100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

November 15, 1996 - Image 108

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 1996-11-15

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

Tin Pan Monroe

He coined the name, but he didn't keep the coins.

ELIZABETH APPLEBAUM ASSOCIATE EDITOR

Q: I alreadYkilow, or can guess, at where some of the world's largest

Jewish populations live, like Israel and the United States. But can you tell
me about unusual places that remain home to Jewish communities?
A: It's very interesting, as a matter of fact, to consider some of
the places where you'll find Jews. Take Surinarae, a South Amer-
lean country with a population of 450,000, about 200 of whom
are Jewish.
Here are some other statistics, from the 1996 American Jew-
ish Yearbook, you might fmd surprising.

WELCOME CANTORS ASSEMBLY
DELEGATES TO THE TRI-STATE
CONFERENCE!

General Population Number Of Jews

Country

El Salvador

5,900,000

100

Ireland

3,600,000

1,300

Gibraltar

31,000

600

Belarus

10,300,000

35,000

Moldova

4,300,000

12,200

Poland

38,600,000

3,500

Armenia

3,700,000

100

Tajikstan

5,800,000

2,200

Hong Kong

6,000,000

1,000

India

930,600,000

4,400

61,300,000

14,000

125,200,000

1,000

Syria

14,700,000

800

South Korea

44,900,000

100

• Iraq

TEMPLE ISRAEL'S
SINGLES EXTENSION GROUP

Invites Jewish Singles
50 and over to

THE AUTUMN SWING

Sunday, November 24, 1996 7:30 P.M.

at
Temple Israel - Herman Hall
5725 Walnut Lake Road, W. Bloomfield

Dancing to the Music of Wally Duda

Light refreshments - Bagels
Non-Members $12.00
Members $9.00

For further information, call:

108

Barbara Ginsbury (810) 353-7261
Party Chairperson Mary Adler 356-0955

Incidentally, you're absolutely
correct about where the largest Jew-
ish communities live. According to
the Yearbook , the top 15 cities, in
order, are New York, Tel Aviv, Los
Angeles, Jerusalem, Haifa, Miami-
Ft Lauderdale, Paris, Philadelphia,
Chicago, Boston, San Francisco,
London, Buenos Aires, Washington,
D.C., and Toronto.

A Joint Distribution Committee
volunteer, right, teaches Jewish
boys in India how to use tefillin.

Q: Correct me if I'm mistaken, but
I seem to recall that a Jewish com-
poser once wrote a song about a
president who fathered an illegiti-
mate child. Is that really the case
and, if so, what's the story?

A: It's certainly true, and the
man behind the music — as
well as the song itself — has
quite an interesting tale.
Monroe Rosenfeld was a
19th-century composer (of sorts)
and a native of Virginia who
worked as a journalist and press
agent, among other occupations,
before becoming a popular song-
writer in New York.
He first found fame in New

York, however, among the city's
bookies. Rosenfeld was a devot-
ed gambler (a habit that would
eventually lead to his downfall)
who loved to hang out on Broad-
way, which he nicknamed "Tin
Pan Alley" in an article in the
Herald Tribune. The name, of
course, caught on quickly, as did
Rosenfeld's reputation for writ-
ing a snappy tune — or at least
finding someone else who could
write it for him.
Rosenfeld was not exactly the
boy next door. He was so des-
perate to get his hands on mon-
ey for gambling and betting that
he often was in trouble with the
law (like writing bad checks).

Once, he was being chased
by police and jumped out a
second-story window. As a
result, he broke his leg and
spent the rest of his life limp-
ing.
Many of Rosenfeld's songs
were popular in the late
1800s, though most have
been forgotten today. Among
these was "Ma! Ma! Where's
My Pa!" which chronicled a
real-life scandal involving
Grover Cleveland. As a pres-
idential candidate, Cleve-
land admitted to having a
child out of wedlock. When
Cleveland won the election,
Rosenfeld's song recounted
the fate of the child's father
who was "up in the White
House ... making the laws,
working the cause."
Rosenfeld's real specialty,
however, was maudlin songs
— the more sappy and sen-
timental the better. Typical
of these was "Gold Will Buy
Most Anything But A True
Girl's Heart," a nauseating
number about a rich man
who wants to wed a girl in
love with another. "I'd rather
have my Jack than all your
gold," she sings, "for gold will
buy most anything but a
true girl's heart."
Oh, sob, sob.
Often, Rosenfeld
felt free to steal
huge chunks of
melodies from other
composers to use in
his musical master-
pieces. Perhaps this
is the reason for his
decision to write
most of his songs
under pseudonyms;
certainly it was not
a reflection of his
modesty, as Rosen-
feld was more than
happy to add his
real name as a composer to oth-
ers' songs, when often his con-
tribution was minor, at best.
Remarkably, Rosenfeld was
well-liked by just about every- c'
one who knew him. He died
bankrupt after years of squan-
dering his money.

Send questions to Tell Me Why,
The Jewish News, 27676
Franklin Road, Southfield, MI
48034, or fax to (810) 354-6069.
All letters must be signed and in-
clude the writer's address. Ques-
tions answered in the column will
feature only the writer's initials
and city of residence.

Back to Top

© 2025 Regents of the University of Michigan