Jews Join in Greeting Pope Paul VI; Vatican H Explains
`Deploring' Bather Than Condemning' Anti-Semitism
(Continued from Page 1)
movement. The American Jewish H. Ullman, Charles Fergang, and Mor- College, of Worcester, Mass.; Rev.
offered Tuesday two reasons for
Lipsett, members of the cabinet,
of the United Nations and of the Committee delegation, led by presi- ris
Jewish Center; Marcel Franco, Consul- Elmo L. Romagosa of New Orleans,
the
decision by the secretariat to
Jewish Center for the United Na- dent Morris B. Abram, included tative Council of Jewish Organizations. Rev. Donald Campion of New York.
substitute the milder word "de-
Also, Morris B. Abram, president,
tions.
all former presidents and Dr. John American
Jewish Committee; Jacob
The fact that the amended
plores" for the word "condemns"
cabinet, Jewish Center for
"During this hour of trial for Siawson, executive vice-president. Blaustein,
text
of
the
Vatican's
draft
dec-
the United Nations; Rabbi Samuel Bel-
with reference to anti-Semitism
humanity as mankind faces con- Among the absentees were Dr. kin, president, Yeshiva University; Rabbi laration on Jews does not con-
contained in the original draft
Louis Finkelstein, chancellor, Jewish
tinuing crises, your meeting with Louis Finkelstein, Chancellor of Theological
Seminary of America; Judge
demn but only deplores anti-
of the document.
representatives of the faith com- the Jewish Theological Seminary, Joseph M. Proskauer, American Jewish Semitism is pointed out strongly
Committee; and Stanley Kreutzer, 0.
Replying
to • a question at the
and
Dr.
Isaac
Lewin
of
the
Agudath
munities gives new promise for
Roy Chalk, Howard Samuels, and David
in the Corriere della Sera, of American Bishops' Press Panel of •
Danzig, all members of the cabinet,
the future. Our world yearns for a Israel.
Milan, one of the foremost news- the Ecumenical Council, Father
Some of the Jews present, in- Jewish Center for the United Nations.
great moral revival to forestall the
apers in Italy.
Long, a member of the secretariat,
cluding
a
number
of
rabbis
and
evil and to strive toward the real-
Anti-Semitism Only
The original text, which was ap- said that, in accordance with th
Orthodox
representatives,
made
a
ization of the Prophet's vision
proved by a large majority of the "mocli" set forth by the CounC,
which Your Excellency expressed point to sit not in the chapel but 'Deplored' in New
Ecumenical Council at its session Fathers, the word "condemn" is
in
the
adjoining
Pacem
in
Terris
so eloquently this afternoon: 'Na-
last year, said that the Catholic not used in council decrees or
Vatican Declaration
tion shall not lift up sword against library.
Church "deplores, indeed con- declarations. He recalled that, at
The list of Jewish representa-
nation, neither shall they learn
ROME (JTA) — The Subcom- demns, hatred and persecution of the beginning of the present Ecu-
tives invited to meet the pontiff ,
war anymore.'
as issued by the Papal Visit News mission for Catholic-Jewish Rela- Jews." The amended text, elim- menical Council, the late Pope
"As a people whose ideal is Center, consisted of the following: tions of the American Bishops inating the word "condemns," John XXIII had said that there
Commission for Ecumenical Affairs reads: "The Church, which rejects should be no "condemnations" and
shalom, peace, we pledge our untir-
Jack N. Berkman, national chairman,
ing efforts to help promote peace Jewish Center for the United Nations; intends to begin carrying out the any persecution against any man, "no anathemas."
Freund, president of the Jewish program of fostering better rela-
in every dimension — political, Milton
mindful of the patrimony with the
Center; Rabbi David B. Kahane, of the
The other reason for the substi-
social and economic. Your presence Jewish Center; Rabbi Philip Hiat, direc- tions between Catholics and Jews, Jews and moved not by politi- tution, Father Long said, was the
tor of the Center; Rabbi Max Nussbaum, as set forth in the draft declara-
here is one more meaningful mani- president
cal reasons, but by the Gospels' fact that the church used the
of the American Zionist
festation of the moral and spiritual Council; Edward M. M. Warburg, na- tion before the Ecumenical Council, spiritual love, d e p 1 or es hatred, stronger word only in condemning
tional
chairman,
Joint
Distribution
basis indispensible •to a lasting Committee; Dr. William 'Wexler, presi- without waiting for promulgation persecutions, d i s p la y s of anti- "formal heresy."
peace with truth and justice — dent, Bnai Brith International; Rabbi of the declaration by Pope Paul Semitism directed against Jews at
J. Cohen, president, Synagogue VI, it was indicated here.
Jewish Committee Finds
which material and finite resources Seymour
any time and by anyone."
Council of America; Rabbi Max Schenk,
president, New York Board of Rabbis;
alone cannot achieve."
