IIAGE FOUR ThEl)erRorT,/EwisntARIamaa jr • Nt... ree- Nt, ■ _1., TO' k or more more sympathetic understanding of these difficult political and economic problems. In fact any group which shows any marked political Published Weekly by The Jewish Chronicle Publishing Cm, Inc. or economic understanding has been stigmatized as dis- JOSEPH J. CUMMINS, President loyalists and split allegienists by the group of pseudo JACOB MARGOLIS, Editor scientists who have fathered the Nordic superiority JACOB H. SCHAKNE, General Manager creed. To be able to discuss political, economic and social entered as Second-class matter March A 1916, at the PolitoMee at Detroit, Mich., under the Act of March 8, 1619. questions with any intelligence, places one immediately in the category of the tainted, according to the 100 per General Offices and Publication Building center. 525 Woodward Avenue Telephone: Cadillac 1040 Cable Address: Chronicle America has been busy creating an industrial and Landon wk..: material civilization which has far outrun any mechani- 14 Stratford Place, London, W. 1, England. cal civilization of the past. Our ideas have not kept $3.00 Per Year Subscription, in Advance pace with the terrific tempo of machine development, To insure publication, all correspondence and news matter must reach this and consequently medieval political conceptions run office be Tuesday evening of each week. parallel with the most prodigious engineering feats, The Detroit Jevtith Chronicle invites correspondence on subject. of interest to the Jewish people, but discleimsres ponsibility for an Indorsement of the carried on by men with highly specialized technique, views ex be the writer.. and millions of skilled, semi-skilled and unskilled work- March 12, 1926 Adar 26, 5686 ers. Under the circumstances it is not at all surprising to find that there exists a dull area in the field of social, The United Palestine Appeal. economic and political thinking at Yale University. It On Thursday, March 4, the campaign to raise the is equally not surprising to find that compared with Detroit quota of $125,000 was opened in Detroit. The England we are woefully deficient in our understanding city and state will be thoroughly canvassed by the of these questions. The unanimity on the part of scholars and observ- workers, the message of the needs and importance will be brought by Maxa Nordau, Chaim Nachman Bialik, ers from within and without indicates the obvious char- acter of our shortcomings. It means too that the prob- i‘ Dr. Stephen S. Wise, Shmaroyha Levin, Nahum Soko- lems will immediately become so acute and pressing low and others who are in this country for the pur- that some consideration will have to be given to them, pose of acquainting American Jewry with the work or else we shall find ourselves swamped by the crea- being clone in Palestine, amid the pressing needs of the tures brought into existence by the very culture we so Chalutzim, the Iladassah, the National Fund and all industriously but unthinkingly'produced. To meet these with some measurable prospect of other agencies of reconstruction. One cannot help but feel, after reading the reply of success, we must inevitably develop a tough mindedness the Palestine government to the demands of the Na- and analytic technique. These latter qualities have tional Assembly that the whole burden will have to been conspicuously absent in our sentimental muddling be borne by world Jewry and in particular American policy of "all is well," because we enjoy material pros- perity. Jewry. The simultaneous rebuke from the Angell's should Taxation and budgetry reforms are promised, but have a salutary effect. not immediately, and from slow-footed even though well-intentioned authorities one cannot hope for too much, or too quickly. Showing the Way. Then, too, proportionate civil service appointments The Joint Distribution Committee reports that C. are promised as well as an allocation of waste and Sterling, the owner of the Houston, Texas, Post-Dis- crown lands, but this shall be done only after careful patch, made an unsolicited contribution of $5,000. This and mature consideration of all the conditions. may be a surprise to many Jews because they conceive In the demands of the National Assembly there is the Joint Distribution Committee Drive as a strictly a definitely realistic note, which excludes the idea of Jewish undertaking. The expressions from non-Jewish politics, while the answer clearly manifests all the de- sources indicate that the land settlement scheme for vices which an adroit though powerful mandatory can liquidating the bankruptcy of Russian Jewry appeals employ. At the present juncture it must be evident to all men and women who able to envisage a problem that the single concern of Palestine Jewry is economic which is beyond the limits of -their -own, national assistance. frontiers. The story of the splendid heroism and idealism of We are unable to