tiE " r are• abbb V01 imymt /I E DETROIT / JEWISH aRONICLE Published Mehl, by Me Jewish Chronicle Publishing Co., inc. JOSEPH .1. CUMMINS JACOB H. SCHAKNE PHILIP SLOMOVITZ MAURICE M. SAFIR President -Secretary and Treasurer Managing Editor Advert' g Manager Entered a Second-cuts matter March 3, 1916, at the PostoMee at Detroit. Mich., under the Act of March 3, 1879. General Offices and Publication Building 525 Woodward Avenue Telephone: Cadillac 1040 London Office: Cable Address: Chronicle 14 Stratford Place, London, W. 1, England. Subscription, in Advance $3.00 Per Year To insure publication, all corr.pondence and news matter must rearh this odIce by Tuesday evening of each witch. When mailing notices, kindly use one side of the paper only. The Detroit Jewish Chronicle invites correspondence on subjects of interest to the Jewish people, but disclaims responsibility for an indorsement of the views expressed by the writers. I 1 Sabbath Readings of the Torah: Pentateucbal Portions—Ex. 25:1-27:19. Prophetical Portions—I Kings 5:26-0:13. February 24, 1928 Adar 3, 5688 "Martyrs of Learning." 1 The pogroms in Russia at the beginning of the pres- ent century created two Jewish treks. One of these wound its way to the United States, and tramping over it were the hundreds of thousands of physically abused, economically oppressed and religiously persecuted of our people. Trekking in another direction were the thousands of Jewish students for whom the doors to Russian universities and colleges were.closed and whose urge for learning drove them to the liberal universities of Germany, France and Switzerland. These "Martyrs of Learning," a.o the Jewish stu- dents wre generally referred to, are now finding heirs to the injustice leveled against them in the Jewish stu- dents of Hungary. The "numerus clausus" law of the Magyars is almost a duplicate of the percentage norms in Russia, and in both instances were aimed against Jews as Jews and for no other reasons. In Hungary, however, Jewish conditions generally have become more serious because of the student riots resulting from the Parliamentary discussions on the modification of the "numerus clausus" law. It is unfortunate for Hun- garian Jewry that the supposedly enlightened student class is leading in the anti-Semitic movement. In spite of the fact, however, that anti-Semitism is so evident in the happenings in the Hungarian univer- sities, the Commonweal, a Catholic publication edited by laymen, one of the best periodicals of its kind in the country, is fooled into believing that "the ferment at work is economic rather than social or religious in char- acter." • It is contended, states the Commonweal editorial in its issue of Feb. 8, that as far back as 1901 Jewish lead- ers themselves realized that any attempt on the part of their brethren to "monopolize" the professions would result in trouble, and that "proportional representation" in the universities was necessary. Nothing was clone, however, at the time. Disturbances incidental to the war and the proletarian resolution brought matters to a head. Veteran students, returning from the front, were angered at find- ing the professional school crowded with Jewish students; and after these had in some cases taken a share in the bolshevist uprising, resentment grew strong and bitter. Thereupon the government decreed "proportional represen- tation" by law. The number of students is limited accord- ing to the facilities available and the ability of the country to absorb professional graduates. Each religious group, furthermore, is entitled to that percentage of student attendance which is approximately equivalent to its nu- merical strength in the population. Minister Haller con. tends that the percentage accorded to the Jews is actually higher than they are entitled to. All this procedure must seem cramped and dictatorial to us. But it appears that the ferment at work is economic rather than social or religious in character. is) erRonlmstiff all Jewry, these anniversaries are occasions for cele- bration not merely by Jewish periodicals whose needs this news agency serves, but by a wider public, which would have remained uninformed of Jewish happen- ings throughout the world had it not been for J. T. A. Prior to the organization of the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, the Yiddish press was limited in its sources of news to the Yiddish dailies arriving from abroad. This necessitated the dissemination of news much too old for the consumption of its readers. The more prosperous publications had representatives in three or four of the European capitals, and the more important news, such as the progress of the Beiliss trial in Russia, or the oc- curence of pogroms, was fed them by the Associated Press and United Press. For the latter, however, the Jewish press was dependent upon the mercy of the non- Jewish agencies which discriminated against Jewish news, with the result that Jews generally were seldom offered timely information about the conditions of their kinsmen abroad. It was even