Physician 'Wins' Suit Against Uris Blames Thanes for Sinai Campaign Failure; 'Exodus': Half-Penny Damages Prof. Finer Defends Israel, Britain and France for LONDON (JTA)—A High Court and Co., said the words were true tual and spiritual pride and and repel the assault of Arab "Dulles Over Suez: The Theory jury awarded to Dr. Wladislaw but only 130 experiments had colossal self-righteousness drove soldiers." Practice of His Diplomacy," and Dering nominal damages of one- been performed on Jewish prison- him into a morally indefensible by Dr. Herman Finer, professor Dr. Finer maintains: "The full half-penny, the lowest sum that ers and spinal anesthetics had role, for he evoked the Rule of of political science at the Uni- price has not yet been paid for can be given, in his libel suit been given. Law as the world hope while he versity of Chicago, published by Dulles' deficiency of nerve in not Although the name was spelled against author Leon Uris and the and the. President (the latter Quadrangle Books (119 W. Lake, standing fast at the Suez brink British publishers of his novel, with an `1-1', the defendants admit- soon with some reluctance) clan- Chicago 1) is a devastating work. created by Nasser and Moscow. He ted that it referred to Dr. Dering. "Exodus." destinely subdued B r i t a i n, It describes the blunders against let himself be outbluffed, and the The Polish-born doctor - inmate Dering, 61, who now practices France and Israel with moral Israel, Great Britain and France debts he so incurred are still at the Auschwitz death camp had medicine in London. said he had economic sanctions. Behind his by the United States and t h e coming to light. In public speeches sued over a passage in the book performed some operations at public appeals for 'a decent re- United Nations. It hits hard and and in the remoteness of the State which accused him of performing Auschwitz under fear of death and spect for the opinions of man- views the positions that were Department and White House of- experiments without anesthetics because he wanted to save patients kind,' Dulles was motivated by taken by John flees he truculently talked a for- from unskilled butchery. on Auschwitz inmates. overt and covert panic before Foster Dulles, ward-spirited, domineering, a n d The judge ordered Dering to Russian power. He seems, also, ;:President Eisen- all-too-crafty foreign policy. But pay the defendants' costs and re- World Jewish Congress to have been intimidated by hower and Dag involved in the real war of nerves, fused him permission to appeal. Gains French Backing Dag Hammarskjold's even more :Hammarskjold as where the real bullets fly, he Costs are estimated at 25,000 The growing strength of the powerfully pious personality, as having proven to proved ineffective . . . It was pounds ($70,000). Thirty Ausch- World Jewish Congress in France though he, too, was D u 11 e s' be devastating to simultaneously bedeviled by his witz survivors, from the United has been outlined by the affilia- confessor." the best interests own hyperintense religious pas- States, France, Israel, Poland and tion of three local representative The author of this explosive o f t h e entire sions deep in the recesses of his Austria, testified during the 18-day bodies to the WJC's French Sec- world. I ego. All contradicted each other work had "a long and instructive trial in six languages. tion. Dr. Finer refers even as they were contradicted discussion" of the issue with The trial centered on a pass- The global organization's Paris to Nasser's "dis- by reality. These sentimentalisms President Eisenhower who pro- age from "Exodus" which accus- bureau notes the affiliation of the fedayeen and idees fixes were functionally vided him with information on the patch of Jewish Consistoires of Bas Rhin, ed a "Dr. Dehring" of perform- to perpetrate disabling. And, furthermore, faced subject. Dr. Finer also consulted Haut Rhin and Moselle. These ing 17,000 "experiments" in Dulles murder and arson with reality and stultified by a former Vice President Richard three organizations, embodying the surgery without anesthetics. lists scores of other Nixon and he want of courage." in Israel." He condemns Dulles' The defendants, Uris and his total Jewish community of the world leaders with whom he had actions at the UN as a "dubious In addition to the charge that British publishers, William Kimber area, represent the 40,000 Jews affair" and charges that "the out- Dulles was frightened over pos- personal interviews and who were who live in Alsace-Lorraine. come of his policy was a signal sible Soviet repercussions, Dr. the "principal sources for this In other parts of France, the book." drawals from Sinai, an assurance injustice for Britain, France and Finer maintains that the late Sec- local Consistoires are by no means Dr. Finer points out that Dulles of protection against Nasser, Israel." He declares: retary of State misjudged the as representative as those in Al- "Either he was insincere in his results of the withdrawal of the viewed Israel as a suppliant and Dulles and Eisenhower attempted sace-Lorraine and as a result, the Pressure on American Jews and resented the action that was taken pronouncements that he was pur- U. S. offer for the Aswan Dam, Zionists. But the American spokes- WJC's French Section has estab- suing the Rule of Law. or his that he was confused by Nasser's in 1956 by the little state that was lished committees of its own in 40 on American aid for its men did not reveal that Eisen- moralism overcame any prudent "timid and tortuous diplomacy" dependent major cities. hower already had promised Ibn assessment of the national interest and refused to prevent payment existence. The United Nations under Ham- Saud that Israel's troops would of the United States. Or, perhaps, of tolls at Suez by American ships, A GOOD MAN TO KNOW ! his tactics were a mask for his that he did not properly explain marskjold, too, is viewed as having be withdrawn. Dr. Finer's charge is that "Dulles physical fear of the Soviet Union." the U. S. Suez policy to our allies failed to solve the problem of