Robert S. Tuimatt Dies; Temple Israel Cantor Fled from Nazis Robert S. Tulman, who for 19 years served as cantor of Temple Israel, died May 24, at his home, 1'7144 Stoepel. In ill health for the last two years, Cantor Tulman had never fully recovered from major brain surgery at that time. He was ap pointed cantor of Temple Is- rael when it was organized in 1941, and was signed?. after Rabbit, Le on Fram, spiritual lead- er of the con- gregation, heard him au- Cantor Tullman dition in New York. At one time he was consid- ered to have the "most beau- tiful tenor voice in Detroit," a comment ascribed to the late Fred M. Butzel. He concertized extensively • in the community and on tour, and taught many boys from Temple Israel fam- ilies their Bar Mitzvah maftirs. Although he tried several times, in recent months, to re- turn to the profession he loved he could not stand for any great period of time. He had always hoped to be able to sing again at Temple Israel. The 56-year-old cantor was born in Epatoria in the Russian Crimea. He was the son of a cantor, from whom he learned the profession. He studied music at Odessa and later in Italy, singing in the opera houses of Italy, Russia, France and Germany. At Weis- baden, Germany, where he set- tled, Cantor Tulman became the leading tenor. In 1933, because he was a - r Builder Ben Nosanchuk Dies After Short Illness Ben Nosanchuk, a prominent local builder, died May 23, at Highland Park General Hospi- tal after a brief illness. He had resided at 15120 Pembroke. Born in Russia, Mr. Nosan- chuk lived in Detroit since his boyhood.. He was president of the Nosan and Pearl Building Corp., and was a member of Phoenicia Lodge, F.&A.M., the Detroit Consistory and the Me- tropolitan Detroit Bildors As- sociation. He leaves his wife, Pearl; two sons, Manny and William; his father, Louis; three brothers, Morris, Max and Harry; a sister, Mrs. Sol Sklar; and six grand- children. VIM MEM Obituaries Jew, Cantor Tulman was forced to give up his position. In Aus- tria and Czechoslovakia, he also was required to leave when the Nazis took over the countries. He came to the United States in 1939, and abandoned his ca- reer in opera when he was of- fered the position at Temple Is- rael. Services for Cantor Tulman were held Thursday, at the tem- ple, with burial in Beth El Me- morial Park. He leaves his wife, Rachel; a brother and a sister in Tel Aviv, Israel, and a sister in Paris, France. David Idzal Dies at 63 David M. Idzal, who was prominently identified with the theater for 30 years, and was the manager of the Fox Theater for many years, died Monday in his Park Shelton Hotel apartment at the age of 63. He is survived by his daugh- ter, Mrs. Leslie R. Winegarden, of Flint, and sisters, Mrs. Sam- uel Glassman and Miss Mariam Idzal. A past president of the De- troit Society of Crippled Chil- dren, Idzal was active in' Allied Jewish Campaigns and in a number of other movements and was a member of Temple Beth El, Standard Club, Moslem Temple and Rotary Club. Three years ago, sIdzal went to Israel to supervise the con- struction of the newest movie theater in Tel Aviv. He lived in Israel for more than a year to watch the completion of that task. Anna'S. Rothenberg Dies Anna Schomer Rothenberg, who was known as a leading Hebrew and Yiddish folk singer, died May 18 in her home in New York at the age of 75. She was the daughter- of the eminent Yiddish actor and playwright, Nalum Shomer, and the divorced wife of the late Judge Morris Rothenberg, who was one of the prominent Zionists and a past president of the Zionist Organization of America. Moe Sussman Dies Moe A. Sussman, who was the founder mid co-owner of Suss- man's. Print Shop, 11826* Dexter, died Tuesday in Mt. Carmel Hospital after a lengthy illness. Mr. Sussman, a member of Cong. Bnai Zion, leaves his wife, Sadie; two sons, Benjamin and Herman; a daughter, Edith; a sister, five grandchildren and three great grandchildren. BY HENRY LEONARD 168 "Me loin a Temple, Sam, for what purpose? My daughter was married at the Chateau, my son will be Bar-Mitzvah at