First
Draft More Decisive
Details of the planned work of
Fabrizio de Santis, who 'Wrote
Mrs. Joseph Willen, president, National
the subcommission were reported the leading article on the issue in
Klutznick's "Shalom" received Council of Jewish Women.
NEW YORK (JTA) — The Amer-
Also, Rabbi David DeSola Pool, Ortho- at the American Bishops' press
the Pope's "Shalom" response.
ican Jewish Committee, in a state-
dox adviser, Jewish Center for the panel by Msgr. George Higgins of the Milan newspaper, noted that
Virtually every one of the 47 United
Nations; Rabbi Harry Halpern,
one bishop in the Council had ment issued by its president, Morris
Jewish leaders announced Sunday Conservative adviser, and Rabbi Solomon the social action department of the pointed out that change and asked B. Abram, said that "while the
Freehof, Reform adviser; Alexander National Catholic Welfare Confer-
by the Papal Visit News Center Hassen,
Joseph Mailman, and Ralph
why that alteration had been direct language of the original
to have been invited to the inter- Friedman, all members of the cabinet, ence of Washington, D. C. Msgr. made. "Is it possible," lie asked, Vatican draft is more decisive and
Jewish Center for the United Nations; Higgins also disclosed the names
faith meeting with Pope Paul was Rabbi Nelson Glueck, president, Hebrew
"to 'deplore' and not to 'condemn' satisfactory, the new draft does
present at the session in the mod- Union College-Jewish Institute of Re- of the American prelates compos- a future Hitler who would again declare that what happened in the
ligion; Rabbi Maurice N. Eisendrath. ing the subcommission.
ernistic Roman Catholic church president,
Union of American Hebrew
pretend to solve the Jewish ques- Passion cannot be imputed to all
Congregations; George Maislen, presi-
half a block from the United Na- dent,
He described the task of the sub- tion, putting them into extermina- the Jews then alive without distinc-
United Synagogue of America;
tions complex.
Moses I. Feuerstein, president. Union commission in the words of the tion camps and into crematory tion or to the Jews of our time.
of Orthodox Jewish. Congregations of draft that "since the spiritual
It emphasizes that Jews cannot be
ovens?"
One of the new changes in the America;
Rabbi Israel Miller, president,
list was the presence of Rabbi Rabbinical Council of America; Rabbi patrimony common to Christians
Informed sources said here presented as condemned or cursed
Max J. Routtenberg, president, Rab- and Jews is so great, the Council
Emanuel Rackman, assistant to the binical Assembly; Rabbi Jacob J. Wein-
that voting on the amended text by God as though this follows from
stein, president, Central COnference of wants to foster and recommend a
president of Yeshiva University in- American
of
the draft declaration will take Sacred Scripture.
Rabbis.
mutual knowledge and respect place at the fourth session of
stead of Dr. Samuel Belkin, presi-
"We receive this. declaration not
Also, Rabbi Joachim Prinz, chairman,
dent of the institution. Moses I. Conference of Presidents of Jewish Or- which is the fruit, above all, of the Ecumenical Council between as an act of favor, but as an act
ganizations; Samuel Bronfman, chair- biblical and theological studies as
Feuerstein, president of the Union man,
Oct. 14 and 15. They confirmed of justice," Abram stated. "We cor-
'Western Hemisphere executive,
of Orthodox Jewish Congregations World Jewish Congress; Aaron Goldman, well as of fraternal dialogue."
reports that the form of voting relate it with the statement of
national chairman, National Community
of America, represented his or- Relations Advisory Council; Rabbi Isaac
The NCWC official noted that on amendments could permit res- Cardinal Bea, that 'not even the
ganization; George Masilen, presi- Lewin, chairman, American section, during the past five years "en- toration of the word "deicide." Great Judgment on Jerusalem
Israel World Organization;
A member of the Secretariat proves a collective guilt of the Jew-
dent of the United Synagogue of Agudath
Abraham Goodman, chairman of the couraging collaboration" between
for Christian Unity, which is the ish people for the crucifixion, the
America, was the chief representa- board, Jewish Center for the United Catholics and Jews in the United
Herrhan Fiedelbaum. Albert
Vatican body responsible for the less so can the Jewish people be
tive of the Conservative movement; Nations;
Kanter, Arthur Belfer, all vice-presi- States had already been underway.
dents, Jewish Center for the United He added that "significant develop-
text on the declaration on Jews, considered deicide or reprobate.'
and Rabbi Maurice Eisendrath and Nations;
Moses Kooperstein, treasurer,
Dr. Nelson Glueck were the princ- Jewish Center; Morton M. Berger and ments" could be expected from
sh formation of the subcommission
ipal representatives of the Reform Jerome
C enter foir-t lf: W . al'it:rr iVae
r' i
Nations; ; Jewi
and from further contacts on a
national basis with Jewish official
and unofficial representatives.
