Historical Text Points Out Errors
Weizmann's 'Trial and Error'

In "Fifty Years of Zionism: A
Historical Analysis of Dr. Weiz-
mann's 'Trial and Error'," Dr.
•
Oskar K.
nowicz takes
great pains to
prove that the
autobiogra p h y
of the President
of Israel
abounds in er-
rors. This book,
,Apublished by
-
\AIR obert An s-
Dr. Weizmann combe & Co.,
291 Gray's Inn Road, London,
WC1, England, purports to show
"glaring inaccuracies" and he
lays blame for them on Dr.
Weizmann's collaborators.
Dr. Rabinowicz does more
than indicate inaccuracies; he
also offers criticisms. Richly
annotated to prove his points,
Dr. Rabinowicz makes a good
case for many of his claims. He
is critical of Dr. Weizmann's
treatment of Theodor Herzl and
shows that earlier in his career
he praised Dr. Herzl but in his
book subjected him to attack.
Taking issue with Dr. Weiz-
mann, Dr. Rabinowicz states:
"I have not found in any of
Herzl's speeches, articles, or let
ters, any indication of lack of
respect for or belittlement of
`Eastern' Jewry, nor any desire
whatever to do anything but
strive to unite the nation into
one whole."
"Trial and Error" also is crit-
icized for its "strong words"
against Nordau, Marmorek and
Green berg. Dr. Weizmann's
battle with Brandeis is analyzed
to the former's detriment. Witth
reference to Dr. Max Nordau,
Dr. Rabinowicz claims that the
Nordau Plan, for mass immigra-
tion into Palestine, repudiated
by Dr. Weizmann, has been fully

endorsed in the course of his-
tory: "Thus history has turned
it froin a plan of 'irresponsible'
and 'facile Zionism' into the ac-
cepted blueprint for the up-
building of Israel."
There are 24 pages showing
"discrepancies" and "minor er-
rors." Dr. Weizmann's treat-
ment of David Wolffsohn is re-
jected. A 10-page index simi-
larly points to the pains taken
by the author to show Dr. Weiz-
mann's errors.
Future editions of Dr. Weiz-
mann's autobiography should
take into account the mistakes
delineated by Dr. Rabinowicz.

Three Americans have been
chosen to compete for this
country in the Third World
Maccabiah to be held Sept. 27
to Oct. 8 in Israel. The trio are
Morley Shapir o, diver, and
Hartley Lewis and Charles
Grossberger, sprinters.
Shapiro, who hails from San
Francisco, is Pacific 1-meter and
3-meter diving champion. Lewis
is a sprint expert from New
York, who got his training at
New York University. Grossber-
ger is a New York policeman,
the second chosen for the an-
nual games. He received much
acclaim at N.Y.U.

New Year Greetings

Mr. and Mrs. Julius J.

NEW YORK—Rosh Hashanah
services for Jewish personnel
with the American armed forces
in Korea will be held Rosh
Hashanah Eve, Monday night,
September 11 and on both days
of the Jewish New Year, Sept.
12 and 13. Three Jewish chap-
lains in Korea and a fourth in
Japan, utilizing materials and
supplies furnished by the Na-
tional Jewish Welfare Board,
will conduct the High Holy Day
services, the first to be held in
a combat area since the end of
World War II.
Similar services arranged
through JWB, the government-
authorized agency for serving
the religious, welfare and morale
needs of Jews in the armed
forces, are being organized at
all bases in the Pacific, occupied
Europe and the United States.
In this country, services have
been planned for Rash' Hasha-
nah for youthful draftees away
from home for the first time, as
well as National Guardsmen and
reservists expected to arrive be-
tween Rosh Hashanah and Yom
Kippur at the 17 newly-re-
activated reception and training
centers.
In addition to officiating in
Korea and Japan, Jewish chap-
lains will also serve in the Phil-
ippines, Okinawa, Guam, Hawaii.
Germany, Austria, Alaska and
the West Indies.
For patients at all veterans'
hospitals — including those in
isolated areas — local hospital
committees and Veterans' Ad-
ministration voluntary groups of
the JWB have made plans for
holiday as well as pre-holiday
services. Ambulatory patients
will be transported to religious
services in community syna-
goaues.