discover any valid reason why the chaluzim has been told so often that anyone with the non-Jews of America, especially those who think a most superficial knowledge of Palestinian conditions in terms of humanity and international good will, must by this time know that rarely in the history of should not help to rehabilitate Russian Jewry. This humanity has a finer co-operative effort been under- does not mean that the responsibility of the Jew is in F taken and carried on. These people, inspired by the any manner lessened, should others decide to assist. ideal of cultural values, freed from chauvinistic poisons, The reasons for this are obvious. The unforseen ca- want to orient themselves under conditions chosen by tastrophies of Polish and Bessarabian Jews makes it themselves.' Then, too, the intolerable conditions pre- imperative to raise a larger amount than originally vailing in Europe were no inconsiderable factor in driv- planned. ing them to 'Palestine. But they endure all smilingly The extent and ramifications of the land settlement and hopefully and are anxious to create a polity and movement are so great that should the J. D. C. raise society from which the hateful patterns of despotism $50,000,000 it could all be used to excellent advantage. will be absent. We believe that practically all people capable of From the expressed views of those working in a critical and objective judgment are by this time con- Palestine it must be apparent that political Zionism is vinced that the people of a country are often power- for the present not a live consideration except with that less to direct the policy of their government. Before small revisionist group headed by Jabotinsky and America entered the war the distinction was made and Gruenebaum, who would have no Zionism unless it rightly that the people were a separate and distinct emphasized the political aspects even though the cul- entity, and not to be confused with the military hier- archy which then ruled Germany. For a time, due to tural and economic had to be minimized. Many American Jews are fearful lest the Zionist propaganda, fear, hatred and revenge, we forgot all movement becomes a purely political one and conse- about the distinction and the German people were quently they are chary about helping with their money excoriated with the same viciousness as was that sym- and moral support. If eventually the political Zionist bol of militarism, the kaiser. The war ended, but the accumulated venom and idea should become the dominant note yet from all present indications there is a remote prospect of such fear had not spent itself entirely. Bolshevism pre- sented itself as a menace even more ominous and dan- a contingency. gerous than militarism, and once more the people of The campaign for $5,000,000 has no political con- Russia and the government were lumped together. notations. That much is obvious. Help from Britain Gradually the information seeped through that the in the matter of subventions or loans is not on the im- Russian peasants objected most strenuously and de- mediate horizon. The Jews of Palestine must receive terminedly to grain requisitioning, central control, and funds from somewhere. commisars. The people were not seeing eye to eye Europe is out of the question inasmuch as Poland, with the authorities. The authorities found a solidarity which was the generous contributor, needs assistance among the peasants which had to be reckoned with in the worst sort of a way. It devolves entirely upon and there followed changes. But the outside world American Jewry to raise the $5,000,000. Detroit Jewry did not know that the people and those in control were is asked for $125,000 and that means not a part of at loggerheads. The people of Russia are not respon- Detroit Jewry, but all of Detroit Jewry. The self-sac- sible for many of the indefensible practices of the dic- rificing idealists of Palestine call upon all who have any tators and least of those responsible are the Jews. responsive feeling, so that they may soon be self-suffi- No group has been as hard hit as have those who cient and self-supporting. depended upon trade and commerce. Russian Jewry in the main knew no other occupations and conse- quently when state ownership and control were legal- Student Dull Areas. ized and the co-operatives established the Jews found President James Rowland Angell of Yale Univer- themselves deprived of all possibility of earning a live- sity in his annual address, finds that the student is lihood. They belonged to the least privileged cate- growing "more sensible to the finer values of college gories, for they were not productive workers. life and he manifests a health and seriousness in liter- Is the practical economic annihilation of a people ature and drama which is refreshing, and a ready re- the concern of the immediate relatives only? Can the sponse to the religious and philanthropic appeal." non-Jewish world