the I did not intend to give justice as There is the additional charge and that he muffed on the arms I Arab hostility toward Israel, For Some asked for by Ben-Gurion" because and deals between the Soviets The chapter "Israel Resists that "Dulles failed in fortitude "Nasser had taken Dulles to the of the the 'Double Law' is vital. It brink." and sound reason when he sub- Egypt. reveals the uphill struggle Is- mitted to Arab and Asian accusa- best buys "Whatever one may think of When the Suez mess ended. Dr. rael experienced in seeking jus- Finer believes it ended for Dulles lions of his allies' colonialism." the wisdom and expediency of on new tice during that trying period making war on Egypt, there was but not for Israel. The devious An important reference to the in history. It shows how deter- hardly left to Britain, France methods of Dulles are blamed for Pontiacs Position of Russian Jewry, with mined Dulles was to punish the the sad position in which Israel the charge of additional blunders and Israel any alternative to and to appease little state in order was placed by Eisenhower and such a course except surrender in this diplomatic sphere, contains Nasser, and how Eisenhower his Secretary of State. Tempest the following views expressed by to Nasser, once Dulles' timid went along with him. In his investigation of the facts, and tortuous diplomacy had de- Prof. Finer: It shows how Hammarskjold Dr. Finer makes a. statement that layed, confused and weakened "Most of the Arab nations, played his cards to keep Israel's is applicable today: "Nasser, with them," Prof. Finer declares. including Egypt, have drawn fortunes down, and how Henry Moscow's resolute aid, succeeds in- "He underestimated their ten- back from the Russian embrace, Cabot Lodge was the tool of both timidating America, Britain and acity and undervalued their na- AT realizing that it is fatal. It was Dulles and Eisenhower in his acts France. Justice is abandoned and tional interests and their con- Dulles' grave misjudgment to against Israel. peace becomes more precarious cern for their national dignity, believe they would ever have On the contrary, Senator Ful- than ever." And much of the blame 18650 LIVERNOIS while overindulging Nasser's succumbed to it, Dam or no 1 block South of 7 bright then was sympathetic to for it is pinned on the "hero" corresponding interests and con- Dam, Suez or no Suez. The Rus- UN 3-9300 Israel. The then - Senator (now exposed. in 'Dulles Over Suez." cern. The Suez war having sian intrusion into Egypt remains President) Lyndon B. Johnson pro- broken out, because his own strong, however, for all sorts of tested against "one rule for the proposals had been flouted by arms still flow from the Russian strong and another for the weak" Nasser (with Moscow and Bel- bloc, and (since 1959) Russia is and Senator Knowland, the Repub- grade in support), Dulles al- building the Aswan Dam. But lican Majority Leader • in the lowed his personal indignation the more crucial and enduring Senate (Prof. Finer calls him and his personal moral proctor- grip that Russia has over Nas- obstreperous but with a strong ship to govern the foreign policy ser derives from another power- sense of right and wrong) joined of America. He totally aban- political factor altogether. At Senator- Johnson in a strong pro- doned a feasible insistence on any moment Moscow could allow test against Eisenhower's desire a constructive settlement of the a quarter- or half-million Rus- to impose sanctions on Israel. issue that had caused the out- sian Jews to leave the Soviet Abba Eban was treated badly by break of war. He was abjectly Union for Israel, by opening the Dulles, and Prof. Finer comments: intimidated by the seething eas- possibility to them and supply- "If Israel had depended on Dulles sions of the Afro-Asian nations, ing the exit permits. Nasser alone. it would by now (1957) had transmitted to him by Henry prefers to have these potential been on the list of victims of the Cabot Lodge, whose own per- emigrants imprisoned in Russia crimes of which he accused the sonal susceptibilities amplified rather than have them in Israel Soviet Union." their hysteria. Dulles' intellec- to help guard Israel's borders Indeed, Dulles. who never pre- viously helped Israel in any way, is shown suddenly to have begun to say kind words about Israel— as part of the scheme to force Israel out of Gaza. Other senators joined John- son and Knowland in their opposition to the Dulles-Eisen- hower - Hammarskjold - Lodge SUNDAY, MAY 24, 1964 at Kfar Silver, Agricultural Training School plan to punish Israel. JULY 6, 1964 - AUGUST 23, 1964 "The nation was in an uproar, Non-Profit Educational Project 4:30 P.M. 1 :30 to the credit. of its sense of fair Activities include Conversational Hebrew, Seminars, Israeli Songs and play and common sense about Dances, Sightseeing throughout Israel, Land and Water Sports, etc. power and ethical realities in TOTAL COST $950.00 the world of nations," Dr. Finer 2660 HAGGERTY Chorges cover all educational and recreational activities, field trips, declares. lodging, food, (dietary laws observed) medical care, and transportation Because Israel resisted, demand- V2 Mile South of 12 Mile from New York City to Israel and return. ing as a condition for troop with- Packer Pontiac Favors - Food - For All - Fun ANNUAL OPEN HOUSE ZOA SUMMER TEENAGE CAMP IN ISRAEL Camp Directors: RABBI & MRS. GILBERT EPSTEIN For Information Write or Call: Zionist Organization of Detroit, 25219 Southfield Rd., Southfield, Mich. — 353-3636 THE DETROIT JEWISH NEWS Friday, May 15, 1964 14 MA 6-6308 39th Annual Spring Concert —Detroit Jewish Folk Chorus— Conducted by Harvey Schreibman SUNDAY, JUNE 7th Tsvei Brider 8:00 P.M., AT THE SCOTTISH RITE CATHEDRAL — MASONIC TEMPLE The TWO BROTHERS Text by I. L. Peretx; Music by Jacob Schaefer Guest Artist: NORMAN ATKINS "A Brilliant Baritone Voice" —new York Times Guest Artist: MARJORIE GORDON "Excellent . . . Exemplary Clearness and —New York Times Brilliance" TICKETS FROM MEMBERS OF CHORUS; CALL DI 1-9231 or BR 2-0330; or at BOX OFFICE EVE OF PERFORMANCE