Sunday, March 25, 1973
THE MICHIGAN DAILY
ENGLISH DEPT. CASE:* 'Tracking' brews
Profs denied tenure in Ann Arbor publi
te P (Continued from Page 1) However, School Board President
Michael, however, claims most Ted Heusel says that although
students are aware that they areI there had been an attempt to stop
being "tracked," and those in the tracking in the past, the majority
(continued from Page 1) timehaving to show large amounts i be a humanities subcommittee. non-college preparatory track are of school board members now feel;
sell Fraser. "I find the criteria of publications early in one's ca- Rhodes calls the committee com- generally opposed to it. that tracking is necessary.
reasonable." reer." petent. He cites the need for an ex- A University study in 1966 ob- Aede astakn ildf-
reaonale" rer" pten. e cte th ned or n x- Uivesi yd in16ob Aberdeen says tracking will defi-
It is simply not true, he adds, LSA Dean Frank Rhodes believes ternal as well as internal review served that tracking was. strongly nitely be a campaign issue for a
"that the college cares only about scholarship and publication are of faculty work, as important in associated with dropping out of
publication aid not teaching.'' "one guarantee of the quality of tablishing a uniform standard school, with nearly nine times the
"Scholarship and teaching must teaching." the college. number of students in the lowerr
be in balance. Scholarship is gen- The LSA decision to reject the track dropping out.
erated out of teaching.Thatper- Inadditiontwo professors' tenure "requests The study also found that those
couple of candidates in the upcom-
ing school board election in June.
But he predicts that it probably
will not be called "tracking."
"It might be called 'excellence
in education' or something like
that, but it'll be there-very subtle,
but still there."
SIGN UP NO WFOR CLASS GUITAR LESSONS,
JUST $12.00 FOR A SIX-WEEK COURSE. Rentals
Also private lessons on guitar, flute, recorder, banjo,
piano, and moog.
Ann Arbor Music Mart
336 South State Street
SPECIAL! HOT CHOCOLATE
son who is a lively teacher is likely
to be an active and vigorous schol-
ar. You couldn't get someone
through here who was a bad
English Prof. Marvin Felheim
sees things very differently. He
calls the assumption ofeequal
weight a lie, and he sees an
enormous increase in the emphasis
given to publication in the last
few years. "People ought to pro-
duce all the time," he said.
But Felheim objects to the idea
that the only type of production
is publication. "There are other
areas of creativity."
In addition the problem of pro-
duction is where to publish. Ac-
cording to Felheim, most literary
journals are clogged up and are
more likely to take works by more
established writers. "The journals
are means to an end," he said.
"They are dull and nobody reads
The apparent drive for publica-
tion may be rooted in the past.
Several years ago a ranking of
English graduate schools was pub-
lished, placing Michigan approxi-
mately 17thnationally. Since then,
according to Prof. Steven Wei-
land, there has been an increased
effort to up the department's na-
tional professional standing through
publication. "The ranking is ab-
solutely ridiculous," he contends.
"Our classrooms count first. I am
much less concerned with our na-
"This was once a great depart-
ment, but it is not now," said Prof.
Daniel Fader. "At the time of pro-
motion we all become great teach-
ers. It is so easy to work at ad-
ministrating than scholarship. The
easiest one to judge is scholarship.
Scholarship is the most visible."
Hercontinues: "Teaching is ex-
aggerated. It is required of all of
us that we be good teachers. Bad
teachers should have no place in
the University, no matterahow
good their research.
"Scholarship is the one clear
piece of evidence that a man or
woman is working. Teaching can
become automatic," he added.
Publication is believed by some
to be the only way of judging a
professor's future potential. Fraser
says, "The college is being asked
to make a life time commitment.
Publishing is an indication of vi-
tality of years to come."
Fader agrees. "You want some-
thing promising for the future-
not a remark on the past," he
However W e ia n d disagrees.j
"One can demonstrate scholarly
attributes without at the same
Do You REALLY Want To Go To
Let us help you gain admission
Livonia, Mich. 48152 I
of who is quaiiied to judge a pro-
fessor's publication. Is it up to the
individual department members to
judge each other's work, or should
the decision be up to LSA?
Weiland charges "the dean is
suggesting we are not fit to evalu-
ate our own people."
Fraser defends the college. "I
think it is proper for the LSA
Executive Committee to act as a
check. What the majority of the
of English Executive Committee
wants is not always best for the
department,' 'he says.
Felheim questions the compe-
tence of those on the LSA commit-
tee. "What does the executive
committe know about the problems
of the field?"