Hotel McAlister . . . and when I pats on, there are a dozen mortuaries eager to do the lob." eppr. 196P, Leonard Prtfikin ABRAHAM JACOBS, of. Mi- ami Beach, Fla., died May 18 in Detroit. Services and interment in Detroit. He leaves three sons, Sam, Donald and Morris; four daughters, Mrs. Jay Joseph, Mrs. Joe Steiner, Mrs. Louis Eisen- berg and Mrs. Helen Weingar- den, of Miami; 17 grandchildren and a great grandchild. * * * SHERILL W. SHAP OFF, 19941 Steel, died May 18. He leaves his wife, Adeline; two sons, Marc and Alan; a daugh- ter, Barbara; his father, Mose Shapoff, of Camden, N. J., and a brother. * * * DAVID NUSHZNO, of En- cino, Calif., died in Detroit, May 19. Services and interment in Detroit. He leaves his wife, Anna; a daughter, Mrs. Louis Geer; a grandchild and a great grandchild. * * * IRVING GOODMAN, 17151 San Juan, died May 19. He leaves his wife, Jean; a son, Loren; a daughter, Mrs. William Stoler; his father, Hyman Good- man; two brothers, three sis- ters and two grandchildren. * * * RUTH- BASSIN, 18237 Hub- bell, died May 19. She leaves her husband, Max; a daughter, Linda Sue; her parents, Mr. and Mrs. Hyman Bassin; and three sisters. * * * ABE SMOLOWITZ, 12909 Borgman, Huntington Woods, died May 20. He leaves his wife, Nell; and a daughter, Marsha. * * * LEO M. RUBENSTEIN, 20032 Sorrento, died May 20. He leaves his wife, Hazel; a son, Stanley; a daughter, Ann; a sister and four grandchildren. ANNA GERSHBERG, 11501 Petoskey, died May 21. She leaves a daughter, Mrs. Abra- ham Shulevitz; a granddaughter and three great grandchildren. * * * MORRIS EINSTANDIG, 11501 Petoskey, died May 23. He leaves three sons, Harr y, Philip and Newton; four daugh- ters, Mrs. Moe Buchalter and Mrs. Jack Greenberg, of Chi- cago, Mrs. Barney Shatz and Mrs. Ben K a t s e r; 12 grand- children and 11 great grand- children. * * * MARTIN K •O V A C S, 16205 Woodingham, died May 23. He leaves a brother, Ben Corn, of Cleveland; and four sister s, Mrs. Louis Rice and Mrs. Max Simon, of Cleveland, and Mrs. Ines Brown and Mrs.„ Rudy Esko. Describing Judaism and Christianity as the Same Called 'Cheap Good Will' WASHINGTON — Describing Judaism and Christanity by their similarities can be "su- perficial and cheap good will," says a Jewish authority on the New Testament. Dr. Samuel Sandmel, provost of the Hebrew Union College— Jewish Institute of Religion in Cincinnati, argues that genuine good will "implies acknowl- edged differences accompanied by reciprocal respect." In a pamphlet for teenagers, "Judaism and Christianity," published by Bnai Brith Youth Organization, Dr. Sandmel de- clares that an understanding of religious differences strength- ens Judaism among Jews. He couples an appeal to young Jews to learn more about other religions with a warning that they must first "thoroughly master their own Judaism." His own wish "to understand Christianity accurately and sympathetically" in no way compromises his "undiluted loyalty to Judaism," says Dr. Sandmel. Honor NatioWs War Dead at Service of Veterans, Synagogue Groups . Veterans groups from the ciety will hold Memorial Day American Legion and Jewish services together with the Jul- War Veterans will join with ius Rosenwald Post of the 'synagogues 'and cemetery as- American Legion at 2 p.m., sociations in traditional serv- Monday, in the veterans section ices and ceremonies in observ- of Chesed shel Emes Cemetery ance of Memorial Day this Sun- (Hebrew Memorial Park), 14 day and Monday. Mile and Gratiot. Rabbi Samuel H. Prero . will The Department of Michigan, Jewish War Veterans will hold officiate at the observance, to- special memorial services com- gether with Joseph Goldstein memorating the 15th annivers- and Joseph Shapiro, command- ary of the end of World War er and adjutant of the Rosen- II on the lawn of the JWV Me- wald Post, and Nathan P. Ros- morial Home at 11 a.m., Sun- sen, Louis Rose and Harry Port- ner, president, vice-president day. Rabbi Morris Adler, JWV De- and cemetery chairman of the partment chaplain, will offici- Hebrew Benevolent Society. Members of the Post will