Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options


Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

October 24, 2003 - Image 26

Resource type:
The Detroit Jewish News, 2003-10-24

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.


Home is where
your heart and
Inners-Lyle can be

QA Wm VorftW ,WrA s.

Some in today and experience

the latest products in the

pretniere Innerstyle Collection

of Custom Vertical Blinds from

Hunter Douglas. The new styles,

Abortion Battle

colors and patterns perfectly

reflect today's home fashion trends

and are all within your reach.

Welcome home to Hunter Douglas.



Jewish groups on both sides as Congress moves
against partial-birth abortion.

window fashions

Free In-Home Service • Free Professional Measure At No Obligation

(wiiu, quahog I

visit our website



Call today for a free
in-home presentation

Southfield • 248-352-8622
Canton • 734-692-5002

21728 W. Eleven Mile Rd. • Harvard Row Mall • Southfield, MI 48076



Enjoy the convenience of
Fresh Gourmet Meals
delivered to your doorstep daily!

Get In The ZONE Now!


Lose Weight, Feel Great!


Dieting has never•tasted so good!

Temple Beth El's
Loren B. Fischer Cultural Arts Series for
Children and Their Families

proudly presents


accompanied by
The Good Mischief Band

in a fabulous family concert
featuring sing-alongs, folk tales &
hand motion tunes

Sunday, November 2
12:30 PM
Temple Beth El

7400 Telegraph Road at 14 Mile Road





"If the Pied Piper had been
twins, odds are he would
have been Gemini."

The Detroit News


Jewish Telegraphic Agency

ewish groups are closely
monitoring progress on a
new late-term abortion bill
that could become law by
the end of the week.
The bill, which outlaws a specific
procedure technically known as intact
dilation and evacuation, is opposed
by a majority of Jewish organizations.
They say it criminalizes a medical
At least one Orthodox group sup-
ports the bill, known as the Partial-
Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003,
arguing that the procedure may be a
form of infanticide.
The issue for the Jewish communi-
ty centers around different interpreta-
tions of Halachah, or Jewish law, and
whether the mother's health is more
important than the life of a fetus.
Both sides are gearing up for what
they believe will be a long court bat-
The U.S. Senate passed the ban
Tuesday, Oct. 21, 64-34, three weeks
after the House of Representatives
passed the same act 281 142.
President Bush supports the bill and
is expected to sign the legislation into
law. President Clinton vetoed similar
legislation twice.
The measure would be the first
restricting abortion to become federal
law since the U.S. Supreme Court
ruled on Roe v. Wade in 1973. In a
so-called "partial-birth abortion," the
fetus is partially delivered and then a
doctor punctures its skull. The proce-
dure is generally carried out relatively
late in a pregnancy.
Under the new law, doctors who
perform the procedure could be fined
and jailed for up to two years.
Abortion opponents argue that
fetuses that are inches away from
being born should be protected.
"The gruesome and inhumane
nature of the partial-birth abortion
procedure and its disturbing similari-
ty to the killing of a newborn infant
promotes a complete disregard for
infant human life that can only be



countered by a prohibition of the
procedure," the legislation says.
Supporters of abortion rights say
the procedure is necessary in
instances when the mother's health is
at stake. While the legislation does
exempt doctors who perform the pro-
cedure to save the mother's life, many
Jewish groups want that provision
widened to protect a mother's physi-
cal and mental health. But supporters
of the ban say there is no evidence of
the procedure being used to protect a
mother's health.
Lawmakers say they have gathered
information that shows that the pro-
cedure is never used to preserve the
health of a woman, that it even poses
significant risks to the mother and is
outside the standard of medical care.
Abortion-rights advocates counter
that the bill is vague and could have
a chilling effect on doctors who per-
form other types of abortions.
"The language is so murky that
you can't be sure it only covers these
late-term abortions," said Lois
Waldman, director of the commis-
sion on women's equality of the
American Jewish Congress.

When Is Birth?

But one Orthodox group argues that
a more narrow interpretation of
abortion law is warranted.
"The larger question on abortion,
which is a very fair question, is: Do
we need to have a law that provides
a blanket right?" said Rabbi David
Zwiebel, executive vice president for
government and public affairs at
Agudath Israel of America. "The
notion that fetal life deserves no pro-
tection is wrong."
Jewish groups on both sides of the
issue are relying on different inter-
pretations of Halachah to support
their arguments. Reform leaders cite
laws indicating that the life of the
mother is paramount and has a high-
er value than the "potential life" of
the fetus.
"In Jewish law, we are commanded
to take care of our health and the
well-being of our bodies," said
Barbara Weinstein, legislative direc-
tor for the Religious Action Center

Back to Top

© 2021 Regents of the University of Michigan