MEDLTRon;//wisnORDNIGLE ,, THEDETROITJAWISR 9RON1CL Published Weekly by The Jewish Chronicle Publishing Ca., Ise. President Secretary and Treasurer JOSEPH J. CUMMINS JACOB H. SCHAKNE Entered •s Second-Has. maser Mar. h I .10. at the Poiltollice at Detroit. Mich.. under the Ail ol March 8. General Offices and Publication Building 525 Woodward Avenue Telephone: Cadillac 1040 Cable Addresc Chronicle London Odor 14 Stratford Place, London, W. 1, England. $3.00 Per Subscription, in Advance To insure p.ddicalon, Year all mirreapondenee and news matter must reach office by 'Tuesday evening of each week. When mailing notice.. kindly use one .lie of the paper only. this The Detroit Jewish Chronicle invites norm...minden, on subject. of interest to the Jewish people, but disclaim. responsibility for an Indorsement of the view. expressed by the writers. July 1, 1927 Tammuz 1, 5687 Sons of the Covenant. Detroit will be host next week to the fifty-ninth an- nual convention of the Grand Lodge of District Num- ber 6, Independent Order B'rith. It is appropriate that Pisgah Lodge should do the honors of the host this year. Pisgah has earned that distinction by performing within the last year some very notable achievements. Its intellectual advancement programs have been a distinct contribution to the Jew- ish life of Detroit. In that respect we can safely say that Pisgah is in the forefront among B'nai B'rith lodges, In point of membership and other forms of ma- terial progress Pisgah has been equally successful. An interesting and impressive feature of the convention will be the initiation of 200 candidates. If we judge individuals by their actions, we must judge fraternal orders by their activities, and, on that score, Pisgah is not found wanting. The Independent Order B'nai B'rith has been sev- eral times on the point of senility. More than once it has seemed to have outlived its usefulness and to be re- placed by other organizations. Nevertheless it has always managed to find for itself some new form of service. Far from sinking into senility it is now more alive than ever and seeking a wider and wider scope for its activities. Beginning as a fraternal order molter the manner of other fraternal orders, it has constantly added to its functions until today it is not so much a fraternal order as a fraternal social service organization. Its practi- cal fraternalism is not limited to its members. The ben- eficiaries of the B'nai B'rith are all the Sons of the Covenant whether they be members or non-members. To the true Ben B'rith there are no ,non-members. All Jews are B'nai B'rith. And, in time of need, no one is asked to show his membership card. Wherever flood destroys or fire lays waste or oppression threatens or anti-Semitism raises its hateful head the B'nai B'rith may be found doing its work of rescue and relief. We hope that the delegates to the convention of District Number 6 will find Detroit a pleasant and hos- pitable place to meet and that its deliberations here will be marked by that vision and foresight which we have come to expect of the B'nai B'rith. Anti-Semitism Finds a Way. Hazing is an old tradition in American colleges, and, because it is an old tradition, there are some who count it almost treason to advocate its abolition. Neverthe- less there have been a few who have been willing to risk the accusation of un-Americanism that the lovers of tradition are so quick to hurl against those who see in hazing a barbarous and inhuman custom. Anti-Semites always manage to find excuses for their actions and one of the most serviceable of excuses is the pretext of custom. It is easy to overdo the thing a trifle and then make light of it because "it has always been the custom." "We've had 900 tubbings here and never called in the police force," said one of the physi- cians of Kings County Hospital, in commenting on the hazing of three Jewish doctors by a band of internes last week. What the learned doctor treats so flippantly as a "tubbing" consisted of dragging the Jewish interned out of bed during the night, pulling pillow cases over their heads, throwing them violently into tanks of cold water, smearing their bodies with dye and tossing them into bed again bound and gagged. Just being playful. The charge is made that Kings County Hospital, a municipally owned and operated institution. has been inhospitable to Jews both as doctors anti as patients. We can neither accept nor reject this accusation since we do not possess any other information on the subject than that contained in the press reports, but the fact that there are so few' Jewish doctors on the staff of the hospital lends credence to the accusation. If any dis- crimination exists at Kings County Hospital we can be sure that Mayor Walker will find it and see to it that the guilty are punished as they deserve to be. Whatever their motives may have been the perpe- trators of the recent brutalities should be tried in the courts like any other rowdies. Perhaps such an exam- ple would help to dispose of the idiotic and brutal prac- tice of hazing. Wanted: A New Spinoza. Rabbi Louis I. Wolsey. president of the Central Con- ference of American Rabbis. in his message to the con- ference at Cape May last week. dealt with