBURG RUSSIA Friday, October 29, 7:00pm Blanche Anderson Moore Hall, E.V. Moore Bldg. An a cappella mixture of Russian folk and Orthodox music. ANDRE WATTS, PIANO MASTERCLASS SPONSORED BY THE SALLY FLEMING MASTERCLASS SERIES Saturday, October 30, 10:00am Britton Recital Hall, E.V. Moore Bldg. The Sally Fleming Masterclass series is proud to sponsor Andre Watts. Piano students from the studios of the University of Michigan will perform a variety of works. CONTEMPORARY DIRECTIONS CONCERT* (PART OF MIDWEST COMPOSERS' SYMPOSIUM) Saturday, October 30, 8:00pm Rackham Auditorium H. Robert Reynolds, conductor J. Eric Wilson, guest conductor/Stuart Sims, guest conductor GUEST LECTURE: DAVID BROWNELL, VIOLEN MAKER'S ASSOC. OF MICHIGAN Sunday, October 31, 10:00am Britton Recital Hall, E.Y. Moore Bldg. HALLOWEEN CONCERT Sunday, October 31, 4:30pm & 8:00pm Hill Auditorium Tickets available at the Michigan League Ticket Office. On Sunday, October 31st, remaining tickets will be available at the door at Hill Auditorium. Program Includes: *March of the Little Goblins, Glaser 9Overture to Die Fledermaius, Strauss *Monostatos' Aria from The Magic Flute, Mozart *Danse Macabre, Saint-Saens *Circus Polka, Stravinsky *Red Cape Tango from Metropolis Symphony, Daugherty *Petrouchka (1947), Stravinsky eSensemaya, Revueltas eBack to the Fifties, Wendel. The HoneyBuff Awaits You... T s( - , QUA LITY 16 Jackson Rd. @ Wagner (1/2 mile west of Weber's Inn) West bound 1-94 or M-14 exit @ Zeeb Rd. & go East one mile on Jackson 23 I 3 i m a w z < z 3 - JACKSON yS 23 O Fyq z QP f rP k. SSATURDAY 6& SUNDAY 10 &11AM October 23rd & 24th November 13th &14th *FS Antz (PG) Jack Frost (PG) tober 30th & 31st November 20th & 21st 1 Muppets trom Space Prince of Egypt (PG) fet" November 6th & 7th Rugrats (G) - "I s ALL AUDITORIUMS INCLUDE Digital Stereo Dolby SRD & DTD High back rocking chair seats with cupholders STADIUM SEATING gives you an unobstructed viewSn c Student Prices U COUPON1 I ONE FREE 460Z POPCORN I (MEASURED BY VOLUME NOT WEGHT) IWITH THIS AD EXPIRES 11/14199 MD I so I IN I No no I In ONE I 1'13M mxE i The University Activities Center Orchestra performs classic movie music 0' t'e MICM IGAN ops ORCHESTRA Fop orese-Bt at the for the Performirng Arts By Rosemary Metz Daily Arts Writer "Duel of the Fates," with its dark, mysterious tones accompanied the 1' Michigan Mt -lgt and overtones, screen debut of Darth Maul in George Lucas' reach into the galactic past in "The Phantom Menace" In the choir from Detroit, and the University's Festival Chorus will per- form the "Duel of the Fates" in cone premiere. Later in the concert, the tai groups will join together again to per- form a selection from "Carmina Burana," which was featured in the film, "Glory." As an added attraction, composer Conrad Pope will be presenting a pre- concert lecture The shiect of Pnne's - -- - I II I