100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

November 09, 2006 - Image 42

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 2006-11-09

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

8

g-
k 621e/itt

T o Li fe

!

TORAH PORTION

Ace—Jah

An Upscale Fur Extravaganza

Designer Furs & Coats Up to 75% Off Retail

Thursday
November 16, 2006
7:30 p.m.

$7.5 per person $140 couple

afotts cDtuevites, clAhRe, Tatth

Complimentary Gift Bag

$225 value

• %itt geGt/tUeS • gu/t LAbliS •

• Tectuty Thoducts • deweetty •

• Cigak g Cigars Cutters •
• (Discount Lhlettellandise Coupon •

Luxury items available
for him and her

HUMIDORS, CIGARS
& ACCESSORIES

OPEN TO THE PUBLIC
Friday - Sunday
NOVEMBER 17, 18 & 19
3Pm - 8Pm • FREE ADMISSION

Sponsored by:

Brought to you by:
Michael Milano Furs and To the Finest Detail Events
11111011For tickets call Joanne Shango 248.730.39591Mat

Shenandoah Country Club • 5600 Walnut Lake Road • West Bloomfield, MI 48323

noun
an object of irrational reverence'
or obsessive devotion
Some seek therapy.
Others choose
W- Home.

The world of sophisticated home accents at your feet.

2294i Woodward Avenue Ferndale, MI 482.zo Phone: 248- 544-3944

RICHARD ROSS DESIGNS studio on site.
Hours: M—F 10-6; SAT J.-4. Also by appointment.

42

November 9 • 2006

Ai

What Is God Telling Us?

Shabbat Vayera:
Genesis 18:1-22:24;
11 Kings 4:1 37.

T

-

his week's Torah portion
three "strangers" (as well as the "angel"
contains events that raise the
who wrestles with Jacob (Genesis
important questions as to how
32:24-31) and the "angel" who con-
one is to understand the narratives in
fronts Bilaam and his "talking donkey"
the Torah.
(Numbers 22:20-38) as taking place
We are presented by the classical
in prophetic visions and not "actual"
commentaries, chief
events.
among them Rashi
After all, our portion
(France, 1040-1105), with
tells us (18:1): "And the
a variety of ways to under-
Lord appeared to him
stand the narrative verses
and then interrupts with
of the Torah. Each one
the visit of the "strang-
has his particular point
ers." Maimonides says
of view in general and his
there is no interruption:
own personal interpreta-
The story of the visit of
tion of any given verse.
the strangers is the "way"
But they often disagree.
in which God appeared
We are free to respectfully
Rabbi E liezer
to Abraham. Actually,
accept or reject each inter-
Coh en
it is clear to me that
pretation: Our responsibil-
Special to the
the term usually trans-
ity is to try to find what
Jewish News
lated as "angel" (maloch)
God is trying to tell us
— which literally means
through His Torah.
cagent," is rather used in the Torah to
Thus the Torah, as the eternal source
describe how God manifests Himself
of authentic Judaism, must of necessity
when communicating to human beings.
be interpreted in different ways to be
Thus, God manifested Himself
meaningful and to communicate to dif- and communicates to Hagar and to
ferent generations in different circum-
Abraham at the end of our portion; and
stances. The halachic (legal) parts of
this manifestation is called maloch.
the Torah are, of course, subject to the
Similarly at the burning bush
traditional legal system of derivation
(Exodus 3:2) God communicates to
and application of Jewish law through
Moses through the bush, which is called
the Mishnah, Talmud and qualified
maloch. Invariably, whenever the term
halachic decisors — but the narratives
is used throughout the Torah, the verse
may be interpreted more freely.
refers to God and the maloch as if they
In our day and age, it behooves us
were the same (as in fact they are, from
to find interpretations of the Torah
our human perspective in my interpre-
that are consistent with our scientific
tation) and not separate entities.
knowledge of reality and our con-
Do angels really exist? Who knows?
temporary point of view. The por-
But you can't prove it from the Torah. II
tion, according to Rashi and others,
begins with the "three angels" visiting
Eliezer Cohen is rabbi of Congregation Or
Abraham, with two of them destroying
Chadash in Oak Park.
Sodom (Genesis 18:1 -19:26). Likewise,
an "angel" appears to Hagar (21:17)
Conversations
to help her and her son. And finally
Why would anyone believe in
(22:15), an "angel" calls to Abraham to
the existence of angels? If the
stop him from sacrificing his son, Isaac.
Torah is God's word and eter-
It seems to me that to insist that these
nally valid, how can it be limited
events took place through the agency
by
human interpretation? Why
of "angels" is to limit the divine, eternal
must
there be a different way
TOrah to the fantastic medieval view of
to
interpret
and apply the legal
reality that may seem like superstition.
(halachic)
parts
of the Torah to
But there are alternate interpretations
conform
to
the
traditional
legal
even among the classical Jewish com-
system
of
Halachah,
in
order
to
mentaries. Maimonides (Spain-Egypt,
be
authentic
Judaism?
1135 1204) interprets the visit of the

,

-

Back to Top

© 2021 Regents of the University of Michigan