100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

February 02, 2001 - Image 18

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 2001-02-02

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

This Week

Songs For Sopranos

Women rabbis celebrate 16 years
of Conservative ordination.

JULIE WIENER
Jewish Telegraphic Agency

Click on our new website. Now you can
• Check Availability
• Book Your Date
• And Sneak A Preview

TONE-e Creative Video's
New Location i Convienently. Located
at Star TraxdEvent Productions
24463 Ten Mile Rd Southfield 48034
(248) 223-9300
, if*
icitlitak".

Since
1986

STEVEN TARNOW, C.R.

(248)
626-5603

PREFERRED

BUILDING CO.

Fax

Building Quality Into Every Project With Unmatched Personal Service.

Featuring Andersen Windows

Licensed fic Insured

INF REMOOF LNG INDUSIRT

IS NOW A

PARTNER

NORTHWEST

AIRLINES

.
Mi lesAbove-

Now you can get a great deal
on top-of-the-line Carrier 90 Plus
Heating Equipment and save
on your utility bills all year!

MVP

.A74

-':-

(248) 335-4555

• arrier

CUSTOM NAME INDOOR WaTilel -

www.sunheating.com

Earn Northwest Airlines WorldPerks® MilesAbove' .Bonus Miles.

2/2
2001

18

S

248-932-0950

Residential & Commercial Remodeling

NARK

New York
treaming down the hallway
from the Jewish Theological
Seminary cafeteria Sunday
night came an unusual
sound: 100 female voices, undisturbed
by tenor or bass, joyously singing the
blessing after meals.
Not only did all the voices belong to
women, but almost all belonged to
rabbis or rabbinical students.
It was a significant moment in a
Conservative movement where women
comprise less than 10 percent of the
rabbinical pool, and where the deci-
sion to ordain women 16 years ago
came only after long and divisive
debate.
Gathered from around the United
States and Israel, the rabbis were cele-
brating their growing numbers — now
more than 120 -- and the influence
they believe they are having on the
movement.
"You have to know that your pres-
ence has transformed the Jewish
world," Francine Klagsbrun said in a
keynote address. Klagsbrun, a writer,
was one of the members of the 1985
commission that recommended female
ordination.

H.A. SUN HEATING AND AIR CONDITIONING CO

Northwest Airlines WorldPerks• Bonus Miles will be awarded in the form of MilesAbove° mileage. You must be a member of the
Northwest Airlines WorldPerks program to redeem miles earned through MilesAbove. Additional restrictions apply.

Witness Question

The two-day conference, which was for
women only and was mostly closed to
the press, combined study of Jewish
texts, workshops on "nurturing our-
selves" as individuals and spiritual lead-
ers, and lively dancing to the music of
Mikveh, a female klezmer band.
In the hallways, participants talked
of their victories and ongoing chal- •
lenges and swapped news about their
children.
One of the highest remaining barri-
ers they face is the Conservative move-
ment's refusal to recognize women as
witnesses in marriage, conversion or
divorce.
That issue, which was not on the
conference agenda but was discussed in
the halls, is currently under discussion
by the movement's law committee.
It appears to be widely flouted by
women rabbis.

Several women at the conference
said they already serve as witnesses,
which does not pose a problem for
their communities. Others said they
hope the law committee will rule in
their favor.
The witness question was one of
several raised informally in signs post-
ed on a pillar in the lobby, with
answers scrawled in crayon.
Most respondents wrote that they
serve as witnesses, but make sure to
inform their congregants of the
"implications" — the fact that some
people may not recognize a ceremony
with female witnesses as valid.
Among other questions on the pil-
lar: "Does your spouse play a
rebbetzin" — using the word for a
rabbi's wife -- "role in your profes-
i onal life?" (Answers ranged from
"Heck no," to "They sent me home so
he could build the sukkah"); "What
stereotypes have you encountered?"
("Young, cute, sexy;" "The best part of
having you for a rabbi is I get to kiss
you"); "Why/why not do you wear a
yarmulke and tefillin?"
Many congregations remain appre-
hensive about hiring women rabbis,
and balancing a perpetually on-call
career with family life is difficult.
Rabbi Avis Miller, of Adas Israel
Congregation in Washington D.C.,
said women rabbis may ultimately per-
suade synagogues to treat them like
doctors who have practices.
Instead of expecting each rabbi to be
available around the clock, she said,
synagogues with more than one rabbi
may simply ensure that one rabbi is on
call at all times, freeing others to
spend time with their families.

Times Change

Those rabbis around long enough to
remember the last conference corn-
memorating Conservative women rab-
bis — in 1995 — said the mood has
changed markedly in just six years.
At that 10th anniversary of female
ordination, said Rabbi Debra
Newman Kamin of Am Yisrael
Conservative Congregation in subur-
ban Chicago, the debate over whether
or not to ordain women was revisited

SOPRANOS

on page 24

Back to Top

© 2025 Regents of the University of Michigan