20 Obituaries SHIRLEY KRIM, 26, 925_' Whit- MALVIENE LIPCHINSKY, 3246 more, died March 4, in Los An- Elmhurst, died March 3. Ser- geles. Services and burial were vices at Kaufman Chapel. She in Detroit. She leaves her broth- leaves her sbn, Harvey; daugh- ers. Sol, Mac, Harry and/Leon- ters, Mrs. Arthur Miller and ard; and a sister, Mrs. Camille Mrs. Albert Conn; father, Mar- Kessler, of Los Angeles. tin Hersko; and seven sisters, * * * Mrs. Max Freedman, Mrs. Mil- . SARAH KURLANSIK, 51, 18242 ton Stearn, Mrs. Nicholas Bou: Freeland, died March 9. She ras, Mrs. Alex Weiss, Mrs. BE;ri leaves her husband. Michael; Greenberg. Mrs. Amos Miller and sons, Julius Kurlansik and Mil- Mrs. Irwin White. * * * ton Eisenberg; and daughters. Mrs. William Rockman and DAVID LEVY. 6450 London, Rhea. died March 3. Services at Kauf- • * m a n Chapel. He leaves his ROSE SEGERMAN, 3358 Tay- daughter, Mrs. Otto Hyman; lor. died March 3. Services were and grandaughter, Gail. at Benevolent Chapel. She is * * * survived by her husband, Joseph: ANNA LEVINE, 2640 Sturte- son, Morton; daughter. Jacque- vant, died' March 5 in California. line Sally; brothers, David Good- Services at Kaufman Chapel. man. Max Goodman of Tucson; She leaves her husband, Hyman; sister. Mrs. Sylvia Auster of Tuc- sons, Joseph, Harry S., J. Phillip son. Levant and Melvin M.; and • three daughters, Mrs. Clara ANNIE GOLDENBERG. 2640 Rosenberger. Mrs. Florence Paul Gla.dstone, died March 3. She is and Mrs..Morris Gold. survived by sons, Irving of Mon- • • . treal. Louis and Rubin; daugh- ROBERT MORRISON. 57. a ter. Betty Robinson; eight grand- past commander of Julius Rosen- children. " wald Post of American Legion, a _ leader in Jewish War Veterans, EMIL WEISS, 19393 Carrie. a World War I veteran, died died March 2. Services at Hebrew I March 6. Born in Chicago. he Benevolent Chapel. • He is sur- lived in Detroit for 40 years. He vived by a daughter. Mrs. Helga is survived by his wife, Sadie; Love: sister, Mrs. Velma V. Cie- a daughter. Mrs. Donald Fater- sund; a grandchild. nick; a son. Marvin: brothers, Torn J. and Ben: sisters. Mrs. • SARAH KOVALSKY. 11501 Benjamin Cowan and Marie Petoskey. died March 5. Services. Keating. of Chicago. Hebrew Benevolent Chapel. She is survived by sons, Edward and Samuel: daughter, Mrs. Rose Letehook; 10 grandchildren and two great-grandchildren. +I, • Monument Unveilings BELLA ( LEVI E) WOLSON, 11501 Petosky, died March 8. Services at Hebrew Benevolent Chapel. Survived by husband, Samuel; daughters Mrs. Fannie Fink and Mrs. Mary Traub of Los Angeles; six grandchildren and three great-grandchildren. _ ROSE COHEN, 2940 Richton•. 'died March 8. Services at Hebrew Benevolent Chapel. She is sur- vived by husband, Harry: daughters. Helen Cohen and Mrs. Anna Belle Pollack; son. Sol Cohen; brother, Morris Eck- house ; sister, Mrs. Lilly Aronson. * BEN ON-KIN. 2130 Ewald Circle. died March 9. Services. Benevo- lent Chapel. Survived by wife. Lena: sons. Maurice and Jack: daughters. Faye Onkin and Mrs. Dorothy Fried of Venice, * Calif.; two grandchildren. * * SAMUEL FRIEDLAND. 11845 LaSalle, died March 4. Services at Kaufman Chapel. He leaves two daughters. Ruth and Mrs. Samuel Blender, brother, Wil- liam: Friedland; and sister. Mrs. Samuel Glick. of. Pittsburgh. BETH ,EL MEMORIAL PARK OFFERS JEWISH FAMILIES THE FINEST BURIAL PLOTS AT MODERATE PRICES ON EXTENDED TERMS (Unveiling announcements may be in- serted by mail or by calling The Jewish News office, WO. 5-1155. Written an- nouncements must be accompanied by the name and address of the person making the insertion. There is a standard charge of_ S2 for unveiling notices, measuring an inch in - depth). The family of the late Rose Dobkin announces the unveiling of a monument in her memory at 11 a.m., Sunday, March 13, Relatives and friends are asked to meet at the chapel of the Machpelah Cemetery at 10:45 a.m. Rabbi I. Paneth will offici- ate. In Memoriam In loving memory of our be- loved father, Joseph Velick, who left us 9 years ago, on Feb. 18, 1943 (13 days in Adar); our be- loved sister, Eleanor Velick Ep- stein. who left us 7 years ago, March 16, 1945 (two days in Nis- son; ) and our beloved brother Casper C. Velick (Chap) who left us 3 years ago, March 18, 1949 (17 days in Adar). Sadly missed by Al and Ida. * In loving memory of Charles Flam, who passed away one year ago, on March 23. 1951. Sadly missed by his wife, Clara; and sons. Samuel and Chester. * In loving memory of Charles Flam, who passed away one year ago, March 23. Sadly missed by his wife, Sam- uel and Chester. MONUMENTS One of America's newest and most beautiful ceme- teries, dedicated to the service of Detroit Jews. Beth El Memorial Park 2S120 WEST SIX MILE ROAD Between Inkster and IYIiddlebelt MANUAL URBACH & SON 7729 TWELVr For Information TY. 6-7152 Call Mr. Segall at TR. 54530 s11111111 11111111 111101111111 111111111 1111111111111 1110011 011111111111 111111111 111191111111 111111111 11111011111 111111111 1111111111110 1101.