4 OPINION Page 4 be £rbigniflai g Edited and managed by students at The University of Michigan 420 Maynard St. Vol. IC, No. 137 Ann Arbor, MI 48109 Unsigned editorials represent a majority of the Daily's Editorial Board. All other cartoons, signed articles, and letters do not necessarily represent the opinion of the Daily. Wednesday, April 19, 1989 Intifada's 561 martyrs: Price of the The Michigan Daily 'peace Nalihalin ANOTHER RAID on a Palestinian village. Four young men dead, 50 wounded. Business as usual? Not ex- actly. On April 13th, Israeli border po- lice entered the village of Nahhalin for a pre-dawn attack. When the dust settled, Fouad Najharah, Subhi Shakarneh, Mahmoud al-Sheikh, and Riyadh Ghayathah would never again greet their families. Scores of people were seriously wounded from gun- shots, beatings, and tear gas fired into their homes. Troops sealed off the village, preventing medical relief to the wounded and postponing independent investigations of the incident. For a week prior to the attack, border patrols and settlers had entered Nah- halin and repeatedly harassed the vil- lagers, particularly women. Sexual harassment, indecent exposure, and mocking of Islamic religious practices were reported. The raid itself, coming as people finished their morning meal and left for Ramadan prayers at the mosque, seemed timed to catch the largest number of young men in the village. Border police shot Najharah on his way to pray. When the sound of gunshots brought villagers out of the mosque, border police opened fire in- discriminately. Human rights field workers in Jerusalem report that vil- lagers were pulled from their homes and beaten. The Nahhalin pogrom caused the In- ternational Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) to issue a rare public statement, pogrom protesting the increasing use of fire- arms and acts of violence against defenseless civilians and the interfer- ence in the work of physicians. The ICRC called on Israeli officials to end "such practices as violate the funda- mental principles of humanitarian law." While the Nahhalin incident seems, on surface, to be merely the latest act of Israeli violence against Palestinian civilians, it indicates a disturbing new pattern. Nahhalin, an isolated village of 4,000 Palestinians, surrounded by three Israeli settlements, was beset by border police (i.e., professional sol- diers, not reservists) in a premeditated and extremely violent raid, following a week of harassment by soldiers and settlers. Border police, known for their ferocity, aggression, and hatred of Palestinians, are purposely used to in- timidate. The Palestine Human Rights Campaign predicts that isolated Pales- tinian villages will increasingly be at- tacked and sealed off in order to intimidate the populace. Both the ICRC and the PHRC note a rise in brutality against Palestinians in the last few months. Last week in the United States, Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Shamir said that Gaza and West Bank will remain under Israeli control. That statement can be parsed down to Palestinian bodies, because Palestinians will not stop struggling for their rights and the only language the current Israeli government speaks is the language of force and terror. Readers may wonder why the Opinion page has consistently covered the Pales- tinian uprising. The following martyrs' list was compiled by the Database Project on Palestinian