Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options


Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

January 02, 2004 - Image 11

Resource type:
The Detroit Jewish News, 2004-01-02

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

Question Of Black And White

Reality Check

ne of last
that came
and went in a rush
was The Human
It was about an
college professor
passing as a Jew.
(And he thought he
had problems

The movie received lukewarm
reviews, but some commentators
were especially critical of the casting.
The lead was played by Welsh-born
Anthony Hopkins.
Why, they demanded, was a light-
skinned black actor not hired for
the part?
I noticed that none of
these articles suggested the
name of such an actor
who could have carried
the lead in this demand-
ing role. Moreover,
Hopkins is an Oscar-
winner whose name on
the marquee will sell
some tickets. Oh, maybe
not as many as the
supremely gifted Eminem
but a goodly number, nonethe-
So the revelation. that Hopkins'
character is actually a black man car-
ried that much more of a dramatic
impact. Here is a very well-known
actor and it turns out that he con-
ceivably could be passing.
The whole thrust of the film was
the ambiguity of racial classifications
in America. I am sure there are many
instances we never will know about
in which the black-Jewish boundary
was breached, as it could be with
most Mediterranean people.
The movie has been gone for a few
months but it came to mind again in
the stories about the late Sen. Strom
Thurmond's daughter.
Thurmond was, of course, a noto-
rious racist in the first part of his
political career. After South
Carolina's blacks got the vote, how-
ever, he suddenly saw-the light and
became a great friend of the African

George Cantor can be reached via e-
mail at gcantor@thejewishnews.com

American. Whatever.
The incredible irony of this man
fathering a. child with a black woman
while spewing hatred for her race is,
of course, inescapable. Many colum-
nists felt moved to chastise the
woman, though, because she hadn't
spoken up years before.
Their reasoning is that such expo-
sure would have ended Thurmond's
career long ago and limited some of
the damage he did back then.
But not everyone wants to live
their life as a symbol. The demand
for racial justice is an honorable one,
but if she had stepped forward 50
years ago this woman would have
been shaped by her story for the rest
of her life.
Besides, this was her father and,
apparently, he always treated her
well. I can't pretend to
understand the con-
flicting currents that
she must have felt
as she grew up —
the duties of a
daughter weighted
against the chance
to shatter an icon
of Jim Crow.
In the end, she
chose to be a daughter.
I could never second-
guess a decision like that.
In my career, I have
known several Jewish
journalists and media stars who
chose to change their names and
keep their ethnicity a deeply private
matter. They were mostly people
who began their careers in the late
1940s or early '50s when it was not
easy being a Jew in this market.
They didn't want to fight that
fight. They had no interest in being
anyone's symbol. The mass audience
never gave a second thought to their
identity and they were happier that
And that's how it should be. The
hardened lines of race and religion
are far too intrusive in American life.
By government directive, we are told
that we must classify ourselves that
way for purposes of education and
If we are ever to reach the just
society, that is, surely, one of the
things that must change. Cling tena-
ciously to our identity in private and
make it nobody's business but our
own. H

Besides the highest rates
available, we're also offering
a Free Gift during our...

Check out these deals today!

*Annual Percentage Rate is effective as of November 21, 2003.
The interest rate 61 3% is compounded quarter1 Penalty for
early withdrawal. Business or brokered accounts not eligible.
Rates subject to change without notice.

21211 Haggerty Rd.
North of 8 Mile
(888) 437-8243

1917 East Big Beaver
At John R Rd.
(248) 619-0264

Farmington Hills
28300 Orchard Lake Rd.
Suite 101
(800) 914-3524

1/ 2


Back to Top

© 2021 Regents of the University of Michigan