The Michigan Daily - Thursday, September 4, 1986 - Pagel9
INFIGHTING RESTRICTS ASSEMBLY DECISION-MAKING
MSA hires mediator to resolve tension
By MARY CHRIS JAKLEVIC
On-going tension among members
of the Michigan Student Assembly
this summer led the assembly to hire
Mediation has resolved some im-.
medite disputes, but assembly mem-
bers say the long-term effectiveness
of the mediation will not be evident
until fall, when the full assembly
resumes meeting. During the summer
only about one third of the assembly is
Vocal and often heated infighting
and name-calling during meetings
have prevented the assembly from
making any substantive decisions sin-
ce the MSA elections in April.
Tension from elections
Most of the conflict is between MSA
PresidentRurt Muenchow, a member
of the moderate-to-conservative
Meadow party, and members of the
liberal Student Rights Party, who.
hold a majority of seats and nearly all
chairmanships on the assembly.
Bad feelings developed during the
assembly election campaigning last
spring, when members of both the
Meadow and Student Rights parties
engaged in heavy-handed mud-
Since then the resentment between
the two groups has been perpetuated
by a number of power plays attem-
pted on both sides.
Much of the controversy during the
summer centered on Muenchow's op-
position to Student Rights supporters
who work for the assembly. In May,
Muenchow fired former Student
Rights presidential candidate Jen
Faigel, and in June he refused to sign
the timecards of Faigel and MSA
Military Research Advisor Robyn
Watts for work they had done since
Faigel was hired by former MSA
President Paul Josephson in
February to research the feasibility of
a University-wide orientation course
Zena Zumeta, director of the Ann
Arbor Mediation Center, was hired in
June to observe assembly meeetings,
and meet both with the assembly as a
whole and with individual members to
suggest ways to improve com-
Zumeta spent 25 hours working with
the assembly in June and July, and
charged $50 per hour for her services.
MSA employee Richard Layman is
optimistic the mediation will lead the
assembly away from personality
disputes and toward the issues which
divide the assembly members.
Layman said the assembly has a
more cooperative spirit than it did at
the beginning of the summer. "The
kind of armed-camp atmosphere isn't
there anymore," he said.
Art School representative Dave
Lovinger says the assembly has lear-
ned to place more emphasis on
the process -of decision-making,
rather than merely the content of the
issues. This includes being more con-
siderate of members who hold op-
Lovinger hopes this process can be
carried over in the fall, when the full
assembly resumes meeting.
"There needs to be a way for people
to express dissent and also feel like
they're part of the organization,"
In the past, more conservative
representatives such as those from
the Engineering College have clashed
with other assembly members over
issues such as military research on
campus, which MSA as a whole has
Some problems to persist
But Faigel said she does not believe
the mediation will make a dent in the
"A lot of (the problem) is the per-
sonalities involved. There's been too
much water under the bridge to go
back," Faigel said.
Faigel agrees that volatile issues
could again split the assembly in the
fall. "In certain issues there is going
to be a lot of infighting," she said.
Meadow and Student Rights can-
didates split during the elections over
whether MSA should pass resolutions
on national and international events.
Previous assemblies have taken con-
troversial stances against U.S.
foreign policies, especially insCentral
Muenchow said he is optimistic that
the assembly will run smoothly in the
fall, but he refused to comment on
how the mediation may effect the
"The mediation won't resolve those
differences of opinion, but it will help
us learn to deal with them," Layman
Lovinger said the ability of the
assembly to hold together in the fall
depends largely on the issues that
come up, and how the assembly mem.
bers handle a particularly divisive
issue with strong ideological im-
... heads split assembly
Panel suggests partial research ban
(Continued from Page 1)
adopt guidelines which:
" prohibit keeping the existence of a
sponsoring agency or research
" require that the contents of a
research contract or grant be made
" forbid any research where the
results are "unreasonably" kept
from public knowledge;
* allow researchers to use classified
documents in their projects, but for-
bid them to generate classified in-
" allow the project's sponsor to
review the documents generated but
not to classify them after completion.
The sponsor has six months to com-
plete the review.
Only nine of the 12 committee
members signed the report. Phar-
maceutics Prof. Gordon Amidon,
Pathology Prof. Rees Midgley and
Philosophy Prof. Carl Cohen submit-
ted a minority opinion calling the
recommended guidelines too restric-
tive because they would apply to all
"(The majority report's) restric-
tions would vastly enlarge the scope
of the restrictive rule, inhibiting in-
tellectual inquiry not only when it is
classified for reasons of national
security, but also when the resear-
cher and the sponsor would agree to
refrain from publishing results
longer than one year," the minority
It also said the majority report con-
centrated on general openess atethe
expense of academic freedom.
Making all research open to the
public, the minority report said, costs
researchers the freeedom to do the
research of their own choice.
Michigan Student Assembly
Military Research Advisor Robyn
Watts disagrees with the conclusions
of the minority report, and says the
majority recommendations aren't
"The current guidelines aren't en-
forced enough right now," Watts
said." The committee was called to
make the guidelines more specific,
and not to use the restrictions by
trusting the integrity of the
The regents are expected to act on
the recommendations during winter
Watch for it in
Recruits lose eligibility
P under Proposition 48
(Continued from Page 1)
standards, but dislikes the SAT
"I think that (SAT) is so prejudiced
that it concerns me," he said.
"Whether it's due to culture or
whatever, there's no question that
black kids haven't done as well on
that test as well as white kids."
averaged about 40 points higher than
Frieder said he was not at all con-
cerned about the academic abilities of
Mills and Robinson.
Coach supports recruits
"I have absolutely no concerns
about (Robinson) or Terry," he said,
"because they're serious students
who'll do the work.
"Phil Hubbard (1975-1979) was a
great player here, but he probably
couldn't pass that test today. But he
got his degree from Michigan and
he's been a great person to have out of
our program," Frieder said.
"Where would Phil Hubbard be
today if a place like Michigan hadn't
give him a chance'?" he asked.
Hubbard is currently a player in the
National Basketball Association.
Frieder said the potential effects of
Proposition 48 would have little in-
fluence on his choice of future
* COME JOIN US " FELLOWSHIP " WORSHIP *
CII PE L
(one block south of CCRB-off Washienaw) }
z WORSHIP: Sunday 10am & 6 pm
a Wednesday 10 pm
A campus ministry of the Christian Reformed Church
REFLECTION * ENTHUSIASM * FRIENDSHIP
... questions SAT legitimacy
You can place your order for telephone service from
August 20 through September 5 at our Michigan Bell
Customer Service Center. We're located at-324 E. Huron in
Ann Arbor. Center hours are from 9:00 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Monday through Friday. (We will be closed on Labor Day.)
There are four important points to remember
when placing your order for service:
1. Michigan Bell now provides basic telephone
service only, NOT the telephones. If you already
own modular telephones, just keep them and
plug them in once your service is installed. If you
don't own any telephones, there are a number of
companies from which you can buy or lease them.
2. If your residence is already equipped with
modular telephone service, no installer visit will
3. Michigan Bell is able to provide your local and
long distance service within the 313 Area Code
only. For calls to other places in Michigan and to
other states, you need to make arrangements for
service with a long distance company. If you do
not make any arrangements, you will not be able
to place long distance calls to telephone numbers
outside of the 313 Area Code.
4. Please bring picture identification, such as a
driver's license or passport, when placing your
order for service.