viewpoints » S end letters to: letters@thejewishnews.com

Nutritionally
Speaking

By Barbara Beznos, RD/LD/N
Integrated Nutrition, LLC

for openers

DEAR BARB,

Orchestrate Your Speech

Can you tell me
what to do with
my child of 6
years old, who
needs to lose
weight? How do

M

usic is well said to
this person never hesitates to
be the speech of
pipe up.
angels,” according
You are aware that as par-
to Thomas Carlyle, Scottish
ents we try to drum into our
historian and writer. Though
offspring the proper way to do
many of us fall a bit short of
things. Of course, we have to
the angelic, there is, no doubt,
work to snare their attention.
a lot of music in our everyday
I do not want to toot my own
Sy Manello
speech.
horn,
but I am often eager to
Editorial Assistant
How “instrumental” are
trumpet the news when some-
you in contributing to this?
thing good happens to someone
Consider, if you will, the following refer- somewhere. I try not to harp on it.
ences.
Though, heaven knows, good news is
The voice itself is a beautiful instru-
often hard to come by these days.
ment. Sometimes, however, you will be
Have you ever been tempted to fiddle
aware of a certain pitch or timbre that
around with a project? Doing something
makes you believe the speaker has hit a
different is a good way to keep your
sour note. Someone whose voice grates
interest in what is going on; it keeps one
really has brass to speak up publicly.
vibrant. When talking with others, be
Being unaware of the sounds produced,
sure to chime in with your latest accom-

plishments — not bragging, of course.
When seeking new adventures, try
whatever rings your bell. Be wary,
though of new purchases that are costly
because of all the bells and whistles
attached.
If I were given to the use of puns —
(what?) — I might offer this: At work,
if you were to issue to the personnel a
brief memo, then it might be said that
you gave the staff a half-note. (Oh, stop
that groaning and compose yourself!)
When it comes to conversation, never
be afraid to play along. What you learn
may be music to your ears.

*

guest column

Jews And The Left Reconsidered

O

n Sept. 12, the New York Times
Communist Party of Poland in 1930, for
published an op-ed piece by
example. In addition to participating in
Dr. Dave Rich, an associate
general leftist movements, Jews organized
research fellow of the Pears Institute
a number of explicitly Jewish socialist par-
for the Study of Anti-Semitism. Dr.
ties before the Second World War.
Rich’s op-ed describes notable changes
Why were so many Jews sympathetic
in the voting behavior of British Jewry
to left-wing causes at an earlier point in
in recent decades and quotes
history? Explanations revolv-
from an analysis written by the
ing around the purported racial
British historian Dr. Geoffrey
characteristics of Jews, the impact
Alderman:
of Jewish religious ideas and the
“Anglo-Jewish political atti-
marginality of the Jewish popula-
tudes and loyalties, which were
tion have been expounded by
substantially Liberal for much of
prominent scholars. However,
the 19th century and substan-
there is reason to question both of
tially Labour in the mid-20th,”
the first two of these explanations.
Jack Jacobs
Dr. Alderman noted, “are now
The notion that Jews are a race
substantially Conservative.”
has long since been discredited by
The tendency mentioned by Drs. Rich
reputable social scientists. The idea that
and Alderman is part and parcel of a
Judaism per se is intrinsically progressive
broader trend. Jewish political opinion
is not tenable. Jewish religious beliefs can
has shifted away from the left not only
and have led some to deeply conservative
in Great Britain, but also in major Jewish
political positions. But explanations for the
communities around the world.
one-time link between Jews and the left
Jews played highly visible roles, over
revolving around marginality have a great
an extended period of time, in the leader-
deal of merit. Jews were regularly marginal
ship of socialist, communist and anarchist to the societies in which they lived when
organizations. Rosa Luxemburg and
the left came into being and in the era
Ferdinand Lassalle, Leon Trotsky and
during which it developed. The rejection
Pavel Axelrod, Alexander Berkman and
of Jews by mainstream society contributed
Emma Goldman were all Jewish.
to their sense that a dramatic change was
In the first half of the 20th century,
both desirable and necessary.
significant numbers of Jews were also
However, the Jewish socialist parties
evident in the rank-and-file of specific
that had been active in the Russian Empire
left-wing political parties. Jews constituted did not long survive the Bolshevik consoli-
some 35 percent of the membership of the dation of power in the U.S.S.R. And most

of the Jews sympathetic to the non-Jewish
leftist parties of Central and Eastern
Europe, or to the Jewish socialist move-
ments in those lands, suffered the same
fate as did the rest of the Jewish popula-
tion during the Second World War. The
bulk of the European Jewish leftists who
remained in Nazi-occupied Europe during
the War died or were murdered during the
course of that conflict.
The arc of Jewish ties to the left in the
United States was ultimately parallel to
that in Europe — though the reasons for
the decline of these ties were, I hasten to
add, markedly different. In 1979, Professor
Arthur Liebman wrote in Jews and the
Left that the economic and geographic
mobility of American Jewry had led to a
“socioeconomic metamorphosis,” which
“could not but be damaging to the Jews’
commitment to socialism.”
The trends described by Liebman have
continued and help to explain the continu-
ing decline in ties between American Jews
and the left.
In the 21st century, leftist anti-Zionism
and other factors have also contributed
to further reductions of support for leftist
causes within American Jewry.
To be sure: American Jewry is more
liberal than many other American ethnic
groups. American Jewry is, however, not
currently identified with the American
political left, but rather with mainstream
American political institutions and ideas.
More American Jews were supportive of

continued on page 6

I approach this?

Thanks, Ruthie

I have some solutions
of Guidelines for Parents

‡ Provide your child with lots of love
and attention. Don’t pressure your
child to lose weight.
‡ Have regular meals and snacks.
Try to discourage eating at other
times.
‡ Let your child decide how much to
eat. Don’t limit the amount of food
a child can eat, or make a child clean
the plate.
‡ Serve the same healthy food to all
family members. Don’t put your
child on a special low calorie diet.
‡ Have appealing snack foods
available…like popcorn, frozen
fruit juice bars, string cheese, and
frozen low-fat yogurt. Don’t have
lots of high fat snack foods like chips,
cake, pie, ice cream, cupcakes and
doughnuts.
‡ Expect your child to grow into his/
her weight. Don’t expect your child
to lose weight.
‡ Encourage your child to be more
active by playing with toys like balls,
Frisbees, jump ropes, and bicycles,
by joining a sports team, by taking
gymnastics, swimming, tennis or
other lessons, by walking the family
dog, or by joining a 4-H club, Girl
Scout, or Boy Scout troop…don’t
let your child spend a lot of time
watching TV or playing video games.
‡ Go on family outings that include
hiking, swimming, and going to parks
and playgrounds where everyone can
play actively. Don’t let your family
become “couch potatoes”!

Contact Barb At:

Integrated Nutrition, L.L.C.

31731 Northwestern Hwy., Suite 105 E
Farmington Hills, Mi 48334

Phone:
(248) 538-8050

E-Mail:
rds@integratednutrition.com
Web:
www.integratednutrition.com

2097330

November 24 • 2016

5