Human Rights in Jerusalem for December 9, 1988 through April 14, 1989. The number of deaths by gunfire is 381; deaths by other causes (i.e., beatings, tear gas) is 180. The media often neglect to give the names of the victims. We believe that their names should be known. Israel is the largest re- cipient of U.S. foreign aid and the tear gas the Israeli military uses is made in the United States. So here is America's con- tribution to the peace process. Hatem Siss, 15; Ibrahim Ekeik, 18; Wahid Abu Salem, 13; Suhaila Ka'bai, 53; Ali Abdallah, 13; Sahar Jirmi, 19; Hassan Jarrghun, 22; Nafez Abu Qteifan, 16; Talal Hweiwi, 17; Ibrahim Saakhlleh, 25; Khaled Taqiyeh, 22; Abdul Hussein, 23; Atwa Samhadaneh, 20; Maisara Batniji, 26; Abdul Fteiha, 29; Mahmoud Qsisi, 19; Yusef Ararwi, 24; Bassem Sawafta, 19; Nazek Sawafta, 17; Raed Shihadeh, 16; Khaled Hameed, 20; Mustafa Beik, 19; Haniyeh Gha- sawneh, 25; Ali Dahlan, 19; Mazen Musallam, 17; Khaled Awadeh, 22; Khalil Abu Lul, 54; Bassam Musalem, 27; Naji Kamil, 43; Touqan Misbeh, 32; Rabeh Hamed, 17; Atta Khdeir, 26; Mohammad Fayad, 20; Bassel Yasurei, 23; Mohammad Yazuri, 30; Ramadan Sobeih, 14; Hussein Ma'ali, 19; Ah- mad Ta'amreh, 43; Moh'd Tubaza, 16; Ibrahim Na- hel, 31; Musiyad Sha'ar, 21; Murad Hamdallah, 17; Asmaa Subbubeh, 25; Ibrahim Mansour, 26; Thamer Disuqi, 10; Tayseer Awad, 18; Moh'd Shweiha Adi, 18; Imad Sabameh, 26; Abdul Juma', 27; Nabil Khalil, 14; Imad Hamalawi, 20; Ahmad Sabil, 37; Basem Jitan, 14; Bashar Ma'di, 20; Isma'il Mashni, 22; Nassrallah Nassrallah, 12; Abdallah Ataya, 19; Ragheb Ammara, 19; Kamal Darwish, 23; Mahmud Hushiyeh, 23; Rawda Hassan, 13; Mohammad Zeid, 4; Sami Dayeh, 19; Issam Khalifeh; Iyad Ashqar, 13; Hassan Kheiran, 22; Rashiqa Daraghmeh, 63; Ahmad Bitawi, 30; Ahmad Barghuthi, 21; Raed Barghuthi, 17; Majed Atrash, 22; Abdallah Baker, 17; Nihad Khmour, 20; Yasser Abdul Jabber, 17; Bakr Shibani, 17; Moh'd Salah, 18; Mohammad Sa'afin, 22; Mahel Waridat, 30; Rasem Atlul, 28; Ayman Ajaq, 17; Bassam Badarin, 18; Moh'd Hamed, 17; Najeh Hijaz, 18; Khader Hamideh, 41; Yusef Abu Eid, 22; Arafat Hweih, 22; Alam Sadaqa, 16; Ashraf Ibrahim, 22; Omar Hamarsheh, 27; Hisham aLushi, 31; Sabri Sharar, 25; Hani Hammam, 23; Khaled Hussein, 23; Nameq Milhem, 26; Adel Jaber, 18; Muhamed Abu Zaru, 22; Majed Sawalmeh, 22; Hikmat Daraghmeh, 26; Khaled Muraqtan, 18; Walid Abdul Fatafta, 18; Awad Ibrahim, 30; Majed Deeb, 19; Ayad Khalik, 21; Hussein Odeh, 19; Yasser As'ad, 15; Fahim Nu- seirat, 27; Omar Rabai'ah, 22; Ghassan Mir'i, 17; Hussein Hussein, 25; AbdulKarim Halaika, 24; Khaled Salah, 23; Shaker Shaker, 26; Wajiha Rabi', 55; Moh'd Ziban, 29; Sleiman Jheidi, 18; Ishaq Silmiyeh, 24; Jamal Tumeizi, 22; Ala' Kurdi, 21; Ahmad Kurdi, 42; Jamil Kurdi, 55; Khamis Ahmed, 38; Jihad 'Assi, 18; Salim Sha'er, 23; Ali Abu Ali, 46; Hamzeh AbuShab, 20; Hamed Ze'dat, 18; Hatem Jabber, 22; Musa Shamsa, 22; Issam Said, 16; Yusef Rabi', 75; Fuad Ashqar, 21; Moh'd Yahia, 20; Jalal Milhem, 21; Nasser Lidawi, 22; Wael Taha, 225; Hala Amiri, 20; Mihyi Mawalha, 20; Hilmi Turuk- man, 22; Saadah Sabah, 40; Bassam hariri, 23; Rikri Daghmi, 22; Abdul Hanun, 19; Ayman Amer, 22; Atwa Sha'er, 14; Taysin Bouji, 16; Jamal Shehadeh, 17; Munir Tatari, 24; Farid Darras, 25; Iman Kamar, 22; Nizar Jaloudi, 26; Ahmad Eiyeh, 20; Ayda Totah, 30; Moh'd Nassar, 22; Farraj Farrajallah, 23; Moh'd Zeid, 16; Ahmad Salem, 27; Arij Dik, 13; Sari Rus- tum, 