= NORTHWEST HEBREW MEMORIAL PARK -2 ▪ Beauty Dignity EE Adas Shalom ( Northwest) Synagogue - Inquiries May Be Made at Synagogue Office Labor Zionists Mourn Mrs. Linsky's Passing UN. 4-7474 Letter - Box Federation Meeting Rep* Sharp Criticism and Rep y Labor Zionist circles are (pay- Editor, The Jewish News: I was deeply shocked when I ing tribute to the memory of Rebecca Lipsky of 2465 Cortland, read your account of the Annual who died ;Feb. 23. Mrs. -Linsy was Federation meeting. I could not 3ne of the or- believe it to be the story of the anizers of local same session I attended. Pioneer W o m - You applaud with delight n ' s Organiza- "one of the finest demonstra- tion here. She tions Of democracy in action" was a lo y,a 1 with both sides receiving "an worker f o r all equal voice in the discussion." Labor Zionist You ignore the fact that several causes and was Federation partisans made "un- in the forefront scheduled" oblique attacks upon of all important the Community Council during activities for Is- the regular course of business, Mrs. Linsky rael. , long before the Council's Surviving her are her husband, amendment was introduced. You Louis I.; a daughter. Mrs. Louis hail the lengthy "unbiased dia- Carick of Put-in-Bay, O.; two tribe against the Council's po- sons, Benjamin of Detroit and sition by Morris Garvett who Harry- of Chicago. had been given the simple as- Mrs. Linsky's death strikes signment of "impartially" pre- hard at the Pioneer Women's senting the amendment. It was movement. which only a week against this background that prior to her passing mourned debate on the amendment was . - the death of Mrs. Sophie Siegel. "opened," with the chairman The women were two of .the about to enforce a five minute three founders of the Pioneer ; time limit upon the very first Women in Detroit. Mrs. Linsky's E speaker to take the floor in fa- great love in Pioneer Women I vor of the amendment. Only was the work which took her • the suggestion of an intended into contact with children at Federation spokesmah that he the United Jewish Folk Schools. would require at least 10 min- In honor of her lifelong utes himself persuaded the achievements, the organization chairman to grant a 10-minute is starting a Rebecca Linsky opening. - Fund for S1.000 to build a room i You gloat over "the masterful in the Meshek in Israel on the control of the situation by" the Road to the Negev. Donations chairman of the evening, the are being accepted at PWO head- Federation president—and you quarters. 11818 Dexter. are quite right,—if by "absolute fairness" you prefer the "abso- solute" over the "fairness." trthrir Shutkin Dies; you prefer the "absolute" over Directed Detroit JNF the "fairness." Surely, you heard the chairman rule "out of order" The Jewish National Fund a motion by Rabbi Wohlgelernter and Labor Zionist ranks here to table,—rule "out of order" an were saddened this week to attempt by Morris Zwerdling to learn of the death of the former amend the amendment,—rule director of the JNF Council in "out of order" two motions ap- Detroit. Arthur pealing from the ruling of the Shutkin. Death chair. You heard him proclaim, ..occurred in .Mi.- —in an outstanding "demon- ' ami Beach and stration of democracy."—that his body was Federation does not follow par- shipped for bur- liamentary procedure—does not ial in Milwau- recognize Robert's Rules of Or- kee, w h e r e he der. had resided for Apparently. you did hear .many years. He Council representatives plead Shutkin was a Socialist for peace and unity—and Fed- leadet' and was elected on his eration leader reject their pleas. party ticket as a member of the There was, indeed. ample cor- Milwaukee Common Council. A roboration for your statement, Labor Zionist; he devoted him- "None was restricted in express- self primarily to the JNF. He ing an opinion,—no matter how was eloquent speaker in Yid- bitter the attitude,"—with all of dish and in English and in De- the bitterness and invective ex- troit he won the esteem and res- pressed by Federation spokesmen pect of individuals and organ- Unfortunately, you missed or izations he worked with. failed to note many after-meet- Mr. Shutkin, who was=_66, was ing comments by Federation a graduate of the University of supporters, who, however they Wisconsin school of pharmacy voted, deplored the perform- and operated drug storeS, in Mil- ance of some of their leaders. waukee for a. number of years. Why did you misquote me as He studied law at Marquette asking "Federation not to make University and tile practice of was law admitted in 1927. to ugly faces at Council represen- tatives," when, actually, I ask- He is survived by a son, a ed that "you direct your Feder- daughter, twci- sisters and three ation leaders and your Council brothers. leaders to stop making ugly faces at each other" and to set Lewis DeYoung Dies up negotiating committees of Lewis J. DeYoung, form er