one of the most perplexing pluses of the Jewish problem in America. "The groups in Judaism that are learned in so many a secular science and art and history are abysmally ig- norant of the well-springs of Jewish thought and life. Here we have an opportunity for a new renaissance. The time has come for our conference to give to a Jew- ish scholarship that has kept pace with the new discov- ery of biology, psychology. philosophy and history such studies as the God idea, Judaism and the doctrine of evolution, the election of Israel, the efficacy of prayer, immortality, the authority of the Bible in Judaism. The scientific and scholarly activities of our many Jewish students and thinkers could be tangibly and resultfully encouraged if the laymen of Jewry could be given to see the value to Judaism of more intensive studies in Jewish literature." said Rabbi Wolsey. It is true, as Rabbi Wolsey points out, that learned 9.Q.9. Q. Jews, eminent in the arts and sciences, have neglected Jewish scholarship. Undoubtedly one reason is that the institutions of learning in America do not offer ade- quate courses of instruction in Jewish literature, his- tory or philosophy. In the curricula of the leading uni- versities Jewish scholarship plays only it minor role. Every thoroughly educated man knows that familiarity with Jewish history and philosophy are essential to a balanced education. But the university student must acquire such knowledge by self-education or go with- out it. An educated laity is badly needed in America. Or- thodoxy has taken a step in that direction by founding the Yeshiva. Reform will have to solve the problem in its own way. If the reform rabbinate regards the Yeshiva as an "orthodox" parochial school it will have to find some other way to create an intelligent Jewish laity. Perhaps the thing can be accomplished by in- ducing the universities to offer more courses in Jewish studies. Perhaps Reform Jewry would do well to es- tablish its own Yeshiva for laymen and teachers. Pul- pit and platform are not enough, and never were enough. There was always the "house of Instruction." When Rabbi Wolsey says that "the time has come for our conference to give to a Jewish scholarship that has kept pace with the new discovery of biology, psych- ology, philosophy and history such studies as the God idea, Judaism and the doctrine of evolution, the elec- tion of Israel, the efficacy of prayer, the doctrine of im- mortality and the authority of the Bible in Judaism," he mistates the problem. It cannot be the function of the Central Conference of American Rabbis or any other conference to "give" anything to Jewish scholarship. The doctrine of im- mortality and the efficacy of prayer are not to be "giv- en" by conferences. Anti the Jewish secular scholar- ship of America would not take them simply because they are given. To the secular scholar such matters are problems and some of them admit of no solution that would be acceptable to any mind trained in the sciences.• Rabbi Wolsey calls them "studies" but he states them in a manner that smacks of finality. Certainly he must know that Jewish scholarship, even in America, has not completely ignored some of the studies he would bring to its attention. And, in some cases, the results of such studies have not been acceptable to the rabbinate. In the past some of the most searching and profound studies in Jewish philosophy and history have been the work of laymen—not only Jewish but gentile laymen as well. Their ideas have often met with the bitterest opposition from the rabbinate, in some cases with ex- communication. The attitude of the rabbinate, like that of any other priesthood, has always been that the Jew- ish mind should seek knowledge but its conclusions must coincide with the accepted doctrines of the day. In other words, that study is all right as long as it leads to certain pre-arranged conclusions. Is it any wonder then that the truly creative minds among Jews have so often published their wisdom to the world from the scholars study rather than from the rabbi's pulpit? Sooner or later, of course, the pulpit has absorbed the heresies of the excommunicated Spin- °US. Rabbi Wolsey is well aware, no doubt, of the pos- sible consequences of any comprehensive study of the subjects he recommends by the Jewish secular schol- ars of America. We agree that such study would be of incalculable value to the lay Jewry of America. Per- haps we shall see another Guide to the Perplexed and discover a new Spinoza. Jewish Art. Articles and speeches deploring the lack of interest in Jewish affairs among the young people appear almost daily on the editorial desk. They come from all sources but all sing the same song: The Jewish youth are fail- ing to claim their heritage, Jewish culture. Another favorite theme is the failure of the educat- ed Jew to apply his well-trained mind to the problems of Judaism. Rabbi Wolsey's address before the Cen- tral Conference of American Rabbis last week bore heavily on this theme. Now we hear that the Jewish poets and musicians are likewise indisposed. The Jewish National Fund offered a prize for a Yid- dish song that should express in words and music the aspirations of Jewish nationalism. A number of songs