worse for the Anglo-Jewish press. Un- less the editor of a particular weekly could read Yid- dish and was interested enough in the needs of his read- ers, the latter remained ignorant of Jewish happenings. A study of the pages of the average Anglo-Jewish weekly of eight or nine years ago reveals that its con- tents were limited to sermons by local rabbis, syna- gogue news, the reprint of a speech by a governor or senator, telling us how fine we are, and no more. Only in exceptional cases did these weeklies contain Jewish news, and such news was almost invariably limited to the publication of a photograph of Nathan Straus, or Oscar Straus, or Justice Louis D. Brandeis. The J. T. A. has succeeded in filling this need for Jewish news. It has enabled the Anglo-Jewish weekly to serve the Jewish people on a par with the Yiddish daily; by publishing the Jewish Daily Bulletin it sup- plied the non-Yiddish reader with the same daily news services enjoyed by the Yiddish-reading public; it has stretched its hand across the waters and brought Euro- pean and American Jewry into a closer bond of Jewish fellowship by keeping each informed, in a twenty-four hour service, of the happenings in the camps of each. We greet the Jewish Telegraphic Agency and the Jewish Daily Bulletin with wishes for many more happy birthdays. Washington on Genuine Religion. At Epiphany Church in Washington, D. C., at the annual service of the Sons of the Revolution, last Sun- day, the Right Rev. John Gardner Murray, D. D., Bish- op of Maryland and Presiding Bishop of the Episcopal Church, read a letter written by George Washington in August, 1789. In view of present day religious discord, one paragraph of this little known letter is worth quot- ing. Writing to the Episcopalians then in convention in Philadelphia, the first President of the United States said : On this occasion it would ill become me to conceal the joy I have felt in perceiving the fraternal affection which appears to increase every day among the friends of genu- ine religion. It affords edifying prospects, indeed, to see Christians of different denominations dwell together in more charity and conduct themselves, in respect to each other, with a more Christian-like spirit than ever they have done in any former age or in any other nation. Those who would divide this country's sentiments on religious issues in the coming Presidential election have something to learn from this. "More Christian- like spirit" is needed even more in the present-day bit- terness that divides Catholic and Protestant. they had been wearing. The ninth anniversary of the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, and the publication of the one-thousandth number of the Jewish Daily Bulletin, the only Jewish daily printed in English, were events of the past week. In view of the J. T. A's. accomplishments benefiting c pa C a.ACZAC- 'bo = GAS. Eh , ^ , ,, c..J 0 S EP H,=— This means a return to the clays when Jewa wore yellow badges to distinguish them from their non-Jew- ish neighbors. It means a return to the humiliations of the Dark Ages. Self-respecting Jewish students should never have consented to wearing special badges to dif- ferentiate them from non-Jews. Such an admission of inferiority does us little honor. ,, By RABBI HERBERT PARZEN. The next time r. Mencken, when I come to your Congregation Avaltai Sholom, Portland, Oregon. town, you will please stay at home. I have written evi• dence that you threatened to have me murdered for $45 and my carcass thrown into the Potomac River if I ever dared to enter Baltimore. Well, I am prepared to sum- mon eight hundred good-natured, tolerant, patient wo- men who will testify that sey sat an hour (that most have seemed an eternity) listening to me speak in liar Sinai Temple, on Monday afternoon, Feb. 13. And I dis- covered while in your city that you have Jewish neigh- bors of whom you and your fellow-liberals may well be proud. I know that you will congratulate them on the fact that they are unable to become members of the Rotarians, the KiWalliS or the Shriners. After all, we Jews do have something in life to be thankful for! A fine Jewish community indeed is Baltimore's, which maintains the finest traditions of its faith. The Irish around Tammany Hall are raising the Dutch because Tammany is trying to "high hat" them and pre- venting them from going to "Manny" Smith's party down in Houston, Texas. I imagine there is a lingering sus- picion that maybe "Manny" has sonic Jewish blood con- cealed somewhere on his person. For you must remem- her that Al's other Christian name smacks of Jewishness, which is none other than "Emanuel." But knowing Al to be a Democrat who wears his hat on one side of his head and his cigar at the other site of his mouth that I can fraternally address him as "Manny." ,,,, The Historical Background of Central European Jewry in the I 9th Century OtfpfT5 The following is the second in aseries of four articles by Rabbi Parsen, a former Detroiter. The third and fourth articles to follow will discuss the coming