TEL AVIV, (JTA)—The Hista-
drut executive decided to accept
0\
an invitation from the Yugoslav (184;,
Trade Union Congress to send flew `,
a delegation to visit Yugoslavia.

Greetings to our Friends
and Patrons

GLADYS-KAYE

Slenderizing Salon

Holiday ,„

JO-MEL--
CLEANERS

SPOT REDUCING
Vapor or Steam Cabinets
Figure Analysis
Ladies Exclusively

LEATHER SPECIALISTS

908 DAVID BRODERICK TOWER

7915 Wyoming at Ti reman

WO. 1-1668

WEbster 3-1733

City-Wide Service

Holiday Greetings

Mr. and Mrs.

Isadore Kolodney

and Family

4052 Sturtevant

Ring and Family

Best Wishes for the

New Year

Wish All Their Relatives, Friends,

and the Whole Jewish Community

a Very Happy and Prosperous

CRANE
UPHOLSTERING
SHOP

JEROME HOAG

Theatre Seats Upholstered

Real Estate

5966 CHENE

Peacefial New Year.

WA. 1-2171

Best Wishes for

Holiday Greetings

Holiday Greetings

Holiday Greetings

HAROLD FLORA

Heller's
Upholstering Shop

COBO CLEANERS

A Happy New Year

Mr. and Mrs.
Sam Gold & Son

2640 LESLIE

Holiday Greetings

Jewish Gi's in Korea
To Observe Holiday

Three Vie for American Histadrut Agrees to Send 56/,
Honors in Israel Games Delegation to Belgrade

Realtor

Custom Repair Work
Done in Your Own Home

3400 Guardian Building

Antique Pieces Restored
Furniture Re-Upholstered

WO. 1-2760

FREE ESTIMATES

16719 FORRER
VE. 7-8653

INCORPORATED

Craftsmanship in Cleaning
You'll See a Difference
In Our Cleaning

18135 Livernois at Curtis

UNiversity 3-0400

Holiday Greetings

Holiday Greetings

HEWITT BROS.

I'm Doubly Protected!—Are You?

Butterfly Moving
& Storage Co.

Roofing-Siding-Sheet Metal

24-HOUR SERVICE

Victory Loan & Investment

9092 N. TELEGRAPH

Let Us Solve Your Shipping
Problem

4864 BEAUBI EN

KE. 1-4120

Holiday Greetings

Holiday Greetings

CARLTON W.
GAMES

RICHMAN
HEATING CO.

GAS HEAT

8235 LYNDON

TE. 4-2610

New Year Greetings

ALBERT KANE
REAL ESTATE

List Your Property or Business with
Albert Kane . . . Benefit by 27
Years of Experience.

13113 DEXTER

Nr. BUENA VISTA

WEbster 3-3616

Shanah
Shel Shalom

Holiday Greetings

CADILLAC FENCE

and SUPPLY CO.

Free Estimates

13675 PLYMOUTH

4309 THIRD AVE.
TE. 1-3179

WE. 3-8755

Holiday Greetings

MANCHESTER
TIRE CO.

BEST WISHES

FOR A

HAPPY NEW YEAR

Specialists in
Recapping & Vulcanizing
New and Used Tires

234 MANCHESTER

TO. 8-3533

Best Wishes

MARLIN
LUMBER CO.

For A Happy

and Prosperous

SHECTER
Furniture Co.

New Year

1330 HILTON RD.

Ferndale 20, Michigan -

Miller Bros.

A Friend

8928 - 12th

TR. 2-3636

POULTRY

Best Wishes For

1317 Gratiot

A Happy New Year

WO. 2-3277

RING BROS.

Best Wishes for a Happy New Year
to Our Friends and Patrons

Roofers

Holiday Greetings

HARLEY B.
FERGUSON

Auto and Truck Service

2991

W. Davison

If No Answer

TO. 8-8456

ZENI & MAGUIRE CO.

WE. 3-1391

Plumbing Contractors, Heating, Industrial

Greetings to Our Customers and Friends

Power Process Piping

Day and Night Towing

19989 VAN DYKE
TW. 1-9000

OUTLET POULTRY

2735 W. DAVISON

TOwnsend 8 4281

-

12216 Woodrow Wilson TO. 8-3070

