— 21 — Purely Commentary: By Philip Slomovitz lions as a First Lieutenant in the U. S. Army in World War II, he is deeply interested in Israel and is assisting the country economically in his present capacity. Hordes and Feinberg were in Detroit several months ago and conceived the idea of establishing supermarkets, patterned after thoSe in their native city, for the Israelis. They felt that through such an effort they could help solve Israel's food problems and assist in reducing the cost of living. They enlisted the support of men well known in the supermarket industry in Detroit—John . Lu- rie, Nathan Lurie and Sam Frankel, of the Wrigley chain; Tom Borman and Abe Borman, of Food Fair; and Irwin Cohn, all of Detroit, and Bertram Loeb of Montreal. Israelis in the main were enthusiastic about their scheme, and they were heartened by the encourage- ment they received from -the Minister of Trade and Industry, Pinchas Sapir. The middlemen's newspaper Haboker and the rightists' Herut gives the plan strong backing. But the labor daily Davar is critical of the idea. It follows the line of the Tnuva, the Israeli food distributing cooperative organization, which desires to share in the plan by having control of the food distribution. Hordes and Feinberg seek independence from Tnuva. They have made arrangements with inde- Israel — a Land of Miracles and 1 Firsts: Even the initial rainfall of the year provides a sense of accom- plishment. pendent cooperative settlements to supply them with food, and they hope to be able to retain independence from the Tnuva, which is controlled by the Histadrut, the Israel Federation of Labor. The hornet's nest has been stirred, and the con- troversy goes on. Predictions as to the results of this dispute vary in accordance with one's political views, but in the main Israelis appear to be sympathetic to the idea. A chief objection to the plan comes from the small grocerymen, of whom there are untold num- bers wherever one turns in Israel. Wherever a new settlement arises, there immediately spring up these small groceries, and some fear that super- markets will drive too many of them out of busi- ness. Meanwhile, Hordes and Feinberg have come to an agreement with Rassco—the Rural and Suburban Settlement Co.—for the construction of the first supermarket. Rassco has undertaken to build a nine- story structure on Beth Yehudah Street, one of Tel Aviv's main thoroughfares. A 10,000 square foot su- permarket will be provided the Detroiters on the ground floor and the balance of the building will be used for office space to be rented to space-hungry Israeli industrialists. The two Detroiters plan to pattern their business after that of Detroit's supermarkets, and they also plan to use the differing methods of Switzerland and England that are applicable to Israel. Detroit-Backed Company Aids Israel's Rebuilding Philip Slomovitz, editor of the Detroit Jewish News, and Mrs. Slomovitz have been visiting in Israel. This is another of his spe- cial reports for the Free Press. By PHILIP SLOMOVITZ Editor, The Jewish News, HAIFA, Israel — In the Evan Vashid Building in this Israel port city there are offices of the Rock Products Corp., one of the largest private invest- ments made by Americans in be- half of Israel's reconstruction. It is strictly a Detroit project in Israel, and a number of the' leading Jews in Detroit are par- ticipants in it. S lo m o v itz While the ma- jor contribution toward the de- velopment of Israel's economy is being made in the United States through the sale of Israel Bonds, numerous private investment ef- forts have been made, and the Rock Products is proving one of the most productive. * * * THE PLANT, located In the Wilhelm district between Lydda Thursday, Oct. 31, 1957 Detroit Free Press-1S in this project exceeded $600,000, and there was added to it a sim- ilar investment by its Israel coun- terpart. It was a struggling enterprise for the first three years. This year, however, the corporation hopes to net a profit of 400,000 Israel pounds—the American dollar now being valued at 1.8 pounds. Within a short time, at this rate, the Detroit group hopes to wipe out the losses sustained at the beginning of the enterprise and eventually to benefit from a profit- able concern. There are other private invest- ments in Israel by Detroiters. Leon Kay has planted more than 100 dunams (25 acres) of orange plantations with the Mehadrin, Ltd., in honor of his son Barry S. Kay, and he speaks with pride of the sign at the Mehadrin planta-: tions with his son's name. Similar investments have been made by Morris Schaver, for his son, Isaac, and- by a number of other Detroiters who desire to as- sist newcomers to Israel by help- ing them become self-supporting— through industrial enterprises. Israel's major industries are fi- nanced by Israel Bonds, in whose campaigns more than 6,000 Detroit THE DETROITERS' investment Jews are counted as participants. and Tel Aviv, produces large rocks for water-retaining at beaches and breakwaters and smaller rocks for road-building. It also produces sand for finer concrete and aggre- gate mixes for concrete. The Detroit group's investment is part of the Israel America Ag- gregates Corp., a combination of two equal stockholders — Evan Vashid and Rock Products. They own, together, five quarries and crushing plants, and operate a large trucking service. This project had its foundation in a study made of Israel's needs by Leon Kay, Detroit engineer, who was one of the owners of the Keystone Oil Refining - CO. Upon his recommendations, he was joined in initiating The Rock Products effort by Israel Davidson, of the Federal Department Stores; Abe Kasle. of Kasle Steel Corp.; David and Hyman Safran, printers; William Roth, of Frigid Food Corp., who now is president • of the corporation; Irwin I. Cohn, Louis Berry, Edward C. Levy; Joseph Holtzman, Alfred A. May, Tom Borman, Philip Lipson, 111orris Schaver, Benjamin Wilk, Richard' Sloan and a number of other prom- inent Detroit industrialists. , cs, t:, O 4.,