20 — THE DETROIT JEWISH NEWS -- Friday, July 7, 1961 'Detroit Conductor Herschel Leib, Betsy Kanter Wed Cantor's Son, Recalls Life of Music to Joel M. Cohen By CHARLOTTE HYAMS The Jews haven't had a coun- try long enough to claim a music of their own. It is a mistake, then, to call one month of the year "Jewish Music Month," according to. Herschel Leib, director of the Detroit Concert Band. He con- cedes that Israeli music is "go- HERSCHEL LEIB ing places," but "How can we call synagogue music, or Yid- dish songs, of Israeli composi- tions, or anything by a Jewish composer 'Jewish music?' None of these really represents the Jewish people. It's not authen- tic." Leib _is sure his view is not a popular one, but with a musi- cal experience of more years than he cares to count, and an extensive Jewish background that stems from • his cantor- father, he bases his judgment on more than casual interest. - Nevertheless, the Detroit Concert Band conductor (the name is a new one; it was formerly known as the Sum- mer Parks Band because the eight-week concert series is played each night at a dif- ferent city park) speaks ani- matedly of Yiddish and He- brow melodies, and to illus- trate their adaptability "to any occasion" likes to hum snatches of "Eli, Eli" or "Havah Nagilah." Although Leib's voice bears Marilyn Lucas Wins Music Scholarship to Tanglewood Center Marilyn Lucas, 18-year-old pi- anist, has been named the recipi- ent of the National Federation of Music Clubs Scholarship to Tanglewood at the Berkshire Music Center in 'Lenox, Mass. Miss Lucas, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Samuel B. Lucas, 19481 Mark Twain, started her piano studies at four, made her debut at 13, and has been on several occasions soloist with the Jewish Center Symphony Orchestra and the Wayne State University Sym- phony Orchestra. A piano major at Wayne State University, she is a former student of Julius Chajes and is presently studying with Eleanor Lipkin Rocchi. Educational TV Award Given to Bnai Brith's ADL for Drama Show ATLANTIC CITY, (JTA) — The national "S c h o o 1 Bell Award" for an outstanding edu- cational television program was presented here to the Anti- Defamation League of Bnai Brith for a full-hour dramatic program, "A Question of Chairs: The Challenge of - American Education." The program had been broad- cast last January by CBS-TV network in conjunction with the ADL's annual meeting and is now being shown before edu- cational and civic groups throughout the country. The presentation was made at the convention of ,the National. Edu- cation Association. no resemblance to the soprano he once offered as a boy in the choir of the famous cantor Meisels. ("I offered him a ruble to let me sing under him") he still demonstrates the vocal training his father gave him back in the home town of Eka- terinoslav, Ukraine, today known as Dniperpetrovsk. It was a town that boasted great cantors, and there was much competition among syn- agogues, and even opera com- panies, to win the favors of the hazzan. But the comfortable life came to an end with a threatened pogrom. Cantor Leibovitch left for America to find a job, and eight months later nine-year- old Herschel, his mother and six brothers and sisters, arrived in New York, shortly before an anti-Jewish riot killed a number of their former fellow townsmen. `VAUDEVILLE-. SHOW' In those days of mass im- migration, Leib's education - was not unlike that of many other young musicians. He picked up his formal education where he could — in Birmingham, Min- neapolis, St. Louis, Toledo, wherever his father the cantor happened to be called. Leib continued to practice violin, to sing in and direct his father's choir. And he work- ed in a butcher's shop to help out at home. They were hard years, and Leib speaks bitterly of "the vaudeville show" that used to characterize the life of a can- tor, hired for a short period and then dismissed at will. But Leib learned to love synagogue music with all its shades of meaning ("Do you know why the Jews so love the minor chord in their music? Because the minor key represents the tragedy of their history").. The son of the Orthodox can- tor launched his first three- piece orchestra in a burlesque theater in Toledo. "Burlesque wasn't then what it is now, of course. I learned a great deal about playing for musical shows, and when I came to Detroit in 1922 for the opening of the Capitol Theater, I was ready to play for- opera and ballet." In the silent movie era, he picked up a phenomenal mental music library, playing at the Fisher and Adams, State and Fox theaters. "Music for films was a big production," Leib said. "At the Fox in 1931 we worked seven days 'and seven nights, 100 men in my orchestra presenting a real stage show." Leib finally arrived at the Niederlaenders' Shubert Thea- ter and has been house leader there and at the Riviera 'ever since. RUNS IN THE FAMILY The family's- musical talent, however, is not limited to Her- schel Leib. His three brothers distribute their interests like so: Max leads the orchestra at Northland and Cass Theaters; Sam plays the bass; and Sol, of California, is a cellist. Leib's older brother, Isadore i now de- ceased, played the violin, and his daughter Bernice, who pass- ed away three years ago, stud- ied piano. Leib's wife, the form- er Minnie Gordon of Canton, 0., while not a musician, comes from a long line of cantors. And as the tradition goes in the Leibovitch family of Eka- terinoslav, the musical talent passes from father to son. Don- ald Leib, 37, is a clarinetist in the Belle Isle Band, teaches music in the Livonia Public Schools and plays under