100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

March 31, 1989 - Image 11

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 1989-03-31

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

LETTERS 1

WATCH FOR US
"SHOE REVIEW"
.

Tikkun Article
Reminds Of Korach

I read the Media Monitor
column in your March 17 edi-
tion with a sick feeling in my
stomach and came away with
one conclusion. The reason
the "Orthodox" rabbi who
wrote the Tikkun article
would not sign his name was
because he did not want us to
know that his name is
Korach.
We learn from the Torah
and Midrash that Korach was
a leader among the Jews at
the time of Moses, an
educated man (an "Orthodox
rabbi"?) who tried to
challenge the leadership of
Moses by taking certain
Torah laws and subtly
twisting their meaning to
make them sound foolish or
cruel. His purpose was not to
promote learning or debate: it
was to attract attention to
himself and take power by
creating dissent among the
people.
Living under Torah law is
not a dark "senario." Those of
us who do cling to the Torah
find that "all its ways are
pleasant." The rabbi who
wrote this article is not real-
ly interested in "horrifying
possibilities"; he is interested
in power through dissent.
Was what your interest in
reprinting it?

Yehudis Rabinowitz
Oak Park

New Improved
Blood Libel

For centuries, Jews around
the world were tormented by
the blood libel. Around
Passover time practically in
every country in Europe,
rumors sprang that Jews
allegedly killed a Christian
child supposedly to use the
blood in making matzahs for
Passover.
Now, when these rumors
subside and killing of one
child would not make a great
news, a liberal-leftist Jewish
magazine Tikkun introduced
a new improved and revised
murder libel. The article
"The Problem With Halachic
Ethics" in its March/April
issue was extensively review-
ed in the last issue of The
Jewish News under a title
"Tikkun Chides Jewish Law
As Problematic and In-
tolerant."
In the Tikkun article, an
anonymous Orthodox rabbi il-
lustrates a future scenario
when a brilliant surgeon at
Jerusalem's Hospital driven
by a halachic fervour alleged-
ly killed or let die more than
800 of his patients.
This accusation is not brand
new. In national socialist Ger-
many and the socialist Soviet

Union, Jewish doctors were
customarily accused of harm-
ing or murdering their pa-
tients .. .
editors
Tikkun
The
rightfully realized that the
outside world would not trust
secular, Reform and Conser-
vative rabbis in matters of
Jewish law. Therefore, these
allegations are brought in the
name of an Orthodox rabbi.
This rabbi calls for a public
trial of the huge body of
Jewish law. This progressive
call returns us to a grim
medieval practice of the
"Tournaments for God" and
numerous Talmud trials .. .
Another insult to the
Jewish community at large is
the anonymity of the author.
Our great rabbis of old as well
as our contemporary rabbis
have never been afraid to
stand for their causes .. .
With due respect to freedom
of the press and different opi-
nions for every walk of life, I
would request The Jewish
News not publish or circulate
the anti-Semitic, anti-Jewish,
anti-Israel and anti-humane
materials without thorough
editorial comment. Leave the
distribution of such materials
to publishers like Tikkun.

Alexander Y. Gopp
Ann Arbor

Camp Fund
Thanks Paper

Thank you! Thank you!
Your generous contribution in
honor of Mitzvah Maker
Chuck Pearlstein was great-
ly appreciated. Your contribu-
tion will send a single parent
child to overnight camp for
one week. That means that
for one week a single parent
will not have to work for sup-
port and worry about child
care . . .
The Jewish News is truly
the Mitzvah Maker of the
year because of the increased
contribution to community
Yiddishkeit through your
many holiday projects.

(Formerly BAGS 'N THINGS)
Jack & Carol Cohen

WE ARE MOVING UP THE ROAD TO
"CROSSWINDS MALL"

(Orchard Lake & Lone Pine Rds.)

Lookfor our opening around April 3rd.

SHOE REVIEW

Crosswinds Mall
4301 Orchard Lake Rd.
W. Bloomfield, Mich. 48033

855-8355

Begadim

on the Boardwalk

APRIL'S
FOOL

SOO MUCH
FOR SOO
LITTLE

DIAMOND SOLITAIRE

SINGULAR BEAUTY

IN THE MOST CLASSIC WAY
. . . ELEGANT!

in Fashion for the Young al Heart
Excellence
6919 Orchard Lake Rd. • West Bloomfield, MI
855-5528

Ruth Krieger
The Marilynn Klein Camp Fund
Southfield

Purim Spoof
Was An Insult

I feel I would be remiss in
not telling you that many of
us thought your insertion of
"Purim Schmooze" in your
March 17 issue to be in ex-
tremely poor taste.
Fully realizing it was
meant to be humorous and a
tongue-in-cheek type of
writing, it was nevertheless
an insult to your heretofore
standards of journalism,
which I had always felt to be
of an extremely high caliber.

Helen M. Lipton
West Bloomfield

Save S1.00 on the purchase of
a battery with this ad.

George
Ohrenstein

Jewelers Ltd.

• Certified Gemologist
• American Gem Society

HARVARD ROW MALL

Lahaer and 11 Mile Rd.

Enlarged to show detail

Pear shaped diamond masterfully
set in Platinum, with tapered
Baguettes. 4.18 cr. t.w.,
G color, SI clarity.

EXCLUSIVELY PRICED
$39,000.00 plus tax.

Fine Jewelry
& Gifts

26400 WEST TWELVE MILE RD., SOUTHFIELD, MI • 357-5578

353-3146

THE DETROIT JEWISH NEWS

11

Back to Top

© 2025 Regents of the University of Michigan