to this country of Eastern European Jews and to ■ general discussion of the problems affecting American Israel. - Just listen to the rude conversation of the editor of the Gaelic American, who is pleading for "home rule": Many leaders are men of experience who know that if they accept the advice (or orders) of a group of Jewish women and a handful of men of the same race and exclude every man of Irish blood and every Catholic, there will be desertions by the thousands and the state will go Republican . . • The advisors of the Governor (Smith) are Mrs. Belle and Dr. Moskowitz (both Jews), Judge Joseph Proskauer (a Jewe, Judge Bernard Sheen- tag (a Jew), Robert Moses, secretary of state (a Jew), Col. Herbert Lehman (a Jew), Nathan Bur- ken (a Jew). I knew there was something suspicious about that name 'Manny." With the birth of the nineteenth century, approximately figured, western civilization underwent a series of revolutions—political, economic, cultural and philosophic —whose effects and influence still pervade the world. So deep root- ed were the upheavals that funda- mental attitudes and age-long con• cepts of men changed. Not a sin- gle phase of human life was left unaffected. The world was in re- volt and in turmoil. Humanity almost blindly and naively but en- thusiastically hewed new channels for its life activities. Politics and philosophy, religion and science, economy and education, literature and art—all sought new forms of expression as if tired and fatigued with ,its old, traditional, formal habits. It was a changing world. As is always the case with men, the reaction to the old staid, long established system of life and thought was extreme and radical. The world turned from a religious idealistic "Weltanschaung," based uponanagricultural-maritirne econ- omy, and became thoroughly irre- ligious and materialistic in its out- look, accompanied with the new industrial regim e '. Romanticism was replaced by rationalism. Skep- ticism, agnosticism and even athe. ism struggled to overthrow the his- toric faiths. Every human institu- tion had to fight for survival and justify its existence. devising means to subdue the wild erness and to win the West. The European scientific theories wens applied to inventions to enhancs life. Here there was just as much change and turmoil as in Europe but it manifested itself in differ ent forms. In Europe the new life benefited immediately the few. In America it benefited the masses. Perhaps it may be said that in Europe there was chiefly a cultural revolution. Here oc cursed an economic revolution. Promised Land for M Democracy, the nineteenth cen- tury hope of mankind, was dy- namically functioning in Anierica. There was no need to struggle to procure it and to share in its bless- ings. It existed. It wns a fact. In Europe it was a dream, a Utopia. There men struggled for it and for every right gradually acquired torrents of human blood were expended. Naturally therefore Anierica be- came the promised land for vast masses. They began to come to procure these American boons— economical political opportunities. To win for themselves in reality the things about which Europeans dreamed was the cause of the flow of European immigration to Amer- ica. Among these migrating mass- es were also Jews who were de- feated and disappointed in their dreams and expectations. Jewish despondency was all the keener because, in addition to the failure of the modern movements to effect human happiness, there was also the unfulfilled exp•cta- tions of assimilation and the un- fulfilled expectations of assimila- tion and the unfulfilled promises of governments. The world of west European Jewry at the dawn of the nine- teenth century changed even more radically and stormily, than the Gentile world because they entered society without experience and knowledge of the new epoch. They were completely loosened from their moorings without under- standing whither they were drift- ing. They thought that they were entering Paradise—but as matter of fact, they were faced with a Ge- hennah of problems. New lima. A reader sends me a clipping which refers to a raid by a prohibition officer on the home of a Rumanian sub- ject in New York. It seems the agent was a rude fellow so that the subject in question appealed to the Rumanian minister to the United States, George Cretziano, who in turn appealed to the state department for an investiga- tion. In Rumania they get away with murder, literally and figuratively, while Minister Cretziano writes com- forting letters to the Jews in America. And Mr. Louis Marshall, who for some reason or other has had his fight- ing ardor cooled, says that we should take the minister at his words. And wait. You remember the ancient Spanish war-cry of 1898, "manana"—tomorrow, always tomorrow? I felt like yelling with the small boy, "ba- mans," or for the more discriminating, "banana oil." It is really a shame that a Rumanian in this country should suffer such an indignity as being insulted by a prohibition agent. He should go to Rumania and learn from