+ - - - AMW WIRIpw- mf ................... . .......... .......... ................. Who is. Guerr e The Return of Martin Guerre Starring: Gerard Depardieu, Nathalie Baye, and Roger Plachon Directed by Daniel Vigne By Malcolm Robinson TIHE RETURN OF Martin Guerre, by French director Daniel Vigne has the same easy charm and grace as a fable. The story is a true one, unem- bellished by artistic flourishes, and not a moment in the film passes that is not thoroughly permeated by the essence of 16th century France, in particular the daily routines of a French peasant' village.1 It is obvious that great care has been taken in order to make the details of this film "correct," from the costumes and the sets to the ethos of the period. Princeton University professor Natalie Davis served as historical consultant' and later wrote the book. The attention director Vigne paid to the tiniest details is what gives this decidedly middlebrow entertainment much of its appeal. Unfortunately, the problem in making this sort of film is that unless a true artist (like Rossellini) is at work, fidelity to history can often act as a blinder about a film- maker's eyes. Concern for detail can become an end rather than a means. It shouldn't be surprising then, that this is the direction in which Vigne, in his second feature film. begins to err. Vigne may not yet be an artist of either the first or second rank; he is, however, a fine enough storyteller that this flaw is not a fatal one. Instead, he makes superb use of his sense of dramatic structure in this telling of a story long studies by historians. Young Martin Guerre becomes the object of ridicule in the village when he cannot impregnate his bride, Bertran- de. Guerre manages to get his wife pregnant, but still frustrated begins to abuse her. Finally he abandons both wife and child, only to suddenly reap- pear after eight long years. Vigne, along with Jean Claude Carriere manage to give form to the broad material in Martin Guerre by structuring it around the questionable authenticity of the newly-returned Guerre. The film also explores the role of women in society Bertrande is torn between protecting the man she has fallen in love with, the returned Guerre, who in all probability is not her husband, and fullfilling her duties to her family. In the end she must side with the Guerre family and hope that the court proves that indeed the man she loves is Guerre. The film carries quite an emotional wallop due in great measure to the ac- ting of the film's three leads. Nathalie Baye is perfectly proper and demure, and like the French stage director Jean de Coras, who plays Planchot (the in- terrogator), gives a marvellously precise performance. Gerard Depar- diew gives what is certainly the finest performance I have ever seen from him as theMartin Guerrewhoshas returned. Without exaggeration his best, early scenes are some of the most miraculous bits of screen acting ever to be put to celluloid. glory Angelo's 1100 Catherine Hours: Monday-Friday, 6 a.m. -7:45 p.m Saturday, 6a.m.-3 p.m,; Sunday, 7 a.m.-2 p.m. IS THIS WHAT YOUR KISSES TASTE LIKE? If you smwke cigaret t es. y(Au t aste like r M-F8:3 No S i Raisin toast: An Angelo's favorite X f . . w.. ...._ _- ...tV TT.'W 4"f/T 7.. ' 1 V .... J', ;Z..7.L w . ..... .. ..., .....R.,... ... -. ,. e ,.. ..... .. .- r .r r r .. .- _ . r w w r s .., ... .. .. . .. a. ,o .. ,. ,.-.._....... ®.., . ,.... .. m... .. . .. . . . _ _ __ _ ~.,, '-wi