According to Rhodes, all tenure
recommendations are reviewed 'by
an LSA executive subcommittee
from that department's area. For
the English department this would
was also based on a difference of
opinion about unpublished manu-
In general, according to Rhodes,
the college p r e f e r s published
works. "Getting a book published
says something about its quality,"
he comments. "Theereviews re-
ceived also indicate something
about the quality. We prefer print-
ed material, but will on occasion
look at manuscripts."
The English department commit-
tee hadnapproved the unpublished
work of one of the professors.
"Mere publication is not always
a sign of quality," Weiland says.
"It is an acknowledged joke of how
much junk there is in our field."
In addition, there is a time ele-
ment involved. A person shouldn't
be spited because his work is only
a year or two away from publica-
tion, he adds.
pupils from working-class homesj
are far more likely to be in the
general curriculum than those
from middle-class homes.
And grading standards in the
college-oriented curriculum tend to
become more lenient than in the
Human relations ombudsman Dr.
Robert Potts submittedaa proposal
in 1971 asking the Board of Edu-
cation to abolish the system of
tracking in Ann Arbor schools, but
it was set aside for "further
It still has not been acted on, but
some administrators continue to
believe tracking is prohibited.
THE GRADUATE STUDENT COLLOQUIUM
ANNOUNCES A LECTURE BY
PROFESSOR WARD BISSELL,
Caravaggio and the
Spanish Baroque Masters
March 26, 8:00 p.m., MLB, Room 4310
LOTS OF PEOPLE
Room, 4th Floor
LOTS OF FOOD
Beautiful Hand Embroidered Blouses, Dresses, t
Jackets and Shawls, Alabaster and Copper Works,
Handmade Jewelry, Rugs, Puzzle Rings.
VERY REASONABLE PRICES
Turkish Arts & Gifts, Imports
215 E. Liberty 10 A.M.-6 P.M. 761-5554
>(O C <- !tIO<-YV<>.<-y O G7<-- > t<--yoO w
THE WALGREEN CONFERENCE ON
The University of Michigan Michifish
VISIONS OF FUTURE PASSED
Annual U of M Synchronized Swimming Show
MARCH 29, 30, 31
WEDNESDAY, APRIL 4-3:00 P.M.-Hill Auditorium
"ARE WE FREE TO HAVE A FUTURE?"
DR. B. F. SKINNER
Presenter-DR. EDWARD WALKER, Professor of Psychology
Critic-DR. JAMES McCONNELL, Psychologist and Professor of Psychology
WEDNESDAY, APRIL 4-8:00 P.M.-Rackham Lecture Hall
"POPULATION DYNAMICS AND
DR. NAZLI CHOUCRI
Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Department of Political Science
Presenter-DR. DONALD STOKES, Dean of Rackham School of Graduate Studies and
Professor of Political Science
Critic-DR. A.F.K. ORGANSKI, Professor of Political Science
MARGARET BELL POOL
Tickets at the Margaret Bell Pool
. _ _ 1
THURSDAY, APRIL 5-3:00 P.M.-Rackham Amphitheater
"THE BELIEFS THAT CAN LINK MEN TOGETHER"
DR. JOHN PLATT
The University of Michigan, Mental Health Research Institute
Presenter--DR. ALFRED SUSSMAN, Associate Dean of Rackham School of Graduate Studies and
Professor of Botany
Critic-DR. CHARLES TILLY, Professor of Sociology and History
THURSDAY, APRIL 5-8:00 P.M.-Rackham Lecture Hall
"THE QUALITIES OF THE HUMAN MIND"
(DO YOURSELF A FAVOR)
A portion of BAITS HOUSING and SOUTH QUADRANGLE will be open for
occupancy during the Spring-Summer Term. Applications will be accepted
in the Housing Information Office, 1011 Student Activities Building, in
(ROOM AND BOARD) (
SINGLE, DOUBLE OR TRIPLE SUITES
May 6-Aug. 28)
(May 6-June 30)
(July 4-Aug. 28)
World Health Organization
Presenter-DR. MYRON WEGMAN, Dean of School of Pub!ic Health and Professor of Public Health
Critic-DR. GARDNER QUARTON, Professor of Psychiatry
FRIDAY, APRIL 6-1:30 P.M.-Rackham Lecture Hall
"UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN STUDENTS AND
TEACHERS: SCIENTIFIC AND 'HUMAN' VALUES"
rt n -r -r- n n e in --- n oAn
Several FRATERNITIES and SORORITIES will be open for occupancy during
the Spring-Summer Terms. Accommodations available include:
Co-ed, male or female residences