ate, and members of the Gold Star Parents and all Posts and meet at 9 a.m., that day for its Auxiliaries in the area will par- annual breakfast at Eddie's. At ticipate. The Lansing Post will 11 a.m., they will join JWV present a new 50-star AmeriCan units in the services at Mach- pelah before proceeding to flag to the Home. Chesed shel Ernes for the day's The Department also will final services. hold services at 11 a.m., Mon- day, in the military section of Technion Confers 577 Degrees Machpelah Cemetery, Wood- The largest number of degrees ward at 8% Mile Rd. Relatives ever awarded in one year by and friends are invited to at- the Technion, Israel Institute tend the service. of Technology, was conferred Irving S. Cane, JWV com- here upon 577 graduates of the mander, will preside at both Institute. services. The Bachelor of Science deg- Services by Cong. Shaarey ree was awarded to 404 gradu- Zedek at Clover Hill Park Cem- ates; the professional degree etery, in conjunction with Shol- of Ingenieur to 113; Master of om Post of the JWV, will be Science, 48; Doctor ate in held at 11 a.m., Monday, at the Science or in Technical Sci- cemetery, 14 Mile Rd., east of ences, 12. Woodward. Rabbi Morris Adler will lead Hebrew Corner responsive reading, and Rabbi Irwin Groner will deliver the MeMorial Day • address. Cantors Zobarim Together Jacob H. Sonenklar and Reuven with New 'Olim' Frankel and the synagogue Translation of Hebrew Column choir directed by Dan Frohman, (Published by the Brit Ivrit Olamit) will officiate. When three years ago Yechiel Erez came to a settlement of new Other participants are Julius immigrants in the mountains of Jer- Goldstein, past commander, and usalem he found fifty-five families Kurdistan there. The situation Fred Sorkow, commander of the from in the village was difficult; for Sholom Post, and Milton M. though the immigrants knew how to tend fruit trees they did not Maddin,' chairman of the board know the meaning of a budget or of of trustees for the congregation. cooperation. Yechiel was the social instructor Patriotic exercises at Oak of the Jewish Agency. Instead- of View Cemetery are planned going home every evening as is he brought his wife, Ed- jointly by Cong. Bnai Moshe and customary, na, and their one-month old son Lt. Bloch-Gen. Rose Post of the with him to the village. They were followed to Even JWV in honor of the nation's Sapir by another Zabar family, war dead at 12 noon, Monday. David Eichenbaum who worked in the University in Jerusalem, his Boy Scouts and Cub Scouts wife Rachel, who was a teacher and will participate in the service.- their daughter Dinah, who was ten years old. First of"all Rachel taught The memorial address will be the inhabitants to read and to write. given by Rabbi Moses, Lehrman, After a while David stopped work, ing in Jerusalem and together with and other speakers will be Mel- his wife established a rural educa- center for the villages of the. vin Weisz, Bnai Moshe vice- tion neighborhood. Sixty inhabitants of president, and Morris Elken, seven villages come twice a week to Post" commander. Cantor Louis Even Sapir to- study Hebrew and arithmetic. In the school there is Klein will chant the memorial also a high school class and here the working youth of all the vil- prayers. lages of the neighborhood receive The Hebrew Benevolent So- special lessons. . trzir 134 ‘?iv bv In! trIs rart? "AO intgkt • 7htti ,n49 nr41 ,rr-pn mrp-T itg LIBnItti7L? r3,4y nVir! rir.i7T itg 14t*??, ,n!'pttprr. rri r rpz? '701 .it47 n4 ;vinri nrt nirlYV? tti??r,.11 tiV7?r! nt.1 1 7 -111gRI n*n r .1tpniiw? •nh t ?`.1 n??"Mi it#7 n:j p4pp;:1 'P -1717-1 1 3 1.1 . " "; rx,'?ir,7t# z7ptoz? imAt 13V In' trpm si7 ,npri-4g174, '24 44 ri'7 .fP'? "IPz 117; .arid v10 •r14.4 t?n TlInn n:rj '7rr.11' trkq rany .n4-prrri vpion nvol? ;14 P0- P L? vintP n4PPD `7? rirTrnri toip74 •Iintr1 ) ny, 1 2 nrip =-.); t1 rirP r4ttj! van 134z?7_r? inVkt n.41 14 11 -44pn z7V`qiIrrT i .ritt:11 -74 ItT,17.1 trirrz triirtti 13 14Pt?"7W? nrri nr:141.nx, 1 :11 ,n142 '7t# rirj.V?? r),1; rit3i.n?) —14,41x4 -pvtg ,tpacq:d ,17r11 T " 4