100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

July 04, 2003 - Image 21

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 2003-07-04

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

inion

Editorials are posted and archived on JN Online:

www.detroitjewishnews.com

Still In The Dark

Dry Bones
sosH 91 r
TN ARE
11ROGNI
ADMIN1IS-

he U.S. Supreme Court last week pro-
vided a terribly disappointing decision
on affirmative action, one that ratifies
the status quo, but does almost nothing
to resolve the larger question of how America is
to deal with the persistent educational inequality
plaguing blacks in our society.
Writing for a 5-4 majority, Justice Sandra Day
O'Connor enunciated a principle that American
Jews would overwhelmingly endorse: "Effective
participation by members of all racial and ethnic
groups in the civic life of our nation is essential if
the dream of one nation, indivisible, is to be real-
ized."
But then, the court failed to provide
any consistent rationale beyond expedi-
ency for upholding the constitutionality
of the affirmative action program that
the University of Michigan law school says it fol-
lows in deciding which applicants to admit. (The
court rightly and unsurprisingly invalidated the
university's undergraduate affirmative action
admission process, with its mindless blanket of
extra points to all minority applicants.)
At the same time that it decried governmental
action that either blesses or burdens individuals
on the basis of race alone, the court said the law
school could decide it had a compelling interest
in a diverse student body and, thus, could give
bonus points to be sure it reached a "critical
mass" of blacks, Hispanics and Native Americans.
It said the process was acceptable, now, but might
not be 25 years from now.
"Racial classifications, however compelling their
goals," O'Connor wrote, "are potentially so dan-
gerous that they may be employed no more
broadly than the interest demands. Enshrining a
permanent justification for racial preferences
would offend this fundamental equal protection

principle. We see no reason to
exempt race-conscious admissions
programs from the requirement that
all governmental use of race must
have a logical endpoint."
In short, the court cut intellectual
corners to find that a desirable end
can be sought by means that are so
fundamentally unfair that they can-
not be allowed to stand a generation
from now.
The four dissenters provided much
the more rigorous and principled
critique of the admission process
and results. They faulted
the law school's vague defi-
nition of what constitutes a
"critical mass" of minorities
F
— 100 blacks versus three Native
Americans, for example. And they
pointed out that the school's eager-
ness to accept minorities in almost
exactly the same proportion as it got
minority applicants led the admis-
sion's officers to base their actions
on the numbers rather than on each
individual's potential to bring some-
thing special to the new class.
In a notably lucid dissent, Justice
Clarence Thomas, the only black on
"tick.
the court, said the court could have
Ti Clc
compelled the law school to change
TICK
--ri C
its admission policies, just as it did
five years earlier when it forced
Virginia Military Institute to open
its doors to women.
Many American Jews have worked hard over
the years to help repair the stain of racism that
soils the national conscience. They are going to

A Daunting Thirst

That's a worthy pursuit. So is the reversal of
increasing apathy among students.
U.S. campuses serve about 400,000 Jewish stu-
dents; most feel assimilation's tug no matter how
hard they try to resist it.
Rabbi J, assisted by Rabbi Aaron Eisemann, does-
n't push one religious stream over another. But he
does strive to make our holidays, culture, teachings
and ideals resonate for students and parents alike.
For every Jewish success story on campus —
thanks to Machon, Hillel, Chabad, Ohr
Sameach, Aish HaTorah and other Jewish
outreach groups — other stories bubble
up that aren't so upbeat.
"We can do more," Rabbi J said in keynoting
Machon's 23rd annual dinner last week in Southfield.
Indeed, we can.
We can do something as simple as building
bridges of understanding to this next tier of Jewish
leaders. We can show these young adults what it
means to live as a Jew. We can help them conquer
doubts and fears. We can encourage them to do

AT
AGREES
ISRAEL si-touul)
"'TAKE our"
TERRORISTS

EDIT OKIAL

generation of Jewish college students is
thirsting for spiritual nourishment. It's
incumbent we step up as a community
and quench that thirst. At stake is the
seamless passage of Judaism from one generation to
the next.
So says Rabbi Avraham Jacobovitz, the outspoken,
tireless founder and director of Machon
L'Torah-The Jewish Learning Network of
Michigan.
"I see a tragedy in front of my eyes," he says.
And he has a front-row seat. Machon reaches out
to Jewish students, whatever their religious upbring-
ing, on several state campuses.
Detroit Jewry would be foolish to ignore the plea
of the popular rabbi. Rabbi J, as students call him,
yearns for our history, heritage and traditions, and
unconditional support for Israel, overwhelming the
lures of materialism, gossip and lifestyle fads.

A

I oM g S "

Ti c tc-

Ti

710
7+-

tsu- r.
PRoethm

ts

OVER

WASH D.C.

EDIT ORIAL

"TICK

vl

be disappointed that the nation's highest court
has so badly failed to provide principled guidance
on making our graduate schools open to all citi-
zens in ways that all would recognize as just. ❑

Jewish things and embrace Jewish values. We can
challenge them to learn at their own pace.
Beyond that, we can teach them to have "a good
eye" — to see the good in everything, even if it is
hidden under layers of wrong. As Machon teaches,
perspective does matter. ❑

The Exodus Of Uris

L

eon Uris helped a whole generation of
Americans understand the founding of
modern Israel. His powerful novel Exodus
was for the 1960s and
1970s what Schindler's List
was for that generation's chil-
dren. The author, who died
two weeks ago, provided a stunning account of
what it means to say "Never Again." Friends of
Israel are forever in his debt. ❑

EDITORIAL

7/ 4
2003

21

Back to Top

© 2020 Regents of the University of Michigan