De- reasonable men to bring "har- mony, not discord, into our com- troiter who was well known here, munity?" Why didn't you find as the advertising manager of the now defunct Detroit- Satur- it more importan-r to quote from day Night, died in Miami, Fla., my detailed story of events that Saturday. Funeral services were led up to the Federation-Coun- cil impasse,—which left Council held there Sunday. While residing in Detroit, Mr. no alternative but to bring the DeYoung was a member of Tem- issue out in public? What standards of journal- ple Beth El. He was also a member of Ashlar Lodge of the istic ethics prevented you from ascertaining and then reporting Masonic Order. A native Detroiter, Mr. DeYoung, the actual result of the vote* on who was 66, made his home in the amendment, instead of Florida in 1939. He is survived printing only the vote in favor by his wife, Beth; daughters, and implying, erroneously, that Dorothy Foy and Betty Jane everyone else voted against it? —SIDNEY SHEVITZ. Goldstein; sisters, Mrs. George a a Wuelfing and Mrs. Lena Gold- Editor's Note: •We regret Mr. smith; four grandchildren. I By Karl C. Berg Owner Max , Krotslaysky Monument Works Distinctive Monuments Priced 3201 JOY ROAD Corner Wildeniere TYler 6-0156 Reasonably Maintained by E- - = THE JEWISH NEWS Friday, March 14, 1952 — Shevitz's intolerant misinter- pretation of our news story which, we believe, represented impartial reporting. We ad- here to the view that a pub- lic meeting at which ALL ele- ments are given the right to express their opinions and in whose deliberations all have an equal voice as voters is democratic. There were un- fortunate occurrences at the meeting which are touched upon editorially in this issue, but it does not help commu- nity unity to IMPUTE delib- erate unethical approaches to our reportorial and editorial staff. We gladly present Mr. Shevitz's direct quotation of his own comment with rela- tion to making ugly faces. On the score of the last point he makes, we offer the following facts: 'The only figure that was available to us at the time we went to press—before noon on Wednesday—was the figure we used in our report. Upon receipt of Mr. Shevitz's criti- cisms we requested and secur- ed the exact wording of the Federation by-laws providing for a two-thirds vote of those present on any proposed amendment. The rule states: "These by-laws may be alter- ed, amended or repealed and new ones enacted by - the vote of two-thirds of the members of Federation PRESENT at any meeting of the members, in the call for which the substance of the proposed alteration, amend- ment, repeal or enactment has been set forth." - The supporters of the Coun- cil amendment did not num- ber a majority'of those pres- ent, or a majority of the votes marked, and therefore not a two-thirds vote of the 1,012 present or those who marked their ballots, and our report therefore was correct. In the interest of accuracy, we quote in the editorial in this issue an unofficial figure given us of those who reportedly marked their ballots in opposition to the amendment. A reporter does not express opinions, but he does reflect the mood of an audience, and our reports echoed an over, whelming majority sentiment. Federation President Samuel Rubiner is well able to speak for himself, but our view of the Federation meeting is that it assumed the form of a vot-• ing booth where you cast your ballot—even though a Town Hall Forum, preceded the vot- ing—but wherein you are un- able to rewrite the published amendment. Much as we sym- pathized with Rabbi Wohlgel- ernter's viewpoint, we there- fore believe that he could have been as much out of order as Mr, Zwerdling definitely was. Mr. Shevitz unfairly con- tends that we did not publish HIS detailed story of the Council - Federation dispute. The Jewish News, !vhose col- umns always have been open for free and frank discussion of community problems, pre- sented the Council's viewpoint in full in its isue of Feb. 11, in its report of the Council meet- ing of Jan. 31. a a From Proverbs 14:15: The thoughtless belie veth every word; But the prudent man looketh well to his going. d e ll/r y - On (he _Ai, This Week's Radio and Tele- vision Programs ot Jewish Interest Time: 8 a.m., Sunday, March 16. Station: WWJ. Feature: "A Song for Queen Esther" will be presented in celebration of Purim. The mus- ical drama tells the story of the deliverance of the Jews from Haman by their beloved Queen Esther. lilcDonald Gets Portrait NEW YORK, (JTA)—A por- trait of former U. S. Ambassador James G., McDonald was pre- sented to him at a dinner by a group of friends headed by Mr. and Mrs. Benjamin Abrams. The portrait is the work of Joseph Margulies. Mr. McDonald has left for a six-week tour of Israel to stud_y the economic situation there. PHILIP M. KLUTZNICK be- came the first receipent of the Sam Beber AZA Alumnus Award at a testimonial dinner given in his honor at Chicago's Coven- ant Club.