his father in the theater. And Leib's 21/2-year-old granddaugh- ter?, "Why .of course she'll study music." He Wouldn't Fly Secession Flag David Einhorn, Freedom Rider'1861 By DAVID SCHWARTZ (Copyright, 1961, Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Inc.) MRS. JOEL COIIEN Mr. and Mrs. Joel Mitchell Cohen left for a Bermuda honey- moon following their marriage June 25 at Adas Shalom Syna- gogue. Rabbi Jacob Segal and Cantor Nicholas Fenakel officiated. The bride- is the former Betsy Sue Kanter, daughter of Dr. and Mrs. Norman Kanter of North- lawn Ave. The bridegroom is the son of Mrs. Ethel Cohen of Dex- ter Blvd. and Nathan Cohen of the Fort Wayne Hotel. The gown worn by the bride was ivory silk mist in princess lines with rounded neckline and empire bodice of appliqued peau de lange lace. The dome-shaped, floor-length skirt with garlands of matching lace fell into a chapel train. A tiara of heirloom orange blossoms held her two-tiered fin- gertip veil of illusion ivory silk. Mrs. Alvin Buch was her sis- ter's matron of honor. Brides- maids were Audrey Kramer, Sue Mandell and Gail Shapiro. Gail and Marcy Greenbert were the junior bridesmaid s. Robert Cohen, brother of the bridegroom was best man and seating the guests were Dr. Harold Green- bert, Alvin Buch, Sheldon Rock- lin, Herbert Polk," Arnold Mon- drow, Robert Wolfe and Larry Edelheit. Educator Says . Is Education in adeq e' `Tragicall Ont., (JT •‘) HALLIB T S wish educator --A lea g ere at Jewish edu- charge cation n the United States is "tr 'tally inadeq an is - "n furthe ica Was s ular ed n of the c to at the x Baer, n o a dire Dr. ai Brith th Org of the tion, to the annual con ere Young A of Bnai drastic st b that there overhauling o it will Jewish schools so d of subject- child-centered in the needs of centered, refle today's youth of of their grand- parents." Baer sug sted a "coordin approach t Jewis:Scoli local corn nities." New Y k's 3,00 t 000 Passes NEW Y K, (JTA) — of ish Appe United k d 19th6 e Greater New its $23,000,000 ma campaign during "Fat elep one Son Day" in th eadquarters, rooms at UJA where 400 vo Leer workers, o generations, representing special "person- participated icitations. to-person" vernor and ex .S. Former rbert H. Leh Senator' telet n. headed t gner, Robert F. rk 's the New unit mit- sectarian C nor. He of tee, was a g - made was awarded silver - plaque ins eo- notable service to Isra ple„" Want ads bring fast result The chaplain of Yale Univer- sity who was arrested along with the Freedom Riders in Missis- sippi, is married to the daughter of the famous Jewish pianist, Artur Rubenstein. The story of this preacher reminded me of Rabbi David Einhorn of Balti- more, who did a little battling for freedom back in 1861. The pro-slavery forces were strong in Maryland. It was there that the abolitionist, Garrison, first tasted prison. In 1861, the anti-Union, anti-Lincoln senti- ment there reached fever heat. Mobs even dared attack Union soldiers. David Einhorn however, rose in his pulpit to attack slav- ery. He was warned repeatedly, but he did not waver. Most of the ' churches and other buildings flew the seces- sion flag. Members of his congre- gation said to him, "Rabbi, we've got to hang that flag, too. Our temple will be destroyed wise." But David Einh woul not permit it. The mob gr w fiercer. Einhorn w. told that his life was in d er. The Members o his con gation, even differe ith his view horn great 're • - Davi Einh or was o- - e ps dozen f the -atest Americ as see He w ceptional ebrew - versed in philosophy and a nobility of char Since the abbi woul yield, so of his formed oluntl pro- tect him om 'th s() it was n that y would be able shie im. night of ril , 18 Einhorn w orced more Severa was more Rabbi orn come b , but his con gation keep s t on slavery. He ref d. He left Saltimor going firs Philadelphia ally to N ork. mil G. Hirsc e of Ein horn that he belonged to the great leaders of abolition along with Phillips, Beecher and Garri- son and would have been bracketed with them in American history except for the fact that he preached in German. (The great majority of American Jews of that day were of German origin.) West Germany to Loan $250 Million to UAR BONN, (JTA) — A loan of a billion deutschemarks ($250,- 000,000) will be granted by the government of West Germany to the United Arab Republic, it was announced here by the Economic Ministry. After two days of - negotia- tions by Vice Premier Boughadi of the UAR, and Ludwig Er- hardt, West German Minister of Economic Affairs, it was de- cided that West Germany would finance the construction of the Euphrates dam in Syria, as well as other industrial projects in the UAR. Chancellor Konrad Adenauer nuonced that 'he plans to visit UAR next year. Want The Best? Ask the Folks Who've Had SAM BARN ETT and His Orchestra LI 1-2563 J. is CLARKE PHOTOGRAPHY Weddings - Bar Mitzvahs Formals, Candids, 3 D's, Movies For Quality Workmanship Call Mr. Rosen NOUNC1NG .. UN 1-9000 your Simcha Bright! the Band that's Right!! m LONDON ENGLAND n GILBERT HIS ORCHESTRA "The right mood for the right occasion" CALL UN 1-3065 • THE OPENING OF TERIORS By PHIL MORGANROTH N.A.D.A.—Registered Decorator Consultant UPHOLSTERING—DRAPERIES Lincoln 8-0611- 14520 Rosemary Oak Park, Mich. Residence Lincoln 7-8858 ake Our Own Glasses . HEADQUARTERS FOR • LATEST DOMESTIC AND IM- PORTED FRAME FASHIONS • PRESCRIPTIONS FOR GLASSES ACCURATELY FILLED • Reasonably Priced • Immediate Repair — ASK ABOUT OUR CONTACT LENS — ROSEN OPTICAL SERVICE 13720 W. 9 MILE nr. COOLIDGE LI 7-5068 OAK PARK, MICH. Hours: Daily & 'Sat. 9:30 a.m. 6 p.m. — Thursddys to 9 p.m. -