say to our people, who are least re- There is another side not so bright and promising sponsible, that this is your problem and you must find for President Angell discovers an area of dullness a way out? For those of liberal mind and good will which he describes in the following words: both questions can be answered in the negative. They know that Russian Jewry was for centuries the pariah If there is a dull area, it is perhaps in the field of political and social thought and action. A few ardent under Czarism. They know that no opportunity for souls are always stirred by the unrighteousness of social, substantial economic rooting or social orientation was industrial and political conditions. But, in general, the alloi..ed them. Should the non-Jewish world say to undergraduate Is ill informed about political questions, and notably indifferent to them, except in the presence them this is your cataclysm and we will have nothing of an election. to do with it. Whatever may be the shortcoming of America, it This indictment of the Yale student is also drawn against the citizenry of the country generally. In a does have a marked sense of fairness and decency. lecture before the Council of Jewish Women, Norman In the present situation this fairness and decency. Angell makes the same charge against "Babbitt" who should be called forth in an effort to increase the amount which is needed for salvaging, actual life sav- represents America politically and socially. Our adult population made an industrial and social ing and rehabilitation. The owner of the Post-Dispatch•'of Houston has revolution in the last 30 years, but the significance and connotations of this revolution have escaped it almost shown the way, others will surely follow if the matter is brought to their attention. We suggest to the lead- entirely. If the responsible leaders of trade, commerce and ers of the J. D. C; that this fruitful field should not industry have not been able to orient themselves among be neglected because the fun i s are needed; the non- esponsibility and wants the complexities which the industrial revolution has Jewish world recognizes i aterlally help in brought in its wake, how can we expect out adolescents to help in the work which shoo s in the world. with marked imitative weaknesses to show a broader wiping out one of the •worst plague a LTROR/EWISil efRomaq a :1 4 .2# . ,91 - . writ. k 114.nrir rordn' .4.1. Vr. - 1 DIGEST MAX NORDAU By PIERRE VAN PASSEN Palestine and Zionism. The reply of Lord Plumer, high commissioner of Palestine, to repre- sentatives of the Arab Executive has been noted with satisfaction by sev- eral Yiddish newspapers. The Jewish Daily News thinks that the high commissioner's words to the delegates of the Arabian agitators were fair to the Arabs and in strict- est accordance with the spirit of the law. They will have far-reaching re- sults. They will bring certain Arab elements to reason. "In this reply," says the News, "there is a world of political wisdom, and it will be well for the Arabs to study them long and thoroughly. It is exhaustive and does away with all the unfounded complaints of the Ar- abs that the Palestine administrtion is partial and against the interest of the Arabs, seeking only the interest of the Jews and fostering the founding of a Jewish National Homeland in the country. Lord Plumes is a mil- itary man and is not too talkative. He contented himself with but a few hints on several previous occasions, when Arab delegations attempted to approach him with their eternal and unjust complaints. This time the high commissioner did talk, and his words were weighty and impressive. They should have impressed them- selves upon the minds of the Arabs that the Palestine Mandate will not be changed, and that it inn° way in- jurious to the Arab population. In assuring the Arab delegation, that the government will do much for the industrial development of tht Arab settlements, and in warning them that the authorities will take the se- verest measures, if need, be, to se- cure law and order in the country, the high commissioner gave the anti- Jewish agitators among the Arabs a dignified reply in unmistakable words, which should convince them that it is in the best interests of the Arabs in Palestine that these agita- tors liquidate their aitivities of incit- ing the Arabs against the Jews." A similar opinion is expressed by the Jewish World of Philadelphia, in an editorial of Feb. 25. "The result of the interview of the Arab agitators with the high commissioner, Lord Plumer, was awaited impatiently," the paper writes—"If the latest re- ports are correct, we may feel satis- fied that the high commissioner's re- ply to their complaints was what it should have been. Of course, the Jews can have nothing against a pro- gram of industrial development for the Arab population. This the gov- ernment should do, provided it is done not for the Arabs only. The high