35; Naim Farha, 22; Khaled Umayrah, 25; Nidal Balo, 19; Omar Manasra, 18; Rizek Sabbah, 16; Jamal Madhun, 20; Judah Taiyem, 28; Ibrahim Odeh, 35; Abdul Mu'ti, 21; Mahmud Zeid, 33; Ala'addin Saleh, 15; Jihad Issi, 16; Majdi Hillah, 16; Kawthar Mohammad, 23; Mod'd Lulu, 57; Amin Radaha, 14; Iyad Shanaa', 16; In'am Hamdan, 25; Moh'd Ghanem, 26; Mustafa Halaika, 19; Imad Mawari, 16; Saed layek, 18; Bassem Sabbagh, 21; Deib Hamad, 45; Nidal Hassan, 20; Taysir Blltat, 27; Raed Yusef, 17; Taalat Zaqqout, 17; Ibrahim Aranqui, 15; Arafat Hanani, 16; Fatmeh Sahwil, 26; Na'el Khameiz, 17; Abdul Dababat, 17; Rayek Hussein, 25; Zuhdi Zreiki, 17; Faris Anabtawi, 17; Hassan 'Adis, 16; Amjad Khawaja, 17; Samir Sayah, 13; Jamal Qaddoumi, 29; Nidal Rabbadi, 16; Zaki Halaika, 23; Hisham Zeid, 26; Fuad Urrabi, 16; Muhamad Saif, 17; Maher Ghazzaleh, 24; Husam Azia, 23; Jiryis Qunqar, 43; Yasser Sabaana, 25; Suheir Afani, 13; Abdel Alayan, 17; Hani Turk, 37; Aladdin Aghbar, 18; Nidal Bouzieh, 16; Hussein Asway, 14; Ahmad Salah, 17; Riad Mandil, 26; Yusef Damaj, 12; Moh'd Rizak, 52; Mahmud Rizq, 20; Jamal Odeh, 19; Ibrahim Samoudi, 27; Asad Shawwa, 19; Rasha Arqawi, 9; Rajah Suwafneh, 17; Na'el Hamad, 18; Ahmad Shaghnubi, 23; Khaled Hashhash, 22; Moh'd Shqeir, 31; Ayman Yamin, 16; Louai Barghouthi, 22; Minawi Araysha, 17; Abdel Baruud, 18; Moh'd Salah, 39; Ahmad Dababseh, 26; Rami Samra, 10; Imad Arqawi, 17; Munjed Sarhan, 26; Imad Thuriya, 17; Hanni Median, 15; Nahil Tukhi, 12; Jihad Zaino, 20; Jamal Shqeirat, 23; Naser Jundi, 22; Nabil Jamal, 21; Osama Breika, 18; Hussam Gharbawi, 19; Ayman Sharar, 17; Kayed Salah, 42; Zein Karaki, 18; Nitham Hawaila, 24; Adnan Khanfa, 31; Samir Bahlul, 26; Nidal Najjar, 18; Ahdae Mashharawi, 21; All Sa'eh, 20; Moh'd Ahmed,a24; Ahmad Kilani, 28; Fadel Najjar, 24; Kamal Saria, 23; Osama Dahi, 18; Nazim Judeh, 18; mahmud Khader, 18; Ahmad Ajrab, 19; Omar Assi, 18; Osama Shalabi, 18; Khaled Tabeileh, 15; Diya Moh'd, 5; Moh'd Shahin, 17; Mahal Samour, 14; I process' mal Zakameh, 14; Riyad Shalabi, 23; Issam Bulbol, 25; Ammar Turk, 18; Ahmad Yazouri, 14; Moh'd Rishaq, 55; Ahmad Muharam, 17; Atweh Harazal- lah,25; Marwan Korraz, 24; Ahmad Azami, 19; Ibrahim Jabbour, 24; Hakam Bakir, 18; Atef Jundiya, 16; Zuheir Hama, 24; Moh'd Shreim, 17; Abdul Sharif, 20; Fawzi Bakhit,.20; Majdi Qurani, 19; Ta- lal Araj, 26; Assad Hamudeh, 17; Samer Aruri, 12; Nu'man Jaradat, 15; Ahmad Hadid, 11; Maher 'Adeili, 14; Marwan Tamam, 17; Adli Rabia, 20; Ashraf Jazar, 17; Amjed Nasrallah, 4; Abdul Abdul- lah, 20; Akram Khweiled, 19; Moh'd Rabo, 23; Nasr Nasr, 24; Awad 'Amr, 30; Akram Yasini, 17; Moh'd Baba, 17; Salem Salah, 26; Mahmud Nabhan, 12; Ahmad Sneineh, 60; Khaled Shawish, 26; Jamil Nat- she, 22; Khadera Awwad, 21; Musa Omar, 45; Ma'azuz Yamin, 25; Moh'd Kitaneh, 25; Ribi Kaid,; 61; Jalal Khadijeh, 24; Miryam Khouri, 65; Salah Kasab, 22; Inad Shalabi, 43; Nasser Thabet, 22; Ibrahim Shamali, 45; Riad Madah, 18; Rami Madah, 18; Salem Amr, 45; Rajeb Ismail, 47; Jawad Amr, 44; Nimnr Najjar, 17; Omar Saker; Nawal Thuriya, 52; Fatmeh Qidri, 1 day; Najwa Masri, 18; Khalil Mahsiri, 76; Khaled Qidri, 14 days; Amal Qseisa, 5 days; Raed Obeid, 3 mos.; Mariam Zahir, 81; Wijdan Faress, 38 + 9 month fetus; Amira Askar, 35; Fay- rouz Shobaki, 11; Moh'd Tubbaza, 17; Moh'd Shahin, 75 days; Imad Asi, 15 days; Samer Badaha, 5 mos.; Sa'd Shaban, 25; Ali Isamil, 31; Taleb Zeid, 46; Issam Hamoudi, 27; Abdallah