4 Page 8 - The Michigan Daily - Sunday, November 4, 1984 Inconsistency marks Michigan's tumble By DOUGLAS B. LEVY Special to the Daily WEST LAFAYETTE - Ouch! Final score: Purdue 31- Michigan 29. Throw it out, it's a lie, a misrepresen- tation of the worst kind. For the 60,159 souls in attendance yesterday at Pur- due's Ross-Ade Stadium, the game bet- ween the Boilermakers and Wolverines was over at the end of the first half. AFTER THE first 30 minutes of play yesterday, Purdue, behind the in- credible passing of Jim Everett, was annihilating Michigan, 24-0. "Our defense wasn't up," under- stated a slightly annoyed Bo Schem- bechler. "This is the first time our defense has let us down this season." Michigan's vaunted defense, previously the top-rated in the Big Ten, allowed the Boilermakers to stuff the ball down its throat. Purdue scored on its first four and only possessions of the first half, driving at will, doing anything it wanted. It was like taking candy from a baby. THE WOLVERINE offense was no better, racking up a measly 32 total first- half yards. "They came out and they were flat," described Purdue's nose guard Brad Horner. "I don't know if they had a bad plane ride or what. But they didn't have the sharpness that we had seen on film." With Schembechler's squad mired in at 5-4 overall and 4-3 in the conference, the question arises: "Bo, which team will we see next week? Will it be fired up or flat?" Following an exhilarating win over Miami of Fla., to open their season, the Wolverines were sloppy and unen- thusiastic the next week and fell to Washington. THEN, AFTER escaping with wins over Wisconsin and Indiana, Michigan was humbled by Michigan State and sported a record of 3-2. New quarterback Russel Rein easily guided Michigan past hapless North- western. But two weeks ago, in Iowa City, Rein and the Wolverines were humiliated, 26-0. Last week's 26-18 triumph over Illinois afforded Bo's team a new lease on life. A third quarterback, Chris Zur- brugg, emerged wielding an unstop- pable option offense. Then came yesterday's first half, showcasing a sh- ocking display of Wolverine ineptitude. IN ALL FAIRNESS to Schembechler, since his starting signalcaller, Jim Harbaugh, went down against the Spar- tans, Michigan has been operating at a big disadvantage. Coincidentally, it has been the second game for each of Michigan's three quarterbacks that has devastated the Wolverines: Harbaugh against the Huskies, Rein at Iowa, and yesterday, Zurbrugg at West Lafayette. Excuses aside, the 1984 Wolverines have been sorely lacking in consisten- cy. SHOULD THE current pattern con- tinue, and it's a good bet that it will, Michigan will cruise to victory over Minnesota next Saturday, only to travel to Columbus two weeks from now to be embarrassed by a sky-high Ohio State team that expects a prestigious bowl bid. Every Big Ten coach has been quoted ad nauseum this season about the parity that has enveloped the conferen- ce. Michigan has contributed more to this notion of parity than any other team. But is it parity or parody? Has Michigan fallen backwards? Last year the Wolverines creamed both MSU and Purdue, 42-0 and 42-10 respectively and downed Iowa 16-13. Have these teams improved so vastly in just one season to inflict so much damage on the Wolverines? To Schembechler's credit, after each loss he has promised, "We'll be back. I'll guarantee you that. Michigan is not dead." After the four losses the Wolverines have certainly come back strong, but they seem always to follow up with another lackluster drubbing. True, Michigan's pride was evident in yesterday's second half, as the team fought back from the 31-7 fourth quar- ter blowout score. Zurbrugg completed 19 of 25 second half passes to rally the squad in a decidedly un-Michigan-like attack. None of this analysis matters, though, because despite Purdue's sterling performance, Schembechler knows his team was easily capable of stopping the Boilermakers. Wolverine inconsistency keyed yesterday's defeat, as it has flawed this entire '84 campaign. Ouch! Daily Photo by DAN HABIB Rick Rogers lunges for an extra yard during yesterday's game at Purdue. Despite a valiant fourth quarter rally, the Wolverines lost 31-29 and their record dropped to 5-4.overall. Bukck on the Draw Bv i'AYIikVcraw. Purdue little, Purdue late Seeing is believing . ... Bo's boys lucky to be off TV WEST LAFAYETTE THE MOST unfortunate aspect of yesterday's game was that none of the bowl scouts arrived late. The reps of the Liberty, Peach, Citrus, Holiday, and Hall of Fame Bowls