BUY A CASE OF FOOD TO
HELP FEED THE JEWISH
HUNGRY.
Of Wine And Whine
A generous Rothschild and his vineyards; plus, insight from a
brilliant reader on a Tell Me Why mystery.
YAD EZRA
feed/mg the Jewsti /*ivy
ELIZABETH APPLEBAUM ASSOCIATE EDITOR
Use this coupon to help feed the Jewish hungry.
YAD EZRA Will use your donations to purchase cases
of food and distribute them to our neighbors in need.
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
❑
1 case chicken (54 lbs.)
1/2 case chicken (27 lbs)
1 case 27 oz. canned gefilte fish (12 per case)
1 case 18 oz. Quaker oatmeal (24 per case)
1 case 6.5 oz. tuna in water (48 per case)
1 case 15 oz. tomato sauce (48 per case)
1 case 18 oz. creamy peanut butter (12 per case)
1 case 16 oz. thin spaghetti (20 per case)
1 case 16 oz. rice (24 per case)
$80.00
$40.00
$39.00
$37.00
$30.00
$25.50
$21.00
$18.00
$13.33
$50.00
❑ 1 nutritious food package for family of four
YOUR CONTRIBUTION IS ELIGIBLE FOR A 50% MICHIGAN TAX CREDIT.
(subject to certain limitations)
Enclosed is my check in the amount of $
cases of food as a tax deductible contribution
for
to YAD EZRA to help feed the Jewish hungry.
Name:
Address .
City/State/Zip•
Area Code & Phone:
Make checks payable and mail to:
26641 Harding, Oak Park, MI 48237
YAD EZRA
Tributes and Memorials Available • For more information, call:
YAD EZRA • (810) 548-FOOD (548-3663)
DESIGNS IN DECORATOR
LAMINATES, LTD.
IT DOESN'T HAVE TO COST A FORTUNE...ONLY LOOK LIKE IT!
FEATURING
LU
C)
• Wall Units
• Bedrooms
• Dining Rooms
• Credenzas
• Tables
• Offices
was perfect for viticulture, for mankind. Excerpts from her
Q: Jewish folklore seems to have rael
Baron
Edmond sent grape vines letter follow:
an endless number of stories re-
You will no longer need to be
and experts to the settlements
and built great wine cellars, still in your anxious state of turmoil,
ripe with curiosity and confusion
used today.
Because Rothschild regarded about why your readers cannot
his activities as private philan- remember the name of your col-
thropic projects, he did not con-
There are three points that
sider them part of the burgeoning
Zionist movement. It was not un- support my theory about why
til 1914 that he acknowledged his people would rather title your col-
role and that of the Zionists as di- umn "Ask Me Why." "Tell Me
Why" has more negative tones —
A: The Rothschild family is in- rected to the same objective.
At the end of 1923, Rothschild it borders on aggressive, rather
deed vast, and its mystique cer-
tainly has made a lasting impact founded the Palestine Jewish Col- than assertive; it sounds almost
on the European Jewish con- onization Association, headed by as if a young child were blurting
it out, rather than a sophisticat-
ed adult. And it may feed into
stereotypical expectations of oth-
ers that Jews are "demanding."
First, 'Tell Me Why" takes the
reader's point of view and makes
him sound demanding. If we all
went around saying, "tell me," or
"give me," we would sound bossy.
"Ask Me Why," on the other
hand, sounds like it is a direct in-
vitation from you to have readers
query you, and it saves your read-
er the despair of feeling he may
be imposing on you to work for
him.
Also, "Tell Me Why" smacks of
the curious little 3-year-old hang-
ing on your pants leg while you
are trying to cook, clean or use
the rest room, who repeatedly
Wine aging gracefully in Israel.
asks, "Tell me why ... why mom-
my
... why daddy ... tell me ... tell
his
son,
James.
The
primary
pur-
sciousness. Since the late 1700s,
when the Rothschilds first rose pose was to found new settle- me!" For some reason, "ask me"
to prominence, probably every ments. Throughout Jewish sounds more adult, more chal-
generation of Jews has told sto- Palestine, Rothschild was a hero lenging, more daring!
Finally, we certainly do not
ries of encountering Rothschild and became known as ha-nadiv
wealth and generosity. In each ha-yadua, ("the well-known bene- want to add to any stereotype
generation, at least one Roth- factor"). His generosity generat- that Jews are "demanding" or
schild has taken an active role in ed the acquisition of 125,000 "pushy." To rename "Ask Me
Jewish affairs. This is true even acres of land and the building of Why" avoids some of these over-
today, although by now the Roth- almost 30 settlements in Eretz ly sensitive concerns of some who
schilds are intermarried with Yisrael. One of the settlements worry others would lump us into
gentiles and their presence on the was Binyainina, on the southern this category. (Not that I worry
world Jewish scene is eclipsed by spur of Mt. Carmel, named in about this — after all, I do de-
other wealthy and powerful Jews. honor of the baron (whose He- mand excellence of myself and
When stories center on the role brew name was Avraham others!)
So there you have my theory
of "Rothschild," more often than Binyamin).
as
to why some readers want to
Rothschild
died
in
Paris
in
not they are referring to Baron
Edmond James de Rothschild of 1939; his wife. died one year lat- remember your column as "Ask
the French branch of the family. er. In 1954, the remains of the Me Why." You asked for it, you
Born in 1845, Baron Edmond baron and his wife were rein- got it! Editor's Note Again: Whoa!
was known as one of Europe's terred on a hilltop tomb at Ramat I feel the weight of the world is
most famous art collectors and Ha-Nadiv ("Benefactor's Height") off my shoulders. Life is good
again!
experts. To the Jews of the world, near Zichron Yaacov.
Editor's Note: As many of you
however, he was revered for his
-devotion to the Land of Israel and recall, I recently wrote a heartfelt
Sendquestions to Tell Me Why,
letter pleading with readers to tell The' Jewish News, 27676
the Jewish people.
Beginning in 1882, he gave me why (get it — tell me why!) Franklin Road, Southfield, MI
considerable financial support to no one could remember the name
48034, or fax to (810) 354-6069.
new Jewish settlements in Eretz of this column.
All letters must be signed and in-
Mercifully, L.A.S. of West clude the writer's address. Ques-
Yisrael. In fact, one of them, Za-
marin, was renamed Zichron. Bloomfield. was kind enough to
tions answered in the column will
Yaacov in honor of the baron's fa- respond — with brilliant insight,
eature only the writer's initials
ther. Convinced that Eretz Yis- I might add. This gives me hope
and city of residence.
garding someone named "Roth-
schild." I know the Rothschild
family has many members, all of
them wealthy, but are these stories
about one of them in particular, or
is "Rothschild" just a general term
referring to whichever family mem-
ber lived when the stories suppos-
edly occurred?
sM
a
•
a
•
.
❑
SPECIALTIES
CC
U_I
LU
• Formica
• Woods
• Stones
• Glass
• Lucite
.
LOIS HARON
851-6989
Allied Member ASID
411