the anti-Semites in that country how to act like a gentleman. Well, here's one right out of the oven. It comes written on a piece of asbestos, from Washington, D. C. The writer is a Jew—at least I so suspect, as he has been reading a Jewish newspaper (and these days that's about as accurate a way to discover who's who in Jewry as some others). So he writes: Because of the cowardly manner in which you attack anti-Semites by your writings, it is only reasonable that they should fight back. It seems to me (and many others) that some of your article-writers have been in a sort of slavery—per- haps under the Czar's rule—and now that they have acquired some sort of freedom, are running wild. Some of you are such poor Jews that you cannot follow the teachings of our sages. There- fore I would advise you to do as Christ said, and turn the other cheek when attacked. Or at least you can fight back fairly. How would you have felt had your parentage been made fun of, as you did in your attack on Cecil De Mille. It was the most brutal and cruel disgrace you could have caused a man to suffer. I accept full responsibility for any attack made on Cecil De Mille. But it seems a pity to waste my energy There are several slurs contained in this editorial. Jules Verne Was Not a Jew. The first and most offensive is the inference that Jew- Pierre Van Paassen, Paris correspondent of the New ish students crowded the professional schools of Hun- gary at the time that their non-Jewish fellow students York Evening World, writing apropos the approaching were busy at the front fighting the fatherland's cause. one-hundredth anniversary of Jules Verne's birthday, Nothing could be more injurious to our people every- makes the claim that a matter "that is certainly little where than to disseminate such false charges. No na- known is that Jules Verne was a Jew, and that he came tion has suffered as has the Jewish people as a result to France from Poland when a young man." of the World War. German Jew was pitched against A writer in the American Hebre• denies this claim the French Israelite, the Russian Jew against his Aus- and points to the town records of Nantes, the chief city trian co-religionist, each with the same "Shma Yisroel," of Brittany, for proof. The father of this distinguished —"Hear 0 Israel"—on his lips, but each fighting val- prophet-author, whose works were translated into iantly for the land of his birth, even though his fellow every important language including Hebrew and Yid- Jews have been oppressed for centuries in that land. dish, was an attorney-at-law who wanted his son to fol- The proportional loss of Jewish lives, as compared with low in his footsteps. Ile dispatched Jules to Paris, with non-Jewish casualties, and the lives of hundreds of the object of the boy's entering the legal profession, thousands that fell victims in the pogroms following the but the son's artistic urge drove him to the Bohemian war, are other reasons why a periodical like the Com- life of the French capital, to art and to poetry. monweal should not quote as facts the ridiculous The legend of Verne's Jewishness developed from charge of Jewish participation in Bolshevist uprisings. his name. According to the story, his name was origi- To contend, futher, that the Ilungarian university nally Olschewitz, from Olscha, meaning an alder tree uprisings are economic rather than social or religious in Polish, and becoming Vergne, or Verne, in French. in character is to ignore the facts in the case. In the This is one of the claims that are being made from course of the Parliamentary discussions at Budapest last week on the government bill to modify the "numer- time to time upon the Jewishness of great men. It is time, however, to declare a halt. If we will be given us clausus" law, Deputy Patrovac, representing the Christian Socialist Party, even made demands upon his due credit for our genuine claims. and Jewish genius will be permitted the freedom of exercising its ability government that "a numerus clausus should be intro- unmolested and unpersecuted, it will be sufficient. It duced not only in the field of education but also in in- is not necesasry for us to place non-Jewish names on the dustry and commerce." Such is the spirit of Magyar law. Once students are limited "according to the facil- roster of our great men in order to prove that we make contributions to the world. ities available and the ability of the country to absorb professional graduates," anti-Semites will go a step fur- ther in oppressing Jews. Experience throughout the A Return to the Yellow Badge. history of Jewish suffering has taught us to expect in- tolerance to engender greater intolerance. Thatjs why In the series of humiliations to which our people is the "numerus clausus" law must be opposed to the bit- being subjected in the anti-Semitic wave now encircling Europe, the following cable of the Jewish Telegraphic ter end, lest there be several such measures to fight. In the meantime it is well for Hungary to be careful Agency from Cracow, dated Feb. 