commsisioner, however, was very tactful in making use of this opportunity to warn the Arabs, that order will be secured in the country even if the most drastic steps will have to be taken, and that if they are honest in their political activities, they should use their influence with the Arabs to refrain from any dis- orders." The fact of the recognition of the Palestine Mandate by the govern- ment of Egypt is discussed by Ab. Goldberg in the Jewish Morning Journal of March 1. Mutual friendly relations between these two neigh- boring countries will be of the great- est benefit to both. On the other hand, the Egyptian nationalists are perfectly justified in seeing in the Palestine Mandate a lessening of the burden upon Egypt. The British Em- pire and people are not prepared to give up their most vital artery, the Suez Cane'. Egypt was hitherto the key to that artery. Now, however, with a loyal Jewish population in Pal- estine, Britain can depend upon Pal- estine for the defense, of the canal, and so the military burden will be shifted from Egypt to Palestine, where but a small force will be need- ed for this purpose. "At the same time, it must be re- membered that Egypt had been a nest fors Arab agitation against Palestine. Now that the government recognized the Palestine Mandate, it thereby made an end, or at least weakened the dreams of an Arab Empire. Egypt should also become now a cen- ter for a propaganda among the Ar- abs and the Moslems everywhere with the aim of making clear to them the real object and significance of Zion- ism" Referring to a news item published in the Yiddish newspapers through- try that "the Council of Ministers of Poland has recognized the Jewish Homeland in Palestine," The Day ex- plains that the action of the Polish Council of Ministers was but an in- ternal affair aiming at the legaliza- tion of the Zionist organizations in the country, which were on many • ities on the ground, that the Zionist organization was not legal The step taken by the Council of Ministers to be greeted as one of importance to Polish Jews and Zionism in Poland. It will once for all do away with in- numerable and endless abuses and misunderstandings which added much to the suffering of the Jews in that country. The Zionist organization is from now on a legal political party in Poland." The Jewish World of Cleveland discusses the movement inaugurated at Tel Aviv for a $50,000,000 loan for Palestine guaranteed by the Brit- ish government. The paper compares the project with the recently pub- lished news of a similar loan advised by Henry Morgenthau with the finan- cial backing of American Jewish capi- talists. "The Tel Aviv plan," says the World, "is much sounder in every way. The Morgenthau plan is essen- tially philanthropic, and the carrying out of that plan was quite doubtful for various reasons. While such Jews as Julius Rosenwald, Felix Warburg and Herbert Lehman do donate for Palestine, such donations are not made for the building up of a Jewish national home in Eretz Yisroel. The Tel-Aviv plan, however, is entirely in the intreseta of the national home, and of the British government as well. The Jews of Palestine have within the past six or seven years demonstrated their absolute reliabil- ity as upbuilders of the country. They have Converted the Balfour Declara- tion into a reality. The present Jew- ish national wealth in Palestine is surely not less than the amount of the projected loan, which would ; thus lave the soundest basis." 1t. vir' A.-t nrip-Iliktre- ar igg• Revealed by His Daughter Maxa. (Editor's Note:—Mlle. Maxa Nordau, noted French painter and lecturer, is to be the guest of the Detroit Zionist District on Sunday, March 14, when she is to lecture to a local audience on the subject "Reminiscences of My Father." We are printing an article on Max Nordau, as revealed by his daughter, by the famous American columnist, Pierre Van Passen, co-editor of the New York Evening World.) "The gods were generous with of genius, which in other instants, their gifts of talent and genius to the furnished the Christian world with Nordau family. They had not reached christologists who were of Jewish the limits of their bountiful bene- blood and the Hebrew world with ficence when they endowed Max Nor- grammarians of Grayish antecedes!., dau with a mind that was almost Mlle. Nordau revealed her father cosmic in its consciousness, universal man intensely interested in Hint in understanding and cosmopolitan in mysticism. sympathies. They filled the cup to And yet when we recall that overflowing. To his daughter they great Hindu leader, a contemporary gave an esthetic vision, that, ex- of Nordau, uttered those stirring pressed in her paintings, has become words about the Satanic nature of intellectual and poetic to a rare de- the civilization that dominates Eu- gree. But what is more, the daugh- rope, in which every canon of public ter's talent is not confined to a mas- morality has