were submitted but not a single one was judged worthy of the prize, "The judges have carefully examined the manu- scripts submitted in the Yiddish Song Contest," reads the announcement. "They have regretfully arrived at the unanimous conclusion that none of the songs submitted possesses the necessary literary qualities. nor does it express the character of the occasion that is being celebrated with sufficient adequacy to be entitled to the prize." As we all know, there are a number of very able Yiddish poets in America today anti not a few compos- ers of great talent. In all likelihood they simply ignored the contest. The same thing is constantly happening in essay contests and short story contests. The really talented Jewish authors never compete although they frequently compete and often win prizes in other con- tests. A glance through "Who's Who in American Jewry" reveals the fact that very few of the first rate Jewish literary men and artists make Jewish themes the subject of their art. That is not true of the Yid- dish writers but it is invariably true of those who write in English. When the literary, musical and artistic talent of a people begins to look outside of the group for its themes it is high time for the group to look withn itself for the reasons. Genius does not turn away from the material at hand and go afield for its subjects unless there is something inhospitable in its environment. For a long time American artists of the highest talent forsook their native land and went to Europe for the materials of their art. Of late there has been a change. Ameri- cans have become more hospitable to the better books, painting and music and its artists have complied with some of the finest works in contemporary world litera- ture and art. There is certainly no lack of genius among the Jews of America. Is there not, rather, a noticeable lack of interest in and appreciation of works of art and liter- ature on subjects of purely Jewish interest among American Jews. • • ••• ••,erITIF'014IY-rP601 ,,,,,,,,,,,,, Tevr,t4;34-44:44-A-trga--,, boo GAS. ,,,,, 0if9-1445 JOSEPFt'' I do hope that my calling attention to discrimination against Jewish girls applying for office positions has been helpful. A reader living in Chicago sends along this en- couraging bit of information: "Dear Mr. Joseph: "I saw two ads, similar to the one 'Stenographer--Jewish, with general expe- rience; West Side office; state experi- ence, age, and salary expected. Address II K 452, Tribune," in the 'Tribune.' Maybe your campaign is start- ing to have some effect. Perhaps a good way to reform some Jewish business organizations who won't employ Jewish help is to publish their names. This surely would not be very good for them in the way of free advertising." I must say that it is a long time since I have seen a want ad worded like the one above, so maybe agitating the subject is doing some good. I thought there must be some mistake. I just couldn't figure out that only six of those internes in the Kings County Ilospital, New York, would undertake to haze three Jewish internes. You know that the old William Jennings Bryan ratio of 16 to 1 in the Free Silver Cam- paign is just about the Ku Klux Klan ratio when it comes to beating some man or woman that it doesn't like. Once I recall that 40 of them went out after some chap that hadn't done exactly what the Knight Shirts wanted and when they arrived and discovered that a woman was also there, they hustled back a courier for reinforcements. Of course, I wasn't present, but that's the story that ap• peered in the newspapers. • - However, to get back to those brave lads in Kings County Hospital. They are said to be doctors, and I ex- pect they are in training for Muscular Medicine. There were six accused of the cowardly attack upon the three Jewish internes, but I learned later that there were 20 in the attacking party. That sounds more like it, 20 to 1 is a good, old-fashioned 100 per cent. anti-Semitic way of attacking the Jew. In Russia, they used to bring up a regiment to kill the defenseless Jews, men, women and little children. So the brave boys from the west—the great red-blooded he-men from the Big Open Spaces, who are so hard that when they tall they break the pavements --they lined up 20 strong and went after those three Jewish doctors to show them in a practical way that they didn't like them. Congratulations, fellows! I shall be happy when you finally become doctors to please send me your office address. I shall be glad to publish them in order to encourage Jewish patronage for you. In the meantime, the Huskies have been suspended and Mayor Walker is going to clean house. My best wishes, mayor! A friend of lazy Zarakov's dropped in to see me the other evening. Izzy is one of the plain every-day boys at Harvard, who has won as many letters as one finds on a Chinese laundry check. Ile is Harvard's star athlete. And there is no Jewish question for lazy at Harvard, Ile comes from Boston and has earned his living while get- ting his education. He isn't one of those apologetic rac- coon-coated Jewish boys who tries to dodge his fellows and his religion. On the contrary, Izzy advertises what he is. He joined the Zeta Beta Tau fraternity, and just