Nabi, 70; Um Hamed; Asmaa Sharif, 18; Nabil Orti, 25; Atef Fayad, 30; Salah Ataar, 22; Nu'am Abed, 26; Abdul Shamaleh, 25; Nawaf Shamaleh, 24; Abdul Shamaleh, 22; Salah Damuni, 60; Ma'mun Jarad, 16; Badriyah Shahin, 55; Nidal Shomar, 17; Hassan Buhi, 80; Shamseh Qaadan, 65; Moh'd Qaadan, 35; Majdi Safaka, 12; Rahi Lahaliyeh, 41; Ahmed Sh'alan, 12; Attallah Misleh, 55; Hussein Frush, 16; Salah Marai, 16; Bassam Allah, 11; Nidal Allah, 10; Mahmud Hamudeh, 66; Kayed Tmeizi, 10; Moh'd Siam, 41; Zakaria Katash, 26; Abdul Ghannam, 63; Mustafa Shamasneh, 23; Akram Rashid, 21; Ibrahim Habal, 26; Omar Hajajlah, 37; Moh'd Nassar, 23; Abdul Nadi, 34; Abdul Fleifel, 70; Khaled Antarzi, 27; Ahmed Ahmed, 61; Islam Daifa, 25 days; Imad Assi, 1; Haj Taha, 49; Ahmad Khawaja, 70; Tawfiq Zakameh, 55; Qassem Natshe, 60; Yusef Zidan, 52; Badr Karadi, 12; Naim Naim, 12; Talal Basharat, 8; Amin Rub, 15; Iktamel Wahdan, 5; Moh'd Hamiyeh, 18; Mahmud Masri, 37; Omar Salman, 19; Subhiyeh Hashash, 55; Moh'd Ibeid, 28; Moh'd Badran, 34; Rami Aklouk, 15; Ayad Agel, 17; Khader Tarazi, 19; Moh'd Shweideh, 68; Anwar Amireh, 27; Yusuf Ki- lani, 1; Khaled Ardha, 21; Kamleh Sharaf, 60; Moh'd Skafi, 4; Moh'd Khaled, 19; Moh'd Hamed, 24; Omar Marahil, 27; Khalil Khamzawi, 18; Ibrahim Zeid, 28; Suad Yusef, 90; Atiyeh Risq, 19; Ibrahim Aishe, 71; Husni Mahsiri, 41; Ayad Nadi, 25; Hus- sein Jalaleh, 20; Saber Nimnim, 23; Simone Ghan- nam, 17; Khalil Abadl, 41; Said Abed, 20; Maher Maqqab, 28; Atta Ayad, 21; Hisham Maqdad, 23; Nasim Abed, 26; Nabil Bedah, 20; Maysara Mattar, 25; Hanni Shamni, 49; Ayman Najar, 28; Ibrahim Matur, 32; Marwan Qaneiri, 27; Abdul Miskawi, 2 mos.; Haitham Shqeiro, 4 mos.; Amneh Darwish, 72; Fatima Salman, 57; Arafat Rous, 6 mos.; Rana Adwan, 3 mos.; Ahmad Sahiyeh, 65; Ranin Sfair, 3 mos.; Ruad Sha'rawi, 48; Salman Daher, 63; Khitam Aram, 8; Salim Amer, 10 mos.; Salahaddin Naqib, 33; Shirin Elayan, 4 mos.; Khaled Hawajreh, 3 mos.; Yusef Hassuna, 3 mos.; Sanaar Ebeid, 40 days; Yahia Maghrabi, 2 mos.; Juma Tukhi, 66; Salim Yahia, 60; Mustafa Froukh, 68; Ali Hajjar, 70; Ola Sharifa, 4 mos.; Hussein Iqmail, 70; Nabila Yajizi, 30; Shirin Maniarawi, 1 mos.; Hamid Asmadi, 20 days; Rajab Slaibi, 75; Subhiyeh Mankush, 60; Hassan Qaud, 22; Wadfa Allah, 70; Farid Amarneh, 11; Jamal Alqam, 3 days; Ismail Sheikh, 50; Moh'd Hamad, 30; Moh'd Samhan, 52; Naima Adi, 55; Khaled Najar, 55; Dina Sawafri, 3; Maisa Jaffal, 40 days; Abdallah Khalaf, 28; Tawfiq Malamha, 55; Moh'd Shaabilo, 35; Thaer Badr, 25 days; Ansar Heju, 65; Ghalia Abdul Nabi, 31; Khalil Baalushi, 52; Ala Ful, 12; Moh'd Aza, 2; Qawqar Arrar, 17; Nasreen Nawajhah, 3; Ibrahim Hamdiyeh, 80; Fouad Najharah, 16; Subhi Shakarneh, 20; Mahmoud Sheikh, 22; Riyadh Ghayathah, 27. PALES TINE Ziad Thabet, 15; Basel Dweikat, 17; Iyad Saada, 19; Jalal Fayoumi, 21; Mujahid Karim, 18; Ismat Mah- mud, 21; Ahmad Besharat, 21; Osama Ghanima, 3; Alam Hantuli, 27; Sabri Arnous, 25; Tareq Samhadaneh, 25; Yusef Shibbli, 22; Muhib Ha- layem, 12; Farid M'ghari, 14; Hani Hersha, 16; Hamid Haj, 14; Asmaa Abadi, 15; Ysef Sbeih, 17; Husni Siddu, 14; Abdallah Mahruq, 20; Hamdan Na- jjar, 26; Ashraf Daoud, 15; Yasin Shakhshir, 20; Fayez Shaqo, 21; Nidal Haq, 20; Moh'd Kawni, 22; Zuheir Fayyad, 23; Moh'd Farhat, 40; Ibrahim M'baser, 23; Abdul Qaddura, 26; Moh'd Hawash, 21; Moh'd Othma, 19; Samir Shehadeh, 18; Jibril Qir, 19; Sami Rahim, 23; Musbah Dallul, 19; Abdul Bakhit, 22; Zaki