been broken by victors tery of the painter's brush. In her in the name of virtue; where no lit. lecture in Town Hall on Saturday has been considered too foul to be ut- night, she enriched her audience with tered, where the motive behind every a word-picture of her father's private crime is not religious or spiritual but grossly material then we see a har- life, of his joys and sorrows, of the idiosyncrasies of his genius and the mony of spirit, a modicum of ap. unutterable sadness of his disillu- prochement between the philosopher sionment. and critic of Paris and those Hindus, The anecdotes she told of her fath- who have given the world that dazz- er did not detract from the philosoph- ling and self-renewing mysticism. er's austerity and loftiness that was In her balanced description of her Max Nordan's,•but rathe•her•paint- father, Mademoiselle -Nordau brought er's instinct applied needed decora- home more than ever to this writer tive treatment of color and form. the striking resemblance that there is With deft, ethereal, "spiritual" between him and men like Tolstoi, strokes she worked out and present- Ghandi and Rolland. With Max Nor- ed a canvas of Max Nordau that was deo that triumvirate has been strong- distinguished because of its reality of est in their condemnation of Euro- arrangement and because it brought pean and Occidental civilization, but out a closer semblance to the human they have also more than any other men represented the conscience of form. This writer has more than once ex- humanity. pressed the opinion that he would Max Nordau was not a follower of sooner spend another night on lis- the fashions of his day. As Mlle. tening patrol in a shell-crater of No Nordau sketched him, we saw a short, Man's Land than face an audience as stocky, short-legged individual, limbs critical, we may as well say it, as • encased in baggy trousers, disregard. mercilessly penetrative and analyti- ing the dandyism of the boulevard- cal, as one composed of members of iers, a man concerned with weightier the Jewish intelligensia. Ile could matters than the frills and fancies of therefore enter fully into what must "la mode de I'aris." But he was have been Mademoiselle Nordau's punctilious in the upkeep of that mental agitation, when for the first aristocratic white beard. He took time in her life she ventured to ad- pride in it and cared for it with a sort of lovinse.kindness. dress an audience in English, to her an alien tongue. Yet outwardly she It was not astonishing to hear that maintained from the beginning a per- he was a man of extreme kindness of fect calm and composure. As a mat- whose sympathies went out to all ter of fact her performance was an those who were suffering either the act of extraordinary courage If physical ills or the pangs of storm- there were disturbing emotions surg- tossed wayfarers, who seek the truth ing through her head, she did not be- in the gloom of.noctural shadows that tray their presence in the least If loom over the path of life. that most difficult variety of human Her picturization of this sage as a speech, the English language, sought Peter Pan who never grew up, of a with its pitfalls and hidden traps to philosopher addicted to Tom Sawyer- ensnare her Gallic idiom, it was for ism, who could not resist the tempta- once foiled to a fine and satisfying tion to push a cat into a barrel of perfection For Mlle. Nordau spoke cooked spinach and then "run home almost without a trace of an accent. to tell us about it" was a delightful, And yet that does not mean to say charming and convincing attempt at her address was formal or stilted. To humanizing the possessor of such a sublime intellect. the contrary. It was punctuated and enlivened with piquant Parisian hu- While the world was seething with mor, it abounded with sparkling and intrigue and the rehancellories of Eu- racy gauloiseries and captivating rope puzzled with excited whispers French shrugs and gestures, often and the way was paved for the great more eloquent and expressive than criminal assault upon mankind that the spoken word. matured in 1914 and of which Max She was a breath from Paris. Not, Nordau was aware even in its small. to be sure, the Paris that is constant- est detail, he still found time to read ly being sought and explored by the the Bible. His daughter said he pre- parvenu tourists of the world, but ferred the Latin version of the Scrip. the Paris of the artists, who claim tures. Like no many luminous spir- the absolute and limitless liberty of its, Nordau also found that the Bible dreams. The Paris of an air so pure is the foundation, the crypt on which and rarified that it is difficult to ab- the whole fabric of true civilization sorb and breath its atmosphere for a rests. Ile found the crypt alone was being of coarse fibre. durable. The rest is temporary and This is the Paris that in a sense only designed to serve during the produced her illustrious father, whose