to show him what they thought of Izzy Zarakov, the Jew- ish tailor's boy, from Boston, the swagger crowd at Har- vard elected him to the very swaggerest fraternity in the university. All of which shows that if one respects him- self he gains the respect of others. • • The "Forum" offered prizes for the hest definitions eif "What is (leaven?" A gentleman by the name of Laza- rus, living in Brooklyn, won the first prize. But I fear that he must be a lawyer, for his definition reads in this fashion: "Heaven—a spiritual land of peace, plenty and equality, situate, lying, and being in the upper- most region above the clouds, conjured up by re- ligion to assist in the maintenance of law, order, and good-will among God's children while in the bodily state on earth, through the exaction of a strict compliance with the precepts of the Ten Commandments as the price of admission, which the soul must pay, after departure frrno the physi- cal being at death." All of which goes to show that if that's all there is to Ileaven, then we don't have to leave this earth to at- tain it! • • Well, I guess I'll have to pin the rose on "Jim" Davis' lapel. I have been reading the history of every adminis- tration, from George Washington's down, and I believe that the Hon. John J. Davis, secretary of labor in the cabinet of our own South Dakota Cal, is the first cabinet officer who bid the highest price for the privilege of open- ing a synagogue about to be dedicated. This happened at Beechview, a suburb of Pittsburgh, Pa., on Sunday, June 19, when the Beth-FA synagogue was dedicated. a Secretary Davis paid $225 for the honor of opening the door, and then for good measure delivered an address. I always did like Secretary Davis. lie's human.... Some one sends me a clipping from a newspaper in which this question is asked: "Was the assassinator of Abraham Lincoln a Jew?" and it is answered in this fashion: "John Wilkes Booth, who shot Lincoln, was of Hebrew ancestry, but was a member of the Epis- copal church." I have a dim recollection that Edwin Booth, the brother of John Wilkes, was said to have had a Jewish ancestor, but somehow or other, I never gave it much consideration. It may be true that the Booths were of Jewish ancestry, but I have seen no definite proof. • I sometimes think that even our own better-informed Jews do not quite understand their own problems. For example, in speaking to a Jewish woman, active in com- munal affairs, concerning the singing of Christian hymns in the public schools, they seemed to think that the "chil- dren would not be harmed!" Now you cnn begin to un- derstand why sometimes the members of the Jewish press become pessimistic. It just shows how very superficially issues vital to Jewish life and Jewish welfare are con- sidered. Senator Reed, of Pennsylvania, is as nervous on the subject of immigration as Secretary Kellogg, of the state department, is nervous about Bolsheviks landing in this country. All one needs to do to get the Pennsylvania senator into a hysterical state is to whisper "immigrant!" At night he dreams of great shim' filled to the gunwales with immigrants corning to the United States. Ile sees all Europe and Asia shutting up shop and preparing to ship their hundreds of millions to these shores. So pos- sibly the nervous senator from Pennsylvania will be more at ease when he learns of the astonishing report submit- ted by the *Charity Organization Society of New York City. Instead of the immigrant families camping by the thousands in front of the offices of the charities seeking help we find this amazing situation: "Usually the public assumes that foreign-born are our chief concern. Such people will be sur- prised to learn that of the foreign-born under uor care only 5 per cent. had been here less than One years. This disproves the idea that it is the moat recent immigrant who needs help and guidance." Now I hope Senator Reed will be able to sleep a little better. It's just one thing after another. Just when we have become more or less reconciled to a summer of three months. Eastman, the kodak man, and a lot of other cap- tains of industry, want to change the calendar and give us another summer month. The calendar agitation, which has been going on for years, calls for a change to 13 months of 28 days each, with the three hundred sixty- fifth day added to December, making that month the longest of the year, with 29 days. In leap year, the three hundred sixty-sixth day will be added to June. making June a 29-day month. But what bothers me most is that the extra month (the thirteenth) will be sand- wiched in between June and July, and it is to be named Sal. Of course, that's a Good Jewish name, but even that doesn't compensate for having a swelter through four hot months. These calendar reformers think that the present calendar is too confusing. We have enough problems now without bothering about the calendar. kinlYWAYMMIZt `1,1*. tatt;Ina? Schwartzbard Trial Stirs Sentiment Victims of Pogroms Offer Heartrending Testimony. By I. SCHECHTMAN There is an old story of a Jew who for the first time in his life visited a town and on his return kept telling everybody about the wonderful things he had seen there. What struck him as the greatest wonder