100%

Scanned image of the page. Keyboard directions: use + to zoom in, - to zoom out, arrow keys to pan inside the viewer.

Page Options

Share

Something wrong?

Something wrong with this page? Report problem.

Rights / Permissions

The University of Michigan Library provides access to these materials for educational and research purposes. These materials may be under copyright. If you decide to use any of these materials, you are responsible for making your own legal assessment and securing any necessary permission. If you have questions about the collection, please contact the Bentley Historical Library at bentley.ref@umich.edu

February 13, 1987 - Image 18

Resource type:
Text
Publication:
The Detroit Jewish News, 1987-02-13

Disclaimer: Computer generated plain text may have errors. Read more about this.

DOES FOOD CONTROL YOU? DO YOU LIVE TO EAT?

OP-ED

IT'S TIME TO TAKE CONTROL!

HEALTHY OPTIONS, INC. offers
• Individualized Dietary Program
• Individualized Weekly Counseling
• Group Sessions Weekly

To take control of yourself now, call for your Free Consultation

DEA FARRAH, MSW, ACSW — Weight Control Therapist

HEALTHY OPTIONS, INC. -

(313) 647-5540

BINGHAM CENTER • 30800 TELEGRAPH • SUITE 2960 • BIRMINGHAM, MI 48010
YOU ALONE CAN DO IT, BUT YOU CAN'T DO IT ALONE!

HOW TO GET
THIS DESIRABLE FIGURE
IN JUST ONE DAY.

BEFORE

WINNING $5,000
IN THE DAILY 4 GAME.

AFTER

WINNING $5,000
IN THE DAILY 4 GAME.

As told by Barney G.

6

11A1 hen I heard you could get a

III figure like $5,000 in just one
day, I was skeptical at first. Sure, I
had read about people who have made
$5,000 in just one day. But I never
dreamed it could happen to me.
Then a friend told me about the
Daily 4 Game. 'Barney, he said, 'all
you have to do is pick any 4-digit

number. Just tell your Totten' agent
you want to place a Si straight bet in
the Daily 4 Game. Then you watch the
nightly televised drawing at 7:29 p.m.
And if your number matches the num-
ber drawn in the exact same order,
boomba! You win:
So I played it. And, whaddaya know'
I won it! 5000 smackers. Now I'm the

envy of my friends. I was so happy,
my own dog didn't even recognize me!
So if you would like a desirable figure.
I highly recommend the Daily -I Game:*

GET IN THE GAME.
THE DAILY 4 GAME.

Obstacles

Continued from Page 7

can marry a woman who con-
ceived while still being a vir-
gin, i.e. she became pregnant
through artificial means.
The questions raised are
many:
In the event of a married
surrogate mother is the child a
mamzer? Although the major-
ity opinion would say that the
mingling of a stranger's seed
with the married woman does
not constitute adultery, the
question of mamzerut still
exists. The question of the
child's status as a bastard, with
all its social implications, may
still apply.
There is the problem of the
possibility the child might
marry his or her relative. The
natural father is the man who
gave his seed, and the surro-
gate mother is the mother in
Jewish law. No matter to
which home the child would
remain, the possibility exists
that he or she might marry his
other sibling, since the identity
of the other family would be
unknown.
This problem would exist
even if the mother is married.
Who would be responsible
for child care? The surrogate
mother's husband does not
have to support this child. The
natural father could be re-
quired by Jewish law to sup-
port the daughter even if he is
not the custodial parent, but
for a son after the age of six,
when according to the
, Halachah he should ideally
have custody, the father could
say he is withholding support
because the child is not in his
home.
Besides these questions and
the prohibitions to sire chil-
dren that could possibly marry
siblings, there are other
halachic grounds. The
Halachah provides that a man
can only marry one woman at a
time. This is primarily for the
mitzvah of procreation.
Marriage must be done by
sanctification. The method of
marriage must also be in line
with accepted social and
Jewish procedure. To meet a
woman in the street without
proper introduction and eng-
age her to marry is severely
dealt with because it borders
on prostitution. It would be a
fortiori (Ral Vachomer) that
solicitation of a non-married
partner for reproduction with-
out sanctification, would cer-
tainly border on prostitution.
It would certainly blur the bar-
rier against sexual solicitation
for reproductive reasons. For if
the motive was for infertility,
why couldn't the woman pro-
vide a sexual service as well,
since the motive is "pure?"
The conception of a child has
profound spiritual and
psychological effects on the
. child's future behavior. When
the motive for motherhood is
profit, what intent of love and
sanctity exist in the formation
of this child?
In the event the mother is

not Jewish, although no ques-
tion of mamzerut would then
exist, nonetheless, it is forbid-
den for a Jewish male to sire a
non-Jewish child.
There is also the question of
emitting seed in vain. Many
halachic authorities permit in
vitro fertilization of one's
spouse and even consider it
commendable, in cases of infer-
tility. However, this is only
permitted when the recipient
is the wife. When the recipient
is not his wife, all authorities
forbid it.
There are psychological
problems as well. The spouse
raising the child may forever
be reminded of her inability to
perform and may resent the
child. The natural mother, as
in the case of Baby M, would
feel profound guilt and an-

-1

Is the child a
mamzer? Could it
marry a sibling?

guish in giving up the baby. No
legislation or iron-clad con-
tract could remove a mother's
regret of giving up her child.
The procedure is, emotionally,
a time-bomb ready to explode.
There are many people who
would conceivably pay large
amounts of money for this serv-
ice. This could become an area
where organized crime would
exploit defenseless women.
The story of the Oriental
woman who had to exchange
years of service for entry into
this country is well known.
Child selling in its ugliest form
could very well become an un-
derground industry.
Regulation procedures
would not serve as a deterrent
if there were not large num;
bers of women available or if
the cost were high enough to
warrant the risks.
In the case of Baby M, the
contract according to Jewish
law would be invalid, for the
woman cannot sell her body,
nor can she sell a child not yet
born, for it is a "Davar Shelo Ba
Le Olam," something that is
not here, which cannot be sold.
According to Rabbi Bleich,
use of a donor ovum in the
spouse's womb may be permis-
sible, since according to many,
the mother is the one in whom
the child is grown and experi-
ences the opening of the womb.
This is consistent with the con-
cept that the effect of birth
validates that which at concep-
tion was not complete. Thus,
while impregnating one's wife
artificially may be a virtue,
surrogate motherhood, is out.

Chaim Bergstein is rabbi of
Bais Chabad of Farmington
Hills and a member of the
Council of Orthodox Rabbis of
Greater Detroit.

4

'14

Back to Top

© 2024 Regents of the University of Michigan