transition years, until the plans for a universalism made him kin to that cathedral worthy of the Hebraic little band of noble souls, and lumi- groundwork could be worked out. nous minds 'who are fighting for a In the plan of a reconstructed so- living faith, whatever faith it be ciety, he also saw an honored place struggling eternally to reaclf the sum- for his own people, back on its own mit in their holy war against ignor- soil, where it could take up the inter- ance, disease, poverty and prejudice. rupted task of creating again a con- Mademoiselle Nordau represents scious unit. Hence his fervent ardor that France that is forever giving for Zionism, his never wavering faith in his own people. For Nordau con- new life to poetry and painting and sidered the task of Zionism not only music, the France that is always the enemy of dim, crepuscular life, and the redemption of Eretz Israel, but of tantamount significenee the prepara- that has this in common with the tion of Israel for the land of Israel. sages of the Jewish people that it And where Max Nordau touched champions liberty and justice and seeks the light of reason. fleetingly upon the characteristic. , Mademoiselle Nordau dispelled a and home life of her father, Louis myth. Her father, she said, was of- Lipsky, who was the chairman of the evening, complimented the tableau of ten regarded as a sceptic, a merciless critic and a destroyer and in fact his that brilliant career, with a searching and profound tribute to Nordau, the first works, attacking as they did the tribune of his people, who had caught moral decadence of Europe, had the reflection of Herzl's dream. who largely contributed to this belief, but had recognized the hero who had of- Max Nordau was also a builder, an fered himself as the interpreter, the idealist with a fervent hope in the exponent of the great Zionist adven- future, one who had not lost faith in ture. the essential goodness of man. "Con- sciously or unconsciously he had map- Mr. Lipsky evoked a picture of Nordau with settled features, its va- ped out a task for himself and his lit- rinhy , heroism , .. chivalry lucults ec 5 illumined by the l e magic light that ' .troy, and later he would build. Con- the perspective of years can lend to temporary criticism has not paid the same attention to the second period so variegated and manifold a person- ality. of his activities," she said, "and con- "As destiny has robbed us of the sequently I am afraid he is often mis- opportunity of looking into the eyes understood." of the father, we welcome tonight the To her audience she revealed her daughter who combines in herself s o father in the days of his glory; when many of Max Nordau's qualities and princes and statesmen consulted him; whose presence stirs again the embers when his far-seeing and keen concep- of resemblance of that dominating tion of the European situation made the position of Paris correspondent of personality in Jewish life." the Vienna Neue Freie Presse, which he occupied, more important from the standpoint of international politics • PATROTISM AND PIETY than the Austrian ambassador's post in the French capital. At that time How some Jews have deteriorated! every scientist and every scholar passing through Paris came to pay his Their ancestors sacrificed property and person to conserve the Sabbath. respects at the Nordau home. She Themselves refuse to sacrifice even sketched him also in the days of ad- the convenience. In no doing they - versity, when he rose to the sublime do not realize that they are not only height of placing his conscience damaging the present and future of above the dictates of the earthly their own people religiously and mor- fatherland and he, along with Romain ally, they are also injurious to their Rolland paid the price exacted by social environment. An observant chauvinist patriotism, banishment Jew is a better citizen than one who from France. is lax. Accordingly both patriotism She portrayed an old man, perhaps e somewhat bewildered by the momen- and piety counsel proper observanc tous changes of the great war, a man of • day of rest. To have such duly consecrated and conserved ought to twice disillusioned, first by the mass be the ambition of Jew and Christian insanity that drenched Europe in a working together—Rabbi Alexander sea of blood and secondly by the Lyons. merciless savagery of the conquerors, who had earlier waved the banners of justice and self-determination before FOR CRITICS the eyes of the war-worn and ex. haunted peoples. The Balfour Dec- laration had also been ■ disappoint- It taken a big person to recognise, acknowledge and rejoice that some ment to Max Nordau. In that docu- ment he did not see the reality of one else is bigger. Little people pre- fer to find others smaller than them- which he and Theodor Ilerzl had selves. Critics will kindly ponder dreamed together. this —Rabbi Alexander Lyons. By one of these unexplained twists