22 | MAY 16 • 2024 J N O verall, University of Michigan graduates and family members of the class of 2024 were joyful that their com- mencement ceremonies actually hap- pened. After all, graduation ceremo- nies were canceled at Columbia and USC because of anti-Israel protests. This was the class who had their senior year of high school abruptly halted, their prom and graduation ceremonies a casualty to the COVID pandemic. Still, after the disruption on March 25 of pro-Palestinian pro- testers which brought the honors Convocation Ceremony at the Hill U-M Graduation Disrupted Pro-Palestinian protesters drown out speakers for many attendees. STACY GITTLEMAN CONTRIBUTING WRITER OUR COMMUNITY Zach Goldstein of Florida holds up an Israeli flag. Salma Hamamy carries a Palestinian flag during a pro-Palestinian protest during the University of Michigan’s commencement ceremony on May 4. Benny Shevsky was sitting near the pro-Palestinian protesters. NIC ANTAYA/GETTY IMAGES/JTA