16, reveals the most disgraceful of all insults: and not abuse the loyalty of her citizens. The "numer- us clausus" law may do to the land of the Magyars The controversy between Polish and Jewish students what the percentage norm has done to Russia. It may over the uniform and insignia of the Jewish students' organization, which led to several riots, was satisfactorily send her Jewish students trekking to foreign univer settled. The settlement was brought about by the inter- sites, and Hungary will be the sufferer. Because it vention of the dean of the University of Cracow, it being all of the world's history no land on earth has yet beer understood that the members of the Jewish student organ- ization have agreed to wear caps of a different color than known to benefit by exiling its Jews. An Event in Jewish Newapaperdom. .te for such apologies for Jews as signed the foregoing let- ter. I said that De Mille was half Jewish, and for that reason, if no other, he should not have produced the "King of Kings." If that be treason, make the most of it! And I might add that I have not and never intended to turn the other cheek. The Jew has had one pretty well slapped. And before he turns the other he wants to see a few followers of Jesus experiment in that line. If they like it, perhaps we will follow their example. But in the meantime we shall pursue our policy of watchful waiting. Dr. John Haynes Holmes, in an address before a Jew- ish group, took occasion to express surprise over the fact that there is prejudice among Jews, that is, prejudice of one group of Jews against another. lie seemed to think that the JON has enough persecution to stand from the outside without encouraging it from the inside. Unfor- tunately, the statement of Dr. Holmes is true. There is a social prejudice that seems to exist among all peoples. Even Christians have it one for the other. Yet, in jus- tice, it must he said that whatever prejudice may exist among Jews themselves cannot compare with that which they experience from the outside world. A writer in the New York Evening World attempts to show the different relationship that exists between the Jews and Christians in New York's East Side at Christmas time, and in the homelands whence came the Jews. After reading the statement, one begins to glmipse something of the reason for the amazing success of "Abie's Irish Rose." There is a camaraderie among the Irish and Jews in the poorer sections of New York that is reflected in such plays as "Cohens and the Kellys," "Abie's Irish Rose" and others of like type that I can't recall at the moment. Soppose we give over a lengthy paragraph to this article in the New York paper. It's quite interesting: Very different is the experience of one who came to America when four years old, the child of devout Jews who merged their family into the New melting pot. It is a tradition of his family that at Christmas time in Prague when he was but two years old, his nurse, a Jewess, of course, took him in her arms across the bridge over the Mol- dau River past the garlanded Christian inrages along the roadway, and whispered in his ear, "Give the Goy saints a slap, baby!" But five yea later, a toddler in the Tompkins Square neighborhood here in New York, the same Bohemian Jew baby Was initiated into the neigh- borhood gang. Ile went through the ordeal if being pointed at and jeered as a greenhorn be- cause his pants buttoned behind; his tiny shirt tail was pulled out so he could not get it tucked in again without going home to his mother. But in time he was taken into the homes of the other fellows. Ile saw the preparations for Christmas and heard of the beauties and joys of the Christmas tree and went home in sorrow to his mother to know why he, too, could not share in the joy of the Christian season of worship. And his mother and older sisters made a tree for him, told him to hang up his stocking and put gifts in it. And to he has grown up in th eland of tolerance to find the Jewish and Christian friends entering together into the good will of the season. Within the week we have learned of a scien- tific study made by a chain-store merchant dealing in Christmas notions as to the amount of business derived in the season from Jewish and Christian customers; his reports showed that 30 per cent of his Christmas sales were made to Jews. New isms—cosmopolitanism, in- ternationalism, nationalism, capi- talism, socialism and anarchism— appeared in simultaneous waves on the political arena. Each pro- phesied its own Utopia and assured the salvation of man, a salvation of this earth and not of "the other world." New methods of thought of sig- nificant consequence were pro- mulgated. The historical, scien- tific comparative method under- mined the accepted idea of religion and sociology. The Bible was put to the test of the new standard and found to be a human document without any special divine inspira• thin or supernatural influence. 