Steiti, 20; Ismail Barghouthi, 23; Anwar Tayeh, 13; Nasr Nassar, 16; Marwan Madani 18; Abdul Habaibe, 11; Moh'd Sahlug, 18; Nabil Laban, 15; Rana Masri, 17; Hanadi Sultan, 12; Moh'd Aboushi, 18; Ziad Radwan, 17; Ahmad Mustafa, 17; Radwan Sbeih, 17; Issa Manasra, 16; Ibrahim Siam, 17; Samer Kasem, 17; Moh'd Dawawsi, 17; Talal Basharat, 8; Amin Rub, 15; Ik- tamel Wahdan, 5; Moh'd Hamiyeh, 18; Mahmud Masri, 35; Ali Sharifeh, 13; Issam Mara'beh, 20; Mustafa Mara'beh, 40; Majid Farrah, 23; Salameh Sbeih, 14; Ala Arandas, 15; Majid Haq, 16; Moh'd Matar, 17; Akram Nahleh, 19; Nidal Dheib, 23; Ka- Bollinger sells out to alumni Associated Press Israeli border police harrass Palestinians at the entrance to Jerusalem's Temple Mount. Prolonged searches prevent Palestinians from worshipping at the Al Aqsa Mosque during Ramadan. Note M-16 assault rifle and teargas grenade launcher. Kurds rights denied ON APRIL 19th and 20th, the Ann Arbor chapter of Amnesty International will hold a conference in the Michigan Union on "Human Rights in Turkey and the Kurdish Issue." Amnesty International, the world- wide human rights group that won a Nobel Prize in 1977, has noted that the Turkish government is currently em- barking on a publicity campaign to im- prove its global image for the purposes of gaining membership in the European Economic Community. Turkey has not taken steps, however, to improve its human rights record. Torture of politi- cal detainees in Turkey is virtually guaranteed; one quarter of a million persons have been arrested on political charges since 1980. A large number of those arrested are Kurds, members of a minority that comprises as much as 18 percent of the population of Turkey. Kurds through- out Asia (they are also found in Iran, Alternative A GROUP OF students who don't r Iraq, Syria, and the USSR) suffer from political repression, particularly in the course of their struggle for their own state which has been ongoing through- out the century. But it is universally agreed that Kurds have the fewest rights in Turkey. Kurds in Turkey are not allowed to have Kurdish names, speak the Kurdish language, own a book in Kurdish, receive radio or TV broadcasts in Kurdish, or even wear the national costume of the Kurds. Kurds are incarcerated for such infrac- tions as stating publicly that they are Kurds. Amnesty International is calling for the Turkish government to eliminate torture in prisons, unfair trials, and to make changes in the Turkish penal code which prohibit freedom of expression and freedom of association. The global community should support AI's campaign to pressure Turkey to improve its human rights record. graduation alienated by the mainstream campus By David A. Cerda and Rogelio M. Ruiz The University of Michigan Law School's anti-discrimination policy has been bought off by law school alumni. Three months ago, the law school revoked the FBI's recruiting privileges after the FBI was found guilty by a federal district court of systematically discriminating against Latino agents. Subsequently, to appease alumni upset with the law school's decision, the dean of the law school, Lee C. Bollinger, decided unilater- ally and secretly to honor the FBI's direc- tor, William Sessions, by inviting him to speak at this year's law school com- mencement. If the Law School follows tradition, Sessions will also receive an honorary degree. The dean's decision is a nullification of