of all was the electric bell. There was a button at every front door, ii , e :oid as soon as one pressed it the door opened and a maid ap- "It is simply marvelous," he said. "You a button and out jumps a Here in Paris, too, we have been struck lately by wonderful things; not, however the wonders of the great metropolis, but the unexpect- ed marvels contained in the ordi- nary Jew. It is enough to "press the button." The Schwartzbard case roused the Jews all over the world into a state of unexpected readiness. Without anyone asking for them, hundreds of documents and letters arrive day after (lay in Paris re- vealing entirely new, sometimes terribly tragic aspects of the Jew- ish character. In order to produce such a spontaneous and self-reveal- ing outpouring of the Jewish heart one only needs to "press the but- ton." Out of the heap of letters now lying before me, I select only a few. Here is a letter from the little Ukrainian township of Snitkoff in the Province of Podolia; a double foolscap sheet filled with writing on all four sides. The langauge is a good, plain, juicy Yiddish. The writer is a woman of 60, but the hand is still firm. She addresses herself to Schwartzbard's counsel, Maitre Torres. "I am an old woman of sixty," she writes. "I live in a small town in the Ukraine. Since the great blow, of which I am going to write here, tuefell me and poisoned all my thoughts and made my body a bur- den to me, I have kept away from the world and its news. But a short time ago, while in someone's house I overheard it man reading in a paper that Solomon Schwartzbard had killed Petlura and now was to be tried, and that you were going to defend him. 'Now,' I thought to myself, 'the time has come when I can tell something that you may find useful.'" And she proteeds to tell in sim- ple touching words the story of the great misfortune that happened to her in 1919. Her son, Isaac, a boy of 10, together with two other young men, and old woman and a girl, all of the same township, started out on fru i t for liar, a larg- er town some 30 vierts (24 miles) away. A few miles ahead of liar they were met by four mounted sol- diers of Petlura's army, who drag- ged them into the wood. One of the boys, doted, Beresin, with throat and holy badly cut, pretended to be dead and was left lying there by the murderers, afterwards he man- aged to get to the town and told the people what had happened. "'The others were found the following day in the wood cut up into tiny pieces. . . They were 'done in' slowly, with knives, cruelly tor- tured," explains the old woman, and then, unable to continue, she breaks off: "I cannot describe everything," she writes, "my hands tremble, my heart beats as if it is gluing to burst and my eyes cannot see for tears. I must break off. Let a mother vent her grief in tears." Soon she composes herself and she resumes her story: "Even the Ukrainian gendarmes in Bar from Galicia were struck with pity at the sight of the dead bodies; they took photographs of them and sent them to Petlura's Directory in Kamenetz-Podolsk. But we heard nothing from the di- re' S 'th'r eh' a ' s a great deal to tell about Petlura's treatment of the Jews: "Although everyone knew who the murderers were and where they were to be found, not one of them was punished. When the District "Starosta" Kirienko was asked to arrest the murderers, he declared that although the murderers were known they could not he punished. 'These things are not punished here,' he said. It was true. Every- one in Snitkovo remembers how when Simon Petlura was passing through the place in his car on his way to the front, the Jews went out to meet him with bread and salt and the Torah and begged him not to let his troops make pogroms on the Jews. At first he did not even want to recevie them, and when he finally heard them out, he merely said: 'Never you mind; you had better tell your Jews not to fire on as as they did in Kopaigorod' Is township near by where a po- grom took place.)" She concludes the letter with a touching pasage: "Our tears will help you to de- fend Sholom Schwartzhard and ward off the heavy sentence that threatens him. Shalom Schwartz- bard has done a holy thing. May his every step be blessed...." And here is another letter: The writer is a cultured man, an industrialist; he is living in Vi- enna now and he can speak French and German. He declares in this letter, fully authenticated with his name and address, that he is pre- pared to share the responsibility with Schwartzbard for the shooting of Petlura. "Schwartzhard," he writes, "has done what I several times tried to do, but failed only he- cause that beast of a man always managed to elude me. I ant con- vinced," he writes further, "that there are thousands of men like my- self, whose lives were made mires- able because of that man, and whose dream it was to kill him." He goes on to explain why he hated Petlura so. On August II, 1919, he writes, Petlura occupied Kiel. He war there only ror the but lads' managed even in that ith short t i time time to arrest 31 young Jews between the ages of IC and 20, who were members of the mi- litia organiz,d by the municipal- ity. Petlura was in Kier for one thy only. "Two days after hi, re- treat," the