100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

January 05, 2001 - Image 19

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 2001-01-05

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

Specializing in
Alzheimer s and the
Physically Frail

kind of Israeli interpretation before,"
he notes.
Shikaki says Arafat will not compro-
mise on the Temple Mount, which the
Arabs call Haram al-Sharif; he must
have full sovereignty, again, chiefly out
of fear that if he agreed to share sover-
eignty, Israel would stake its claim of
sovereignty in a way that would
impinge on the Palestinians' claim.
This is why a compromise suggested
for the Temple Mount -- that the
Palestinians rule over the surface
(Haram al-Sharif) while the Israelis
gain sovereignty over what's under-
neath (referred to in Clinton's bridging
proposals as the Jewish "holy of
holies") — is unnacceptable to Arafat,
says Shikaki.
Even though Israel's share of sover-
eignty on the Temple Mount would be
symbolic only, because the bridging
proposals bar them from excavating,
leaving them with nowhere to go and
nothing to do under the Mount, the
Palestinians fear that Israel would use
its sovereign status to excavate the
Mount as a provocation with the
intent of conquering Haram al-Sharif,
he explained.
Asked if the Palestinian position
didn't grow out of their belief that no
ancient Jewish temples ever actually
stood on the Temple Mount, and that
this was an invention aimed at grab-
bing Haram
H ram al-Sharif from the
Moslems, Shikaki said underlying atti-
tudes weren't important at this late
stage, only political practicalities.

Refugee Rights

As for the right of 3.7 million
Palestinians to return to Israel if they
choose, Shikaki said Arafat will not
give up the "right," but he will con-
cede nearly all of the actual "return."
In other words, Israel must agree
that each of the refugees has the right
to apply for resettlement in Israel, but
Israel would retain the right to accept
them or nor. In reality, Shikaki
believes that only "some tens of thou-
sands" of refugees would choose to go
back to Israel, and Israel would be
compelled to accept them.
If millions wanted to return, Israel
would not be bound to accept them,
but would be required to put them on
a "waiting list" to show good faith.
Regarding Israel's key demand —
that Arafat and the Palestinians pub-
licly declared an "end to the conflict,"
with no more outstanding claims —
this would only come once Israel ful-
filled its commitments on territorial
withdrawals. Israel is saying that it

would want to maintain a presence in
the Jordan Valley for six years. "In that
case, the declaration of end of conflict
would come after six years," Shikaki
says.
Shikaki and Klein agree on the
terms of a deal that Arafat could agree
to — Israeli withdrawal from the
equivalent of 100 percent of the West
Bank and Gaza; exclusive Palestinian
sovereignty over the Temple
Mount/Haram al-Sharif, and a mini-
mal resettling of Palestinian refugees in
Israel.
They disagree, however, on whether
it's going to happen. "The chances are
very, very slim, because the trust
between the two sides is zero," says
Klein.
Shikaki, however, thinks that the
Clinton bridging proposals will be
kicked back and forth between the
Palestinians and Israelis and will rake
on a "momentum of their own."
"Not all the Palestinian leadership
will accept them, but 51 percent will.
The key is the [18-member] Fatah
Central Committee, but with Arafat
heading it, he will push the agreement
through, and once the Fatah leader-
ship accepts the deal, the remainder of
the Palestinian mainstream will follow
suit," says Shikaki.
And what about the Israelis, who
would decide its opinion of such a
peace agreement in the Feb. 6 election
between Barak and Sharon? "Fifty-one
percent of the Israelis will support it,
too," Shikaki replies.
Well, it was the oldtime Zionists,
after all, who said that to be a realist
in this part of the world, one must
believe in miracles. 0

Corrections

• In the Community Views guest
column, "We Are Making A
Difference," (Dec. 22, page 36),
Kibbutz Ein Dor, established in
1948, was misspelled.

• In the letter "Our Money
Misdirected" (Dec. 22, page 37),
Rachel's Tomb was identified as
in Schechem; it is near
Bethlehem. The Palestinians dese-
crated the tomb of Yosef, her son.

• In the introductory story on the
Table of Contents page (Dec. 29,
page 3), the names Dana Burnstein
and Ervin Posner were incorrect.
Posner's first name was misspelled
in a caption on page 14.

SUTTON
HOMES

Sutton Homes proudly presents

The Bradford - ouse

Sutton Homes are inure than general
dementia. Each home is located in a fine
suburban residential neighborhood.
assisted living facilities. We are unique.
highly specialized Personal Care Homes
Each home accomodates 5 or 6 elderly
for the frail elderly. or
residents with care specialists
those with memory loss, Call or Visit Today. present 24 hours a day and
confusion and related The Bradford House daily on-site nurse visits.

3132

E. Bradford Drive, Bloomfield Twp.

(248 ) 72 3-5911

Located between Maple & 1st off Lahscr, east on Lincoln. Open Mon-Fri ID am -4 pm

7M:t, ffffE;;M:rinn,..ANZW.Z.VOLSV.R.MWOZWZINMARMS:SMWAMEMEMANEXPANIMIThaVELSLMV-.:Z. .RIMPI- VO.A.raWA7/7

Relax! Your loved
one is in good hands.

If you're responsible for the care of an
adult loved one at home, you know all
to well time away is precious.

Heartland's respite/vacation program
gives you the opportunity to :ake a '
break from these demands. While
at Heartland, your loved one will
be welcomed into our facility
which features a friendly,
attentive staff, tasty meals and
activities. you'll have the added
serenity knowing your loved
one is receiving around the
clock professional care in a
secure and comfortable
environment designed with
the health, safety, and well-
being of our residents.

Heartland Health
Care Center
West Bloomfield

Skilled Nursing and
Assisted Living

6950 Farmington Road
West Bloomfield, MI 48322
248.661.1700

Heartland Health
Care Center Georgian
Bloomfield

Skilled Nursing,
Assisted Living
and Alzheimers Care

Whether you use respite
care on a regular basis,
or just for a special
occasion, call to learn
about our short stays and
affordable rates.

2945 North Adams Road
Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304
248.645.2900

Owned & Operated by HCR ManorCare

47'

...4

02:45ffff

Wood Rockers from $ 911.00
Gliders from
$ 168.00
Child's Rockers from . $ 48.00
Rocker Cushions & Accessories

FREE LAYAWAY • WE SHIP ANYWHERE
21325 Telegraph, Southfield

(Between 8 & 9 Mlle)

(248) 948-1060

36539 Gratiot Ave., Mt. Clemens 3337 Auburn Rd., Auburn Hills

(South of 16 Mite)

(810) 790-3065

(Between Adarns & Squirrel)

(248) 853-7440

1/5
2001

19

Back to Top

© 2025 Regents of the University of Michigan