were all here to watch a Michigan team that came out of the lockerroom as flat as the Indiana countryside and trailed Purdue, 24-0 at halftime. When you recall that the worst Wolverine defeat during the Bo Schem- bechler era was 26-0 - two weeks ago against Iowa - you can imagine how badly Michigan played to encounter a deficit that was growing as fast as Ronald Reagan's. The Wolverines were moving the ball after receiving the opening kickoff. They reached the Boilermaker thirty nine, but when Eddie Garrett dropped a sure first-down pass on a third-and-six, the onslaught began. From that point on in the first half, Michigan was outgained 286 yards to -9. Prime time promise The bowl boys had to be enjoying it. Before them was a team with an ex- citing offense, big-play potential, tough defense and all-black uniforms. What better to attract a large Mizlou television audience come bowl day. Possible consolation for Michigan could come thanks to its big scoring flurry in the final minutes. Now some bowl big shots who skipped this game might read the 31-29 final in today's paper and think, "Wow, that must have been a great game.' Well, at least it wasn't on national TV like the Washington and Iowa losses were. Few people will really know how bad the Wolverines looked in the first thirty minutes of play. You've got to not like the post-season outlook for Michigan after this weekend. This defeat, coupled with Wisconsin's tie of Iowa (on TV, no less), has dropped the Wolverines into fifth in the Big Ten bowl-popularity stand- ings behind Iowa, Ohio State, the Boilers and Badgers. You've heard the phrase, "this game is like a bowl game for us" many times from mediocre teams that are playing a big opponent and have little. hope of a bowl invitation. Well that's the situation Michigan faces now, headed for the Buckeye Bowl, November 17 in Columbus. Pass the cranberries Sure, Thanksgiving bowls don't carry quite the same prestige as the New Year's ones, but you've got to take what you can get. And if a loss to Ohio State is added to the Wolverines' record, not even the Cherry Bowl in Pon- tiac is going to want them. At least yesterday's game ended on a somewhat positive note *to carry Michigan into the final two games of the season. Once the players woke up at halftime, they came back strong. Chris Zur- brugg looked great throwing for touchdown passes in the second half. They should have done it all game though - 208 of the Michigan yards and 22 of its (points came in the final seven minutes. But that's been the story of the 1984 Wolverines - not quite good enough. And they picked a season to have an off year when the Big Ten happened to be especially strong. Not just hoop-la Look at Purdue. No one was expecting anything more than seventh place for Leon Burtnett's team, but it's in second. Kind of reminiscent of last win- ter's Boilermaker basketball squad - picked eighth, finished first. In fact, after the football was over yesterday, the Purdue hoopsters scrimmaged for the fans next door at Mackey Arena in an early preseason warmup. Hmmmmm. I'll bet a lot of Michigan sports fans will be thinking about basketball this fall a lot earlier than they usually do. SCORING MICHIGAN ..................... 0 0 7 22-29 Purdue .......................... 7 .17 0 7-31 SCORING PLAYS PU-. Berry two-yard pass from Everett (Rendina kick) PU-Jeff Price six-yard pass from Everett (Rendina kick) PU-Rendina 22-yard field goal PU-Medlock one-yard run (Rendina kick) MICH-Jokisch 1-yard pass from Zurbrugg (Ber- geron kick) PU-Carter 16-yard run (Rendina kick) MICH-Markray 13-yard pass from Zurbrugg (Ber- geron kick) MICH-Bean 15-yard pass from Zurbrugg (Bean pass from Zurbrugg) MICH-Nelson six-yard pass from Zurbrugg (Bergeron kick) Passing (Att/ Comp/Int) .... Total Yards ....... Fumbles (No/Lost) Punts (No/Avg.) .. Penalties (No/Yds) Time of Possession 31/21/2 378 3/0 4/36.3 2/6 23:50 32/23/0 475 0/0 2/41.5 5/23 36:10 PASSING MICHIGAN Att Comp Zurbrugg...........31 21 Int 2 Yds TD 259 4 PURDUE No Griffin..................... 6 Carter..................... 5 Price ...................... 4 Scott....................4 King ...................... 2 Brunner ................... 1 Beery ..................... 1 RETURNS MICHIGAN Punts No/Yds Yds 112 43 55 29 28 21 2 TD 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 PURDUE Att Comp Int Yds Everett ............. 32 23 0 290 RUSHING MICHIGAN TD 2 4 Rogers.......... Morris ............ Garrett......... Perrymann .... Zurbrugg .......... Carter........... King ...:........ Everett......... Medlock......... Att Yds 15 76 5 48 3 9 2 8 7 -22 PURDUE Att Yds 27 89 14 82 4 13 2 1 Avg 5.1 9.6 3.0 4.0 -3.1 TD 0 0 0 0 0 TD 1 0 0 1 RECEIVING MICHIGAN No Nelson .................... 6 Bean ...................... 4 G. Johnson ................ 4 Markray................. 3 Rogers...................2 Jokisch................... I M orris .................... I First downs ....... Rushing (Att/yds) . N t Parin Yad d MICH 22 32/119 259 PU 28 47/185 246 Avg 3.3 5.9 3.3 0.5 Yds 45 81 67 45 0 15 6 TD 1 0 0 1 0 Morris....... White ....... G. Johnson .... Carter......... Cooper ...... 1/3 PURDUE Punts No/Yds Kickoffs No/Yds 2/30 1/4 Kickoffs No/Yds 1/14 1/6 Defense decays under air atack 17 first downs, contrasted to Michigan's 32 yards and three first downs. Everett marched the Boilermakers 97 yards into the end zone on their initial possession, setting the pace for the rest of the half. Purdue scored on all four of its first half possessions. ON THE OTHER SIDE, Michigan came out meekly. A fired-up Purdue defense held Bo's running attack to under one yard per carry (12 yards on 15 at- tempts). The option, which was so effective against Illinois, was irrelevant. "They came out and they were flat," observed Purdue nose guard Brad Horner. "I don't know if they had a bad plane ride or what, but they didn't have the sharpness that we had seen on film. "In the second half, they came out high and were a completely different team." "OUR DEFENSE wasn't up," said Schembechler. "This is the first time our defense has let us down all season. . . We had too many points to make up." Michigan made a gallant attempt to make up that ground in the second half. On their first possession,. the Wolverines moved 80 yards for their first score. The drive was capped by a 15-yard touchdown pass from Zurbrugg to split end Paul Jokisch, the first of Jokisch's career. The Wolverines were poised for another score early in the fourth quarter, but an interception by safety Rod Woodson on the two-yard line and a subsequent Purdue TD made Michigan's frantic pursuit a moot point. Zurbrugg threw touchdown passes to Triando Markray, Vince Bean and Sim Nelson in the final 4:08 of the game. The pass to Nelson came with three seconds left. THE VICTORY completed Purdue's heralded Triple Sweep. During the week, players wore t-shirts with the words "First time ever: Notre Dame, Ohio I don't know if they had a bad plane- ride or what, but they didn't have the sharpness that we had seen on film.' -Purdue Nose Guard Brad Horner State, Michigan" printed on them. This is the first time Purdue has defeated that prestigious troika in one season. Although Everett said he doesn't like to compare victories, history may have made yesterday's victory the most savory of the three. "It seems like every year they kind of ran the score up on us," said Everett, referring to 52-21 and 42-10 Wolverine victories in the past two seasons. "That hurt me. I don't like to see that from any team. So we had a lot of debts to pay." WITH ITS accounts squared up and its sweep of traditional enemies completed, Purdue is enjoying the intoxicating prospects of its bowl appearance sin ce the 1980 Liberty Bowl. For its part, Michigan faces a perilous struggle against unfamiliar mediocrity. "We just have to play together as a team for the rest of the season," said Zurbrugg. "Winning is a tradition at Michigan and it's just not right when you lose." BIG TEN STANDINGS Conference Overall Iowa ............ Ohio State...... Purdue ........ Illinois........ MICHIGAN ..... Michigan State .. Wisconsin ....... Minnesota ....... Northwestern ... Indiana......... W LT WL T 5 11 621 5 2 0 7 2 0 520 630 530 640 430 540 430 540 331 531 250 360 260 280 070 090 4 SCORES Iowa 10, Wisconsin 10 Illinois 48, Minnesota 3 Ohio St. 50,Indiana 7 Michigan St. 27, Northwestern 10 Texas 13, Texas Tech 10 Kansas 28, Colorad 27 Oklahoma 49, Missouri 7 Brigham Young 42, Texas El Paso 9 Florida 24, Auburn 3 SMU 28, Texas A&M 20 Nebraska 44, Iowa St. 0 NotreDame 18, Navy 17 South Carolina 35, N. Carolina St. 28 Georgia 13, Memphis 3 Oklahoma St. 34, Kansas 6 USC 20, Stanford 11 Washington 44, California 14 Penn St. 37, Boston College 30 Virginia 27, W. virginia 7 Blue Banter " Chris Zurbrugg's four touchdown passes ties the Michigan single-game record, set by Steve Smith against Purdue last via , " Once again turnovers were a big factor in the outcome. Michigan had two turnovers, Purdue had none. In every Miehiion anme this eaonn the team with fewer turnnvers :z: +: . y it ' : -%;:. ..k %-,