letter says, "we found on a field outside the town the hod- ies of the unfortunate young men who hued been arrested—all terrib- ly mutilated." Among these young men was the writer's only son Bor. The father, an old man, has kept himself alive since only by the thought of revenge. Now he has seen his longing realized—by an- other man. And his only remain- ing wish is to be allowed to bear a part of the responsibility for an ad which, but fur chance, might well have been the deed of his own hands... Here is another letter. The writ- er is a young man in Czernowitz, and he writes in German. Ile was horn in Itokovina and has lived all his life there. In the winter of 1919 hundreds of Jewish refugees began pouring from the Ukrains into Bokovina and Bes- sarabia and they told terrible stories about the outrages and po- groms carried out by Petlura. These stories completely unsettled hint; he felt that he must go to the Uk- raine, no matter how great the per- il, and see for himself what was happening there. "I declare," he writes, "that I undertook the jour- nu to the Ukraine entirely on my own initiative. I was not sent there by any individual or news- paper. Up to the present I have not published a word about what 1 saw in the Ukraine. The facts I am submitting here are being set down for the first thee." In July, 1919, he writes, he went to I3essarabia and was held up by the hanks of ' the River Dniester (the Roumanian-Ukrainian Fron- tier.) Ile found he could taut cross the river in a smuggler's boat, so lie decided to swim across. He found a suitable place on the Rou- manian bank, between the vil- lages of Ikniza and Ataki, and one night, unobserved by anybody, he undressed, tied his clothes into a hag, fastened it to his head, and dived. He evaded successfully both the Roumanian and Russian front- ier guards, And on reaching the other bank he hid in a field. At sunrise he emerged from his hiding place and walked towards Mohilev. Ile was taken fur a soldier of the defeated Polish army and he man- aged to find work in a peasant h o usehold. About tire days later, while work- ing with the peasant on the field, he saw something hurtling in the distance. The peasant explained: "That is a tire in the Jewish col- ony. The Petlurists seem to have been at work there." lie prevailed upon the peasant to take him to the place that he might see the pogrom. While they were still some distance off they saw a large village burning; when they came nearer they were able to make out every detail; they saw urn running about and soldiers deliber- ately shooting down everyone who came out of the burning houses. When they about 100 yards away from the village, they saw a big group of amounted men near them cooly watching the pogrom. "This is Petlura," his companion said suddenly. "Where? Which one?" he asked. "That one fumbling with his glove." "Are you sure?" "Of course I ant sure. I have seen him hundreds of times." A few hours later the Petlurists left the village and proceeded in a westerly direction. The writer and his companion entered the village. All the houses were burned down. They began counting the corpses. The-re were 104 of them, men, women and children, all half- charred. "I had seen enough," he writes. The following day he left the lo- cality. His attempt to return to Roumania was not as successful as his crossing. Ile was caught by the Roumanians while swimming across the river and was arrested ems a spy. He was threatened with execution and 11,;;, had a very diffi- cult time before he was at last set free. The Schwartzharel affair has pressed the button, so to speak, and a host of experiences and facts have come to light which otherwise would have remained hidden away in the darkest recesses of Jewish life. moovriaht 1927. J. T. A ) "Go to the ant thou sluggard; consider her ways and tie wise." (Proc. vi. 6.) Rabbi Simon ben Helena said: "I shall go and see if it is so." In the heat of summer he went and spread his mantle near a nest of ants, and one saw the shade and went and told those in the nest that there was shade and they came nut. lie took away the mantle and the sun smote them, and they killed the first ant. The Rabbi said. "Surely they have no chief or ruler" (see ib. "for if they had, they would not have killed the informant without asking permission." (Hal. 57b.) "Remember what Amalek did," ate. Duet. xxv 17)—one might think from this that salient re- membrance is sufficient; but when it is said further (ib. 19), "thou shalt not forget" (which means inwardly), then the first phrase means not inwardly and silently, but that 'he recollection shall be uttered with the line. (Meg 188.) In the daily hymn which all cre- ative things render in praise of the creator, the song of the ant is, "Who giveth food to all flesh; for to eternity endureth His kind- ness." (Ps. cxxxvi 25; Parek Shi- rah v.) Lamson in his last prayer to God said: "Remember unto me that dur- ing the twenty-two years I have judged Israel I did not so much as ask anyone to carry my staff." ( Sota h 10a.) "Since I have come to my right senses," said Phineas ben Jair, "I do not even eat free meals at my father's house." (I. e., he would not receive any benefit be did not earn.) (Hal. 7a.) Vii ? 44: .