100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

December 25, 1998 - Image 45

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 1998-12-25

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

441

Torah Portion

BILL MEYER

internal Strife
Divides Us As A People

JERRY FENBY

RENNIE KAUFFMAN

HOT ICE

FENBY-CARR

SIMONE VITALE

ERIC HARRIS-DJ

PERSUASION

QUIET STORM

PLERSE CRLL FOR
R FREE VIDEO
APPOINTMENT

PERSUASION

SUN MESSENGERS

fraternal feud. The bickering and
internal struggle of the future would
sunder the union of the Jewish people.
The ultimate tragedy, the destruc-
tion of the temple and the loss of
Jewish independence, would be the
bitter fruits of this disunity and dis-
sent. The brothers achieved reconcilia-
his week's sedrah describes
tion in the days of Joseph. But Joseph
the confrontation between
and Benjamin grasped that unrecog-
Joseph and his brothers, the
nized hatred and unresolved hostility
climax of a story of hatred,
would erupt with renewed fury and
jealousy, separation and, after many
violence in generations to come. And
years, reconc ili at i on.
so, they wept, both for the injuries of
The text recounts the poignant
the past and the anguish
moment of the encounter
that would be encountered
between Joseph, the ruler of
in the centuries to follow.
Who could blame them?
Egypt, with his younger
One of the greatest tragedies
brother, Benjamin. Joseph
fell upon the neck of his
of Jewish history has been
brother, Benjamin, and he
not only our persecution,
wept; and Benjamin, similar-
but also our capacity for
ly embracing his brother,
divisiveness, disunity and
enmity of brother against
Joseph, also wept. The
Midrash introduces a strange
brother.
comment, "Why did they
Scripture records the
RABBI IRWIN
weep? They wept because
story of what happened after
GRONER
they foresaw at that moment
King Solomon died. The 12
Special
to The
that two temples, sanctuaries
tribes that comprised his
Jewish News
kingdom would not remain
of God, would be built in
together; 10 of them created
the Land of Israel and they
were both destined for
their own kingdom; only two tribes
destruction."
remained loyal to Solomon's son,
What did the Midrash have in
Rehoboam, and to the descendants of
mind? What does the reunion of
the House of David.
Benjamin and Joseph have to do with
In the first century, the Jewish
the temples of Jerusalem, events that
people were faced with divisions and
are many hundreds of years apart?
schisms that greatly weakened their
Why did they weep and mourn for
strength and vitality. Pharisees,
tragedies that lay beyond their lifetime
Sadducees, Essenes and revolutionar-
and the lives of their children?
ies vied for the support of the peo-
Upon reflection, we can understand
ple. In the war against Rome that
the intent of the Midrash. This is a
ultimately erupted, Jewish disharmo-
story not of brotherly love, but of
ny and disunity created tragic conse-
brotherly hatred, of the jealousy, rival-
quences that led to the loss of Jewish
and
hostility
that
tore
apart
a
fami-
ry.,
independence.
ly, and led to crime and brutality and
During the Middle Ages and
the deception of an aged father by his
beyond, Jews were an embattled
own sons. This is a story of sinat chi-
minority, living on the rim of a pre-
carious existence, suffering from exclu-
nom, causeless hatred, without reason
or purpose, based on irritation, caprice
sion and disability. Even so, conflicts
.
arose that sundered Jewish communi-
and envy.
The Midrash probes the meaning
ties and that sometimes led to the per-
of the tears that were evoked by the
emotional encounter of Joseph and
Benjamin. When they wept in pro-
found response to the hatred that had
Is the story of Joseph based on
separated them, they realized that the
brotherly love or hatred? Why is
senseless hostility was not yet finished
the hatred of Jew against Jew so
and had not yet been expunged from
dangerous for the welfare of the
the hearts of their brothers. They fore-
Jewish people? What can we do
saw that in ages yet unborn, there
today to replace such hatred with
would be a recurrence of this sad
understanding and reconcilia-
drama, a reenactment of this tragic
don?

Shabbat Vayigash:
Genesis 44:18-47:27;
Ezekiel 37:15-28.

T

Conversations

Irwin Groner is senior rabbi of

Congregation Shaarey Zedck.

SUNSET BOULEVARD

TIM HEWITT

248-553 - 9966

LOVING CUP

ENTERTAINMENT AGENCY

AtiebigNiti

:401g,

BEST BANDS AND SERVICE IN TOWN

EmiZ

Our Exclusive Service Offers:
• Home Space Planning • Packing •
• Unpacking •
Deluxe
Move Packages •

"Everything In Place
The Day You Move"

Ruth Schwartz

ASID - IFDA

(248) 352-2264

Professional Interior Designer,
30 years' experience

House To House
EZ Move

Space & Home Planner

Call for a detailed brochure!

* * * * * STAIRWAY LIFTS* * * * *

THE CAREFREE WAY TO
CLIMB STAIRS

When you're disabled, or lust not able to move around
as freely as you once could, stairs can be a real prob-
lem. But there is a simple answer. The powered stairway
lift. Easily installed to fit curved or straight stairs. They
give you back the ability to move around your own
home. Folds back-gets in nobody's way.

I love my
Stairway Lift!

/ It takes me up
' and down the
stairs with the
push of a but-
ton. Call for
details!

CALL OR STOP BY FOR A FREE DEMONSTRATION

ACTON RENTAL & SALES
(313) 891-6500 (248) 540-5550

LARRY ARONOFF

PLANNING A PARTY?
CHECK OUT

rill

11

ELITE
&per o to ,



(248) 661-4021

1-877-802-8111

Portrait Gift Certificates

GORbACk

STU& Of

— THE PERFECT GIFT FOR THE

PERSON WHO HAS EVERYTHING

phoroc,RAphy

Show Someone How Much You Care With Gift Certificates for The Holidays

32731 FRANkLIN Rd. • FRANKLIN, MI 48025 a

(248) 6263666

Batch the best
Music Reviews in
.1N Entertainment

Detroit Jewish News

1212t

19 95

45

Back to Top

© 2025 Regents of the University of Michigan