'Higher Criticism" directed Scrip- tures into documentary atoms. Human customs and habits, re- ligious ceremonies and concepts, were revealed as universally pre- valent in certain stages of civiliza- tion. The industrial revolution had full sway. It created unprece- dented misery and wretchedness as well as undreamed-of wealth. The new economics too was hos- tile to religion because its suffer- ers—the proletariat—were made to believe, that religion was an opiate used by the capitalists to keep them in their drudgery. The church was utilized by capital, so they were told, to advance its in- terests at their expense. Men became pessimists. They were disappointed at the failure of the new isms to produce happi- ness on this earth. And they no longer had faith in the happi- ness of the next world. They grew weary of struggling for a pitiful livelihood as well as for 'political opportunities. So immigration to America began, in large numbers, as a last hope for happiness and life. The Jew's New Makeup. We must remember that the Ghetto life was still prevalent. its walls were just beginning to crumble. Its inhabitants were emerging into the light of the broad world. They were dazed and dazzled at its brightness— and dumbfounded. After some hesitation, they hurled themselves into the maelstrom with all their nervous energy. The thirst for learning which for ages was limit- ed to rabbinic lore was quenched at the fount of Western thought. Nothing was questioned. Every- thing was accepted at its par value. The more steeped the Jew became in Western learning, the more he deprecated Jewish culture. Like every novitiate he entered fully and enthusiastically and uncom promisingly the new life. Just as the peacock is proud of his colorful garb, so the Jew prided himself on his new makeup. The strivings of the Jew were encouraged and abetted by the government. The various chancel- lories held out to the Jew the promise of emancipation from the old Slavish burdens and the in- human rightlessness. "Become European," they intimated, "then we will give you the prerogative of the European." "Remove the Oriental characteristics and cus- toms, then we will recognize you as Western men." "Evidence your loyalty to the state by renouncing your historic allegiance to Zion." "Learn to speak our language and to think our thoughts, then we will emancipate, liberate you from your servile status." Jews, in huge numbers listened to these official Hosannahs, and presumably acquired their human rights at the baptismal font. Many more, for philosophic reasons, dis- associated themselves from Jewry and plunged completely into the vortex of the Utopian ideologies which dominated European life without officially adopting Chris- tianity. For the Sake of Tradition. Through the Napoleonic Syn- Influence on America. In America, too, life flowed swiftly and turbulently. The in- fluence of European thought was indeed felt. But it was intensive rather than extensive. It was principally manifest in the larger cities along the coast. But it was utilized for different ends, for practical purposes to enhance the struggling economic fabric of Young America. The new world, as a whole, was too busy wrestling new fortunes from its bountiful resources to care for illusory Utopias. The American possessed an actual Utopia in lands that thirsted for the plow. he had no time for the new European theories. Young America had practically no vested interests. Economic op- portunity, certainly in the West, beckoned to every energetic character. Poverty, the mother of all human rumblings, was prac- tically non-existent. Work ac- complished here what Kutopian dreams failed to produce in Eu- rope. The intellectual forces in Amer- ica were primarily interested in C (Turn to next page.) WHY NO T • ASK THE RABBI A Sheaf of Shetlas By RABBI LEON FRAM Director of Religious Edwation, Temple Beth El. 10. What were the chief agricul tarot products of modern Pales tine? 11. What are the chief agricul- tural products of modern Pales- tine? 12. Who is the president of the Bar Association of Detroit? 13. Who is Mark Gunsburg? (Readers of The Detroit Jewish Chronicle are invited to submit questions for Rabbi Fram to ans- wer. Address Rabbi Leon Fram, Temple Beth El, Detroit.) 1. What Jew secured the 'Suez Canal for the British Empire? 2. What is a shekel? 3. How much is a shekel worth in American money? 4. When was the first Jewish coin issued? 5. Where in Detroit can one see one of these original Jewish coins? 6, What is the Sabbath of the Shekel? 7. What modern Jewish organi- zation still imposes the poll tax of one half-shekel? 8. Where in the Bible can .one find a description of the ancient Temple of Jerusalem? 9. What Methodist minister has exchanged pulpits with a Rabbi? 4-:̀,1:44- 0WA:444IT, 14. What is a Yiddishist? 15. What is a Volkschule? 16. How many volkschule are there in Detroit? 17. What is the Fenkell Branch of Temple Beth El? Is. What Jewish composer has advanced the jazz music to the symphony concert platform? 19. Who is Leopold Pilichovaki? 20. Who is the leading writer and composer of American popular songs? (Answers on last page.) ' ,.; 4=c4:4-444aa4k