the law school's anti-discrimination pol- icy. More importantly, the decision is a shocking demonstration of the little weight civil rights merit to the larger law school community and to the University administration as a whole. As Latinos, we feel that if this decision remains unan- swered the ominous implication is that when push comes to shove, Latinos are a minority group easily written off because of our slight numbers in the student body and faculty. We hope we are wrong. We trust a detailed account of events, includ- ing our efforts toward reaching a compro- mise solution, will awaken those unaware had found the FBI guilty of systematically discriminating against Hispanics, and the FBI's defense counsel was also found guilty of using improper litigation tactics. Since the court's original decision, the court has twice found the FBI guilty of recriminating against the agents who brought the law suit. Other recrimination suits are pending. Thus, the FBI's discrimination continues under William Sessions' leadership. Michigan was the first law school in the country to ban the FBI for its proven dis- criminatory actions. The decision received national coverage in the New York Times and was followed by at least three other major law schools. The minority commu- nity at the law school, and the Latino community in particular, applauded the dean's decision. At a time of increasing racial intolerance on this campus, the de- cision signaled the University's willing- ness to work toward building a more re- spectful environment for people of color. But the decision to enforce the law school's anti-discrimination policy was to be short-lived. After banning the FBI, Dean Bollinger travelled around the country speaking to alumni groups to raise money for the Law School - one of the dean's most impor- tant functions. During an April 6 meeting with the Hispanic Law Students Associa- tion (HLSA), the dean explained candidly that alumni were very upset with his deci- sion to ban the FBI. He said these alumni -.... -A L._ .r 6.r... . ..- .r-- ...: law school's involvement in respecting civil rights. Sessions' invitation serves as another glaring example of this University's in- sensitivity to the concerns of minority students. When first responding to student outcry, Dean Bollinger claimed that it never crossed his mind the minority stu- dents would be angered by Sessions' commencement appearance and honorary degree. We disagree. We believe that the dean carefully weighed the interests at stake and sacrificed minority - and espe- cially Latino - interests. As HLSA members, we have been en- gaged in a continuing dialogue with Dean Bollinger during the past month. He said that Sessions had been invited to speak on eradicating discrimination in government. The dean has since reported that Sessions intends to speak on "public interest work in government." We realize the political difficulty of withdrawing an invitation. Thus, we asked the dean to invite a second commencement speaker - the Latino attorney who won the original suit against the FBI - to balance the political symbolism and ad- vance social discourse. Unfortunately, the dean rejected this too. And although Bollinger finally accepted the idea of a second speaker, he later reported that Ses- sions would not accept another speaker, nor would he withdraw his acceptance. It now appears the FBI is directing the law school's commencement. 4 I