In reply to a question, he said
collaboration would be sought with
The Fightin' Irish of Notre Dame
Gilhooley isn't sure what his all Jewish "confessional" groups,
have nothing on a fighting young future plans are, partly because he including Orthodox, Conservative
Irishman from the University of doesn't know how he'll perform on and Reform, and also with lay
Michigan, Bob Gilhooley, who the field. "If in the spring I re- groups. American Orthodox lead-
thinks his name is the result of a ceive an offer to play professional ers have criticized Jewish leaders
comedy of errors.
baseball, I will definitely take the for their contacts with Catholic
prelates in the handling of the
In case there's any doubt, opportunity," he said.
draft on Catholic Jewish relations.
Gilhooley, 1966 captain of the U. of
A member of Sigma Alpha Mu
M. baseball team, is Jewish.
Actually, the text as dis-
Fraternity,
Gilhooley
also
belongs
And the name? The shortstop
tributed
in English by the Amer-
from Skokie, Ill., explained it this to Michigama, senior men's hon- ican press panel, showed not
orary
and
participates
in
inter-
way to The Jewish News:
only that the word "deicide" had
"My grandfather on my father's mural sports "just to keep busy." been dropped, but also that anti-
side emigrated to Ireland from
Semitism was only deplored, and
Romania or Russia. When he ar-
not condemned. The summary
rived, there appeared to be some
also showed that the title of
trouble in communicating with the
Chapter Four of the Declaration
officers there, and hence, my
on Relations with Non-Christian
grandfather's name, which was
Religions had been changed.
originally Galloula, was transform-
Originally, that chapter had been
ed into Gilhooley . . . Anyway,
headed "On Jews." Now it is
that's the way I heard it."
entitled "On the Jewish Reli-
A distant relative of Detroiter
gion."
Jerome L. Schostak, 20-year-old
- Most of the subcommission mem-
Gilhooley, a junior, has a batting
bers are also members of the Amer-
average of .279 and is a mainstay
ican delegation to the Council. In
of the U. of M. team. He origin.
addition to Msgr. Higgins, other
ally came to Michigan as an in-
members of the subcommission are:
fielder, but necessity moved him
Msgr. J. M. Oesterreicher, director
to outfield last season. As short-
of the Institute of Judeo- Christ-
stop, he'll be moving in again.
ian Studies . at Seton Hall Univer-
The 5'9, 175-pound accounting
sity, Newark; Rev. Raymond Bosler,
Sandy Koufax walks off the field at Dodger Stadium in Los
major was born in Cincinnati, but
editor of the Indianapolis diocese Angeles after chalking up his 25th victory of the season, Sept. 29,
from there his parents moved to
newspaper, the Criterion; Rev. G. a 5.0 shutout over the Cincinnati Reds that practically sewed up the
Chicago and then to the suburb
F. Van Ackeren, SJ of St. Mary's National League title for this year. The loss eliminated the Reds.
of Skokie. His father is a general
College, St. Mary's, Kan.; Rev. Koufax. struck out 13 for his fifth consecutive shutout, and allowed
sales manager for an auto parts
Edward Flannery, editor of "The only two hits With him is Coach Lefty_ Phillips (left).
firm operating out of Cincinnati.
Providence Visitor," of Providence.
The lower photo shows Koufax (center facing camera)
Bob and his brother Mark, who
Also, Rev. Roland Murphy of the as. he tries his best to accept his teammates' congratulations after
also attends U. of 11/1., claim similar
Carmelite Order, Washington, D. the Dodgers won the Oct. 2 game.
athletic interests, but Mark's prow-
C.; Msgr. Francis J. Lally, editor of
Winning his 26th game of the season on Saturday, when he
ess is displayed best on the wrest-
"The Pilot" of Boston; Msgr. Daniel pitched the Los Angeles Dodgers to victory in the battle for the
ling mat. Another common in-
Cathwell of the Catholic Council National League pennant, Sandy ran up his strikeout record for the
terest: both have been operated
of Chicago; Msgr. Mark J. Hurley year to 382. In that game he became the third lefthander to win 26
on for shoulder injuries from high
of San Francisco College; Rev. games in a single season in the National League, the others, both
school football. "Today," Bob
Edward Duff, SJ, of Holy Cross Giants, being Rube Marquard, in 1912, and Carl Hubbell, in 1936.
boasted, "Mark and I have match-
Observing Yom Kippur, Sandy Koufax did not pitch on the
THE DETROIT JEWISH NEWS
ing scars, his on the left and mine
opening day of the World Series, on Wednesday. He was scheduled
on the right."
BOB GILHOOLEY
32—Friday, October 8, 1965
to pitch on Thursday.
Sandy
From Auld Sod to Ann Arbor
•
After His 25th, 26th Wins
ti